Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The "strong female lead"

121 replies

Sarah5q · 17/08/2023 10:55

Hi,
I'm basing this on reports about the new Snow White movie and how much the movie is being changed and it just got me thinking and I thought it'd be interesting to hear other people's opinions or perspectives.

I am a big fan of the original Snow White. She was my favourite princess growing up and I find it a shame that the story has been belittled in the upcoming movie. Yes, she was kissed by a prince at the end but surely the main concept of the film is kindness and her friendship with the dwarves?

This post could be super long if I wrote all my details but why does every female these days need to have a "strong" and "powerful " story?
What is wrong with being the "shy, quiet" one? Surely you can still be "powerful" in other ways.

And in the interviews, the actors are saying "Snow white won't be saved by a prince". Fair enough, it was all a bit quick. But rather than change that aspect entirely, why not just "fill out" the story and develop the relationship of snow white and the prince.
There are some women out there who do dream of having that family-lifestyle and having their happily every-after with their "prince charming". Not every woman wants to be that 'female boss" narrative that seems to be going around in Hollywood.

Maybe I'm completely missing the point or maybe I'm speaking rubbish and make no sense but I think I'm just tired of having that "girl boss" narrative rammed down my throat as if wanting to be anything other than that is "dated".

OP posts:
Cakesandbabes · 17/08/2023 18:24

The "woke" refers to unnatural injection lf sociatal issue. Thwre are mamy movies and series who whose them natirally without the feelimg of beong lectured.
Modern family is my fave example. Uncoupled etc

FrippEnos · 17/08/2023 17:56

calmcoco · 17/08/2023 14:31

Firstly, what is wrong with being woke? It just means 'not a twat' as far as I can tell.

And secondly, there is nothing remotely new about fairy stories where women get rescued being considered a bit shit.

The problem with being woke is when they are complaining about a Hawaiian actress not being Hawaiian enough to play Moana.

TrixieFatell · 17/08/2023 17:45

TheBirdintheCave · 17/08/2023 15:06

@TrixieFatell @MojoDojoCasaHouse You're so right! I've never really noticed before that 'quiet heroine' was such a big thing for Ghibli but it explains why I love (most of) their films so much. As a shy person I never really identified with your typical sassy kick-ass leading ladies.

They are such well rounded characters, each has her own set of attributes and none of it seems forced unlike Disney and Marvel characters. I struggle to have a favorite

Towst · 17/08/2023 17:44

Bruisername · 17/08/2023 11:32

Why can’t we have a film where a shy introvert succeeds in life through quiet confidence and without having to become a sassy kick ass clever clogs?

I would watch this.

Sarah5q · 17/08/2023 17:36

@calmcoco I think most people have a problem with "forced wokeness".
Putting Snow White aside, even the fact their not including dwarves and changing it to "magical people" or whatever if ridiculous, even many of the dwarf acting community are unhappy about it because, naturally, Snow White is a big role for them in the acting world

OP posts:
Sarah5q · 17/08/2023 17:28

@FourTeaFallOut oh my goodness yes, I forgot about the tight outfits that every almighty powerful female must wear!

OP posts:
TheBirdintheCave · 17/08/2023 15:06

@TrixieFatell @MojoDojoCasaHouse You're so right! I've never really noticed before that 'quiet heroine' was such a big thing for Ghibli but it explains why I love (most of) their films so much. As a shy person I never really identified with your typical sassy kick-ass leading ladies.

HowDoYouSolveAProblemLikeMariaa · 17/08/2023 14:56

The thing is fairytales were originally very much centred on the female experience, albeit in a patriarchal world. They deal with things like navigating rape and domestic abuse.
The problem with these ass kicking new women is, that's not a real solution in the world we currently live in. The original tales showed girls how to survive and sometimes best men in a man's world.
We need a fairytale that helps girls navigate and make sense of the world we live in. Not some fantasy one where problems are solved with a high kick.

Bruisername · 17/08/2023 14:47

I have no issue with them doing a different take on the story (as you say - the cartoon was a take on the original) - it is the last sloppy way they are doing it. The Theron/Robert’s films dealt with this quite well I thought even if they weren’t great films (and you even got to see the evil queen dance to death so nods to the original)

AmazingSnakeHead · 17/08/2023 14:45

The things is you're holding up the 1930s version as your ideal of this story because that's the version that you grew up watching. But that version is not the "original", it's a Disney version of a much older story that they themselves adapted for the audiences at the time. In fact, Disney added on that ending with the kiss. In the original they all think she's dead and grieve for ages, then as they're carrying away her coffin someone trips and the apple gets dislodged from her throat and she wakes up. Disney felt it was too macabre for a kids film, and added on the sleeping beauty true love kiss ending.

Does this change your opinion at all? Each era does its own thing to appeal to its audiences. I agree that the sassy American girl boss isn't for everyone, and it's boring when all the main characters are like that. But we also need to be careful about what we really consider to be the problem. In this case, it really isn't that they've messed around with the "original" it's more that they've taken out things that were themselves messing around with the original (and no doubt added their own slant, as always happens).

Bruisername · 17/08/2023 14:39

There is a difference between being woke and performative wokeness - which this seems to be. Let’s tick all the boxes we can - oh but not this or that one or we won’t be able to sell it in China/ME/India

and no one wants the princess being rescued trope but it would be good if they could think abit outside the stereotype box of the sassy kick ass princess as well and claim that this somehow makes it ‘modern’

calmcoco · 17/08/2023 14:31

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Firstly, what is wrong with being woke? It just means 'not a twat' as far as I can tell.

