Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you’ve got a big family how do you get by?

115 replies

Schnitzelvonkrummm · 17/08/2023 09:38

I guess Big is relative, but say 3 kids +. How do you afford it?

how do you holiday? And how much does it cost?

what’s your house like? Does each child have their own room?

i wonder if the majority of big families are on mega bucks (or so to speak) like 70k+ each? Then how do you have time for it all?

i was mindlessly scrolling on insta as you do and came across the Collins kids, 10 kids and open to more (now they philosophy behind it is a bit wonky to me but won’t get into that) and the mum was saying people assume that they have a mansion and are super duper wealthy but they aren’t, they are average and they just make it work and her husband works very hard. My guess is that they have to be a bit above average at least but still.

OP posts:
Honeychickpea · 18/08/2023 15:13

I read somewhere that to have a large family, you either have to be very rich or very poor.
That is true in my experience.

feralunderclass · 18/08/2023 13:23

On MN all families with 5+ kids are millionaires, with the kids all having their own bedrooms, being high achievers and doing loads of EC. In reality, these families are generally the poorest and are in need of the most intervention (ONS).
There are certain communities in the UK that have very large families due to religious conviction, and these children are now living below the poverty line in very overcrowded conditions due to the benefit cap. I read somewhere that to have a large family, you either have to be very rich or very poor.

AllTheChaos · 18/08/2023 00:08

Hufflepods · 17/08/2023 10:42

@Ladyoftheknight My nursery fees for 3 children would be about £5500 a month

I find that very hard to believe.

I don’t know. It was £2k per month for full time nursery, and may be more now. There’s discounts for siblings but I can see how having 3 in at once could cost an absolute fortune!

TheaBrandt · 17/08/2023 21:17

The drive to procreate must be so strong the price paid by some - no nice things no decent holidays being over crowded. I just don’t understand why anyone would choose that. I kind of get it if you are wealthy but personally the environmental guilt of a large family living a jet set lifestyle would cripple me.

SantaBarbaraMonica · 17/08/2023 21:09

4 young kids. I earn very well. DH earns very very well. We’ve a large 5 bed house, lots of rooms and outdoor space. Full time nanny. Travel is expensive but we ski and summer holiday with the kids as well as travel on short trips without them. Family holidays are around £8k. It’s expensive! We spend so much money on the house, gardens, kids activities. Our bills are massive though mortgage is pretty small. We are incredibly lucky not to have to worry about the cost of things. I don’t know how people are managing these days.

threeisacharm18 · 17/08/2023 20:56

We have a decent income with 3 kids - but we spend 4.5k on childcare. It means we have no money for luxuries like holidays. It sucks . I can't see that hill coming down more when all 3 are in school as I'll be paying for wraparound care too.

Honeychickpea · 17/08/2023 20:14

Murrain · 17/08/2023 09:50

This. I have one child by choice, as a direct result of growing up in a large, poor family. It was miserable — we shared not just rooms but (small) beds for long periods, there was nowhere quiet to do your homework (I studied for my A level equivalents lying flat on my lower bunk, because there was nowhere else), barely enough food, knowing never to invite a friend because there was no extra to go round), parents only focused on food and clothes, and individual attention only to the younger ones who had, obviously, more physical needs.

So no, sometimes it just doesn’t work. Petiole do just have large numbers of children they can’t afford..

I grew up in a place and time where large families (6+ kids) was the norm, and it was as you described. Never any holidays, very few new clothes, everything handed down. The older kids treated as built in free childcare for the younger. Older girls often kept home from school to help the mother cope. Much much lower expectations, parenting was really down to feeding and just about clothing the kids. It's not much like you see on television.

DemBonesDemBones · 17/08/2023 19:48

4 kids here, in our married life our income has ranged from 17k to now 55k. We've just bought a house where everyone has their own bedroom (2 share, currently.) We moved to a cheaper country to be able to buy a house. We haven't been abroad on holiday yet, we will be going next year and it is costing £4300 all inclusive for a week.
No family nearby, and we have never had family help.

Schnitzelvonkrummm · 17/08/2023 19:28

TMess · 17/08/2023 19:05

About 250k. I don’t think that much is necessary by any means at all to have a larger family (I have a number of friends with more children on a lot less money) but I won’t pretend it doesn’t help tremendously.

Wow, what does your dh do? I’d love to earn that much but it’s probably out of my grasp

OP posts:
9peoplecalling · 17/08/2023 19:08

I have 6 children - dh works i am a sahm . We home educate (well the two oldest are at college now but the youngest 4 are still home ed).

im not sure what the answer is to your question income is around 80-90k from dh and as for time i enjoy it so it doesnt seem too much to me.

my kids seem happy enough with it at least the oldest when offered an opportunity to move out for college says she would
much rather live here so it cant be that bad!

