Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder whether having kids makes you "better"?

144 replies

Finlesswonder · 17/08/2023 21:23

I don't have kids.

My mum said she was so scatty and forgetful until she had kids and then she couldn't "afford" to be anymore.

I'm wondering whether kids can make you "better" in a sense, for example if you're a panicky or anxious person, did having kids make you be "forced" to relax a little more or get out of your own head, if you were lazy before them did having them force you to be more active, etc? Or is it more usual for it to be the other way around, can having kids "worsen" unhelpful traits?

OP posts:
Ifeelsuchflutterings · 18/08/2023 09:48

FourTeaFallOut · 18/08/2023 07:40

I really like being a parent, it's one of life's big adventures that brings me an enormous amount of satisfaction. I'm not sure it has whittled me into a better person - beyond honing skills around caring and organising.

Although, that doesn't mean that I don't Believe it can be transformative. I mean, it would have been uncontroversial if the op had said she had taken up yoga/meditation/ journaling/ travelling and it had given her a space to become a better person. But the idea that motherhood could have done that is met with a wave of distain and accusations of internalized misogyny. MN is weird.

It's not that you're horribly selfish before yoga, you just don't need to put anything or anyone before your own needs until you do yoga

I have no idea if the op thinks this but there seems to be a lot of thought going into people choosing not to do yoga and running instead, saying they are happy about it but a lot of posts about being a runner and how wonderful it is, do they need to convince themselves

I have four female friends who dont do yoga and as they've got older all have become really quite self absorbed (we are 45-50)

Being a parent may be transformative. Saying that you don't put anyone else's needs first, you are self absorbed and you have to convince yourself that you are happy without children isnt quite the same thing though is it.

Give0fecks · 18/08/2023 09:08

@WibblyWobblyTimeyWimeyStuff Sorry I genuinely don’t get what you meant by your comment. Oh the irony 🤣

Boomchuck · 18/08/2023 09:06

The thing about parenting is that you only get one chance to get it right, and it’s a person’s actual childhood you’re responsible for, so the pressure to get it right feels enormous. That pressure has made me more responsible and efficient at getting things done, but it has also made me more anxious and neurotic (not helped by a decade of sleep deprivation). I wouldn’t say I’m better, I’m just different.

Morewineplease10 · 18/08/2023 07:54

No. I'm so exhausted, nearly all of the time and that's impacted everything.

The only thing I can think of is that I'm more patient but as I was very impatient before that's not saying much!

I've lost my sleeping powers, I worry more, feel anxious etc. I've had some really harsh things happen in the last 13 years and now I just feel afraid for my kids.

And I'm definitely not more organised either! 😑

FourTeaFallOut · 18/08/2023 07:40

I really like being a parent, it's one of life's big adventures that brings me an enormous amount of satisfaction. I'm not sure it has whittled me into a better person - beyond honing skills around caring and organising.

Although, that doesn't mean that I don't Believe it can be transformative. I mean, it would have been uncontroversial if the op had said she had taken up yoga/meditation/ journaling/ travelling and it had given her a space to become a better person. But the idea that motherhood could have done that is met with a wave of distain and accusations of internalized misogyny. MN is weird.

MephistophelesApprentice · 18/08/2023 07:36

Ha! No.

Evidence: my mother.

Tumbleweed101 · 18/08/2023 07:26

If you have certain traits then having children just forces you to bury them a little but they are still there. Many of my traits are returning now mine are pretty much grown because I don't have to be so focused on the needs of others as I have been for the past 25years.

GrannyWeatherwaxsHatpin · 18/08/2023 07:16

WibblyWobblyTimeyWimeyStuff · 17/08/2023 23:28

It may make you a better person, or it may not @Finlesswonder , but most people will vote YABU on here, because for some reason despite this being MUMSNET, there seems to be a high density of posters who aren't keen on children - or mums!

Anyone with half a brain would see that MN has long since moved on from being “just” a parenting site. There’s a lot of content here that’s not remotely related to children or parenting, and there’s even a Childfree Mumsnetters board.

RecklessBlackberries · 18/08/2023 07:05

Not better than other people, but a better version of myself, yes. The biggest way is that I'm caring more about my health and taking control of my eating habits, as I both want to be around to see more of my son's life and don't want to embarrass him.

I plan for the future more, and temper my every day behaviour based on those plans. We budget more carefully and protect our savings more from casual spending. I get out the house more and talk to a broader range of people, and I'm getting to know a lot more people in our village. I'm also vastly more organised both in terms of completing tasks but also balancing mental load.

I'm definitely not perfect, but I'm better than I was and for me personally that motivation wasn't coming from anywhere until I had my son.

CaptainJackSparrow85 · 18/08/2023 06:58

Thewallsof · 17/08/2023 22:11

In my opinion a lot of parents might put the kids and immediate family first and be giving or organised for them or whatever. But honestly I think it makes you more selfish or less considerate to everyone else. I'm sure this isn't a popular opinion and many will say that's absolutely not the case for them...

I also think in many cases where parents need to be mega on it will all the child admin and organisation it means they have less headspace and time for the other areas which require this organisation.

No, I think you’re right and I was thinking this as I read the first few posts. I think having children has made me less selfish in the sense that my own needs take a back seat, but much more selfish in a broader sense. For example, before having kids I volunteered and donated to charity which I can’t do now because I don’t have the money or time. And I’m less generous with gifts to friends and family because I’ve got less money and the money I do have I’d rather use for the children.

toddlermom99 · 18/08/2023 06:36

After signing the consent forms for my baby's leg amputation - alone as a 21 year old single mother - I realised in that moment that motherhood gave me a strength and resilience that I didn't even know I had.

