Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Healthy, not healthy, the internet is insane!

39 replies

TangledTeabags · 17/08/2023 18:03

I was just googling recent opinions on the health benefits of coffee (I don't drink it much) and discovered a landslide of contradictory results. One saying coffee is great, it contains a plethora of antioxidants, can prevent diabetes, cancer, etc. Next result says no, it raises cholesterol and is bad for the heart. Even decaf.
Next thing, apparently cholesterol (and trans fats) do not affect the heart, then all the way back to Ancel Keys and his 'butter clogs arteries' mantra.

I doubt there is any rational, measured info left on the internet. It seems every writer, influencer or publication has it's/their own bias, it is quite dizzying!

I'm not hung up about food and eat a good diet, but you can guarantee that the incessant levels of analysis online will tie anyone in knots. If you attempt to locate a thorough source, it will usually inform you that, whilst there are correlations to such and such, the jury is still out.

There is a lot of talk that the NHS and other health bodies provide outdated guidance, which I dare say is true, but it does leave the doors wide open for snake oil influencers, which many people blindly trust. And is it surprising since avoiding fats have not quite had the result Mr keys was expecting..?

A lot of us complain about the amount of crazy cure-alls touted online by dubious sources, I can sort of see how we ended up this way considering how confusing and conflicting all of the data out there is.

I love the mediterranean diet personally, it's my favourite, but I might be a fool to imagine Mr Mosley isn't just another potential profiteer in a time of global confusion and fear.

I have no idea what's what, so I opt for moderation and just hope for the best Grin

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Tartareistasty · 20/08/2023 16:58

Yeah he is. I looked at it once and it's a mishmash of diets. Fast, low cal, low carb and whatnot.
This bit from wiki is quite something
"On the programme Mosley asserted that people can lose a stone in 21 days by calorie restriction to only 800 calories a day. This advice is considered dangerous by medical experts and the programme received a backlash on social media platforms.[11] Beat, a UK charity supporting those affected by eating disorders, stated that "the programme caused enough stress and anxiety to our beneficiaries that we extended our Helpline hours to support anyone affected and received 51% more contact during that time".[12]"

verdantverdure · 20/08/2023 16:51

Is Michael Mosley that very low calorie diet extremist? Like 800 calories? When even toddlers need more than that?

Not a fan.

Tartareistasty · 20/08/2023 16:44

I went old style a bit and it worked wonders for my intestines as someone who has ibs like symptoms during high periods of stress.
Proper bread, proper bone broth, fermented food are the biggest changes. I lived on that in my native country, but lost my ways in UK because it was a pita at some point to find the food or ingredients. I mean like how fucking hard can it be for tesco to have bag of bones on their butvher ounter like they did in my country. Halal butchers I discovered later saved me. Cheap and plentiful bones. 4 out of 5 standatd butchers in my area looked at me like I asked for Alien rump steak🙄
Twice a week broth, kefir daily, fermented veg at leaat 3x a week. Bliss, no pain in my intestines!

TangledTeabags · 20/08/2023 16:30

I didn't eat carbs, or at least was very low carb for 7 years. I thought this would help my IBS.
It didn't, it grew worse.
I reintroduced some rice and made my own flatbreads and do much better now, so I think a lot of this stuff is really personal and doesn't apply to everyone.
I don't eat much in the way of 'bad' carbs, iyswim, but saw no improvement without them. Have never been overweight though. To the best of my knowledge a reduction in carbs can be helpful for people with diabetes but I am no expert!

I think it's all a result of decadence tbh, since the west is abundant with both healthy and unhealthy foods. Our culture has exploded with divisive dietary advice, and there is often a lot of arguing wherever it is discussed online. Those who follow a strict regime that works for them often make the mistake of preaching to others that the same will apply - and it so often does not!

OP posts:
Vegetus · 20/08/2023 08:04

underneaththeash · 20/08/2023 07:41

It is. The issue is that nutrition isn’t a regulation job, so anyone can call themselves one with little or no qualifications. As a group the also suffer from stating something as absolute fact, when it usually isn’t.

if you want fact rather than opinion, it’s best to work out what are the scientific terms for things and then type in those terms + abstract.
eg ‘bioavailability of calcium from non-dairy compared to diary sources + abstract’ will usually give you a range of peer reviewed articles which you can form your own opinion on.

even them you need to be wary of bias - in the above example, research for example commissioned by the vegan society or the milk council (if that still exists) is likely to be biased.

I actively look for people in this space who change their minds when the data disproves their biases. Layne Norton is absolutely fantastic and unlike most of the fitfluencer types is a qualified nutritionist and Dr.

It's very telling to me when he engages with quacks they refuse to debate him or respond because they're outgunned. Some of his YouTube takedowns of Jason Fung and Paul Saladino are things I frequently watch just for the comedy of it.

Tartareistasty · 20/08/2023 07:45

Far better to demonise food group for the old bank balance and Instagram clout.

