Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder that psychopaths can't help being like they are because they're born that way?

38 replies

GemGi · 19/08/2023 02:15

If psychopaths are born psychopaths then can they really help being such awful people? Aren't they just born damned to be really awful people?

YABU - psychopaths CAN help it
YANBU - psychopaths CAN'T help it

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
notlucreziaborgia · 19/08/2023 21:38

A lot of people are quick to diagnose psychopathy based on how hideous they find the crime, as if isn’t possible that someone that isn’t a psychopath. could do such a thing. I wonder to what extent it is a coping mechanism.

Lucy Letby doesn’t present as psychopathic, based on what I’ve read about her, and from what I can see Broadmoor psychiatrists themselves don’t consider her to fit in the antisocial category.

grmsk · 19/08/2023 21:27

Togastorm · 19/08/2023 21:24

Letby's crime is seemingly so motiveless and the victims so clearly innocent and total strangers to her Most violent crimes have a reason: passion (e.g. anger), greed, accident. The guilty are rarely strangers. Loads have reacted in a fit of anger or if they're premeditated they're not so out of character. She was cool as a cucumber. It's utterly bizarre. Psychopath or not - like Shipman - she certainly presented a different persona to her real one and was clearly an apt liar. It seems even her parents didn't even know the true her.

Look into murderers working in the healthcare industry and particularly in caring positions and you will realise that she is by no means a rarity. It does not make her a psychopath.

Togastorm · 19/08/2023 21:24

Letby's crime is seemingly so motiveless and the victims so clearly innocent and total strangers to her Most violent crimes have a reason: passion (e.g. anger), greed, accident. The guilty are rarely strangers. Loads have reacted in a fit of anger or if they're premeditated they're not so out of character. She was cool as a cucumber. It's utterly bizarre. Psychopath or not - like Shipman - she certainly presented a different persona to her real one and was clearly an apt liar. It seems even her parents didn't even know the true her.

grmsk · 19/08/2023 21:23

GemGi · 19/08/2023 21:04

Thank you for sharing. If you don't mind, please can you give examples of what experiences you have had with your impulses/needs? I'm just curious.

Mine are mainly control driven and they affect every part of my life to some degree. It impacts relationships, both intimate and professional ones and there are times when I find it difficult to keep in check but I usually succeed.
I have certainly prioritised my own needs over my partners (and will continue to do so), but I am aware when I am overstepping "common" boundaries.

GemGi · 19/08/2023 21:04

grmsk · 19/08/2023 20:56

ASPD diagnosed person here (m).
Never ever trust anyone who claims or boasts to be a psychopath. It's just attention seeking behaviour of the highest order.

Like other conditions ours is on a spectrum, but most people think of the Hollywood trope type because that's their only exposure to the concept. I don't know how many times I have heard people making the most stupid claims because they read a buzzfeed article or the like.

I cannot speak for everyone on the spectrum and there might be people who genuinely cannot adapt and who will behave in an extreme fashion. Genereally we know how we are supposed to act, and we want to fit in. At the same time we know that we are acting because we cannot understand the need for these seemingly superfluous requirements.

Impulses and needs are very difficult to manage though, and they are probably the main reason why we hurt and cause chaos. It can be controlled to a certain degree but probably never 100%. As stated above I cannot speak for everyone but we are not sitting around at home trying to think of ways to make other people miserable. We are just looking out for ourselves while trying to stay above water.

Hope this helps.

Thank you for sharing. If you don't mind, please can you give examples of what experiences you have had with your impulses/needs? I'm just curious.

OP posts:
grmsk · 19/08/2023 20:56

ASPD diagnosed person here (m).
Never ever trust anyone who claims or boasts to be a psychopath. It's just attention seeking behaviour of the highest order.

Like other conditions ours is on a spectrum, but most people think of the Hollywood trope type because that's their only exposure to the concept. I don't know how many times I have heard people making the most stupid claims because they read a buzzfeed article or the like.

I cannot speak for everyone on the spectrum and there might be people who genuinely cannot adapt and who will behave in an extreme fashion. Genereally we know how we are supposed to act, and we want to fit in. At the same time we know that we are acting because we cannot understand the need for these seemingly superfluous requirements.

Impulses and needs are very difficult to manage though, and they are probably the main reason why we hurt and cause chaos. It can be controlled to a certain degree but probably never 100%. As stated above I cannot speak for everyone but we are not sitting around at home trying to think of ways to make other people miserable. We are just looking out for ourselves while trying to stay above water.

Hope this helps.

TetrapanaxRex · 19/08/2023 11:10

I think childhood experiences and upbringing must be factored in as to how a psychopath behaves later on in life.

If spoilt or neglected this must have some bearing?

MereDintofPandiculation · 19/08/2023 11:02

I have heard, just in general I mean, 'they don't know what they doing' yeah right but regardless they sure try and cover their tracks afterwards so they know it is wrong what they are doing Perhaps they know society will disapprove rather than that it's wrong.

thelinkisdead · 19/08/2023 10:52

I really don’t think it’s that simple. A lot of people who are labelled ‘psychopaths’ because they’ve done awful things probably have other conditions or personality disorders alongside lacking empathy. Don’t forget, the Hare checklist is based on prisoners and so it will be skewed towards criminal behaviour / history.

