Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why adoptive parents get paid?

141 replies

Member786488 · 17/08/2023 09:52

I’ll try and post a link to the story…

Possibly being dim… not unheard of.
I understand the fostering payments obviously but surely finance is something you consider if you’re going to have a child, so why is that different if you adopt.

other than some initial costs, why do you receive regular ‘adoption’ payments until the child is 18?

Parents 'broken' by withdrawal of adoption payments say funding is a 'postcode lottery' — Sky News

Michelle Haigh can still remember the first time she saw a picture of her adopted son, Thomas.

https://apple.news/A30DpF_HoRfuDHxBSb35hmQ

OP posts:
Spacecowboys · 17/08/2023 11:33

I suspect that those who receive payment, do so when circumstances are particularly challenging. £612 a fortnight isn’t going to be provided without very good reason. A stay at home parent is probably needed, limiting the earning capacity of the household.

JenWillsiam · 17/08/2023 11:32

Gwenhwyfar · 17/08/2023 10:32

When my friend fostered the allowance was much more than the children actually cost them.

I don’t believe that for a second. Consider it’s also because foster parents don’t work. It’s supposed to cover all expensive, contribution to living environment etc etc.

NeedToChangeName · 17/08/2023 11:29

I'm shocked that photos of the children are included in that story

cheeseisthebest · 17/08/2023 11:23

I worked in adoption for 13 years, they do not get paid! This is so misleading.

Whatthechicken · 17/08/2023 11:23

Of all the people to point the finger at and moan that they might be getting something others aren’t, you choose adopters.

We don’t get anything, it’s vanishingly rare for adopters to get an allowance, it’s increasingly rare for adopters to get support of any kind despite the trauma, neglect and issues their children may have had. And if they do get any support, they’ve probably had to fight tooth and nail for it.

Maybe visit the adoption board OP and understand some of the challenges adopters and adoptees face.

Lwrenagain · 17/08/2023 11:11

@Gwenhwyfar do your friends live a lifestyle comparable to Amish elders?

I've got no idea how that is remotely possible 🤔

Delia123 · 17/08/2023 11:09

Kingsleadhat · 17/08/2023 10:56

We didn't get adoption allowance and are still working in our late sixties trying to support our now adult highly complex children. The children also got zero therapeutic support growing up. I don't know any adopters who did manage to get adoption allowance. It's not standard

I'm sorry you're struggling. Allowances are much more common now precisely because of situations like yours and also to help prevent high numbers of complex adoptions breaking down.

HarridanHarvestingHeldaBeans · 17/08/2023 11:09

It might be better to ask why more adoptive parents don't get paid, and why the ones who do, aren't paid more?

Adopted children often have complex needs and problems. Their parents are saving the state a huge expense as well as providing safety, security and love. That should be recognized and properly supported, IMO.

Delia123 · 17/08/2023 11:06

Gwenhwyfar · 17/08/2023 10:32

When my friend fostered the allowance was much more than the children actually cost them.

Then your friend wasn't spending the money as it should have been spent.

Rufus27 · 17/08/2023 11:04

The majority of adopters don’t get an allowance even when their children have high levels of need.

Due to my children’s needs, we tend only to socialise with other adoptive families who ‘get it’. Of those families, the only one who has a small allowance is the family who were misled about their child’s needs and the mum has had to give up her work. She was a well paid professional and now gets £900 adoption allowance monthly. In the five years since they adopted, there has never been a time their children were both in full time education as no schools in our county can meet the children’s complex needs (one needs 2:1 support and both are violent as a result of the hideous trauma they’ve suffered).

The fact you’re even questioning access to this allowance makes me incredibly sad.

Tlolljs · 17/08/2023 11:03

im sorry that I offended you @Ted27 that wasn’t my intent.

Duchessofspace · 17/08/2023 11:00

littleripper · 17/08/2023 10:11

My friend was a corporate lawyer, her wife was a social worker. They adopted a group of 4 siblings from an incredibly challenging background. They receive caters allowance as well as other benefits. They deserve 10x as much. It's humbling to see what they have done and the life they have given these children.

I agree. My friend has adopted a child with serious early life trauma - they were 4 when adopted - they have to have therapy twice a week, both times with mum present, the child has attachment issues and I’ve never asked and don’t ask if she receives money - but I wouldn’t begrudge her a penny - everything she does as a single parent is for her adopted child. The child hits her and has made extreme progress forwards from their early life without her adoption the child would be in a home and would not be where they are now - mainstream school and likely to gain employment at 16 and much of the early life trauma is physical eg no teeth, physical abuse etc do you serious think them being in a home would be cheaper? As for mum, she’s given up work living off pensions etc cashed in early and she was a solicitor - she does some odd work but has given up her career etc to look after the child and be there for them 100% that’s commitment and I hope she does get something.

nothingcomestonothing · 17/08/2023 10:59

What would you prefer OP? That harder to place children spend a lifetime in the care system?