MissTrip82 · 18/08/2023 00:53

Two of the most selfish, self-absorbed people I’ve ever met were the mothers of four children each.

If you were an arsehole before you had a baby, you’ll be an arsehole afterwards. The normal biological imperative to make something that comes from you live is not remotely unselfish.

I have children.

Beezknees · 18/08/2023 00:49

I think it just depends on the person.

Having a child did change me for the better. I was young and quite self destructive. When I found out I was pregnant I stopped drink and drugs, and left my abusive partner. I don't think I would have if I hadn't got pregnant.

Having somebody else relying on me to take care of them was a big wake up call.

brokenlore · 18/08/2023 00:45

Na I don't think it changes you. If your a selfless person you'll remain a selfless person, if you're a selfish person you remain a selfish person. If you have a tendency to being forgetful, you'll more than likely become even more forgetful because not only do you have more to remember but you'll get constant interruptions. If you already struggle to do things on time, or get out the door on time, that's likely to get even harder...coz you can guarantee that toothlessly smiling gurgling little cuddle buddy, with fill a nappy just as you step out the door, or if a toddler they'll decide they'd rather do something else and have a tantrum which the whole neighbourhood can hear!
Na on reflection being a parent not only makes you public enemy No 1 and everyone will judge you whatever your parenting style, but also complicates life in unimaginable ways!

fitzwilliamdarcy · 18/08/2023 00:13

Finlesswonder · 18/08/2023 00:08

@fitzwilliamdarcy
That's not what this thread is about

I know - I’m sorry that it’s been diverted.

Ifeelsuchflutterings · 18/08/2023 00:11

Finlesswonder · 18/08/2023 00:08

@fitzwilliamdarcy
That's not what this thread is about

But it is the direction its gone in, and the fun thing about Internet forums is sometimes they can divert from the original topic

Finlesswonder · 18/08/2023 00:08

@fitzwilliamdarcy
That's not what this thread is about

OP posts:
fireflyloo · 18/08/2023 00:08

There's no one answer to that question.

I work in a role where I meet lots of families. Children can have an amazing positive impact on an adults life but for others it can tip them over the edge.

So many variables and depends on the internal and external resources available, e.g. mental health, a loving partner, the number of children, wider family support, finances, career etc.

For me I'm fortunate that I did make a conscious decision to have one. I was ready emotionally, physically, financially and so far it's worked out well and we're happy. I don't think my dc has made me a better person or less selfish. They have added to my life and I grew more love.

Fiddlesticks24 · 17/08/2023 23:56

(I Ike children and mums btw, but voted yabu for the reasons above)

Fiddlesticks24 · 17/08/2023 23:54

I have become far more scatter brained and forgetful (due to lack of sleep). And far more "selfish" in that my priority is my family and not my (public sector) job or anything else. I'm less vain (no time to care) but that's about it.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 17/08/2023 23:51

I think it’s inherently misogynistic to suggest that a certain class of women is inherently better than another.

Ifeelsuchflutterings · 17/08/2023 23:49

hopsalong · 17/08/2023 23:44

'I'm so fucking sick of this misogynist trope that you're a selfish person if you don't have kids.'

I'm sick of the misuse of the words:
a) misogynist (I agree that this is a poor idea, but what is specifically women-hating about it?)
b) trope (it doesn't mean idea, it means figurative language).

I think in some ways it is mysoginistic though because its a thing that's used against women

Men tend to get less judgemental comments about being childfree, but also are not seen as being "better" to the same extent for having children

Therefore when the whole "childfree women are selfish" thing is trotted out, but "childfree men are selfish" isn't, then there is potentially some ingrained misogyny behind that

Maybe it's something around women being expected to be the carers, the homemakers, the nuturers. And then women who choose to be childfree go against that societal expectation. And are penalised by being called selfish (and this is a frequent word I see used in conjunction with childfree people)

So I think in some ways it is mysoginistic

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 17/08/2023 23:48

Witchcraftandhokum · 17/08/2023 21:54

It forces you to behave a different way. Be less selfish. Care more about their future.

I'm so fucking sick of this misogynist trope that you're a selfish person if you don't have kids.

Me too.

Kids are more likely to be abused and killed by their parents than by anyone else.

See also "killed by mum's boyfriend du jour."

Not to mention neglect, emotionally toxic situations, shitty blended families and other ills.

hopsalong · 17/08/2023 23:44

'I'm so fucking sick of this misogynist trope that you're a selfish person if you don't have kids.'

I'm sick of the misuse of the words:
a) misogynist (I agree that this is a poor idea, but what is specifically women-hating about it?)
b) trope (it doesn't mean idea, it means figurative language).

fitzwilliamdarcy · 17/08/2023 23:43

Ifeelsuchflutterings · 17/08/2023 23:38

The downside to the mums are better, more selfless etc rhetoric is it can sometimes feel like society is denying your abuse

Because how can your mum simultaneously be a perfect, better, selfless human being, and be the person who abused you

Some mothers are absolutely fucking wonderful, some are average (in a good way) and some are utterly awful. And it doesnt help the children of the awful ones to pretend that all mothers are wonderful.

Absolutely this. I had to have a lot of therapy on this exact point. I’m so sorry for what you’ve gone through.

Swipe left for the next trending thread