Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dd, 5, asking for a phone

145 replies

Whatisgoingonhey · 17/08/2023 22:09

Sort of inspired by another thread on here about Tik Tok & teens.
Just curious to know how much access your child has to the internet/phones etc.
Dd is 5 and has an outdoorsy type of life, we live next to the woods, so take our dog for lots of walks, we can walk to the beach, she goes to the pool, playgrounds etc
She watched some tv-CBeebies (although it feels as though she’s growing out of this?) shows on kids Netflix & Disney plus.
She recently wanted to watch lots of YouTube (Dh watches it) slime or cat videos etc, it’s pretty harmless, but I don’t like the speed of it all and it just doesn’t seem right for a 5 year old, so we have a lock on YouTube now.
She doesn’t have an iPad, although is desperate for headphones (I don’t know what she’d use them with though?)
She occasionally can play kids games on my phone.
This week she cried for a phone! At 5 🤷🏻‍♀️
Her neighbour friend (6) has his mums old iPhone.
She’s definitely not getting one until older, just was shocked that she was so upset to not have a phone.
What technology/tv etc does your child have of a similar age?
Tbh I hate all of it

OP posts:
Gmary20 · 19/08/2023 19:25

This is an easy one, no. Smartphones are bad for children's development, mental health and expose them to innapropriate content from a young age. Let her cry and stick to your guns, your doing right by herb in the end.

Sugarfree23 · 19/08/2023 18:59

@LucifersPain thats very controlling for a NT 16 yo, less than 2 years they'll be a fully grown adult.
You need to help them navigate the adult world.

Notamum12345577 · 19/08/2023 18:39

LucifersPain · 17/08/2023 22:22

When my young un was a toddler he used my then current iPhone for games.

They don’t need their own phone until about 10 imho. But even then when had own iphone no social media and pretty locked down so could only use certain apps.

Now 16 and no tik-tok,facebook, instagram or whatsapp type garbage - doesn’t need or want it either.

Your 16 year old probably does want Instagram and WhatsApp etc! WhatsApp is just the same as texting though, apart from you can do groups?

HowAmYa · 19/08/2023 17:51

My DD is 5. She has no tech.
Every Saturday morning shes allowed to play Kiddopeia on my tablet. That's pretty much it. I don't allow her to watch YouTube. It's full of junk. She doesn't use or ask for my phone. Sometimes she will want to watch cat videos so I'll show her some funny cat vids on insta. That's about it.

Don't give in. My DD plays up about it ONLY when she sees her cousins glued to a device. Otherwise she isn't bothered

ForeverShark · 19/08/2023 00:11

7yo DSD has a fire tablet, similar to PP it’s picked up for half an hour every couple of weeks. Switch for car journeys (45 minute commute home from school) which gets used for an hour or so on some weekends.
14yo DS has a phone but no social media, was a rule of ours but he now has no interest. Had WhatsApp but it caused him trouble with group chats and bullying so scrapped it.
The longer you can hold out the better with phones, a tablet can provide all the necessary functions she could want a phone for.

Thesenderofthiscard · 18/08/2023 23:54

That’s an easy no! 11 for both kids with MAJOR restrictions around usage, tim, apps and they have no social
media

Premfove · 18/08/2023 23:46

My 5&6yo's mostly watch Netflix/Disney and are obsessed with Audio books so have unlimited access to a tonie box/cds and sometimes use headphones for this. The headphones are a novelty that they seem to love 🤷‍♀️

I have an iPad that I never use that my 6yo discovered a year or two ago and begged for but I held firm, delay it for as much as you can. It is of no real benefit to them at this age. Some parents say it's great for journeys/restaurants etc. but assuming there's no additional needs, I think it's best to teach DC the skills to deal with these situations so I make them wait/play games such as ispy etc.

Our school operates a "parent pact" where the parents agree not to buy their DC a phone until secondary school. It's worked great so far apparently. I'm hoping that will still be the case when mine are that age 🤞🏼

ALongHardWinter · 18/08/2023 23:34

Good grief! A phone for a 5 year old? Absolutely no way!

Shivshav · 18/08/2023 23:23

No not unreasonable. My daughter however has a hand me down kindle fire. Has a kids account with plenty of safeguarding features. Doesn't allow online purchases or app downloads without your consent. My daughter is 4 for context. So maybe I'll have that to come. But she'll definitely not be having a phone for quite a few years.

PalomaPalomaPaloma · 18/08/2023 17:36

If she asked for a pony would you consider giving her one? My point is that just because she's asking doesn't mean that you need to feel that she should have one. Five year olds tend to want lots of things.

user8665438 · 18/08/2023 17:33

5yo has an iPad with headphones. Fairly unrestricted access to YT Kids, but she is sensible with her time on there.

PollyPut · 18/08/2023 16:40

The videos are not good for her brain or concentration. Stop it, now. Is she reading yet? Get her into books and things to improve her concentration

Sprogonthetyne · 18/08/2023 16:25

My 6yo has a table, but he gets school transport for 30-40 minutes each way, and it makes things easier for escort if he's occupied when there's 3 young boy being silly in a confined space.

