Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To have no time for ‘anti-human’ people?

214 replies

Myfavouritepenguin · 18/08/2023 13:09

I’ve seen it quite a lot recently- mostly on here rather than in real life admittedly. I’m referring to both the ‘I don’t like children people; I much prefer animals’ contingent as well as the ‘wouldn’t it be better if humans just died out’ approach.

I’ve been trying to pinpoint what it is that irks me, and I think it’s that this attitude seems like a slightly different version of “I’m not like other girls.” - an attempt to separate and elevate and basically look down on everyone else in your category.

The thing is, we are all human. Unless you are literally living off grid with wolves or whatever, you have not opted out of humanity. Whatever makes a human, that is what you are, and you are to some degree or other not only invested in but contributing to the whole operation, children and climate change included.

The answer to humanity’s ills and issues is not to reject everyone else who somehow isn’t as special and above humanity as these people seem to imagine they are!

OP posts:
JusthereforXmas · 18/08/2023 14:53

CaptainJackSparrow85 · 18/08/2023 14:24

I know what you mean.

See also - the people who say ‘I don’t like any children except my own.’ Soooo cool! Except for starters we all know you’ve copied that from Miranda on Sex and the City and there’s nothing cooler than quoting a 20 year old sitcom.

I don't really think its the same at all.

I adore my children, I went through infertility hell and IVF to have them. They where my lifes mission that I would die for in a heartbeat... but not a huge fan of most other kids though.

I mean its not like I'm going to be friends with them, what am I going to have in common with a 5 year old? They are like hyperactive, space invady, little gossipy co-workers with terrible hygiene and bad social manners.

I'm perfectly happy all those 5 year olds exist though, I just dont want to host them in my house, have them rub their sticky snotty face on me as the clamber up or sit and talk to them about firetrucks on repeat for an hour.

I have also never in my life watched sex in the city.

Myfavouritepenguin · 18/08/2023 14:51

@Naunet

Not all women have to adore children and it’s misogynistic to suggest they should. Is it ok for men not to like children, or are they trying to ‘be better’ than other men?

I didn’t say anything about the sex of the people who don’t like kids 😕

Honestly, I really regret using the ‘not like other girls’ trope as an analogy. It was not linked to the not liking children bit!

The not liking children seems to have really riled some people.

To clarify, I’m not talking about people having or not having children; people with children also spout this nonsense! Im talking about the attitude that lies behind rejecting humanity wholesale.

OP posts:
Naunet · 18/08/2023 14:50

Myfavouritepenguin · 18/08/2023 14:45

I’m more interested in the pp who mentioned the need to take an objective stance in order to understand where people are coming from when they reject the human race.

Yes, humanity is a blight on the planet, without a doubt. But I still think the ‘it’s best if humans just die out’ stance in disingenuous. I think you can only be objective about it because of timescale. That’s all. I mean, if the planet was literally going to become inhospitable to us in the next 20 years, I don’t think those same people would be quite so ‘objective’ about it, shrugging and saying ‘it’s for the best’. They’re saying that in the abstract, for some future generation. They’re not actually being honest about how much investment they have here and now in themselves, as humans, and the humans around them. I find it posturing and supercilious and - to be blunt - dishonest.

I think you just need to accept that we don’t all think the same. I can objectively accept that we’re the worst creation nature ever came up with, in terms of our impact on the planet and other species, and I KNOW that the planet would be better off without us. But if I knew we were all going to die tomorrow, of course I wouldn’t want to on a personal level.

Can you really not understand how you can hold two views like that, both the natural instinct of self preservation, and acknowledge the objective bigger truth?

Jamtartforme · 18/08/2023 14:49

fitzwilliamdarcy · 18/08/2023 14:24

I especially dislike the posters that argue their dog/cat ( but usually dog) is more important than other people's children

But to them, it is. My cat is more important to me that some random person’s child. Because my cat brings joy to my life whereas a random child does not. I don’t know why people expect their kids to be more important to a random stranger than that stranger’s own pet (a member of their family).

Not in a day to say sense, nobody expects you to jack in your vets insurance and redirect the money to a children’s charity. But people who would rescue their cat from a fire rather than a random child, I do not understand that at all.

JudgeAnderson · 18/08/2023 14:48

You can’t possibly know for a fact that no other animal species connects sex and pregnancy. Typical human arrogance

That's true actually. Possibly some of the brighter ones have figured it out.

Optionyougot · 18/08/2023 14:46

Naunet · 18/08/2023 14:43

Then Im not sure why you replied to me on my first post? Looks like we agree 😄

I realised after I posted you were responding to a post I made, but the OP had replied to and it was their reply you were referring to 😂so my message popped up at the too of your response.

We're definitely in agreement!