Yup. There are people claiming not drinking water is healthy🤷

underneaththeash · 20/08/2023 07:41

Vegetus · 17/08/2023 19:57

Nutrition is full of quacks. It's not very sexy to be mainstream with nuanced takes because it doesn't sell or catch anyone's attention.

Far better to demonise food group for the old bank balance and Instagram clout.

It is. The issue is that nutrition isn’t a regulation job, so anyone can call themselves one with little or no qualifications. As a group the also suffer from stating something as absolute fact, when it usually isn’t.

if you want fact rather than opinion, it’s best to work out what are the scientific terms for things and then type in those terms + abstract.
eg ‘bioavailability of calcium from non-dairy compared to diary sources + abstract’ will usually give you a range of peer reviewed articles which you can form your own opinion on.

even them you need to be wary of bias - in the above example, research for example commissioned by the vegan society or the milk council (if that still exists) is likely to be biased.

AvengedQuince · 20/08/2023 07:40

Vegetus · 20/08/2023 07:23

I eat them and I don't feel miserable. I did feel miserable when I fad dieted all the time cutting out things I enjoyed and still couldn't lose weight, once I stopped being a slob and learnt to control my intake I lost a lot of weight and didn't feel like shit anymore.

If your body is okay with them then eat them. If cutting out certain foods makes people feel better then they are not going to be miserable about not eating them. I'm not talking about fad dieting, I'm talking about identifying and avoiding foods that make you feel rubbish. I don't want the foods I avoid, I'm not miserable or missing out on anything.

Tartareistasty · 20/08/2023 07:32

I am with you@Vegetus on carb love.

But this is MN and carbs are mass murdering people. Unlike in most other countries🙈

Vegetus · 20/08/2023 07:23

AvengedQuince · 20/08/2023 06:52

It's not miserable, feeling crap is miserable and I feel much much better when avoiding these things. To me, they are cheap filler foods, now I mostly just eat food that tastes good and benefits me.

I eat them and I don't feel miserable. I did feel miserable when I fad dieted all the time cutting out things I enjoyed and still couldn't lose weight, once I stopped being a slob and learnt to control my intake I lost a lot of weight and didn't feel like shit anymore.

Cazzovuoi · 20/08/2023 07:23

@Vegetus sounds like you have a touch of carb addiction if you think a life without carbs is miserable.

You have to find your joy with healthy alternatives to eating your emotions.

LMNT · 20/08/2023 07:21

The reason that nutrition is so bonkers is because it’s mainly based on epidemiology which doesn’t work for nutritional science. Follow the advice that comes out of RCTs (Randomised Clinical Trials).

I’m a clinical nutritionist and have my degree, my masters and my postgrad certifications all over my wall in my clinic. This is because, unfortunately, nutritionist isn’t a protected category like dietician or doctor and it should be.

I work 2 days a week from the hospital and the rest from my clinic. I wouldn’t get a hospital job without my qualifications yet any joe can call themselves a nutritionist without any training.

Drives me insane. AND don’t get me started on chiropractors calling themselves Dr. X and conveniently leaving out the D.C so people think they are physicians. I’ve had so many people, women mostly, come to me with wrecked hormones and thyroids because they’ve followed their frankly shitty advice.

Tartareistasty · 20/08/2023 07:00

I am not that surprised so many people have issue with some refined carbs. The standard supermarket bread there makes my stomach go weird too. I grew up knowing it as "toastie bread" and the little triangle toasties were it's only use....

AvengedQuince · 20/08/2023 06:52

Vegetus · 20/08/2023 05:37

@PaminaMozart

or artificial sweeteners, which are just as bad!

Isn't Aspartame classed as the same level of carcinogen as hot drinks?

but cutting out sugar and refined carbs

Sounds utterly miserable.

It's not miserable, feeling crap is miserable and I feel much much better when avoiding these things. To me, they are cheap filler foods, now I mostly just eat food that tastes good and benefits me.

AvengedQuince · 20/08/2023 06:48

TangledTeabags · 20/08/2023 03:17

I suppose it is about balance at the end of the day - if you are mindful in general, a few treats here and there are great. Life would be awful without strawberries and clotted cream sat atop a delicious shortbread base.

To be honest though, it would be very difficult to avoid ALL processed foods, many of which, like mayonnaise, are a total faff to put together at home. It would be handy if there were public 'guidelines' similar to the nutrition labels so that we could determine a safe amount of UPF to consume per month or something, but I think the issue is a little too complex at present.

Some ingredients come under fire more than others - palm oil, rapeseed oil, sat fat, etc. Personally I would prefer to avoid trans fats. Can I completely avoid them forever and a day? Probably not!

Dr Wills Avocado oil mayo looks okay

Valerie23 · 20/08/2023 06:37

Everything in moderation.

Mass consumerism has seen people lose the ability to control their portion size.

