Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

People are always 'meh' about me

161 replies

Dooooooooo · 17/08/2023 11:34

As well as social care I've also got over 10 years of experience in education, in teaching and support roles. I see many teachers/support staff like TAs with walls full of cards from students thanking them for being such an inspiration, they've changed their life and so on. Students crying when they leave, bags full of chocolates and gifts.
I've never received anything like that. That said, I received a 'thank you ' email from 2 A level students this year and that meant a lot. But generally, nothing.
It really shouldn't matter, I know, I've worked in this job because I enjoy helping people.
I worked a lot with A level students as part of one department, however because I wasn't a teacher I was completely excluded from the department. I was there for almost a full academic year but I had absolutely nothing to do with them, I was never included in anything which hurt. On my last day there this year it was just like, ok thanks, cya! From them.
I think it's because I don't have a 'big' personality as such, even though I am conscientious, hardworking and caring in my eyes.
A previous coursemate had also worked with an A level group, she told me they were crying when she left and that they've all met for coffee since, I just thought wtf?
This extends to friendships too. I've always had time to listen to people, when they've had a break up or any sort of issue I've listened to them and supported them. I've never mistreated them or put them down, I've always been kind and there for them.
I don't have a large home to offer them space, I don't have a ton of money to spend on them but I have always given them time.
Still, everyone's too busy, nobody really asks how I am anymore or has any interest in meeting, except for one friend but I think that's more as she wants to recruit me into religion (that's another friend).
I'm sorry if this sounds entitled, I've felt this way for years. I do think it's because I don't have bags of charisma and I'm not one of those big bubbly personalities, even though I still think I'm friendly, polite and kind.
It just gets me down sometimes. What to do really.

OP posts:
Dooooooooo · 18/08/2023 10:53

Most of these replies are helpful and I appreciate the advice.
A small number really are not. You see extrapolating, constantly insinuating dull/boring, consently saying I clearly bring nothing else.

OP posts:
Dooooooooo · 18/08/2023 10:52

I've said several times I've obviously had a sense of humour. Not every person seeks out a dark sense of humour or whatever you said. People are failing to reply to other points I've mentioned, just constantly making me out to be nice yet dull. Then when I say I disagree I'm accused of being snippy/stroppy whatever.

OP posts:
Disturbia81 · 18/08/2023 10:47

@MrsDBaddiel Exactly, everyone I'm friends with has a dark sense of humour, banter and can take the pee out of themselves, be real and be vulnerable sometimes.
When I think of someone reserved like OP says she is then I'll have a nice interaction with them but it won't go beyond that.

Dooooooooo · 18/08/2023 10:46

Wasn't going to bother replying but some of these answers are absolute nonsense.
Obviously I know it isn't a box ticking exercise. I have other qualities than kind obviously. I'm not just reeling off a list of qualities. I don't find my friends dull, I said just normal. That's all.

OP posts:
MrsDBaddiel · 18/08/2023 10:40

cinnamonfrenchtoast · 18/08/2023 10:33

Lots of the replies are focusing on OP being nice and kind but I don't think those attributes alone necessarily make someone a good friend.

I mean - all my friends are nice and kind but that's not the reason they're my friends.

I agree, most people I’m friends with have an edgy quality to them. They’re still kind and friendly but usually have a very dry wit/black humour.

The op is presenting on here in a slightly bot like manner where she’s operating on a box ticking exercise and can’t understand why it’s not resulting in a deluge of pals and popularity. That’s not how human interaction works.

cinnamonfrenchtoast · 18/08/2023 10:33

Lots of the replies are focusing on OP being nice and kind but I don't think those attributes alone necessarily make someone a good friend.

I mean - all my friends are nice and kind but that's not the reason they're my friends.

Fortboyard · 18/08/2023 10:32

Leafless1 that’s a really good point. I’m an introvert and although there were many teachers/individuals over the years that had a real positive impact on me, I’m sure those people have absolutely no idea, I never showed them.
As an introvert, you’re more likely to resonate with other introverts but they’re far less likely to tell you. Extroverted teachers will resonate with extroverted students who will loudly and obviously express their feelings.

MrsDBaddiel · 18/08/2023 10:30

KinooOrKinog · 18/08/2023 10:21

Nope, I'm laughing at you.

