Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you’ve got a big family how do you get by?

115 replies

Schnitzelvonkrummm · 17/08/2023 09:38

I guess Big is relative, but say 3 kids +. How do you afford it?

how do you holiday? And how much does it cost?

what’s your house like? Does each child have their own room?

i wonder if the majority of big families are on mega bucks (or so to speak) like 70k+ each? Then how do you have time for it all?

i was mindlessly scrolling on insta as you do and came across the Collins kids, 10 kids and open to more (now they philosophy behind it is a bit wonky to me but won’t get into that) and the mum was saying people assume that they have a mansion and are super duper wealthy but they aren’t, they are average and they just make it work and her husband works very hard. My guess is that they have to be a bit above average at least but still.

OP posts:
Schnitzelvonkrummm · 17/08/2023 10:19

rand0mstuff · 17/08/2023 09:58

When I look at friends with 3+ kids it is usually either a case of having a very high earner or two decent incomes which allow to buy in help. Big house, all kids have their own rooms and nice holidays OR a lot of benefit dependency with at least one parent not in work. So no need for childcare. Low income (guess topped up with UC).

I don't know any people in between with average incomes with big families. If you have to pay for childcare, mortgage etc I don't think more than 2 DC is affordable.

It's just my observation. No idea how true statistically.

I guess that’s what I mean… I don’t know any ‘average’ income households with more than 3kids (guess that depends on what you define as average) and then those whilst they aren’t utterly lavish still earn probably more than average, and had GP support or limited childcare costs and don’t pay for wrap around childcare

OP posts:
PuttingDownRoots · 17/08/2023 10:07

The big families you hear about (like the Radfords, on the ones with Quintuplets, or your example) monetise it some extent. And the social media will only show the good bits while the TV bits are scripted to some extent.

If you read MN there are plenty of threads making the most of a small space a family is outgrowing... parents on sofa beds, toddlers in parents room out of necessity not choice, preschoolers in bunk beds.

A friend was waiting 18 months for a bigger council home because they needed a 4 bed so they couldn't give them a 3 bed despite being in a 2 bed flat (4 children but eldest has autism and was assessed as needing own room)

tequilachickenbird · 17/08/2023 10:02

I have a larger family.
Yeah we don't have nice things and we aren't quite hand to mouth but we aren't far off

rand0mstuff · 17/08/2023 09:58

When I look at friends with 3+ kids it is usually either a case of having a very high earner or two decent incomes which allow to buy in help. Big house, all kids have their own rooms and nice holidays OR a lot of benefit dependency with at least one parent not in work. So no need for childcare. Low income (guess topped up with UC).

I don't know any people in between with average incomes with big families. If you have to pay for childcare, mortgage etc I don't think more than 2 DC is affordable.

It's just my observation. No idea how true statistically.

Summerrainagain1 · 17/08/2023 09:57

BarbaraofSeville · 17/08/2023 09:53

look on MN and there are people who are saying they have a combined gross of 100k that are struggling and can’t cut back anymore

In general, those people have a poor understanding of necessities vs luxuries.

If they posted their income and expenditure, most people would see areas where they could cut back and still have a more luxurious lifestyle than most of the population.

Not really. Your essential spending is based on your previous situation and outgoings. So when things change (lost of living crisis, redundancy etc) it's not always easy to cut back, espeically quickly.

Anyway, to the OP, on insta they probably get loads of income from that. But outside that I think the more you have the cost of each individual child goes down. Is one of the parents already a SAHP? If so there is no additional cost for them stayuing home with subsequent kids. Is there loads to pass down? Then no need to buy anything more. Is the family already happy for the kids to share rooms? If so, putting in a bunk bed instead of one of the twin beds isn't a huge cost increase. Economies of scale and all that.

The problem probably sneaks up on you a bit as they grow older though, as their expenses and need for space increases.

Schnitzelvonkrummm · 17/08/2023 09:53

Murrain · 17/08/2023 09:50

This. I have one child by choice, as a direct result of growing up in a large, poor family. It was miserable — we shared not just rooms but (small) beds for long periods, there was nowhere quiet to do your homework (I studied for my A level equivalents lying flat on my lower bunk, because there was nowhere else), barely enough food, knowing never to invite a friend because there was no extra to go round), parents only focused on food and clothes, and individual attention only to the younger ones who had, obviously, more physical needs.

