Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you enjoy drag, to ask why?

256 replies

ForestGoblin · 17/08/2023 07:08

I don't get it at all. It looks to me like a crude mockery of women. Even on the presumably somewhat sanitised RuPaul, the word for a "realistic" (ie could pass as a woman) drag queen is "fish"... A reference to being so womanly it's as though they have a vagina. I feel like they hate women and are performing all the things they find ridiculous about us in a really hammed up way. Making us seem bitchy and preening.

Also, more fundamentally, I don't understand the entertainment factor of "oh haha it's a man who looks a bit like a lady haha he's in a dress haha". So? On which note, how on earth are the lady boys of Bangkok still going strong with their tour. Don't give me oo the costumes and skillful songs and dances - as if people would go to see "the costumed dancers of Bangkok". There's some wow factor to seeing "ladyboys" specifically.

But loads of my friends love it. So it can't actually be as bad as I think. (Can it?)

Yanbu - drag is offensive to women or just not entertaining

Yabu - drag is awesome

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
bonzaitree · 17/08/2023 09:45

jellyfrizz · 17/08/2023 09:33

I don't think anyone is offended by the dressing up or make up. It's the 'woman' act while dressing up, wearing make up and acting out stereotypes about being bitchy or whatever.

I think that gay men know they’re bitchier than women. This is them poking fun at themselves!

bonzaitree · 17/08/2023 09:42

jellyfrizz · 17/08/2023 09:11

I don’t think it’s really making a mockery out of women. More that they’re poking fun at themselves for wanting to cross dress if I’m honest.

But why the 'woman' persona while doing it? Just wear the clothes and make up and take the piss out of yourself.

What’s offensive about playing a character? Actors do this all the time.

EmilyDickinson · 17/08/2023 09:39

I don’t think that’s why people think it can’t be compared. It’s because blackface is without exception offensive. There’s a wide range of drag with only the extreme end of the spectrum being offensive

I agree with you that blackface is always offensive, but I think that there was also a range and that some forms of blackface were deemed offensive before others.

For example it used to be commonplace for white actors to wear makeup to play parts such as Othello. Laurence Olivier did so and I think it’s on film. Now it is accepted that a black actor should always play the part of Othello.

Also, regarding men playing women’s parts in Shakespeare’s time. This wasn’t a choice made by playwrights or theatre companies. Women were not allowed on the stage in Shakespeare’s time, so if you wanted to write a play with women’s parts a workaround had to be found. This was to have young boys with unbroken voices (not men) playing women as they could most convincingly do so. Even so Shakespeare often contrived to have the female character disguised as a boy for much of the play, so that the portrayal didn’t actually have to be that convincing or jar too much for most of the performance.

Once women were allowed on the stage they did play women’s parts. No one claimed that there was any tradition, art or merit in men continuing to do so.

winewolfhowls · 17/08/2023 09:36

I think in the last few years mainstream drag seems to be making a move to be more about the art and costumes than the horrible misogynistic names and offensive banter. At least I hope so. Women could help by boycotting the crass seaside hen do type shows, I've never got why people support these. I love to see what Utica is wearing from Ru Paul's drag race because that is an androgynous alien style.

jellyfrizz · 17/08/2023 09:33

eish · 17/08/2023 09:18

I agree with this entirely. It would be a bit like saying I like all comedy when I simply don’t. I don’t like the innuendo in any comedy (male, female, drag etc) as I don’t think it is very clever. I don’t get offended by the make up, dressing up I think a lot is brilliant but there are some drag artists that I do find offensive or plain old dull (just like comedians).

I don't think anyone is offended by the dressing up or make up. It's the 'woman' act while dressing up, wearing make up and acting out stereotypes about being bitchy or whatever.

WhatATimeToBeAlive · 17/08/2023 09:31

I used to think drag queens were very funny and sharp - but also very much adult entertainment, along with strippers. But these days they seem to parody women much more and becoming more offensive.