🤣🤣🤣🤣😜😜😜🤣🤣🤣😜😜😜😜
right back atcha sweetie

KinooOrKinog · 18/08/2023 10:21

MrsDBaddiel · 18/08/2023 09:17

I’m calm, you on the other hand…what’s with all the weird laughing emojis? Have your words failed you?

Nope, I'm laughing at you.

Leafless1 · 18/08/2023 10:07

I think, OP, that there will be many students who will value you and remember you as a good teacher. The louder, more extroverted teachers will be appeal to students with similar personalities and they will be more likely to show big displays and gestures as that all comes from the same place. Then other kids in the class feel they need to do the same. More thoughtful, introspective students are probably quietly valuing you (for sure) but less likely to be so in such a big way!

girlygirly · 18/08/2023 10:00

When my sisters group left nursery school they bought all the teachers a card, signed by them all. There were cards with angels on, and unicorns, cuddly teddies etc. - my sisters card had .... a crocodile!

So things could be worse...😂

Piranhaha · 18/08/2023 09:38

What is your actual job? I would love to give cards and gifts to everyone who helps my kids, but I don’t have enough money. I buy something for their main class teacher and that’s all. Just wondering if maybe the reason you don’t receive anything is because you’re not the main class teacher? Also depends how old the kids are. Parents tend to organise gifts and cards for school kids, but not for A level kids who are virtually adults, and they’re not mature enough to do it themselves.

Disturbia81 · 18/08/2023 09:32

And it's not really about being a fascinating person usually.
I'd also add being caring and affectionate to my list, people respond well to that

Disturbia81 · 18/08/2023 09:28

Thepeopleversuswork · 17/08/2023 21:39

@ComtesseDeSpair has it right here I think. The way you describe yourself paints a picture of someone who is diligent, kind and thoughtful and obeys social rules.

These are all good qualities and they help oil the wheels of society so I don’t think you should see them as negatives, but these are not really the qualities that build intimate and long lasting friendships.

Friendships are based on compatibility, humour, shared interests and values. Being “nice” won’t hurt your chances of making friends but on their own they aren’t enough. Sometimes being nice can actually make you seem a bit of a people pleaser, a bit of a drink of water without anything about you. Sometimes it can inadvertently signal that you are a bit of a pushover.

I don’t think you can be someone you are not. But I wonder if at some level you are not allowing yourself to be “real” and authentic with people? It’s hard to connect deeply with someone who isn’t really true to themselves.

Could you be doing this?

This is it.. being kind, a good listener are great qualities.. But for close friendships or for people to make an effort then you need more, to put yourself out there and make an effort with them, suggest things, be brave. All my close friendships have happened because I put myself out there and kept up the effort, they didn't come to me.
You also need to be funny, self depreciating a little, share any troubles you have, all in a balance of course. People like people who are being authentic.

Fortboyard · 18/08/2023 09:18

I get where the op is coming from. At my workplace we have a group of junior staff (late teens/early 20s) One of my colleagues always strikes up friendships with them and is apparently seen as warm and caring and lovely. I am friendly and kind and talk to them but I see my job as to help them develop in their work and skills and give them something good to put on their CVs.
Yesterday first thing I text two who were getting their results to wish them luck. One replied within a couple of hours. The other didn’t reply until 10pm, but I discovered that she did go into work during the day to tell this colleague in person. So I did feel a bit weird about that.
Personally I think this colleague often oversteps the boundaries like purposely probing one young person about a recent breakup when she’d been specifically told not to by a supervisor because the young person had requested that no one talk to her about it at work. Why would anyone would do that? I can only think of selfish motives like nosiness or wanting to be the one that this young person had ‘confided’ in.
She often shares inappropriate details of her life with complete strangers in public (our customers). She constantly talks and talks neglecting her work and distracting others to the extent that i know management have spoken to her about it. Yet it seems the vast majority of people think that she’s lovely. I do wonder though, outside of work she seems to have very few friends and no social life. Although I feel I do tend to keep people at arms length to a certain extent I have a reasonable social life and enough friends to make me content.

I love my job and like most of my colleagues but it is work, not a social club and we are there to get the job done. There need to be boundaries, particularly with young people.

MrsDBaddiel · 18/08/2023 09:17

KinooOrKinog · 18/08/2023 08:41

Haha calm yourself down 😂

I’m calm, you on the other hand…what’s with all the weird laughing emojis? Have your words failed you?

cinnamonfrenchtoast · 18/08/2023 09:16

'A lot of extroverts are quite selfish and fickle underneath I have found

So are lots of introverts 🤷‍♀️

Being selfish and fickle has nothing to do with being extroverted (or not).

