Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Parents tried to pick DC up from holiday club when I didn’t ask them to and I’m in the wrong!

265 replies

TheyTriedToTakeDC · 17/08/2023 16:43

Background: Split with ExH in 2017 due to his violence and control. In the proceeding year he threatened me and threatened to kidnap DC (aged 2 at the time) and take them abroad so I never saw them again. He then repeated the threats in court for the CAO, his dad also got me in a headlock outside court and threatened to kill me so that (quote) “DC was in their rightful home with their father” because of this ExH, and Ex-PILs are banned from picking DC up from school or childcare.

ExH does have supervised contact, it’s supervised by another member of his family who’s never threatened me and I am happy to supervise but they do not have permission to take DC without me knowing either.

Every activity club, childcare or holiday club as well as DCs primary school I’ve shown the CAO to has always said “Unless we have verbal confirmation from you while your stood in front of us, we will not release DC to anyone but you”.

I love doing school or holiday club (HC) run so I don’t ask others to the pick-up. I like hearing about DCs day. Occasionally I’ve needed someone else to pick DC up so I will tell the club or ring school to let them know. In an emergency there is a process in place so school/holiday club can verify that it’s a genuine emergency situation and take DC. There is one other person I add to the pick-up list in case on an emergency, a cousin of mine whose also got DC at the same school.

Today DC was at HC while I worked. Parents rang at lunch to ask if they could pick DC up, I said no as I had booked to take DC out for dinner immediately after HC and I’d paid a bit more for them to stay until 4.15pm (normal pick up is 3.15pm) but if they wanted to pick up or have DC another day let me know and I’d arrange it. It’s a new holiday club for this year that parents haven’t been to or picked up from before.

They decided to go anyway and get DC.

I say get DC; they didn’t manage it. HCs safeguarding protocol kicked in, they moved DC and the other children into another room and rang me, when I said I was on my way to get DC and I didn’t give permission for DC to go with anyone else but me.

Of course, HC Lead (HCL) said this to my parents, who started shouting and saying it was ridiculous as they’re DCs grandparents and if they bought DC to them DC would confirm who they were. HCL apparently said if they could prove they have PR they’d let DC leave. This annoyed my stepdad and he apparently swore and called the HCL a t**t. HCL said if parents didn’t calm down the police would be called, and they didn’t so police where called.

I got there at same time as police, my stepdad especially is still wound up shouting and swearing. When I got there he said “See mums here now she’ll tell you who I am”.

It was all sorted out quite quickly, HCL explained to police and I showed the court order and I also had to prove who I was via ID (which is fine, I have no issue with this and carry my driving license for this purpose). DC was brought to me and we went out to eat. Police decided not to take it any further and HCL said it would be forgotten about despite them being abusive.

I’ve had a long text from my mum saying that it was a bit daft, I could of given permission over the phone for them to take DC and they could have had a lovely evening with DC and bought them home to me. They’ve said next time I need help with DC they’ll be more reluctant to help and this has tarnished their thinking of me as they now think I don’t trust them with DC.
I have replied to explain I couldn’t see through the phone to verify it was them. ExHs family have made threats as recently as Christmas to take DC and I couldn’t risk it. I’d rather be safe than sorry, they don’t mean DC any harm but if they’d been ExH or his family and the HCL had just let DC go they’d be the first ones to complain and be calling for jobs to be lost and compensation.

I got a one line reply of “Exactly how we thought it was”.

Why am I the bad guy for protecting my DC? AIBU to have not let DC go with them?

OP posts:
Solonge · 17/08/2023 21:52

RoadSignFool · 17/08/2023 21:15

That unfortunately doesn’t work as I would say exactly the same if the OP were male.

Its simple, mum has safeguarding in place. Her parents wanted to take her child out of daycare, mum said no but grandparents ignored what she said and attempted to take child. The grandparents are wrong. The parent gets to decide.

Iwasafool · 17/08/2023 21:52

Well the HCL played a blinder, thank heavens for people like her. I don't think people always realise how horrific it is to have a child abducted by the other parent and taken abroad. It happened to two children in my family. I can still hear me sitting on the stairs crying as I listened to my husband on the phone getting the message that they were gone and we'd never see them again.

In fact once they grew up we did eventually see them, these children we loved were strangers and it is so hard to look at them and see what we all lost. Worse for their mother and the children but the whole extended family suffered. Their grandparents died without ever seeing them again and nothing can put that right.