ForestGoblin · 17/08/2023 09:29

YeahIsaidit · 17/08/2023 09:24

I've always thought the "fish" reference was more along the lines of "catfish" as in they're so feminine looking they could pass as a woman and catfish men?

No...

OP posts:
FrogTaped · 17/08/2023 09:28

maslinpan · 17/08/2023 07:18

Drag names like Anna Bortion and Miss Carriage show me that misogyny is deeply entrenched in some performers.

😲

Tinktravels · 17/08/2023 09:28

I really don't understand the appeal, especially the lip sinking? Where's the talent in that?

KimberleyClark · 17/08/2023 09:27

DustyLee123 · 17/08/2023 07:10

It’s no different to men who used to dress up and mock women in the 70’s, like Les Dawson. Except they knew they were not women.

Les Dawson wasn’t mocking women, he knew they had hard lives working in mills and factories where it was too noisy to talk so they had to devise another means of communicating with exaggerated lip movements. He also loved his MIL and she made him promise on her deathbed to not stop telling jokes about her.

Also the likes of Dick Emery and Stanley Baxter - they weren’t drag queens, they didn’t do exaggerated sexualised portrayals of women with huge wigs and loads of make up - they just acted. They both took the piss out of male stereotypes too.

JamSandle · 17/08/2023 09:27

maslinpan · 17/08/2023 07:18

Drag names like Anna Bortion and Miss Carriage show me that misogyny is deeply entrenched in some performers.

Especially when women in many parts of the world aren't able to legally and safely have abortions even if they are victims of rape.

YeahIsaidit · 17/08/2023 09:24

ForestGoblin · 17/08/2023 07:52

It's nothing to do with men wearing dresses and makeup. It's about the "fish" attitude.

I've always thought the "fish" reference was more along the lines of "catfish" as in they're so feminine looking they could pass as a woman and catfish men?

Lisbeth50 · 17/08/2023 09:23

This came to mind because of "Cheryl Hole" appearing on a cooking programme.

I was quite shocked to see this person on Masterchef last night. I'd never heard of them before so I googled and discovered the character was based on Cheryl Cole which I thought was quite offensive. The presenters referred to Cheryl & the two female contestants as "the girls". Cheryl also did a lot of shrieking and hand waving which I presume was them parodying a female.

BIossomtoes · 17/08/2023 09:19

LimeCheesecake · 17/08/2023 09:13

There’s a lot of posters on here saying drag can’t be compared to blackface because the artists performing it are talented and it’s entertainment- it does seem that said posters don’t get that blackface shows like the black and white minstrel show had talented singers, complex and impressive dance routines and great comedians and was still fundamentally racists and offensive at its core.

I don’t think that’s why people think it can’t be compared. It’s because blackface is without exception offensive. There’s a wide range of drag with only the extreme end of the spectrum being offensive.

SallyWD · 17/08/2023 09:18

My friends are all really in to it. They love that Drag Race programme and go to Drag shows and say things like "Oh it's fabulous!".
I however, just don't get it. It's not that I think it's offensive to women or mocking women. I really don't mind that aspect of it and I don't think the main intention is to make fun of women. It's not because I find it crude and am offended by the sexual jokes and innuendo. That's all fine with me.
I just genuinely don't find that type of humour funny. It's all a bit OTT and obvious. I love comedy but I think I prefer more gentle, subtle comedy. I also like surreal, off the wall, clever comedy. The Drag style comedy I've seen is just a bit silly!

MentholLoad · 17/08/2023 09:18

I have seen a handful of drag acts on stage over the years. they all made 'fish' jokes, which the audience seemed to enjoy. they weren't funny and their 'comedy' was all about mocking women. although I have been told they are not caricaturing women, but the stereotype of gay men

eish · 17/08/2023 09:18

FiddleLeaf · 17/08/2023 07:31

Love the makeup, clothes and creativity. Some are amazing comedians and so quick witted.

