Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Healthy, not healthy, the internet is insane!

39 replies

TangledTeabags · 17/08/2023 18:03

I was just googling recent opinions on the health benefits of coffee (I don't drink it much) and discovered a landslide of contradictory results. One saying coffee is great, it contains a plethora of antioxidants, can prevent diabetes, cancer, etc. Next result says no, it raises cholesterol and is bad for the heart. Even decaf.
Next thing, apparently cholesterol (and trans fats) do not affect the heart, then all the way back to Ancel Keys and his 'butter clogs arteries' mantra.

I doubt there is any rational, measured info left on the internet. It seems every writer, influencer or publication has it's/their own bias, it is quite dizzying!

I'm not hung up about food and eat a good diet, but you can guarantee that the incessant levels of analysis online will tie anyone in knots. If you attempt to locate a thorough source, it will usually inform you that, whilst there are correlations to such and such, the jury is still out.

There is a lot of talk that the NHS and other health bodies provide outdated guidance, which I dare say is true, but it does leave the doors wide open for snake oil influencers, which many people blindly trust. And is it surprising since avoiding fats have not quite had the result Mr keys was expecting..?

A lot of us complain about the amount of crazy cure-alls touted online by dubious sources, I can sort of see how we ended up this way considering how confusing and conflicting all of the data out there is.

I love the mediterranean diet personally, it's my favourite, but I might be a fool to imagine Mr Mosley isn't just another potential profiteer in a time of global confusion and fear.

I have no idea what's what, so I opt for moderation and just hope for the best Grin

OP posts:
BarbaraofSeville · 19/08/2023 07:53

How much of this 'research' is evidence based, reproducible, scientifically robust and peer reviewed?

Anyone can write anything on the internet that may sound plausible to the lay person but won't stack up to robust scientific study.

Read scientific papers in published journals if you want to know what is most likely to be correct.

Which in many cases will lead you to 'whilst there are correlations to such and such, the jury is still out' because often, that's all anyone can say because it can take years/decades to reach a definitive conclusion.

So anyone telling you that X will cause Y and/or prevent Z is often deluding themselves and/or their audience.

KimberleyClark · 19/08/2023 07:08

Surely the best thing is to eat a balanced diet with not too much of anything. And ignore the extreme throw out the fruit bowl keto nonsense.

Tartareistasty · 19/08/2023 07:01

It's really bad and confusing but sometimes it get quite hilarious seing what someone confident onlin ecan make people do.
Do you remember famous people drinking their own piss or something like that?

My best healthy diet started when I ignored everything and eat what made my body and mind feel good. 🤷 That includes all types of food including pizza

Nevermay · 19/08/2023 01:21

I recommend "Why we eat too much" by Andrew Jenkinson

It is a summary of much of the current research on diet, all reliable quality sources, all checkable, and none of the snake oil and quackery

TangledTeabags · 19/08/2023 01:14

@BertieBotts excellent comment!

There doesn't seem to be any ultimate mapping of which additives and ingredients are 'bad' as yet though, apart form the more obvious ones which get the most press.
Impacts on long and even short term health will likely depend upon which are consumed and in what quantity over time.

Like I mentioned up thread about my dusted cod steaks - are the diphosphates going to harm me if I ate that food only twice per week? Who knows! I am aware that they are supposed to be harmful to people with kidney issues, and can also affect the general population negatively over time, but they DON'T tell us in what quantity.

@Escapefromhell Ha, I'm sure I noticed a couple of conflicting front pages a few yrs ago; one announcing that the Brits get too much sun and melanoma is escalating, then another a few weeks later saying Brits don't get out in the sun enough, that is why we are depressed!
They do love the word 'Brits' don't they? (not a fan of the dm!).

OP posts:
CallieQ · 18/08/2023 00:11

Agree.. now olive oil is no good as too processed 🙄

MedSchoolRat · 17/08/2023 23:36

It's my job to evaluate health evidence. I pity people trying to do it who haven't been trained. We have a whole set of rules for how we evaluate.

fwiw, al substances are harmful in the wrong exposure & (probably) all substances have a safe exposure threshold, can be safe.

The "Eat mostly plants, not too much" advice is pretty good.