He watches some you-tube on the main TV (not his tablet), but he asks for what he wants then I find it for him, so have some control. What comes us as suggested is based on what's been watched recently, so if your careful what go's on for a few weeks, then the algorithm adapts, and you get more suitable suggestions.

FlamingYam · 18/08/2023 16:21

@Sugarfree23 isn't it crazy how quickly things change! Really does make you think when faced with it in that way! It wasn't long ago that we still used CDs and had to go to the bank with cash rather than a transfer. Crazy.

fivelilducks · 18/08/2023 16:02

We got ds a tablet at 3 and sort of regretted it. He became a bit obsessed so we had many tantrums related to it. It would have been way easier not having it, although handy for long drives or long boring meals out.

stayathomer · 18/08/2023 15:45

The problem with the tech isn't the tech itself but being given it alone or for too long. If you can monitor it carefully and not let it get out of hand it's a great tool and something they'll have to be able to use at school.
This is it really, isn't it, the holy grail-for them to be able to use screens without it being all they think about, and then to get used to using technology to help them but still having a 'real life' where they think about the friends and family, the outdoors, animals, sports, life really!!!

stayathomer · 18/08/2023 15:41

I/m not sure you can compare phones to tablets? You crane your neck and have to focus more for a phone. The rays from both are bad for you, but it's nothing like leaning over a mobile phone-look at the way your children look at a phone. When you think of it our parents used to think tv was bad-at least that was the other side of the room!

Sugarfree23 · 18/08/2023 15:11

@FlamingYam
I hear you I have a 12yo, and no we didn't have old phones kicking around to be used as mini tablets when he was 5 or 6 either.

But now so many people have old phones lying around, especially if they get them on two year contracts. Why wouldn't a 5yo use one to stream music instead of a tablet?

RidingMyBike · 18/08/2023 14:26

7yo. Allowed 30 mins a week on a parents' laptop to play CBBC games but no access to phones or tablets. Don't let her watch YouTube

Watches TV each day (CBBC) for probably an hour (school days) or 1-2 hours (school hols).

FlamingYam · 18/08/2023 14:03

DD is 11 to put timing into perspective. I'm not 100% sure how old she was when we got the tablet. I'd say less than 5.

FlamingYam · 18/08/2023 14:02

@Sugarfree23 I see you're point and completely agree that the word phone is causing discrepancies.

A potential drip feed but I think it was just the timing. Smartphones were relatively new if I recall. I only had an iPhone 5 myself at the time and wouldn't have purchased a phone especially for a five year old at that time but with how cheap and accessible they are now, in comparison, I would. She had my old phone when she did have one so was more about availability than one being better than the other - the phone going from sim free to having data and social apps available is more relevant.

cakecoffeecakecoffee · 18/08/2023 13:38

DD8 and DS4 both have iPads …. they are DHs old ones from when he’s upgraded.

Neither has unrestricted access to it and they have parental controls on to limit what can be accessed.

I don’t mind them spending a bit of time on them as long as they do plenty of other things too.

no way are they having phones, they don’t need them and we don’t have any old ones lying about.

Sugarfree23 · 18/08/2023 13:37

FlamingYam · 18/08/2023 10:38

I'm very much in the "technology is great for kids" camp but I think 5 is on the young side for a phone.

At that age, my DD had a heavily protected iPad. It was expensive but was worth its weight in gold for car journeys, meals when they got too much and just fun games/happy learning. Get the right apps and it opens a whole exciting world for them. That even includes those stupid egg opening videos. Really helped my DDs vocabulary.

I think she got a phone at 8/9 and a sim in that phone at 9/10.

Guard what they do, no communication to unknowns and even friends and family friends, watch what's said. You never know!

I'm confused by your logic, ipad at 5 and sim-less phone at 8/9. Yet not a phone at 5.

What can kids do on a sim-less phone they can't do on a ipad?

I actually think people are falling over the word 'phone' without stopping to think it's really just a small pocket sized tablet. Bit like Ipod touches were a thing back in the day.

Yellowlegobrick · 18/08/2023 13:31

6 & 4 yo each have a yoto player and headphones, with music & stories on it.

We own two amazon fire tablets which notionally belong to DH and I but which the children are occasionally allowed to use. Its rare. Car/plane journeys.

Eldest is occasionally allowed to play a game or 2 on house pc with strict supervision for 30 mins - racing, sports or construction type games, zero fighting. Once per week only and has to be earned by doing school homework etc without being nagged.

30 mins of tv per day. Nothing with any ads in.

Youtube and tiktok etc they do not know exist.

prescribingmum · 18/08/2023 13:20

Sirzy · 18/08/2023 11:03

Supervised watching of it for a set amount of time may be better than a complete no. By putting a complete block on it you’re making it something more and more appealing.

Allowing any form of access just made things worse in our case, it’s just too addictive and they want more and more. The solution was a complete stop for the entire family. One good thing about them being young is they forget quickly after a few days as long as we aren’t using it either.

We are more than 3 years on now and I will use for a specific video but they still do not have access to control it themselves and they don’t complain

Swipe left for the next trending thread