I’m not into the innuendo type drag queens though.

I agree with this entirely. It would be a bit like saying I like all comedy when I simply don’t. I don’t like the innuendo in any comedy (male, female, drag etc) as I don’t think it is very clever. I don’t get offended by the make up, dressing up I think a lot is brilliant but there are some drag artists that I do find offensive or plain old dull (just like comedians).

LimeCheesecake · 17/08/2023 09:13

There’s a lot of posters on here saying drag can’t be compared to blackface because the artists performing it are talented and it’s entertainment- it does seem that said posters don’t get that blackface shows like the black and white minstrel show had talented singers, complex and impressive dance routines and great comedians and was still fundamentally racists and offensive at its core.

FloweryName · 17/08/2023 09:12

I don’t like drag and never have, but it’s only recently that I’ve begun to see that it’s offensive.

Before that I just thought it was a bit creepy because there’s always something creepy to me about people hiding who they really are and that the comedy is banal.

jellyfrizz · 17/08/2023 09:11

I don’t think it’s really making a mockery out of women. More that they’re poking fun at themselves for wanting to cross dress if I’m honest.

But why the 'woman' persona while doing it? Just wear the clothes and make up and take the piss out of yourself.

CurlewKate · 17/08/2023 09:08

I'd be interested in how a straight male comedian taking the piss out of gay men with offensive stereotypes would go down. In the way that was, apparently so funny in the 1950s/60s.

Blinkinbloodyhayfever · 17/08/2023 09:08

I don't feel strongly enough to have an opinion either way. I've always loved the pantomime Dame, especially when its the hairy backed local bikers doing a charity show, but I know this is a world away from the misogynistic element. There are extremists and people who are happy to cause major offence in all niches.

Buffypaws · 17/08/2023 09:06

I used to like drag. Queens would point out that the idea of six inch nails and massive wigs being inherently womanly was nonsense and it was all about rejecting the trappings of femininity we have forced upon us. It was funny and crude but this was fine as it was confined to adult gay bars. It’s now much more mainstream which means people offended by it are going to see more of it. I don’t think Cheryl Hole should be on bbc shows about baking. It’s not some regular demographic it’s specifically adult entertainment. I bet they don’t have a stripper on there.

anyway, as I said for me drag was about rejecting stereotypes, gendered expectations etc. This morning I saw this of a queen who is however very clearly not subverting these, but making a mockery of women’s actual biological functions. Now I’m offended. Basically it’s gone too far. Which is a shame. He is pretending to spew milk from his comedy breasts if the image is not clear.

For the full show: https://x.com/rupaulsdragrace/status/1680642200969834496?s=46&t=R8lbgugSDFu9UAWd3OTT3w

Heronwatcher · 17/08/2023 09:04

So the “proper” drag acts I’ve seen have been more than the dress up, it was a whole show with jokes/ a persona/ singing and generally pretty good and witty. Not seen one for a while though but to me the difference is that unlike many in the trans movement they were also taking the piss out of themselves and in no way expected to be treated as women in other day to day circumstances (I don’t think many of them went and competed in a swimming race as a woman, or went to a breastfeeding cafe for validation the next day!) so on that level I didn’t personally feel that they were harming women kind in general. So I think I see a good drag act as being separate from the issues which come with the trans movement.

bonzaitree · 17/08/2023 09:03

Personally I really don’t find it offensive. I like the makeup, wigs, outfits and humour of drag race and have been to live drag shows too in gay bars. Love how OTT the outfits and humour are.

I don’t think it’s really making a mockery out of women. More that they’re poking fun at themselves for wanting to cross dress if I’m honest.

The comedy is often my cup of tea (although different queens have different styles). Often drag queens are so quick with their come backs etc because it’s a coping mechanism from people saying comments to them as kids / adults.

But I see how it could come across badly. I don’t think you’re being unreasonable for not liking it. It’s your opinion and we all have one!