You are right to guard you child, long may he be safe.

jannier · 17/08/2023 21:49

RoadSignFool · 17/08/2023 17:23

I mean, in your heart of hearts you must of known that it would be a MASSIVE coincidence for your ex’s parents to turn up pretending to be the other grandparents, on exactly the same day that your own parents had said they wanted to collect DC? You could have asked the HC to take a photo of the people who had turned up.

But if the child's parent has said no I have made plans what right does the grandparents have to force their will on her by ignoring her and going to get the child?

rhianfitz · 17/08/2023 21:47

You are absolutely not unreasonable and its great that they used their safeguarding policy

jannier · 17/08/2023 21:44

So you said no to your parents and they decided to ignore you....has there always been a control issue going on?

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 17/08/2023 21:42

The OP is modelling to her child that boundaries matter and that someone trying to pull a fait accompli on you should not get away with it. The OP is modelling that it's OK to stand up to bullies, even if they are family, and it's OK use authority figures to help you with that. The OP is really fucking importantly modelling that it is OK to resist the social pressure to go along with someone else's boundary violations.

That will matter when the child faces bullies at school, sexual assailants, and all the other shitty humans who will try to abuse said child throughout his/her life.

I wrote on here a long time ago under a different name about a bloke feeling me up on public transport. Posters were telling me that, next time it happens, I should pull the emergency lever. I was like "stop an entire vehicle and piss off a whole load of passengers because one bloke can't keep his hands to himself? I'd be too embarrassed". That was social pressure not to rock the boat talking. Now, I'd pull that lever, because it's him that's the problem and reporting him does every woman on that vehicle a favour.

The only people who benefit from "don't make a scene" are abusers.

Conkersinautumn · 17/08/2023 21:31

Ridiculous. No loving grandparent would piss all over boundaries in such a manipulative vindictive way. OP did exactly the right thing. Grandparents who trash a no in this way don't deserve one bloody minute, they've no sense of actual responsibility and are acting put like petulant brats.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 17/08/2023 21:28

RoadSignFool · 17/08/2023 21:18

Yes! Instead of having the club fight her battle for her, as the child was not at risk.

Give in like my chickenshit dad did? With all the damage that did to me and my sister? Nah, the OP took the better option.

You clearly have no comprehension of the power imbalance that persistents between parent and child into adulthood and how that is made 100x worse when the parents are narcs.

The child is at risk if the GPs are allowed to treat him/her like a library book to be borrowed without warning when they see fit, for reasons that I already spelled out.

squirelnutkin11 · 17/08/2023 21:26

They should have listened when you said NO.
I would be furious with them.

ChrisPPancake · 17/08/2023 21:25

You're allowed to say twat on here @TheyTriedToTakeDC you know. Your stepdad was the twat in this situation. Must have been very stressful for you. Glad it got sorted today and don't blame you one bit for limiting contact.

Isitautumnyet23 · 17/08/2023 21:20

HikingforScenery · 17/08/2023 20:33

Will you not be letting them pick up or look after your dc again?

Hopefully not as they sound unstable (or the Step dad certainly does).

Well done OP, just be civil and concentrate on the most important thing - your DC. They dont have any control over your life and your DC’s life (and they especially shouldn’t be making it harder). We manage with holiday clubs without any help from grandparents and to be honest makes life easier that I know the clubs will always be open (no grandparents getting ill, needing to cancel etc).

Keep a distance and hope your siblings will support you in thinking they are crazy!

babyproblems · 17/08/2023 21:19

Catnuzzle · 17/08/2023 16:47

You're not. You absolutely did the right thing.

This. You sound like a great mum.
They clearly have no idea what you’ve been through and how important these procedures are!!! Stick to your guns 💪 x

RoadSignFool · 17/08/2023 21:18

Conkersinautumn · 17/08/2023 21:15

So .... give in to the socially award pressure tactic her parents used?

Yes! Instead of having the club fight her battle for her, as the child was not at risk.

billy1966 · 17/08/2023 21:17

Songbird74 · 17/08/2023 21:10

Your step dad owes a huge apology to that HCL. If he behaves like that in public, I’d be embarrassed to see how he acts in private. Absolute kudos to the HCL for standing her ground - I would never let someone shouting, intimidating and swearing at me collect a child. His behaviour is abhorrent.

Absolutely.

The poor HCL having to put up with abusive scum like your step father.

