Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think British maternity care must be among the worst in the developed world?

628 replies

ForestGoblin · 18/08/2023 08:14

Nurses refusing to watch newborns when a mum needs to poo??? Nurses have got a professional and legal obligation to support patients to receive adequate personal care (not being compelled to poo yourself has got to be rung one of meeting that obligation).

Friends who have given birth in Ireland, france, south Korea, Switzerland were all given support to sleep, recover, be recognised as an injured person in need of recovery time.

British nurses trick new mothers into thinking they can't leave their babies for a minute on a bloody hospital ward (even when they've got numb legs).

Rise up, damnit!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
12
PuddlesPityParty · 18/08/2023 12:06

@Tippley that statistic is shocking! Shock

Daisymaybe60 · 18/08/2023 12:05

I’m so glad I had my children in the 80s. I could tell a few negative tales about the birth experience, but the post-natal care at our NHS hospital was excellent. We had the choice of staying in for 2 days or 5 (or 24 hours by the time I had DC3). The 8 bed wards were very strict, ruled over by a ward sister. Those who prefer freedom of choice, having their DP at their bedside etc would no doubt have hated it, but I wouldn’t have wanted it any other way, it felt safe and comforting. Baby gowns, nappies, bedding etc all provided. New mums were shown how to bath, change and feed their babies. We had 3 decent meals brought to our beds every day. Then tea and toast for supper with a bottle of stout if you were breastfeeding, lights out and babies wheeled into the nursery overnight, and brought to you if you were breast feeding or opted to bottle feed yourself (some even chose to sleep through and let the midwives do it). Yes, dads were sent home as soon as you left the labour ward, but you were looked after properly from then on by midwives - there didn’t seem to be any staff shortage. Visiting was strictly 4 to a bed for one hour each evening, and another hour for one visitor just before lunch. There was a strict nap time (on your tummies, ladies!) for an hour mid afternoon - you couldn’t opt out! We even had gentle exercise sessions each morning, with self care advice.

And if we needed the toilet or a shower, babies would stay in their cots by the bed. They were perfectly safe - they were in secure wards and the only people in there were other mums and always at least one nurse at the desk. Everything was kept spotless. I opted for the longest stay every time.

I’m sure I was lucky in that we had a really good hospital, but it infuriates me to read some of these stories. Women and newborn babies deserve the best of care.

Badbadbunny · 18/08/2023 12:03

Sorry, forgot, DS's care in SCBU for his first few days was brilliant - the midwives in there were so helpful, friendly, etc., which also extended to the HCAs and the receptionists. None of them could have done more. It was them who came up to the ward to wheel me down in a wheelchair to see him in his incubator, not the maternity ward staff! Funny how the SCBU midwives had time to do that, but the ward staff didn't!

DrasticAction · 18/08/2023 12:03

I really hope you alp register your complaints and probably with the rcm as well as fhe hospital via pals.

Sane other womens form this abuse

LittleMissUnreasonable · 18/08/2023 12:03

I've given birth in my home country (Eastern Europe) and it was a great standard of care but very matter of fact and no nonsense. You are properly looked after.

I've also given birth in England and remember feeling so sorry for a poor woman who was sat alone in the post natal ward unable to get any food. I didn't realise we were expected to get food ourselves, as I'd been in hospital before for a minor op and was treated far better. In the end when DH came to visit, he insisted on getting this woman some food as well and came back with enough for both of us. I feel so sorry for those who have noone with them when everyone else has partners/family/friends there and are basically left to their own devices.

TripleDaisySummer · 18/08/2023 12:02

I think part of the problem is that it is a complete postcode lottery.

Yes first nearly 18 years ago fantastic community MW care, great Mw care in midwife led unit at child new area community MW care was dire.

PND ward experience with first was dire - and had HB for next ones - had I a pfb that screamed if not being held by me - I had to leave her in cot at side of bed to go to the loo twice and was shouted at both times for leaving her. They gave me nothing post birth no drink no food np pain killers wasn't allowed to leave pfb but wasn't allowed into breakfast room with baby and no staff would hold her - I was so thirsty and hungry when DH was allowed back.

Only time I think I slept a nurse pulled back curtain shouted I didn't need pain killers and left curtain open - also had one male visitor leering at me trying to bf.