Fruitynutcase · 18/08/2023 09:11

MentholLoad · 18/08/2023 09:03

I am an introvert and gravitate towards other introverts. I avoid extroverts and loud 'charismatic' people.

This . We can't all be the same . A lot of extroverts are quite selfish and fickle underneath I have found .

Fruitynutcase · 18/08/2023 09:09

Op just carry on being you . You are enough . I'm an introvert too . I've learned that if you try to be something you are not people pick up on it quite quickly. They will then think you are trying too hard . The only down side to being an introvert is that some people mistake quietness as a weakness . They soon get corrected on that mistake . I don't care if I'm disliked or not , all I ask is that people are polite and civil as I am to them.

Janieforever · 18/08/2023 09:04

swanling · 18/08/2023 08:32

Can you genuinely not see why if you attack a stranger online - when they have posted about feeling vulnerable and lonely - that might result in the person withdrawing rather than hanging about to absorb more of your "wisdom"?

I think it is sensible to withdraw when random strangers on the internet start assassinating your character and demanding you accept their cruel opinions as fact.

She’s not been attacked. She’s been given gentle constructive criticism as she specifically and proactively started a thread asking about what to do as people do not warm to her. She’s envious of those who are popular and can’t understand why she isn’t.

I also didn’t warm to her from her posts to be honest. Everything was focusing on how many great qualities she has, the list is endless according to the op, she just kept telling us, whilst subtly putting down her colleagues. Too friendly. Too loud, not being proffesional or having boundaries like her. Nothing positive there in her mind.

then she flounced with a superior I won’t be responding further.

this is nothing to do with introversion or shyness. We can only judge from what she’s posted, and that shows a level of superiority, a lack of warmth/empathy and a subtle hint of judgeyness. She is also completely unable to take any form of constructive criticism, and became combative, defensive, and then flounced.

her message is clearly Why do they get the cards and emotion, and she doesn’t, when she is better, her colleagues are just loud with poor boundaries.

if she’s like this in real life, then it will be amplified, and that will be why folks don’t warm to her.

MentholLoad · 18/08/2023 09:03

I am an introvert and gravitate towards other introverts. I avoid extroverts and loud 'charismatic' people.

cinnamonfrenchtoast · 18/08/2023 08:55

Thanks @OriginalBin - I'm not going to lie and say it was easy but it's made the world of difference.

I think I see a lot of myself in OP in that I'm naturally quite reserved and introverted and I always struggled to maintain friendships even as a child.

Basically as an adult I've realised that in order to make friends I have to force myself out of my comfort zone somewhat. That's not to say I'm pretending to be someone I'm not, but it means forcing myself to go out and do things sometimes because I know it would make my friends happy.

It's meant forcing myself to invite people places even though internally I'd much rather be home on the sofa Grin but actually I find that the more I push myself, the more I enjoy it - but also the more that people understand I'm a real introvert at heart, if that makes sense.

Sometimes you do have to force yourself to talk about someone's interests even though you'd rather be watching paint dry, because part of being a good friend is showing interest in the things your friends are passionate about - and in turn the right people will do the same for you.

OriginalBin · 18/08/2023 08:47

Good for you, @cinnamonfrenchtoast. can you say what it was you changed? So many posts on here about friendlessness, and the majority don’t take responsibility for contributing to the dynamics that make them feel left out or overlooked.

cinnamonfrenchtoast · 18/08/2023 08:44

Can you genuinely not see why if you attack a stranger online - when they have posted about feeling vulnerable and lonely - that might result in the person withdrawing rather than hanging about to absorb more of your "wisdom"?

She hasn't been attacked.

She's posted a thread about the fact that she struggles to fit in, but doesn't seem to want to hear any suggestions about how to actually change things.

Or would it be better if everyone just posted lots of platitudes about how lovely she sounds and how it must be everyone else who's wrong?

I've been the person struggling to make friends and you know what? I was part of the problem and it was only when I changed my behaviour that I saw different results.

KinooOrKinog · 18/08/2023 08:41

MrsDBaddiel · 18/08/2023 08:28

No, what an utterly pathetic response.

You clearly struggle with human interaction, I pity you.

Haha calm yourself down 😂