So no, sometimes it just doesn’t work. Petiole do just have large numbers of children they can’t afford..

That was another thing, the emotional time and physical ability to care of that many kids… im sure some do manage but that social media family it seemed like the older ones were taking care of the younger ones but I guess that’s bound to happen with 10 kids and 5 of them being 5 and under.

OP posts:
Hufflepods · 17/08/2023 09:53

Schnitzelvonkrummm · 17/08/2023 09:45

more money is relative though? More money than what?

look on MN and there are people who are saying they have a combined gross of 100k that are struggling and can’t cut back anymore

It's all relative though, that is the point. There is no one way of doing anything. Families with lots of children will either have a high income or they will have low outgoings, plus the whole spectrum in between. Exactly the same for families with less kids.

BarbaraofSeville · 17/08/2023 09:53

look on MN and there are people who are saying they have a combined gross of 100k that are struggling and can’t cut back anymore

In general, those people have a poor understanding of necessities vs luxuries.

If they posted their income and expenditure, most people would see areas where they could cut back and still have a more luxurious lifestyle than most of the population.

TheChosenTwo · 17/08/2023 09:51

We have 3dc and wouldn’t class us as a large family. Very simplistic but we had the amount of children we could afford to have without compromising what we want from life. Would loved to have had more but realistically something would have been compromised and I wasn’t prepared to give things up in order to further expand our family.
We holiday 4 times a year, 2 abroad and 2 UK. Use villas abroad and cottages in the U.K., totally self catering as it’s more flexible and each dc can have their own room/privacy, we can do what we please and suit everyone’s needs.
They all have their own bedrooms at home.
We earn enough to live a comfortable life, it was very hard work at the beginning but now we are both established we have a lot more free time.

Murrain · 17/08/2023 09:50

Hufflepods · 17/08/2023 09:41

How do you afford it?

Either they will earn more money or they will have lower expectations and spending. It isn't rocket science.

This. I have one child by choice, as a direct result of growing up in a large, poor family. It was miserable — we shared not just rooms but (small) beds for long periods, there was nowhere quiet to do your homework (I studied for my A level equivalents lying flat on my lower bunk, because there was nowhere else), barely enough food, knowing never to invite a friend because there was no extra to go round), parents only focused on food and clothes, and individual attention only to the younger ones who had, obviously, more physical needs.

So no, sometimes it just doesn’t work. Petiole do just have large numbers of children they can’t afford..

Caspianberg · 17/08/2023 09:46

Well we only have one. But your examples of house etc, we already had house before Ds was born. We have spare bedrooms so if we chose to we could easily fit say 4-6 children in and the cost would be the same as without children.
Holiday wise depends on holiday. But if your driving and staying in apartment or villa the cost is per rental not per person. Obviously you would need a massive villa for 10+ children, but if your usual is a 3 bed villa your cost for 1 or 4 children would be similar

day to day costs I have no idea though. Must spend a fortune on food, essentials and clothing

Schnitzelvonkrummm · 17/08/2023 09:45

Hufflepods · 17/08/2023 09:41

How do you afford it?

Either they will earn more money or they will have lower expectations and spending. It isn't rocket science.

more money is relative though? More money than what?

look on MN and there are people who are saying they have a combined gross of 100k that are struggling and can’t cut back anymore

OP posts:
Schnitzelvonkrummm · 17/08/2023 09:44

BoohooWoohoo · 17/08/2023 09:40

Do the Instagram family have lots of practical help from extended family? Not having to pay nursery fees alone is tens of thousands of pounds not needed.

From what I saw, no, but they also home school (they have quite strong Christian fundamentalists beliefs so don’t send kids to school because of that)

OP posts:
Hufflepods · 17/08/2023 09:41

How do you afford it?

Either they will earn more money or they will have lower expectations and spending. It isn't rocket science.

BoohooWoohoo · 17/08/2023 09:40

Do the Instagram family have lots of practical help from extended family? Not having to pay nursery fees alone is tens of thousands of pounds not needed.