Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should I tell OW Husband?

256 replies

Daffodil18 · 18/08/2023 10:55

I’m so conflicted on what to do and it’s weighing heavy on me. I feel like I’m now a part of the affair with the secret and lies.

YABU - I should not break up another family
YANBU - He has a right to know

OP posts:
FadeAwayAndRadiate · 18/08/2023 15:13

YES. Tell him @Daffodil18 Why should she get off scot-free? Also, he has a right to know of course!

SlightlyJaded · 18/08/2023 15:12

Usually on these threads, my advice is to leave it alone - not always, but usually.

However in these circumstances, I would 100 percent tell him. How DARE your STBXH lean on the friend he has betrayed? HE has put you in the position where you have no choice but to tell. Had he had the dignity to leave them both alone (OW and her DH) then maybe you could hold your tongue, but the fact that he has turned up at YOUR door supported by his 'friend' means you are now complicit if you don't tell.

And you can frankly tell your STBEH and the OW that it is entirely on them that you are sharing as they have dragged 'friend' into this mess and are humiliating him by using him as emotional support for your Ex.

Fuck that. I'd be round there now (and I NEVER say that).

MaryMagda · 18/08/2023 15:11

I've tried to put myself in your shoes OP, to think what I'd do.

I'd definitely have the urge to blow up OW's life, I'd probably think of lots of scenarios where she'd be thrown dramatically into the gutter, etc.

But my reality would probably be that, even if my relationship had ended due to the affair (and I would end it, no doubt about that), I wouldn't want her to be suddenly single and thrown together with my ex. I'd find that annoying.

I guess I wouldn't do anything to make these 2 , her and my ex, official. So yeah, I'd just deal with my speedy divorce.

MissHarrietBede · 18/08/2023 15:09

He told OW he loves her and wants to be with her. She will not leave her husband, so he now threatens suicide if you won’t have him back.

Wow. He can’t exist without a woman propping his life up, can he?

SliceOfCakeCupOfTea · 18/08/2023 15:03

It's one thing to cheat.
It's another to cheat with your husbands friend
It's yet another thing to then allow your husband to comfort the man you're shagging behind his back AND expect your lovers wife to lie for you.

Libelula21 · 18/08/2023 15:00

I guess one consideration is is that by telling the OW’s DH, you increase the chance that she might set up home with your STBExDH.

But no doubt you’ve taken that into account, @Daffodil18

Runnerinthenight · 18/08/2023 14:56

Reading your update, you can't not tell him. In fact you probably should have told him during that conversation though I appreciate it's a very difficult thing to have to say.

What an absolute bastard your STBX is, first of all cheating on you, secondly cheating with his good friend's wife, and worst of all, using him to comfort him in the aftermath of his affair with his wife!!! Incredible!

Hope you are as ok as you can be. I think when you tell, it will at least be one burden lifted from you. You have been through enough. You shouldn't have to carry their grubby little secret and it's just a bit heartbreaking to think of that poor guy who has been doubly deceived!

Mari9999 · 18/08/2023 14:55

@tooearlyforthis98
If you are not married to someone, you cannot know wht it is like to be married to him. No amount of friendship or familiarity can tell you what it is really like to be his wife.

There are probably any number of people who would say that the OP's husband would never cheat.

ehupo7 · 18/08/2023 14:54

ehupo7 · 18/08/2023 14:51

But it seems many MNers think a beating is fair punishment for a loose woman. God, this place.

No one thinks that, you just made it up

OW has nothing to do with OP's marriage. She's in this position because her own husband cheated.

By your logic, you could just as well say of the OP telling the husband

’OP has nothing to do with OW's marriage. OW is in this position because she cheated.’

Also, this has to be one of the judgiest, grossly sexist posts I’ve seen on this thread:

loose woman, really? 🥴

ehupo7 · 18/08/2023 14:51

DrSbaitso · 18/08/2023 14:46

OP isn't married to him and doesn't know how he is or how he'd react. How many abusers are thought to be angels by people who aren't married to them?

OW has nothing to do with OP's marriage. She's in this position because her own husband cheated.

But it seems many MNers think a beating is fair punishment for a loose woman. God, this place.

But it seems many MNers think a beating is fair punishment for a loose woman. God, this place.

No one thinks that, you just made it up

OW has nothing to do with OP's marriage. She's in this position because her own husband cheated.