It was a horrible experience and next morning staff were much more pleasant than night shift but we had to wait and wait for some mysteries piece of paperwork - we had friend giving us a lift back - we don't drive - in end we just walked out no-one stopped us or questioned us.

I though poor care was because they were so busy - but DH said it was just us 4. I really felt for section twin Mum she had one with her she couldn't cope with and by time we left had gone 24 hours + being promise she could be wheeled down to see sick other twin still hadn't happened.

Recovery with HB much quicker and no bf issues at all.

MariaVT65 · 18/08/2023 12:01

redrighthand83 · 18/08/2023 11:53

Truly horrific to have given birth during Covid. C Section, twenty minutes in recovery and then I was dumped on postnatal alone holding a baby, sweat dripping in my eyes, unable to move, unable to reach the call bell, water, my phone. I ended up hysterically crying to a midwife when she walked past an hour later who moved some stuff about for me so I could at least reach a few essentials but I have never felt more terrified. I literally could not fucking move and I was meant to look after a baby I just gave birth to, with no support. Every single time I needed something, a pissy HCA would arrive to hand me a change bag while I tried to change a nappy with DD on my thighs.
I feel burning resentment when I hear about this supposed golden hour and mythical NHS tea and toast.

Sounds like we had very similar experiences and I really feel for you. Women were treated like animals during covid.

It’s also amazing to read just how many women on this thread had water left out of their reach after their c sections. Was the same of me and it’s crap reading so many other women have been denied this very basic care.

Badbadbunny · 18/08/2023 12:01

None of this is new. I had my son nearly 22 years ago and the maternity ward staff were terrible then, lots of them about, but absolutely zilch "care". I had a c-section. Everything up to giving birth was fine. The post-natal appointments, GP midwife appointments, being admitted early with problems, and then the actual C-section 5 weeks early. Couldn't fault any of it. But once on the ward, some of the midwives were horrible - and no, it wasn't because they were understaffed, they were just plain nasty and rude, no help at all, I'd ring the buzzer and they'd not come, even though I could see them gossiping around the nurses station! They made you feel a nuisance. Once I'd been discharged (escaped), and back under the care of the GP midwife, everything was fine again.

Sadly, I think there is some kind of nasty culture on maternity wards.

Wafflesandcrepes · 18/08/2023 12:00

What feels weird to me is that the doctors were equally busy (if not more) but were all so nice. They were also pissed off with the midwives’ attitude.

mumofteenss · 18/08/2023 12:00

Ive had 3 babies in NHS hospitals and all 3 were positive experiences. One of them the midwives actually looked after my baby as i had to leave the hospital for an hour for something completely out of my control and they supported me with that around breastfeeding and fast tracking our discharge as much as they possibly could.

The biggest negative was i was taken to the assessment clinic after my waters broke, i was in the waiting room when contractions started, my first 2 babies were very fast labours (both under 30 minutes) so i went to the desk and explained and i was sent back to the waiting room, my contractions were less than a minute apart and after 20 minutes i somehow walked back and said im about to have the baby, the begrudgingly took me through even though it wasnt my turn, and i had my baby almost as soon as i got my trousers off on the trolley in the clinic with 5 other women on the monitors, plus their partners/family/friends in the bay. But i guess that isnt a common occurrence of someone having a 25 minute labour!

But the post natal care was all excellent, all 3 were in the 2000's, one prem but not in NICU/SCBU cared for on the ward for 7 days who also had some other developmental problems the midwives supported me to cope with and understand, all vaginal deliveries, amazing breast feeding support with all 3.

I just wanted to add something positive for potential first time parents reading. I dont want to devalue to experiences of those who did have negative experiences and traumatic births.

DuvetCoverNightmare · 18/08/2023 11:59

For me it was just the lack of kindness and compassion. I understand they are busy but there is no excuse in my eyes that means you can be mean to someone who is at their most vulnerable.
I was sobbing in pain after an instrumental birth and the midwife said ‘well yes that’s what happens when you have an epidural’ as though it was some kind of failing on my part. She walked off btw without giving me any pain relief. My DH had to literally flag someone else down to sort it. I’ll never forget that MW for letting me down when I needed it.