I score very highly in terms of psychopathic traits, but not as a psychopath on the Hare checklist: I have no history of delinquency and am able to self reflect and consider consequences. Yet I’m comparison to pretty much everyone else I know, I’m definitely different. Am I a bad person? Absolutely not. I’m law-abiding and very self aware. Am I nice? No, but you’d think I was if you met me. I think there’s a huge difference between psychopaths or those with traits and sadists. The ‘psychopaths’ we hear about in the news and literature tend to be both, and I reckon environment and upbringing has a huuuuuge part to play in this

notlucreziaborgia · 19/08/2023 10:36

bellac11 · 19/08/2023 10:26

I think people get caught up in thinking that people have very distinct elements to them that are either one thing or another

You could have psychopathic traits which lead you to hurt people because people are just tools to you and you dont care what happens or you dont care about social norms or levels of engagement.

That might be on a criminal level or just on an anti social level but equally you might do well in a job because you tread over people and get to the top

You might have psychopathic traits but also have comorbid disorders or syndromes which mean that you're less in control of your actios, you might have MH issues, an illness, you might have SEN or ND disorders.

You might have personality disorders on top of this, leading you to seek out situations where you want to control or hurt people and commit crime, you may not care whether you are committing crime

Im surprised that its seen that serial killers dont have psychopathy as part of their disorder, the whole point of killing someone like that is that the person is just a tool for you to achieve your aims, that is the very definition of psychopathy I would have thought

Certainly there can be co-morbidities and overlapping aspects, but the distinctions between disorders do matter if the goal is to reach better understanding of abnormal psychologies.

There is a difference between someone that hurts someone incidentally with no pleasure gained or guilt felt (psychopathic), someone that hurts someone because they believe they’re in fact the victim of the one they’ve hurt (narcissistic), and someone that hurts someone specifically because they get enjoyment from the pain inflicted (sadistic). You’re talking about very different psychologies for all three.

Sadistic Personality Disorder is very rarely acknowledged or talked about, and is commonly conflated with psychopathy. This really doesn’t help the understanding of either, and understanding is generally purported to be desirable:
https://www.psychologytoday.com/gb/blog/and-running/202106/the-personality-disorder-we-dont-hear-enough-about?amp

The Personality Disorder We Don't Hear Enough About

The sadistic personality may be mistaken for antisocial personality disorder.

https://www.psychologytoday.com/gb/blog/and-running/202106/the-personality-disorder-we-dont-hear-enough-about?amp

bellac11 · 19/08/2023 10:26

I think people get caught up in thinking that people have very distinct elements to them that are either one thing or another

You could have psychopathic traits which lead you to hurt people because people are just tools to you and you dont care what happens or you dont care about social norms or levels of engagement.

That might be on a criminal level or just on an anti social level but equally you might do well in a job because you tread over people and get to the top

You might have psychopathic traits but also have comorbid disorders or syndromes which mean that you're less in control of your actios, you might have MH issues, an illness, you might have SEN or ND disorders.

You might have personality disorders on top of this, leading you to seek out situations where you want to control or hurt people and commit crime, you may not care whether you are committing crime

Im surprised that its seen that serial killers dont have psychopathy as part of their disorder, the whole point of killing someone like that is that the person is just a tool for you to achieve your aims, that is the very definition of psychopathy I would have thought

Dolores87 · 19/08/2023 10:20

Most psychopaths don't go on to do horrendous things so I don't think when we are talking about accountability it depends. If we are talking about a loved one being empathetically incapable some leeway should probably be given but if we are talking about horrendous killings then that is still a choice unless there are some other mental heath factors at play (i dont for example thing someone who kills during a psychosis should be punished and should be housed in a treatment facility for other peoples safety but we are talking about psychopathy not psychosis here ). Someone may not empathetically understand why killing is wrong and may take pleasure from it but they are absolutely existing in a world that tells them it is wrong and psychopaths are capable of understanding this social concept and are in control of their actions.

DrasticAction · 19/08/2023 10:14

I think fil is one.
Completely lacks empathy, towards me and dh at various points and thru this has made tragic situations worse.

He is also beyond competitive.

HamishTheCamel · 19/08/2023 10:09

I think that, on some level, it doesn't actually matter whether they can help it or not. We need to punish them on the basis that they can help it in order to bring justice to the victims and because otherwise law and order would completely break down (lots of people committing awful crimes and saying they couldn't help it).

fitzwilliamdarcy · 19/08/2023 09:59

notlucreziaborgia · 19/08/2023 09:37

The majority of psychopaths aren’t criminals. Unfortunately, the majority of knowledge we have about psychopathy comes from studying the criminal minority, which isn’t representative.

There’s also a tendency to categorize serious criminals as psychopathic when they’re not. Sadistic Personality Disorder and Narcissistic Personality Disorder are distinct diagnoses.

AFAIAA ‘angels of death’, serial killers in the medical field, generally do not fit the profile of ASPD or psychopathy.