BertieBotts · 17/08/2023 23:13

I think this has always been the case but it is easier to see the madness now as you can call up hundreds of different answers in seconds. Whereas previously as people have said you had one Daily Mail article one week and a contradictory one the next week but you wouldn't see both of them sitting alongside each other.

I find it makes a lot of sense if there is an area that you are interested in the actual research developments on to find an expert or a publication that you trust, and just listen to what they say and tune out all the noise from other sources. In the beginning when you're searching for that expert it can help to look through all the conflicting opinions as you will generally start to see some things that repeat and repeat and repeat and there is generally (not always!) some truth in those or they are the ones with the most accepted evidence. Often there are two "camps" and they advocate for conflicting things. But it helps to get it down from 100 different views to two. Then you can start to search for "debunked" etc.

Amy Brown has a great book called Informed Is Best which is how to understand/interpret research studies and evidence if you are not scientifically trained.

Escapefromhell · 17/08/2023 23:07

It is utterly bonkers, but nothing new. Years ago someone did a study on the Daily Mail. They compiled a list of things that the Daily Mail said were causes of cancer, and a list of things that cured cancer (according to the Daily Mail). There was a third list. Things that the Daily Mail had, at some point claimed to both cause and cure cancer.

TangledTeabags · 17/08/2023 23:03

So true, I doubt anyone is going to get rich encouraging us into moderation!

It’s partly because science has evolved, partly because ‘science’ can’t agree as there are so many variables and partly because some fads are marketed/go viral so get more eye balls.
This makes a lot of sense, I agree.

Don't like the idea of a meal replacement tablet though (if that's what you meant - just imagine how joyless that would be...good food being oh so pleasurable!

I eat tons of fresh salad and veg, a decent amount of fibre, and tend to cook from scratch, but recently caved in and bought some Young's frozen dusted cod steaks. OMG they are delicious, a perfect accompaniment to a crisp salad with a lemon and mustard dressing. The only problematic ingredient in there was a diphosphate, although I am not so sure how harmful that would be if eaten twice per week alongside a good diet. I am not a fan of meat and good quality fish never tasted this good - shame:(

OP posts:
Vegetus · 17/08/2023 19:57

Nutrition is full of quacks. It's not very sexy to be mainstream with nuanced takes because it doesn't sell or catch anyone's attention.

Far better to demonise food group for the old bank balance and Instagram clout.

Pedants · 17/08/2023 19:40

It’s partly because science has evolved, partly because ‘science’ can’t agree as there are so many variables and partly because some fads are marketed/go viral so get more eye balls.

I’m inclined to go with Mosley on this, but I also follow the everything in moderation diet. I eat high welfare/quality meat and don’t eat a lot of processed meals (snacks yes). That’s because we like cooking and cater for a few different allergies so easier to cook from scratch anyway. I drink most days too.

Honestly my view is until someone creates a meal supplement tablet that’s perfectly designed for each one of us with the exact nutrients and minerals, being sensible most days is the way to go. And some exercise.

TangledTeabags · 17/08/2023 19:32

The conflicting research has exploded though - according to the Blue Zones website, which champions longevity and the Med diet, they says eggs sit around spreading bad bacteria in the gut. It can make your head spin. However, I go by the evidence that eggs are unlikely to shorten life, so will carry on with my 2 per week!

There seems to be a permanent squabble online between plant vs. meat. Exclusionary diets are still on the increase, with many individuals claiming almost miracle cures from IBS, acne, poor concentration, etc.

Problem is, it isn't the same for us all - if I go very low carb I feel rough. If I eat too much fat or cook in oil I get indigestion. We are all so different. On the other hand, I bloat from pasta and bread, but am fine eating rice.

OP posts:
PollyCreo · 17/08/2023 18:41

Remember when they told us in the 80s that eggs were unhealthy - they didn't know then that there was good and bad cholesterol? Remember Rosemary Conley's low fat nonsense from the 90s?

Advice is much more sensible now, sugar is bad and fat is good (although my mother still loves her low fat diet spread on her toast 🤮) I agree with caffeine though, five cups of coffee a day prevents dementia and I'm sticking to that ☕

Swipe left for the next trending thread