TMess · 17/08/2023 19:05

Schnitzelvonkrummm · 17/08/2023 19:03

How much is a lot? If you don’t mind sharing

About 250k. I don’t think that much is necessary by any means at all to have a larger family (I have a number of friends with more children on a lot less money) but I won’t pretend it doesn’t help tremendously.

Schnitzelvonkrummm · 17/08/2023 19:03

TMess · 17/08/2023 18:41

I have 5. They each have their own bedroom and we have nice holidays etc. The simple fact is that my DH makes a lot. It sounds really crass to say out loud but that’s the facts. My husband grew up with double digit siblings and no money and he loved his childhood, but I’m thankful we’re able to provide ours with both a big family and nice material things.

How much is a lot? If you don’t mind sharing

OP posts:
CaptainJackSparrow85 · 17/08/2023 18:53

Ladyoftheknight · 17/08/2023 10:48

We live in London, where another nursery was going to charge £2,300 a month. We didn't want to put our childrenin nurseries further away from us with poor ratings and reputations, so we picked the next best thing and they charge around £1800 per month.

Without outing my childrens nursery, I can't do much else to help you believe it!

I find it incredibly easy to believe. I’m not even in London (Home Counties) and the local nursery is £100 a day per child. I know lots of people who’ve hired a nanny because it’s often a cheaper option once you have 2+ kids (depending on a few variables like age gaps, entitlement to funding, top up fees charged by the nursery)

TMess · 17/08/2023 18:41

I have 5. They each have their own bedroom and we have nice holidays etc. The simple fact is that my DH makes a lot. It sounds really crass to say out loud but that’s the facts. My husband grew up with double digit siblings and no money and he loved his childhood, but I’m thankful we’re able to provide ours with both a big family and nice material things.

worriedatwork123 · 17/08/2023 18:33

we have 5 - 2 are adults now but still live at home. We have a 6 bedroom detached house - was a 4 and we converted the loft when our youngest was born

we both work full time earning 150-175k between us

we have just had a cheap self catering holiday in Uk - for 3 youngest

we don't go abroad every year but when we do I book a villa and flights separately - much cheaper.

We have both improved our prospects - started off with 2 kids in 2 bed terrance earning about 30k between us - then moved to 3 bed semi and had 4 kids earning as little as 28k but rising to 60k over time

flowertoday · 17/08/2023 18:28

I have a big family ( five children ), we both work and always have and own our own home. We do not claim any benefits and have never had any childcare support from family.
I feel judged often, and unless people ask don't talk about my family size. It is an area where people do feel free to make comments that can be unkind.
Financially we have always made it work. I genuinely feel that avoiding buying / consuming unless it is stuff you really need is the way forward. If we have needed extra money we have worked longer hours. We don't buy new clothes for ourselves ( do for the kids) or new cars, drink or smoke. I haven't been abroad for years - none of it is a big deal as I am happy to buy second hand and holiday in this country. I hope this makes some difference to the environmental impact of having a bigger family, although I know it doesn't entirely.
I love my family , and don't regret anything or any of my choices.
I continue to feel that women cannot win - work / don't work, have too few or no children. There will be criticism from somewhere ....

Ineedasitdown · 17/08/2023 18:21

Schnitzelvonkrummm · 17/08/2023 17:47

I do feel sorry for the kids, in addition to having awful names, the older 3 seem to care for the younger ones, and are almost groomed into either being a ‘pastor’ or into having scores of kids.

ive not seen the pages debunking the gloss though

You won’t see it on instagram. Have a look on Reddit and Facebook- I’d put aside an evening though! It’s a rabbit hole. Google fundie snark.the debunk all the gloss. Essentially these people put a gloss on the lifestyle to evangelise and convert people to what is portrayed as a simpler more wholesome life as long as you forget about women’s equality. These are the trump base. It’s equally fascinating and horrifying when you dig deeper.

Meerkatdog · 17/08/2023 18:20

A lot of people say you can't give 4 kids enough time, but I totally disagree. If you have a supportive husband who is around in the evenings then it's no different to many families who have two and are either single parents or have a partner working away/long hours
It depends how much time you want to yourself, and how dedicated you are to family life. We don't have much of a life outside our kids although that will change once they are older and more independent. But I'm an all or nothing kind of person. Pre kids I was a party girl, loads of hobbies etc then once I had kids I threw myself into family life, wanted lots of children and dropped everything else. I don't try to hold onto any semblance of my old life.

Also children don't need loads of dedicated one on one time. It's important to have SOME one on one time, but raising kids that expect constant attention isn't good either, life won't be like that when they leave home. Being able to occupy yourself, and enjoy a process or hobby without constant praise is important.