This, exactly. And as other PPs have said, often those with psychopathic traits or diagnoses are in careers where they’re wildly successful.

I was thinking yesterday about the ‘angels of death’ - Charles Cullen, Beverley Ailitt, Harold Shipman, none of them have been diagnosed and their motives remain under debate. It complicates things that there are so few female serial killers, as it prevents us from drawing useful patterns.

notlucreziaborgia · 19/08/2023 09:37

The majority of psychopaths aren’t criminals. Unfortunately, the majority of knowledge we have about psychopathy comes from studying the criminal minority, which isn’t representative.

There’s also a tendency to categorize serious criminals as psychopathic when they’re not. Sadistic Personality Disorder and Narcissistic Personality Disorder are distinct diagnoses.

AFAIAA ‘angels of death’, serial killers in the medical field, generally do not fit the profile of ASPD or psychopathy.

ExtraOnions · 19/08/2023 09:35

There was a good Horizon documentary a few years back called “what makes a psychopath” a few years back. Well worth a watch.

We had a psychopath in our work place a few years back - not violent, but all the other traits. Caused chaos, left a trail of destruction .. 2 people lost their jobs. I’ve never met anyone like it, and hope never too again.

user8665439 · 19/08/2023 09:13

Read the book: The Psychopath Test.

FrogTaped · 19/08/2023 05:46

Just to add, I think a lot of psychopaths are born that way.

I know of a child that was placed in residential care aged 8. She needs 24/7 supervision because of her behaviour.

She was adopted at 6 months, and the adoptive parents were hugely loving, caring, so she was well loved and cared for.

Early on, she showed worrying signs, which escalated to her hurting the family dog so badly (it really was horrendous, I won't give details) that the dog needed to be PTS. The adoption broke down.

I still think of her and what lies ahead for her future.

Poppysmom22 · 19/08/2023 05:34

It's really not that simple. The number of people who have psychopathic traits is far far larger than the number of 'bad' psychopaths.
Look at Lucy Letby I think we can say has psychopathic traits has had a good upbringing but look how that turned out, she's a serial killer. Because she chose to be.

iloveeverykindofcat · 19/08/2023 05:33

Ooof, there in lies a question.

I think psychopaths don't feel empathy. That's not their fault, exactly - they can't. They don't have the capacity. We wouldn't blame a newborn baby for not feeling empathy, and they don't have the capacity either. I don't think you can teach a psychopath: 'you shouldn't do this because it hurts people' because they don't care that it hurts people, and they can't care. But you can teach them 'you shouldn't do this because the consequences will be bad for you'. I don't think you can make them better, but you can teach them to behave better.

Also lets not forget that actual psychopathy is pretty rare and most killers aren't psychopaths.

WandaWonder · 19/08/2023 05:31

FrogTaped · 19/08/2023 05:28

I think there must be an element of choice.

They know harming someone is wrong and illegal, so even if you have the compulsion then you have a choice to take yourself away/get help/remove yourself.

But I believe a symptom of psychopathy is believing you're better than others, more intelligent etc, so they assume they'll get away with their crimes because everyone else is too stupid to catch them.

I have heard, just in general I mean, 'they don't know what they doing' yeah right but regardless they sure try and cover their tracks afterwards so they know it is wrong what they are doing

FrogTaped · 19/08/2023 05:28

I think there must be an element of choice.

They know harming someone is wrong and illegal, so even if you have the compulsion then you have a choice to take yourself away/get help/remove yourself.

But I believe a symptom of psychopathy is believing you're better than others, more intelligent etc, so they assume they'll get away with their crimes because everyone else is too stupid to catch them.

WandaWonder · 19/08/2023 05:15

I think people have to be born with something in them that can turn them into a psychopath or any 'label' we can give then but can suppress either intentionally or not, or somehow hide it

Then something triggers on them that switches it on can of course be bad trigger or 'good' but something happens for it to get woken up

People can have wonderful amazing childhoods or terrible ones but something triggers them within that

PretzelKnot · 19/08/2023 05:11

My brother was born wrong. No birth trauma, no life trauma, perfectly average middle class upbringing. Imperfect but definitely good enough parenting.

From a very young age, he got pleasure out of someone’s unhappiness. From age 4 onwards, he would deliberately misbehave to sabotage treats which meant I missed out too. He got more pleasure at seeing my unhappiness than the happiness he would have received getting the treat. From age 7 or so, he was mastering the art of making everyone in his family unhappy. I don’t believe he feels like normal people. In many ways he is devoid of emotions. But he does seem to feel something when making people unhappy. It’s the only time he smiles. I always think it’s like in Harry Potter at the Death Day feast when the ghosts can almost taste the rotting food by walking through it. He can almost feel an emotion when his family are at peak despair and frustration due to his manipulations.

I am not a psychiatrist so can’t diagnose him. However if I heard a psychiatrist had diagnosed him with psychopathy or a personality disorder, I would not be in the slightest bit surprised.

That said, he has perfected his nice guy persona. He holds down a basic job. He is incredibly law-abiding. Every girlfriend he has ever had leaves him about 18 months in. Clever girls.

Swipe left for the next trending thread