By your logic, you could just as well say of the OP telling the husband

’OP has nothing to do with OW's marriage. OW is in this position because she cheated.’

SliceOfCakeCupOfTea · 18/08/2023 14:51

DrSbaitso · 18/08/2023 14:46

OP isn't married to him and doesn't know how he is or how he'd react. How many abusers are thought to be angels by people who aren't married to them?

OW has nothing to do with OP's marriage. She's in this position because her own husband cheated.

But it seems many MNers think a beating is fair punishment for a loose woman. God, this place.

You have absolutely no proof that he is violent. No one deserves a beating for anything. But also, he doesn't deserve to be lied to and betrayed by his wife and his friends.

You have no idea she will be abused as a result of him finding out. You do know that he will be hurt either way.

Xiaoxiong · 18/08/2023 14:48

I would tell XDH and OW that they have, say, this weekend to tell him. If they don't, you will be telling him because he deserves to know, it's wrong that DH is allowing him to comfort him without knowing the truth and you cannot be complicit in this lie and deceit any longer.

I agree with this from Slice above. The fact that he is DH's friend and is comforting him magnifies his potential humiliation when he does find out (and he will, eventually). He needs to know asap and if he says "why didn't you tell me last week when I came round" I think you can easily say "I gave DH an ultimatum to tell you himself" or "I gave DH an ultimatum to tell you himself and he didn't which is why I'm now telling you".

The longer you keep quiet the worse it gets for him and the more you go from being an innocent victim here to being complicit in his humiliation at the hands of his wife and best friend. So you need to act, and fast, I think.

(My opinion might be different if the man was a total stranger and not connected to you guys as a friend or offering your DH support unknowing that his wife is involved too.)

Libelula21 · 18/08/2023 14:46

This by @SliceOfCakeCupOfTea :

I would tell XDH and OW that they have, say, this weekend to tell him. If they don't, you will be telling him because he deserves to know, it's wrong that DH is allowing him to comfort him without knowing the truth and you cannot be complicit in this lie and deceit any longer.

It’s not fair to ask you to carry that secret when your STBExDH is acting that way.

I’m sorry this has happened to you. 💐

DrSbaitso · 18/08/2023 14:46

tooearlyforthis98 · 18/08/2023 13:53

Pity OW didn't think to stay out of OP's marriage. However if you read the OP's it says he isnt like that

OP isn't married to him and doesn't know how he is or how he'd react. How many abusers are thought to be angels by people who aren't married to them?

OW has nothing to do with OP's marriage. She's in this position because her own husband cheated.

But it seems many MNers think a beating is fair punishment for a loose woman. God, this place.

Runnerinthenight · 18/08/2023 14:46

DoomsdayPrep · 18/08/2023 12:48

I feel like telling the OW's male partner might be me weaponising male violence against a woman to punish her for "taking" someone I believe to be my property. That feels immoral to me.

Bollocks!!

I'd tell. He may find out from someone else and as you already know the couple, he'd be very hurt that you didn't tell him. It's not your responsibility but knowledge is power.

SliceOfCakeCupOfTea · 18/08/2023 14:45

TeeBee · 18/08/2023 14:32

Or they'll come up with some cock and bull story to cover themselves. I wouldn't give them a heads-up. I'd just tell him. Let him decide what's best for him.

That's why I would record the conversation where I tell them I'm going to tell him if they don't. They will say something incriminating such as begging OP to not say anything to start with.

HootyMcBoob · 18/08/2023 14:44

DoomsdayPrep · 18/08/2023 12:42

My priorities are the sexual liberation and safety of women in the reality of patriarchy. My logic makes sense in that context.

I don't want to argue, it's not healthy or productive for me, but just offering the perspective that you might be exposing the OW to violence or other forms of domestic abuse.

It is possible to have concern and compassion for people even if they have done something we disagree with, that hurts us.

Either you're on a wind-up or you're blinded by your sheer overwhelming hatred of men. 🙄

Jellybean23 · 18/08/2023 14:42

Get it all out in the open. The STBEX and OW are having their cake and eat it.

TeeBee · 18/08/2023 14:32

SliceOfCakeCupOfTea · 18/08/2023 14:29

I would absolutely want to know. It would break up my family BUT as soon as it happens, the damage is done. The longer it goes on, the worse it is.
It will come out eventually so telling him now is preventing him from being massively hurt in the long run.