And secondly, there is nothing remotely new about fairy stories where women get rescued being considered a bit shit.

GrumpyPanda · 17/08/2023 14:30

HowDoYouSolveAProblemLikeMariaa · 17/08/2023 11:57

Also, if they put more than one girl in each movie they wouldn't need her to be good at everything.
That's how male characters work. One whose strength is humour. One whose strength is brains. One whose strength is bravery. One whose strength is kindness.

Women should not have to be everything all the time. The Barbie movie got that right.

Yes this exactly.

It's not just about leads either. Apparently even for non-speaking extras the sex ratio is around 70:30. Same for actual roles, even though for a lot of them - the generic shopkeeper for instance - they could quite easily swap some women into those roles. It's insidious - we've all been habituated into seeing only a small minority of women in what passes for the general public depicted in a film.

Cakesandbabes · 17/08/2023 14:28

Bruisername · 17/08/2023 14:23

probably - is this low budget!!

looking at the casts of the other 2 the evil queens were Charlize Theron and Julia Robert’s - definitely has the more ‘fun’ role!

Looka like they went to Toys are us for it tbh.
Googl snow white cosplay. They could havw bought some of these🙈

thecatsthecats · 17/08/2023 14:28

SliceOfCakeCupOfTea · 17/08/2023 11:36

Bechdel Test

Bechdel herself says that that test was never meant to be used in the way it is. The Fast and Furious films pass it, FFS.

So many people interpret it as "STRONG female characters" instead of "strong female CHARACTERS" - i.e. women who have clearly defined character traits that aren't pigeon holed into stereotypes, or change at the flick of a switch to suit a man.

Bruisername · 17/08/2023 14:23

probably - is this low budget!!

looking at the casts of the other 2 the evil queens were Charlize Theron and Julia Robert’s - definitely has the more ‘fun’ role!

Cakesandbabes · 17/08/2023 14:19

I think that's more that the dress is bit crap. I've aeen better cosplayera made...

Bruisername · 17/08/2023 14:17

also think the actress looks ridiculous in the iconic yellow dress - it doesn’t work outside cartoon! Maybe they will do some cgi

Bruisername · 17/08/2023 14:16

snow white is definitely if it’s time but does it need remaking at all - there were already 2 a while back which were decent enough.

do they think no one will watch it if it doesn’t have an already known story attached? They didn’t have that problem with moana or braveheart or even frozen

Cakesandbabes · 17/08/2023 14:10

FrippEnos · 17/08/2023 14:03

That would have been a good way to do it.

Must copyright😂

There are so many options to do these things. Lota of the time the excuse is "well it will be a plop since know one knows them". Yeah, so use the known ones to gather interest by injecting them in a bit.
Think of Marvel, DC etc. They can make a completely unknown character, not even from comic books, make a movie and put Thor at the beginning, little bit throughout maybe (and posters) and et voila. Famous (unless it's really incredibly shit story).

I wonder if anyone tries to make 1000 an 1 nights now

Diddykong · 17/08/2023 14:09

Snow white the original is bloody awful though. She rocks up at the dwarf house and promptly cleans and cooks for all of them while they whistle at her.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 17/08/2023 14:07

I definitely agree with there being room for a range of movie characters, so in some, it should be the shy quiet type, some the one who likes making jokes, some a strong character who isn’t physically fit and strong etc

I think the romance is a bit of a bad message if it comes in the form of the woman being saved or rescued because it’s not realistic. But obviously there’s room for movies with romance - those still exist though! I think it’s fine to have a version of Snow White without romance, especially as you’ve mentioned it’s not the main point of the story, and less important than her friendship with the dwarves etc

HowDoYouSolveAProblemLikeMariaa · 17/08/2023 14:05

FaeWings · 17/08/2023 14:02

Slightly off track but my favourite strong female character who actually works as an interesting character who still feels real is Ellie from Jurassic Park. Here's why:

  • She's an expert in her field. Holds her own in all intellectual debates, often delivering the crucial lines that win the argument. "You never had control, that's the illusion!"
  • Gets involved in all the action scenes without superpowers. Looks scared and exhausted, surviving on adrenaline and nerve.
  • Says she wants children in the future and does not fluster or backtrack when Alan says he doesn't.
  • There's not a whiff of 'not like other girls' about her.

I wish we had more female characters like her about now

The t rex is qslo a strong female lead 😂

FrippEnos · 17/08/2023 14:03

Cakesandbabes · 17/08/2023 13:38

They could have easily move onto one of the sisters from the famous series.
Start if off with Ariel (since she is thw most famous) there for 5 min doing shenanigans with her sister to gain an interest and then do some solid story of adventure of the sister. They represeted different seas and different areas. Each could have great own story featuring the area? It could be perfectly and nicely representative of different people and cultures.
If that makes sense

That would have been a good way to do it.

FaeWings · 17/08/2023 14:02

Slightly off track but my favourite strong female character who actually works as an interesting character who still feels real is Ellie from Jurassic Park. Here's why:

  • She's an expert in her field. Holds her own in all intellectual debates, often delivering the crucial lines that win the argument. "You never had control, that's the illusion!"
  • Gets involved in all the action scenes without superpowers. Looks scared and exhausted, surviving on adrenaline and nerve.
  • Says she wants children in the future and does not fluster or backtrack when Alan says he doesn't.
  • There's not a whiff of 'not like other girls' about her.

I wish we had more female characters like her about now