Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Modest fashion

132 replies

Darthwazette · 18/08/2023 15:33

AIBU to dislike the term “modest fashion” when referring to Islamic dressing?

A spa local to me is doing a social media thing about welcoming all, including people who chose modest fashion, featuring two Muslim women, in fully covering swimsuits including head covering.

It feels like, by contrast, I’m being called immodest for dressings in a swim suit?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
Pollyputhekettleon · 18/08/2023 20:38

Whingebob · 18/08/2023 20:26

Literally the only reason you're saying that is because you're petrified of offending Muslims.

Ehhh no

I'm quite happy to call out religions that do things I think are wrong.

Calling your style modest is 100% fine with me.

I can't see how you got not caring about 'modest' to being petrified of Muslims. I don't consider myself politically liberal either

You know exactly why. In any other context, like the rape case I linked to, you'd understand perfectly well that calling a woman's clothing immodest is saying that she intends to attract sexual interest by wearing them, and that a negative value judgment has historically attached to that statement and still frequently does. You would absolutely be aware of the historical, and current, link between that attitude and victim-blaming for sexual harassment, assault, rape and child sex abuse. You absolutely would care. And you would be horrified that 4 year old girls are being forced by their parents to wear shorts that are 'intended to avoid attracting sexual interest'.

Whingebob · 18/08/2023 20:26

Literally the only reason you're saying that is because you're petrified of offending Muslims.

Ehhh no

I'm quite happy to call out religions that do things I think are wrong.

Calling your style modest is 100% fine with me.

I can't see how you got not caring about 'modest' to being petrified of Muslims. I don't consider myself politically liberal either

Myfavouritepenguin · 18/08/2023 20:16

CurlewKate · 18/08/2023 20:07

@Myfavouritepenguin "Are you being deliberately obtuse? What if the pp did say the thing about the modesty/ lack of modesty? If these are fair terms to use to describe clothes then where’s the harm in using those terms among friends"
Isn't that what I'm saying? If I offered to lend a friend an item of clothing and she said "Sorry, I can't wear that-it's nor modest enough" I wouldn't be offended. I'd try and find her something else she could wear. No, I don't like the idea that women are constrained in what they can wear by their culture or their religion, but I'm not going to have that discussion when I want to go swimming and for her to come with me. BTW, I hate those shorts under little girl's dresses too.

I thought you were suggesting a different response not involving the word ‘modest’ but clearly I misunderstood and you do think it’s fine for a woman to reject another woman’s clothes as immodest.

I think the divide on this thread is not between religious and non-religious people but between those who understand how important language is and those who don’t.

Pollyputhekettleon · 18/08/2023 20:14

Whingebob · 18/08/2023 20:09

We llive (most of us) in the uk. Bikinis, shirt skirts, minidresses, backless tops are all normal.

I don't think I've ever even heard the word 'immodest' spoken out loud.

There's many other things in society to be worked on. This isn't one, really. It's a case of roll your eyes and sigh, move on

Literally the only reason you're saying that is because you're petrified of offending Muslims.

'There were cries of protest on an international level earlier this month when comments made about an alleged victim’s underwear were used in a Cork rape trial. To the outrage of women in Ireland and around the world, the accused was acquitted. Senior counsel Elizabeth O’Connell, who defended her 27-year-old client over the alleged rape of a 17-year-old girl, made the initial comments in line with her defence and was accused of victim-blaming'

Clothing worn by victims of sexual assault featured in 'Not Consent' protest exhibition | IMAGE.ie

'Victim blaming' comments in Cork rape trial spark outrage | IMAGE.ie

Comments made about an alleged victim's underwear in a Cork rape trial have sparked nationwide outrage against victim blaming.

https://www.image.ie/editorial/victim-blaming-comments-cork-rape-trial-spark-outrage-133993

Whingebob · 18/08/2023 20:09

We llive (most of us) in the uk. Bikinis, shirt skirts, minidresses, backless tops are all normal.

I don't think I've ever even heard the word 'immodest' spoken out loud.

There's many other things in society to be worked on. This isn't one, really. It's a case of roll your eyes and sigh, move on

CurlewKate · 18/08/2023 20:07

@Myfavouritepenguin "Are you being deliberately obtuse? What if the pp did say the thing about the modesty/ lack of modesty? If these are fair terms to use to describe clothes then where’s the harm in using those terms among friends"
Isn't that what I'm saying? If I offered to lend a friend an item of clothing and she said "Sorry, I can't wear that-it's nor modest enough" I wouldn't be offended. I'd try and find her something else she could wear. No, I don't like the idea that women are constrained in what they can wear by their culture or their religion, but I'm not going to have that discussion when I want to go swimming and for her to come with me. BTW, I hate those shorts under little girl's dresses too.