Good to read you will be stepping back.

People like your step father add nothing to the lives of any child.

Conkersinautumn · 17/08/2023 21:15

So .... give in to the socially award pressure tactic her parents used?

RoadSignFool · 17/08/2023 21:15

haXXor · 17/08/2023 20:57

Dramatic take my arse. Either she predicted that her SF would be reasonable and would take no from the HC leader like any reasonable GP would, as explained by school staff upthread, or she predicted that he might turn abusive and was justified in refusing the release of her child. There is no third option.

You are in a clear minority on this thread for a reason. The rest of us understand safeguarding, boundaries, and who the unreasonable person was in this situation (the SF) and why.

The first rule of misogyny is that women are deemed responsible for what men do. You deem the OP to be at least partly responsible for the abuse her SF gave to the HC. You are a misogynist.

That unfortunately doesn’t work as I would say exactly the same if the OP were male.

RoadSignFool · 17/08/2023 21:13

Puzzledandpissedoff · 17/08/2023 21:08

All she had to do was call her parents directly>

It's right there in OP's very first post, @RoadSignFool*

"Parents rang at lunch to ask if they could pick DC up, I said no ..."

I meant after the club called to say they were there. Obviously.

Songbird74 · 17/08/2023 21:10

Your step dad owes a huge apology to that HCL. If he behaves like that in public, I’d be embarrassed to see how he acts in private. Absolute kudos to the HCL for standing her ground - I would never let someone shouting, intimidating and swearing at me collect a child. His behaviour is abhorrent.

HyggeTygge · 17/08/2023 21:09

She had the chance to speak directly to her parents

Yes OP, all that crucial information you could've given them that would've changed everything, and you just refused.
🙄

Puzzledandpissedoff · 17/08/2023 21:08

All she had to do was call her parents directly>

It's right there in OP's very first post, @RoadSignFool*

"Parents rang at lunch to ask if they could pick DC up, I said no ..."

penelopelady · 17/08/2023 21:04

You didn't need to even mention the ex and his family to your parents. A simple you asked I said no.
I am utterly shocked and horrified by you behaviour today that resulted in the police having to be called....

TheyTriedToTakeDC · 17/08/2023 21:00

Thank you everyone even those who disagree with me, I do think it helps to see it from both points of view.

They will not be left alone with DC again, thankfully DC is 9 (was almost 3 when I split with ExH) and able to tell me if somethings wrong. I will still have to see them unfortunately as I get on well with my Siblings and Step Siblings who will invite them to family BBQs or their DCs birthday parties alongside me, but as I said I will just be civil.

Am drafting an email to HCHQ and will send it tomorrow.

OP posts:
GnomeDePlume · 17/08/2023 20:58

But the only 'resolution' in that scenario was OP allowing the parents to have their way. Why should the OP have to give way? Why are the GPs wants more important than OP's?

Possibly prior to this incident OP would have considered allowing GPs to collect DC. This would then have been communicated with the HC and proper arrangements made.

GPs tried to undermine the safeguarding procedures the OP & HC have put in place. OP already knows the GPs think they know best. This makes them untrustworthy. Is the OP certain they wouldnt be careless with DCs safety simply because they think they know best.

haXXor · 17/08/2023 20:57

RoadSignFool · 17/08/2023 20:44

Sure, if you want to describe that dramatic take as “compelling”, you crack on.

I am not sure how much more simply I can say this:

She had the chance to speak directly to her parents. That is what any rational person would have done when they got a call to say their parents were at pick up asking to take her son. At no point has she stated that her stepfather had form for behaving the way he did . So yes, she was unreasonable to drag the HVL into her family argument and the child was not at risk by going with the grandparents. It was a private matter to be resolved away from the club, not Jeremy Kyle.

Dramatic take my arse. Either she predicted that her SF would be reasonable and would take no from the HC leader like any reasonable GP would, as explained by school staff upthread, or she predicted that he might turn abusive and was justified in refusing the release of her child. There is no third option.

You are in a clear minority on this thread for a reason. The rest of us understand safeguarding, boundaries, and who the unreasonable person was in this situation (the SF) and why.

The first rule of misogyny is that women are deemed responsible for what men do. You deem the OP to be at least partly responsible for the abuse her SF gave to the HC. You are a misogynist.

Coyoacan · 17/08/2023 20:56

I think the people who refused to hand your child over deserve a box of chocolates.