Littleme2023 · 17/08/2023 18:10

Schnitzelvonkrummm · 17/08/2023 09:53

That was another thing, the emotional time and physical ability to care of that many kids… im sure some do manage but that social media family it seemed like the older ones were taking care of the younger ones but I guess that’s bound to happen with 10 kids and 5 of them being 5 and under.

I have 4 children 10 and under and the giving my children my time is what I definitely find the hardest, they are constantly vying for my attention and I’m shattered a lot so it’s what I find the most difficult. I am very lucky that I have a very supportive husband and people that help out so I try to get 121 time in as much as possible.

My eldest is constantly trying to parent the younger ones lol and I’m always having to tell him that’s my job not his. I am teaching my children to be independent and while at I’m not getting them “working” as such they know to tidy their toys away, make their beds, put dirty washing in the basket, rubbish in the bin and dirty plates in the sink etc. they like helping out in the garden and that’s a team job to get that sorted. We make it work.

Financially, it’s not easy but you make it work, vinted, hand me downs from friends and charity shops are a godsend. I don’t get everything brand new. We also save all year for Christmas and I have already started picking up stocking fillers to spread out the cost.

We have an annual income of about 80-85k depending on overtime. Holiday are uk every year. Sometimes a week somewhere, sometimes 3-4 weekends away or overnight stays here and there.

I do worry about finances and am looking to retrain to double my earning abilities to make the future a bit less daunting for us. We are comfortable for now and have play money left each month and decent savings but I know teenagers will cost me double what they cost me now.

NeverAloneNeverAgain · 17/08/2023 18:07

We have 4 between 18yrs - 8months.

My salary is 42k. Husband doesn't work any more (health related) so have no childcare costs which is massively helpful.

We're definitely not wealthy but are comfortable and live within our means. Have everything we need and some of what we want!

We shop at aldi and cook from scratch as convenience food is more expensive. I take a portion of last night's tea for lunch at work so that reduces needless spending for us.

We have 1 car although it's relatively new and live in a 3 bed house. Thankfully all the rooms are decent doubles so we've been able to adapt to create personal space for the older ones. We downsized from a 4bed last year when finances took a tumble.

Holidays - Turkey or haven (the price is very similar!) and do day trips and the odd weekend. We live north Yorkshire area so not a widely expensive pocket of the world.

We don't use credit and have no debts so that's helped during cost of living as no panic over rising interest rates.

I tend to buy clothes out of season when they're cheaper and in sales. Shoes are the big expensive as they blow through them like there's no tomorrow.

I wouldn't say we struggle although by the end of the month things feel a bit tight. If we knew our finances would be changing we probably wouldn't have had our 4th but you make decisions with the info you have at the time and adjust.

monty09 · 17/08/2023 17:58

We have 6 DC between us ages 16-7, 5 live with us full time the other comes eow. We have a 3 bedrooms so 3 in each when they are all here. We have an 8 seater car and have days out. My OH works full time, I'm self employed but still trying to get started. We rent off a family member so it is a bit cheaper.

Schnitzelvonkrummm · 17/08/2023 17:47

Ineedasitdown · 17/08/2023 17:36

I’ll apologise if someone has already commented on this, however the Collins family are US Christian fundamentalists. Main occupation is grifting and conveniently live in a state with low child protection standards. If they were uk based social services would be all over them like a rash and they would be “that” family on the estate. The fundie snarking boards are a mine of information for debunking the instagram gloss.

I do feel sorry for the kids, in addition to having awful names, the older 3 seem to care for the younger ones, and are almost groomed into either being a ‘pastor’ or into having scores of kids.

ive not seen the pages debunking the gloss though

OP posts:
fedupnow2 · 17/08/2023 17:39

Nothing would make me hate life more than having a big family. I have 2 and life is so hard and miserable. 4 would just tip me over.

Ineedasitdown · 17/08/2023 17:36

BoohooWoohoo · 17/08/2023 09:40

Do the Instagram family have lots of practical help from extended family? Not having to pay nursery fees alone is tens of thousands of pounds not needed.

I’ll apologise if someone has already commented on this, however the Collins family are US Christian fundamentalists. Main occupation is grifting and conveniently live in a state with low child protection standards. If they were uk based social services would be all over them like a rash and they would be “that” family on the estate. The fundie snarking boards are a mine of information for debunking the instagram gloss.

Meerkatdog · 17/08/2023 17:32

Just realised 'small 5 bed' sounds a bit insensitive. What I mean by that is it's a small house for a 5 bed, so a standard 3 bed semi with a loft conversion, as opposed to large 5 bed house.

Swipe left for the next trending thread