Tartareistasty · 18/08/2023 20:03

Calibrachoa · 18/08/2023 19:56

If you Google Modest Clothing and click on Images and scroll down. You'll be scrolling for a very long time to find a photo of a man. In fact I gave up scrolling before I got to one, it's that rare.

There are brands for it.
It also might be because men's clothing js generally quite covery. Haven't seen a las around in hot pants yet while doing weekly shop. Nlthing against hot lanta, jusy illustrating men's clothing is generally more towards "modest side" anyway

Calibrachoa · 18/08/2023 19:59

Whingebob · 18/08/2023 19:55

So women shouldn't be allowed to discuss a word that they find problematic then? Why?

So women can't refer to their own style of dress as modest without others thinking they're secretly hateful/judgemental towards them? Why?

If the term annoys you personally fine. But I hate this idea that you don't like it so now other people have to change their speech. Now they have to be

Full coverage
Islamic
Conservative

Rather than choose how they want to refer to their own selves! None ya business!

It's more how clothes are being marketed to women and girls that people are uncomfortable with, and it's OK to have that opinion.

Calibrachoa · 18/08/2023 19:56

Tartareistasty · 18/08/2023 19:53

Men also have modest clothing

If you Google Modest Clothing and click on Images and scroll down. You'll be scrolling for a very long time to find a photo of a man. In fact I gave up scrolling before I got to one, it's that rare.

Tartareistasty · 18/08/2023 19:56

The problem here is that everyone thinks it's only modest or immodeat.
It's not black and white, like anything in life really

Whingebob · 18/08/2023 19:55

So women shouldn't be allowed to discuss a word that they find problematic then? Why?

So women can't refer to their own style of dress as modest without others thinking they're secretly hateful/judgemental towards them? Why?

If the term annoys you personally fine. But I hate this idea that you don't like it so now other people have to change their speech. Now they have to be

Full coverage
Islamic
Conservative

Rather than choose how they want to refer to their own selves! None ya business!

MotherofGorgons · 18/08/2023 19:55

'Conservative clothing" Maybe it should be changed to that. Sometimes I would like to be able to find that. But then all the clothing these days is conservative with the Little House on the Prairie trend.

Tartareistasty · 18/08/2023 19:53

Calibrachoa · 18/08/2023 19:49

And why is it only women and girls' clothes that get called Modest?

Men also have modest clothing

Calibrachoa · 18/08/2023 19:52

screentimehelpplease · 18/08/2023 19:29

This. OP you come across as someone who is just looking for something to be offended by.

So women shouldn't be allowed to discuss a word that they find problematic then? Why?

LolaSmiles · 18/08/2023 19:52

Calibrachoa
I'm not keen, but then I'm also not keen on girls feeling like they have to wear shorts under dresses in general. I also dislike how much girl clothing is sexualised in general compared to boys. Children's clothing is a whole new topic.

If an adult chooses to frame their own clothing choices based on their personal beliefs about modesty then I'm not about to jump to take offence because common sense says they're expressing their own view of their own dress requirements and convictions. If shops want to highlight that their clothing is modest then fine as it allows the women who want to find the clothes they need without having to wade through skin tight unitards, maxi skirts with huge slits.

Then alongside that I'd say there's a bigger discussion about women's clothing in general, the idea that covering up is viewed by many as oppressive but showing flesh (often in a male gaze way) is branded empowerment. That people consider it wrong for a woman to talk of her clothing in terms of modesty, whilst conveniently turning a blind eye to all the problematic sexualised influences in a lot of fashion and beauty for mainstream women's style.

MotherofGorgons · 18/08/2023 19:50

@Calibrachoa I think I would prefer them to be called shorts. But it doesn't bother me so much in swimwear. Or on Asos. Probably illogical.
It's not the OPs original post that bothered me. Its the posts that followed which are weird...

Pollyputhekettleon · 18/08/2023 19:49

LolaSmiles · 18/08/2023 19:42

What you wear and how you think of it should not offend anyone, of course.