Myfavouritepenguin · 18/08/2023 14:45

I’m more interested in the pp who mentioned the need to take an objective stance in order to understand where people are coming from when they reject the human race.

Yes, humanity is a blight on the planet, without a doubt. But I still think the ‘it’s best if humans just die out’ stance in disingenuous. I think you can only be objective about it because of timescale. That’s all. I mean, if the planet was literally going to become inhospitable to us in the next 20 years, I don’t think those same people would be quite so ‘objective’ about it, shrugging and saying ‘it’s for the best’. They’re saying that in the abstract, for some future generation. They’re not actually being honest about how much investment they have here and now in themselves, as humans, and the humans around them. I find it posturing and supercilious and - to be blunt - dishonest.

OP posts:
Naunet · 18/08/2023 14:44

JudgeAnderson · 18/08/2023 14:41

Of course there is a biological drive to raise young, otherwise the mother would just abandon their young after birth, but instead the mother (and sometimes the father) are driven to try and ensure their survival to adulthood.

That comes later, at the birth. But the original drive is to mate. Animals obviously don't link the act with subsequent events.

You can’t possibly know for a fact that no other animal species connects sex and pregnancy. Typical human arrogance. 😉

Whatsthepoint1234 · 18/08/2023 14:43

As a mother sometimes I like my dog more than my kids! At least my dog doesn’t witter at me about computers or wars.

(before I get crucified I obviously love my kids I just don’t want to hear about ds’s custom content or the different types of tanks.)

Naunet · 18/08/2023 14:43

Optionyougot · 18/08/2023 14:41

That's exactly my point. Liking kids, not liking them etc - it's personal preference. Viewing it through the scope of "must be trying to be cool, or edgy, or not like other girls" is so reductive.

Then Im not sure why you replied to me on my first post? Looks like we agree 😄

JusthereforXmas · 18/08/2023 14:43

BIL was always like this... humanity should die out, we're overpopulated, having kids is selfish, people are a plague etc...

Guess who now he has suddenly turned 40 decide to pop out a mini-me due any time now?

I LOATHE it, its so cringey, it falls in that spoilt child attitude. I have literally heard fully grown adults moan that 'they didn't ask to be born' like a petulant young teen.

Like I don't actually think anyone should be killing themselves but if they TRUELY believed what they said instead of saying it to be 'I'm so cool' then wouldn't they not want to be part of the problem?

Saying you hate all humans, we should all die off and you never wanted to be born but then sitting their taking up your place on earth with no desire to give up 'your' place... it's an insufferable yet eye rollingly hilarious irony.

Just stop moaning people.

JudgeAnderson · 18/08/2023 14:42

I think the term "childfree" is borderline offensive. And I don't find much language offensive.

You might want to take that up with MN on site stuff then given that there's a section of the board specifically called that.

JudgeAnderson · 18/08/2023 14:41

Of course there is a biological drive to raise young, otherwise the mother would just abandon their young after birth, but instead the mother (and sometimes the father) are driven to try and ensure their survival to adulthood.

That comes later, at the birth. But the original drive is to mate. Animals obviously don't link the act with subsequent events.

Optionyougot · 18/08/2023 14:41

Naunet · 18/08/2023 14:34

Why though? Are women not allowed to like different things? Must we all be the same or it must be that we’re trying to ‘be better’ than other women? Sounds like you’re taking other peoples views as a personal attack.
Not all women have to adore children and it’s misogynistic to suggest they should. Is it ok for men not to like children, or are they trying to ‘be better’ than other men?

That's exactly my point. Liking kids, not liking them etc - it's personal preference. Viewing it through the scope of "must be trying to be cool, or edgy, or not like other girls" is so reductive.

Naunet · 18/08/2023 14:40

fitzwilliamdarcy · 18/08/2023 14:34

I think the term "childfree" is borderline offensive. And I don't find much language offensive.

For goodness sake. The word doesn’t mean we want to be free of the plague that is children. It’s to denote that we’ve made a choice not to have them (as opposed to not having had a choice, which is generally incredibly painful). The distinction is necessary as the issues are different.

Yeah but it’s offensive to other people (normal proper women) who are completely unaffected by our choices but still deeply upset if we are allowed to be happy about not having children…

SouperMario · 18/08/2023 14:40

I do prefer animals to people but I understand other people prefer people to animals. I can't help it - it is just the way I am.

I do sometimes day dream about setting up my own homestead in the middle of nowhere with minimal interaction with other people.

If I had a choice to press a button that instantly wiped out the entire human race or made it so we had never existed I probably would press it....

Azaeleasinbloom · 18/08/2023 14:40

Have to say, I don’t think I have ever encountered anyone who has a ‘ wholesale rejection of humanity’.