On the flip side, a lovely maternity assistant came to see me in the morning. She helped me wash by the bed, helped me change and dress the baby. She showed me more kindness than anyone else I encountered the whole time I was there.

loislovesstewie · 18/08/2023 11:56

Mine are adults, when i gave birth the first time,the midwife came to the loo with me when I had to pass urine after the birth, she held the baby for me, in fact she tucked the baby inside her uniform next to her chest so he didn't cry. She stayed while I had a shower to ensure I was OK. By the time I had my second the midwife was more 'hands off', I was asked if I felt OK, I was physically checked but was not accompanied to the bathroom. At the time I thought it was solely because I had given birth once and was more confident. Now, I think there were other reasons, it's like they have attended at the birth and their job is done. Now I hear horror stories and TBH, I wonder what midwives feel their job entails. If they don't want to deal with blood,urine faeces, don't do the job. If they don't want to be dealing with women who are their most vulnerable then don't decide to be a midwife
BTW, I fully acknowledge that there are excellent midwives ,I just don't think there are enough .

Endo85 · 18/08/2023 11:55

Had C sections with both babies. First baby (2015) it wasn't too bad as we were in a side room (he had strep B) with bathroom and DP could stay during the day. Second baby (2021) during covid was awful as on ward for nearly a week, DP could only visit once for 30mins per day. Not enough staff to watch baby so I didn't shower the whole time time I was in there! In order to go to the toilet I had to wait until baby was sleeping run down the ward and then back again and hope he hadn't woken up, and they kept telling me I wasn't drinking enough water! I felt for them as there just wasn't enough staff, they did really help me with feeding and were v supportive in that respect (tongue tie).

Dolores87 · 18/08/2023 11:55

ForestGoblin · 18/08/2023 10:45

No. It is an assault. Quite a serious one. If it happened to me I would also sue for civil damages. But 999 is free. "I'm in x hospital in x town/city, I've just been sexually assaulted by a staff member on ward y, please send help."

Good luck win that. I was assaulted by staff, like I mean i was physically held down while a midwife inserted a catheter into my body touching my vulva without my consent while I was literally screaming and sobbing and telling them to stop.

Noone cared. Complaints team didn't acknowledge it. Couldnt find a lawyer who thought I had a case.
The police are not going to do anything for a midwife behaving like this.

RenegadeMrs · 18/08/2023 11:55

notahappybunny7 · 18/08/2023 11:52

Did you not have a relative to bring food in? I did 10 days in hospital once and didn’t eat a single thing they provided. Sobbing through hunger is a bit pathetic sorry!

Do you run a maternity ward? This level of compassion would explain the state we are in.

OoopsOhNo · 18/08/2023 11:55

@RenegadeMrs sounds like your experience had very, very similar vibes to mine. Just such a low point and (for me anyway) sort of set the tone about how I felt about myself as a mother. I think I was profoundly affected by my first bad experience but because no one died expected to suck it up and bury my feelings.

motherofbantams · 18/08/2023 11:54

ForestGoblin · 18/08/2023 08:31

I wonder how many british women go to give birth abroad now. Norway sounds nice.

I went to Sweden at 32 weeks pregnant - the immigration people asked to see my MatB1 form and return flight details to check I was not staying to give birth there!

Viviennemary · 18/08/2023 11:53

The NHS is a disgrace. But why would a new born need to be watched. Wouldn't the mum just put it in the crib.

redrighthand83 · 18/08/2023 11:53

Truly horrific to have given birth during Covid. C Section, twenty minutes in recovery and then I was dumped on postnatal alone holding a baby, sweat dripping in my eyes, unable to move, unable to reach the call bell, water, my phone. I ended up hysterically crying to a midwife when she walked past an hour later who moved some stuff about for me so I could at least reach a few essentials but I have never felt more terrified. I literally could not fucking move and I was meant to look after a baby I just gave birth to, with no support. Every single time I needed something, a pissy HCA would arrive to hand me a change bag while I tried to change a nappy with DD on my thighs.
I feel burning resentment when I hear about this supposed golden hour and mythical NHS tea and toast.

notahappybunny7 · 18/08/2023 11:52

Piranhaha · 18/08/2023 10:27

You don't need a qualified MW to watch your baby while you go to the bathroom or to bring your breakfast to you. It's a secure unit and your baby is tagged. MW's aren't waitresses or care assistants.
But there are no care assistants. So who’s going to help new mums and bring them food? The midwife is the only person there!