However, if you were, for example, to say to a friend who offered to lend you a swimsuit, “No thanks- I’d feel uncomfortable in that because it’s not modest enough for me - though obviously fine for you”, I think your friend might justifiably feel offended, yes.
The friend would be looking to seek offence in my opinion if they were offended

Common sense says that if I've got a religious friend and part of their religion is an idea about dress being modest that's because under their faith, they feel commanded to dress that way. It's a modesty standard for the people who choose to live that faith. It's often about more than the item of clothing and links to other spiritual disciplines and beliefs.

As someone outside of that faith, those standards don't apply to me. If I offer them a swimsuit and it doesn't meet their religious requirements then that's not a judgement on me. It's a statement of fact that it isn't modest enough for them.

The problem is that you're pretending that those religious rules have nothing to do with sex, with placing responsibility on women to avoid attracting the sexual interest of men, with considering it to be immoral to dress in a way likely to attract men's sexual interest. You're also pretending that women and girls are not frequently blamed for their own rapes, sexual harassment etc. because of their choice of 'immodest' clothing.

used to describe something, such as a woman's clothes or behaviour, that is intended to avoid* attracting sexual interest:*

describe

1. to say or write what someone or something is like: 2. If you describe a…

https://dictionary.cambridge.org/dictionary/english/describe

Calibrachoa · 18/08/2023 19:49

And why is it only women and girls' clothes that get called Modest?

Whingebob · 18/08/2023 19:45

Modest is a perfectly simple term where you know it's not going to have massive cutouts, a neckline down to your diaphragm, the complete absence of a back, a 'knee length' where the knees are apparently 4 inches from your arse cheeks, be transparent and might actually have some room around the waist.

Full coverage would also include a long sleeved compression shirt and leggings, which is hardly the intent behind the term.

Well put @NeverDropYourMooncup

MotherofGorgons · 18/08/2023 19:45

@Myfavouritepenguin OK the term is problematic. In which case why are posters saying- and I am on my phone so can't scroll back to see which poster- " women who wear modesty clothing judge you".. That's not just about the term is it? It's about the clothing. And the women who wear such clothing.

Pollyputhekettleon · 18/08/2023 19:44

CurlewKate · 18/08/2023 19:35

@Pollyputhekettleon wow-referencing Lucy Letby's a deeply offensive stretch.

There is no suggestion that anyone HAS to wear modest clothing to this spa. Just that women who, for whatever reason feel they have to, can. So they can swim.

I didn't 'reference' Lucy Letby.

You made an incredibly facetious argument that: 'But is immodest a value judgement? And even if it is, why does it matter? People have different perceptions and values.'

In other words, you're claiming that it doesn't matter that people have different perceptions and values. It obviously does. Women being judged as immodest is not some harmless little personal quirk. Women have been targeted for sexual assault, rape and little girls are abused because of a perception that they're wearing clothing that is 'too sexy'. In other words, that is immodest. We've had centuries of this.

So I'll use whatever example I like to demonstrate the ridiculousness of your statement.

'used to describe something, such as a woman's clothes or behaviour, that is intended to avoid* attracting sexual interest:'*

MODEST | English meaning - Cambridge Dictionary

describe

1. to say or write what someone or something is like: 2. If you describe a…

https://dictionary.cambridge.org/dictionary/english/describe

Myfavouritepenguin · 18/08/2023 19:44

CurlewKate · 18/08/2023 19:39

@Myfavouritepenguin "
However, if you were, for example, to say to a friend who offered to lend you a swimsuit, “No thanks- I’d feel uncomfortable in that because it’s not modest enough for me - though obviously fine for you”, I think your friend might justifiably feel offended, yes."

why? Isn't a more normal response " Hmm-I've got a T shirt and leggings here. Will they do?"

Are you being deliberately obtuse? What if the pp did say the thing about the modesty/ lack of modesty? If these are fair terms to use to describe clothes then where’s the harm in using those terms among friends?

Whingebob · 18/08/2023 19:43

The problem with you op, and anyone who agrees, is your own bias. You perceive Muslims as intolerant and judgemental.

Them calling their own fashion modest (eg a woman styling a hijab with her workwear) has nothing to do with you and your morals. Nobody gives a shit.

It doesn't make you immodest, but arrogant to think anyone gives you that much thought

I dress both modestly and less modestly depending on the occasion and weather.

Calibrachoa · 18/08/2023 19:42

MotherofGorgons · 18/08/2023 19:39

Yes. But the discussion has moved on, hasn't it?

Ok. Who is it that you think has made the point that women in saris must be judging women who don't wear them then?

Swipe left for the next trending thread