Adopters getting an adoption allowance (and many don't get a penny) get it because the placing LA assessed that their children will have needs which will mean a high level of extra expense for the parents. E.g. will always need one parent to SAH, will always need their own bedroom and not be able to share with siblings, will need more clothes/toys/furniture than other children as they deliberately destroy their and others' belongings, etc etc.

Begrudging a small amount of financial support to parents raising challenging children who would otherwise cost the state far more growing up in the care system (not to mention have far more likelihood of criminality, MH needs etc caused by their growing up in care, so costing the state more once they are adults). Is that really the look you're going for?

blackbeardsballsack · 17/08/2023 10:56

When my friend fostered the allowance was much more than the children actually cost them.

Unless your friend fed the kids smart price noodles for every meal, never bought them clothes or toys or toiletries or paid for hair cuts, never used gas or electricity, never drove the kids anywhere and never enrolled them in any clubs or any school trips or any sort of activity ever you are talking absolute rubbish. The fostering allowance is a pittance and always has been.

Kingsleadhat · 17/08/2023 10:56

We didn't get adoption allowance and are still working in our late sixties trying to support our now adult highly complex children. The children also got zero therapeutic support growing up. I don't know any adopters who did manage to get adoption allowance. It's not standard

Whatajokr · 17/08/2023 10:53

I know of 4 families who have chosen not to adopt, but have their children on long term foster care.

That way they know their children will have permanent residence with them, they will continue to get paid as a family, and their LACs will get to the top of the list for school places, CAMHS (if needed), bursaries at uni (if they go) and many other things.

Once a child is adopted, all those things go.

SunWorshipping · 17/08/2023 10:52

I've not read the article, but even if they received some money to help support a child, good. It's often very difficult to find people to adopt children with complex needs as a result of what they experienced with their birth parents. You aren't going to get some rough head family adopting for the money, from the people I know who have adopted or attempted to adopt it's a very long and difficult process, they'd need to be able to afford to support the child, any extras they would receive would be to support their additional needs, through therapy etc etc.

BerriesandLeaves · 17/08/2023 10:52

Simonjt · 17/08/2023 10:07

NICE feel the LA should fund certain things for LAC and ex LAC, LA laugh their heads off and essentially say fuck off when they received a post adoption support request.

That's bad.

Ted27 · 17/08/2023 10:51

@Tlolljs

That's because adopters do not get paid.

I received an adoption allowance, which was means tested. I had to drop to work to three days a week to meet my son's needs.

Without the allowance I would have had to give up work. Then I would have been on benefits and costing the state a lot more.
Then I'm sure I would have beeb seen as benefit scrounger.
Adopters save the state millions of pounds in social worker costs and fostering costs. We care for and raise the most vulnerable children in society. Many struggle financially.
We do not get paid and we certainly do not profit.

ihateexcel · 17/08/2023 10:49

We adopted two amazing kids and we receive nothing. Only thing we have ever had was £500 for furniture and stuff when they first came home over 7 years ago. That didn’t even cover the cost of the double pram, but we were very grateful for it.

Anewuser · 17/08/2023 10:42

Goady post.

A friend adopted a disabled child. As they grew, she realised she needed extra help. We got respite for our disabled child, she didn’t. Social services said it was because she said she could cope alone and that’s why the adoption went through. Awful behaviour. No one is allowed to have changes to their life then?

PP said they knew a professional couple that got carers allowance for their adopted children. That wouldn’t be correct if they stayed in their professional jobs, the benefit is £76.75 per week and you only get that if your job pays less than £139 a week.

Tlolljs · 17/08/2023 10:41

Well I for one had no idea that adoptive parents were paid. None at all. Not saying it’s not deserved, just had no idea.

Totesbabes · 17/08/2023 10:36

As PP have mentioned, adopted children have often been through so much trauma they’ll need more care/ specialist help/ therapy. This little payment is there to help the kids out.

Gwenhwyfar · 17/08/2023 10:32

Nevermay · 17/08/2023 10:02

and you are wrong about fostering too, it isn't always paid, you might get allowances and expenses, but when we fostered we did it at a huge loss.

When my friend fostered the allowance was much more than the children actually cost them.

MillWood85 · 17/08/2023 10:21

Family friends adopted. They weren't given all the facts about the parents, and ended with 2 siblings that had complex learning difficulties/SEN due to drug use/alcohol abuse during pregnancy and physical neglect in their early months/year of life. Their story didn't have a happy ending, and they had no support financially or physically - they took the children on and were shown the door. Neither were able to work full time due to them not being able to manage the children 2:1.

I think it's appalling that these wonderful people aren't financially supported to take children on. Adoption isn't like it was in the 1960's/1970s from single mothers who were shamed into adoption; children removed these days have often suffered horrendous neglect/abuse and are very damaged as a result.