Met plenty who may have been treated unfairly or horribly, and they may have a distrust of other humans, but I think that often they would want to be proven wrong.

Who are all these rejectionists ? ( I may have just made that word up )

Myfavouritepenguin · 18/08/2023 14:39

Optionyougot · 18/08/2023 14:21

Your right, you instead phrased it as I think it’s that this attitude seems like a slightly different version of “I’m not like other girls.”

Which in itself is an attempt to separate and denigrate groups of women. It's all misogyny. And really interesting that this is about people who don't like kids,and people who say the earth would be better without humans, but "not like other girls" is what it makes you think of.

Oh for goodness sake! My use of this analogy seems to have thrown you into a tailspin.

To clarify. The ‘I’m not like other girls’ is a misogynistic stance. I’m tempted to think that it only exists as a trope because male writers put in in Hollywood films. But even if an actual woman says it, it is misogynistic. It’s then internalised misogyny. I would still defend a woman’s use of it, because the whole ‘pick me’ (there, I’ve said it) mentality only came about because women were forced to compete with each other for male attention in a patriarchy. Yes.

But none of this is really relevant to my thread! Neither is the whole ‘child free’ debate tbh.

OP posts:
MentholLoad · 18/08/2023 14:35

I agree 100%. I was anti human when I was a teenager, I grew out of it. it's usually steeped in classism and racism, as well

it is exactly like 'im not like other girls' you are right. and people moaning about the traffic, when they ARE the traffic

fitzwilliamdarcy · 18/08/2023 14:34

I think the term "childfree" is borderline offensive. And I don't find much language offensive.

For goodness sake. The word doesn’t mean we want to be free of the plague that is children. It’s to denote that we’ve made a choice not to have them (as opposed to not having had a choice, which is generally incredibly painful). The distinction is necessary as the issues are different.

Naunet · 18/08/2023 14:34

Optionyougot · 18/08/2023 14:27

No, of course not.

It's the inference that groups of people who say they don't like children, prefer animals is giving "I'm not like other girls", and that it's an attempt to act superior or separate to anyone else. The one that it's not just personal preference but an attempt to separate yourself from your sex and look down in your sex that has gotten to me. That particular example and comparison.

Why though? Are women not allowed to like different things? Must we all be the same or it must be that we’re trying to ‘be better’ than other women? Sounds like you’re taking other peoples views as a personal attack.
Not all women have to adore children and it’s misogynistic to suggest they should. Is it ok for men not to like children, or are they trying to ‘be better’ than other men?

Myfavouritepenguin · 18/08/2023 14:32

@fitzwilliamdarcy

I’ve never met a person who says they hate kids. I’ve seen some who say they don’t like them. Is that OK, OP? It’s just that you’re saying that we don’t have to love all members of a group but it feels like we have to at least like them all, to pass your test of not being a pick me girl?

Well, saying you don’t like kids is not a million miles away from saying you hate kids…

But as for the rest of your post, you misunderstand me. I’m not saying anything about how we must or must not feel about any individuals. We don’t have to like every person! I’m taking issue with the wholesale rejection of humanity. That’s rather different.

I have not used the phrase ‘pick me girl’ either 🙄

OP posts:
Verv · 18/08/2023 14:32

Myfavouritepenguin · 18/08/2023 13:30

It’s a bit different from preferring marmite when people say ‘I hate all children’ though isn’t it? I mean, for one thing, children aren’t a homogeneous mass like marmite. Imagine if someone said they hated all women…

Also, I wasn’t really talking about just preferring but actually rejecting humanity on mass.

"’I'm referring to both the ‘I don’t like children people; I much prefer animals’ contingent as well"

I haven't said "I hate all children"
I identified myself as one of those people who as per your original post prefers animals to children.

If you want to debate people who "say they hate all children" then say so at the outset.

Other than that, yes, preferring animals to children is about as banal a life choice as marmite and marmalade.
We don't all have to like the same things.

SuperBurgers · 18/08/2023 14:32

Kweeky · 18/08/2023 14:29

How old is ‘ole

Not as old as you'd like!

AmazingSnakeHead · 18/08/2023 14:30

Rudderneck · 18/08/2023 14:29

I think the term "childfree" is borderline offensive. And I don't find much language offensive.

If you took any other category of people, women, the elderly, the disabled, whatever, and used it in the same way, people would think it was wildly inappropriate.

it's legitimate not to want to be a parent. And if you don't enjoy being with children, you don't. Some people don't like interacting with the homeless, or intellectually disabled, or old people. It is what it is.

But they would be rightly criticized if they started talking about wanting to live a elder-free life, or anything like that.

Just say you don't have kids, don't want them, or aren't a parent.

Actually this is amazing, I might start refering to beign "husbandfree" or "man-free" as opposed to "intentionally single".