I had an agonising labour followed by a c section and couldn’t eat for over 24 hours. Afterwards I was stuck in bed, still paralysed from the waist down with a catheter in, and desperately hungry. The midwives refused to bring me any food because it was 10pm. Told me to wait till breakfast! Then told me off because I was sobbing with hunger and saying I was going to pass out.

At breakfast they had nothing I could eat - I have a wheat allergy which they were informed about when I arrived at hospital the previous day. They took my catheter out and told me to walk to the shop - but I couldn’t take my baby and they wouldn’t look after her for me. By lunchtime, when the trolley came round yet again with no wheat-free food, I collapsed and fainted. Then they finally took action and gave me a sugary drink - but no food. A CLEANER took pity on me and brought me a microwave meal.

When the doctor came round to discharge me, he was going to keep me in because I’d fainted. I told him I’d fainted because of lack of food, and begged him to discharge me so I could get a proper meal. Made a formal complaint but nothing ever got done.

Did you not have a relative to bring food in? I did 10 days in hospital once and didn’t eat a single thing they provided. Sobbing through hunger is a bit pathetic sorry!

Hayley0203 · 18/08/2023 11:51

Ozziedream · 18/08/2023 11:48

london maternity care is horrendous. First birth the doctors were awesome but the post natal “care” was so abysmal I went private for the next birth just for the private room. Extreme but I avoided the PTSD (diagnosed) after the abuse in the post natal ward.

I’ve lived a lot abroad and also had other non-obstetric hospital procedures in the UK. I think if you haven’t had much experience with hospitals, especially I’d you’ve never experienced another developed country’s medical system, you’re unlikely to realise just how DIRE maternity “care” in the UK is.

Where did you go, if you don't mind sharing? I'm due my third in 7 months and also live in London! Was considering going abroad again but would be great not to have to leave the country.

RenegadeMrs · 18/08/2023 11:50

OoopsOhNo · 18/08/2023 11:22

When I had my first baby I was young and had a traumatic birth. In the night my husband wasn't allowed to stay, I hadn't slept for a few days and baby was crying constantly. I started to cry and asked a midwife to help and she just said "well what on earth did you think it was going to be like?" and walked away. I think how ashamed and vulnerable I felt from her unkindness will stick with me forever.

Diffierent circumstances, but I have a very similar story. I wasn't young, but my first baby arrived after a placenta previa bleed and c-section. So a little dramatic. Because of this, and concerns about estabilishing feeding of my baby born at 36w I was in the hospital for 5 days. No fathers allowed over night (they were actually only allowed in the ward for 8 hours of the day), and I was on a 3 hour feeding and pumping schedule, 24 hours of the day. So I hadn't slept more than 1.5 hours at a time for about 3 days. I'd lost a fair amount of blood. Wasn't confident getting in and out the bed because I'd had a c-section and was generally run down after no sleep for 3 days following surgery. I asked for help settling the baby in the middle of the night (with tears running down my face because I was exhusted) and got 'what do you want me to do about it'. Baby was screaming and I was in a communal ward. I felt I was distrubing every one and failing at mothering, 3 days in. I remember it as one of the lowest moments of my life.

Jk987 · 18/08/2023 11:50

Hold on a minute. I'm sorry if this happened to you but it doesn't represent every hospital in the UK!

Ozziedream · 18/08/2023 11:48

london maternity care is horrendous. First birth the doctors were awesome but the post natal “care” was so abysmal I went private for the next birth just for the private room. Extreme but I avoided the PTSD (diagnosed) after the abuse in the post natal ward.

I’ve lived a lot abroad and also had other non-obstetric hospital procedures in the UK. I think if you haven’t had much experience with hospitals, especially I’d you’ve never experienced another developed country’s medical system, you’re unlikely to realise just how DIRE maternity “care” in the UK is.

Moonrising · 18/08/2023 11:48

I didn't experience anything like you've described OP. And even better it's free! Had lots of appointments, felt listened to, they picked up my diabetes, referred me for mental health , and looked after me and my newborn when I was in hospital for nearly 2 weeks.