It's ok to have a fizzy drink occasionally but some people will guzzle six cans a day.

Eat some crisps but some people will much down a six packet bag in one evening.

Etc

Vegetus · 20/08/2023 05:37

@PaminaMozart

or artificial sweeteners, which are just as bad!

Isn't Aspartame classed as the same level of carcinogen as hot drinks?

but cutting out sugar and refined carbs

Sounds utterly miserable.

readingismycardio · 20/08/2023 05:13

PollyCreo · 17/08/2023 18:41

Remember when they told us in the 80s that eggs were unhealthy - they didn't know then that there was good and bad cholesterol? Remember Rosemary Conley's low fat nonsense from the 90s?

Advice is much more sensible now, sugar is bad and fat is good (although my mother still loves her low fat diet spread on her toast 🤮) I agree with caffeine though, five cups of coffee a day prevents dementia and I'm sticking to that ☕

I was thinking about eggs too! I'm still not sure. 🤣

Istanbulnotconstantinople72 · 20/08/2023 03:37

Stress and the environment is going to kill us all anyway, so why not eat what we want?

TangledTeabags · 20/08/2023 03:17

I suppose it is about balance at the end of the day - if you are mindful in general, a few treats here and there are great. Life would be awful without strawberries and clotted cream sat atop a delicious shortbread base.

To be honest though, it would be very difficult to avoid ALL processed foods, many of which, like mayonnaise, are a total faff to put together at home. It would be handy if there were public 'guidelines' similar to the nutrition labels so that we could determine a safe amount of UPF to consume per month or something, but I think the issue is a little too complex at present.

Some ingredients come under fire more than others - palm oil, rapeseed oil, sat fat, etc. Personally I would prefer to avoid trans fats. Can I completely avoid them forever and a day? Probably not!

OP posts:
PaminaMozart · 19/08/2023 18:40

I am not an expert, but I think there is a pretty solid body of evidence that a Mediterranean type diet is best for us. Basically "eat food, not too much, mostly plants" - plus a small/moderate amount of lean protein, healthy fats and complex/unrefined carbs.

I wouldn't worry about those Young's frozen dusted cod steaks, @TangledTeabags ! Or a few cups of tea or coffee, and the odd glass of wine or an occasional icecream.

The key is to pretty much cut out UPF, refined carbs and, most importantly SUGAR. I think sugar is more addictive than any other food group. Food manufacturers are very clever and find ever more devious ways of adding sugars - or artificial sweeteners, which are just as bad! - to all kinds of processed cr@p.

The other factor that results in so many people being unhealthy is lack of movement, being sedentary, never doing any meaningful exercise. But people are stressed, working all hours of the day, finding it difficult just treading water.

I don't know what the solution is, but cutting out sugar and refined carbs and exercising 15 minutes a day is probably a good start - and achievable.

professionalnomad · 19/08/2023 17:09

Recommend the podcast Maintenance Phase which is all about debunking the bad science around diet plans. It's also very funny but does have fruity language

pigsDOfly · 19/08/2023 16:59

So many fad diets around: cut out this, only eat that, only eat at certain times of the day and so on and so on.

And what is all this juggling of food supposed to achieve.

Meanwhile we have an epidemic of obesity.

And what about the part that genetics play in life span and health?

My late ex MIL lived to nearly 102 she was never heavily overweight but she had a really high fat diet, and did very little exercise. She was, though, in good health and continued to live in her own home and cook for her and her son up until her death.

Her younger sister is now in her very late 90s. She's not in great health it must be said, but she's been a heavy smoker all her life, and rarely walked more than a few yards, but she's still nearly 100 years old.

My family all, slim with reasonably good balanced diets, have mostly only managed to live into their 70s with one or two managing to get into their low 80s. Almost all of them have died of some sort of cancer.

You never really know what all this agonising over what you eat is going to achieve.

Surely a balanced diet is the sensible way to go and hope for the best.

BertieBotts · 19/08/2023 16:13

Honestly I don't pay any attention to it.

Look back over history - there were all kinds of things that were risky and are now banned. Asbestos, indoor smoking, etc. But the majority of people were fine even though these things were commonplace.

And now they are banned and we are all better off for it. So if that gets discovered in the future, something will be banned. Until then, I'll just continue to eat them and not worry about it.

MedSchoolRat · 19/08/2023 15:06

doesn't seem to be any ultimate mapping of which additives and ingredients are 'bad'

That's because everything is safe (used correctly) at the same time that everything is dangerous (used wrong).

I don't think the NHS dietary advice is out of date & wrong at all, btw.

Maybe think about food (and diet etc) in terms of quality for not good/bad. How much nutrition/taste/key micronutrients does it give you for the calories/cost. Similar with things like exercise, how can you get quality exercise benefits with the time you can possibly allocate to exercising. Can you get multiple benefits from exercise (say walk to the train station, which save money & green house gas emissions) at one time.

Swipe left for the next trending thread