He also gets to make an informed decision about his future. It's unfair for him to trapped in a lie of a marriage.

I would tell XDH and OW that they have, say, this weekend to tell him. If they don't, you will be telling him because he deserves to know, it's wrong that DH is allowing him to comfort him without knowing the truth and you cannot be complicit in this lie and deceit any longer.

They will threaten everything from suicide to destroying your life, the will beg, they will blackmail, they will lie etc. I'd probably record the conversation where you tell them what you're going to do. Then when you do end up telling the DH (and you will...they won't) you have concrete proof that you tried.

Or they'll come up with some cock and bull story to cover themselves. I wouldn't give them a heads-up. I'd just tell him. Let him decide what's best for him.

Feraldogmum · 18/08/2023 14:29

My god your ex really is human filth. Threatening suicide because he says he wants to be with you ,emotionally controlling you to keep their secret whilst telling OW he loves her and using the poor hubby as a crutch.Lies all around from him.
Why exactly are you keeping the secret? Is the OW wanting to keep her marriage and the affairs over,doesn't sound like it.
Firstly your ex is not this man's friend,friends don't do that. Secondly he isn't going to kill himself he simply thinks he can have his cake and eat it, he wants to keep you ,keep her, keep his mate.You do realise that in keeping this secret, he is trying to make you look heartless to the husband, cruel because you won't forgive a suicidal man?
Don't be complicit in this sewer they've created, either have no contact with the husband or tell him. Don't feel guilty,you are the wronged party and I'll bet the second the secrets out, you'll see just how suicidal this narcissistic man really is. Be prepared to be the bad guy but get your finances and a solicitor sorted first, oh and change the locks.

SliceOfCakeCupOfTea · 18/08/2023 14:29

I would absolutely want to know. It would break up my family BUT as soon as it happens, the damage is done. The longer it goes on, the worse it is.
It will come out eventually so telling him now is preventing him from being massively hurt in the long run.

He also gets to make an informed decision about his future. It's unfair for him to trapped in a lie of a marriage.

I would tell XDH and OW that they have, say, this weekend to tell him. If they don't, you will be telling him because he deserves to know, it's wrong that DH is allowing him to comfort him without knowing the truth and you cannot be complicit in this lie and deceit any longer.

They will threaten everything from suicide to destroying your life, the will beg, they will blackmail, they will lie etc. I'd probably record the conversation where you tell them what you're going to do. Then when you do end up telling the DH (and you will...they won't) you have concrete proof that you tried.

ChristmasCrumpet · 18/08/2023 14:25

From reading your updates, you absolutely tell him.

ExH's been moping and whining around this other man, using him as an emotional crutch, looking him in the eye like a victim and lapping up his sympathies, when it's actually down to exH fucking the man's wife!!??!! I've heard some cheeky fuckery in my time, but this?...

ehupo7 · 18/08/2023 14:23

theleafandnotthetree · 18/08/2023 13:17

Agreed, when my ex husband suspected I had an affair and subsequently confirmed it through hacking my emails, his behaviour was something I would not have thought him capable of. There was certainly moments I know he would have hit me only he is smart enough to know that would have been game over for his narrative of being 100% victim who was going to get 100% custody of our children. It was like something very primal and very dark was released. I know most here would probably say I deserved it but that is besides the point. The behaviour was still appalling, unpredictable and frightening for anyone around him.

Don’t think anyone would condone violence or frightening behaviour.

That’s the whole point – informing him of the affair wouldn’t justify violence any more than you having the affair would.

Blaming the messenger for a person’s violent reaction is as wrongheaded as blaming the cheater whose actions actually upset them.

FloweryName · 18/08/2023 14:20

Yes you should tell. It’s not your secret carry.

nameitagain · 18/08/2023 14:17

DoomsdayPrep · 18/08/2023 11:33

PS I have somewhat of a double standard on this. I might tell a woman her male partner was cheating, especially if he were gaslighting her.

My goal is to inhibit the multiple ways males abuse women. My husband cheated and gaslit me severely for 2 decades. Finding out the truth was traumatic but important for my liberation.

So for you, finding out the truth was liberating and a good thing but you won't extend this courtesy to others.

Swipe left for the next trending thread