Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Men in Comedy and Transgender People

179 replies

TroglodytesTroglodytes · 18/08/2023 09:29

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-66534454

Just been reading about Graham Linehan getting cancelled due to his opinions in the trans debate. At work, I listen to podcasts everyday day and a lot of these are UK or USA comedy podcast. It strikes me that so many of these comedians have an almost obsessive interest in the subject and bring it into every interview. I enjoy listening to these and I love GL’s work like Father Ted. I just don’t understand why these (mostly men) see it as such a main issue and keep going on about it. IRL I see the odd trans person and there are a couple of non-binary students that are at my children’s school. I may have had a discussion with people about trans a few times in the past five years. In my experience people have a passing interest but the experience of the people on these podcasts suggests that it is the most important issue. AIBU to think that most people are not bothered if a man wants to be known as she/her and transition? I just wonder why people like GL want to hold this particular issue up as a beacon for free speech.

Graham Linehan appeared on a small stage outside the Scottish Parliament

Graham Linehan: Father Ted writer holds gig at Scottish Parliament

Graham Linehan's Edinburgh show was cancelled over concerns about his views on transgender issues.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-66534454

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
Inertia · 18/08/2023 10:48

It’s not just about trans people .

There are huge safeguarding issues when previous identities are replaced, particularly when someone has a criminal conviction . Marking ‘misgendering’ and ‘deadnaming’ as hate crimes (which often carry threats of legal action) means that information relevant to safeguarding may be hidden. Police routinely release details of dangerous, clearly male suspects whom they describe as women-how are the public supposed to know who to be wary of?

It’s also a question of women’s rights. The erasure of the female sex class (as any man can simply identify into this category) has a profound impact on the safety of women and girls. Women and girls who need single-sex nursing or intimate care are told to accept men who say they are women. Men who say they are women (including those who have committed crimes against babies and children) are housed in women’s prisons with mother and baby units. Women have been raped and assaulted by male patients on hospital wards, then gaslighted by the hospital about only ‘female’ patients being on the ward.

If the protected characteristic of sex is eliminated, or if protections related to pregnancy and maternity are lost due to accusations of ‘biological essentialism’, women will face huge problems. Women make up over half the population- our rights and safety are not a trivial issue.

Elleherd · 18/08/2023 10:28

Possibly because comedy, farce and absurdism are closely related and it's a huge issue of the day where children are being taught feelings automatically overrule biology in schools, and natal women in sports and many other situations are being pushed down the ladder? Many comedians automatically go after whatever subject is the flavor of the day especially where farce is involved.

Possibly because there's a huge issue getting some police forces to pay attention to physical crime, yet some police forces are very keen to police women's speech? A goldmine for comedy writers.

In some cases possibly something to do with being painfully aware how certain convicted pedophiles (along with rapists) have been using 'new' trans status to hide their convictions, and being accused of libel for stating the truth?

It's neither libel nor slander when it's true, but twisting laws intended to protect trans people from hate crimes allows spurious claims that 'newname' person is being libeled if they're outed as having committed crimes against children under their old name.
I doubt most trans people want to be used in protecting pedophiles anymore than most gay men wanted to be used to protect them in the 70's when PIE attached themselves to gay rights.

I can't stand Father Ted so knew nothing about Graham Linehan until I did some looking deeper, But I can see why he in particular, might be a bit obsessive about that subject...

Most sensible people have little problem with simply 'a man wants to be known as she/her and transition.'

lightinthebox · 18/08/2023 10:23

It’s an easy target to get people angry about instead of focusing on actually important issues like cancer waiting times.

It’s to get people caring more about this than things like children’s education and funding. We can scrap funding for the NHS as longer as a political party ‘knows what a woman is’.

IRL no one obsesses over this issue.

Popsicle42 · 18/08/2023 10:07

He’s defending women’s rights. It is not as simple as a man wanting to be known as “she/her”. It is men demanding access to female only spaces, compete in female sports and other events, insisting on women being called “person with cervix” or “non-male”. It is also teenage girls wearing breast binders, children being encouraged to go through gender reassignment surgery, homosexuality being seen as transphobic.

I don’t have a problem respecting someone’s chosen pronouns. I do have a major problem with biological males competing against biological females or walking around female changing rooms with their penis out or entering a female-only rape crisis group.

Swipe left for the next trending thread