Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you enjoy drag, to ask why?

256 replies

ForestGoblin · 17/08/2023 07:08

I don't get it at all. It looks to me like a crude mockery of women. Even on the presumably somewhat sanitised RuPaul, the word for a "realistic" (ie could pass as a woman) drag queen is "fish"... A reference to being so womanly it's as though they have a vagina. I feel like they hate women and are performing all the things they find ridiculous about us in a really hammed up way. Making us seem bitchy and preening.

Also, more fundamentally, I don't understand the entertainment factor of "oh haha it's a man who looks a bit like a lady haha he's in a dress haha". So? On which note, how on earth are the lady boys of Bangkok still going strong with their tour. Don't give me oo the costumes and skillful songs and dances - as if people would go to see "the costumed dancers of Bangkok". There's some wow factor to seeing "ladyboys" specifically.

But loads of my friends love it. So it can't actually be as bad as I think. (Can it?)

Yanbu - drag is offensive to women or just not entertaining

Yabu - drag is awesome

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
6
scorpiogirly · 19/01/2024 10:54

I find it very unpleasant. It's not for me although I was willing to live and let live, until they displayed an unhealthy penchant for reading to children.

CurlewKate · 19/01/2024 09:58

I think that basically, drag is not a gender or a sexuality. So I don't understand why it's being treated as if it is.

Flufferblub · 18/01/2024 21:53

I used to like Paul O'Grady as Lilly Savage, and Steve Coogan as Pauline Calf. I haven't taken any notice more recently

CurlewKate · 18/01/2024 21:48

@Trixiefirecracker "Neither is pantomime (witty I mean)"

Yes-that's what I said!

Trixiefirecracker · 18/01/2024 21:17

CurlewKate · 16/01/2024 10:44

It's practically by definition misogynist. A drag queen called Cheryl Hole appeared on Masterchef and this was considered completely OK.

No, it's not the same as pantomime.
No, drag acts are rarely, if ever witty.

Neither is pantomime (witty I mean).😳

BobbyBiscuits · 16/01/2024 12:14

Weirdly when I was about 9 I had a fascination with drag. There was a drag troupe/ show called Bloolips and I begged my Mum to take me. She thought I was on a wind up! Now as an adult woman, can't bloody stand it. Unfunny, sexist, pointless.
Grayson Perry (sometimes) cross-dresses. He does not do Drag and should not be put in that category.

CurlewKate · 16/01/2024 10:44

It's practically by definition misogynist. A drag queen called Cheryl Hole appeared on Masterchef and this was considered completely OK.

No, it's not the same as pantomime.
No, drag acts are rarely, if ever witty.

SiobhanSharpe · 16/01/2024 08:54

I don't generally watch drag shows but a few years ago I was on a girls' night out (Ladies Night, special meal, music and dancing) with a comedian who was a drag performer.
Sadly, this chap, 'Pussy A-Plenty' or similar, wasn't at all funny but he got increasingly crude really, really crude and finally, downright insulting and offensive to the many groups of women in the room. He wasn't getting any laughs and ended up quite nasty and aggressive, perhaps because we weren't adoring him uncritically.

Looking back, he was just mocking femininity and the entire act was performative misogyny. He deserved the reactions he got.

Having also viewed video clips of inappropriate behaviour around children at DQ story hour I can't say I'm much of a fan.

Notimeforaname · 16/01/2024 08:31

I feel like they hate women and are performing all the things they find ridiculous about us in a really hammed up way. Making us seem bitchy and preening.
Cant speak for all of them but this is 100% not the case for my friends who do drag. The friends I've known since we were children.

PriOn1 · 16/01/2024 08:23

I think dressing as women was normalized by comedians and pantomime dames (who always made risqué jokes to make the adults in the audience laugh) and it’s gradually slid into being more publicly misogynistic (previously proper drag was a bit like burlesque - not mainstream adults only) but it’s then very difficult to draw that line of where it slips into being offensive.

A lot of misogyny is like that and I would add that there are many things in society that reflect this but are so common we often don’t even notice them, such as men being taken more seriously and listened to more. I also think there’s a push to normalise sexual behaviour that would previously have been seen as deviant and I think that’s going too far too.

I don’t know what to do about it though, other than pointing out when it’s really stepped over that line and perhaps complaining to the TV station that’s putting that material out.

MyStarBoy · 16/01/2024 08:08

I find it extremely creepy.

Westernesse · 16/01/2024 07:53

i find it grotesque aesthetically and I don’t get the joke. What is funny about it? Where is the humour?

cerisepanther73 · 16/01/2024 06:20

I have never found Lily Savage character funny
but i liked Paul o Grady when he was being very much himself,
I also liked Dama Edna tv series with Julian Clarey back in the day early 90s era,

I have liked other camp characters on tv

Also like pantomimes family entertainment ones
Drag artists

It's just the really crude ones drag artists i just don't get understand their kind of humour being classed as entertaining art at all...

YoBeaches · 19/08/2023 09:00

m.youtube.com/watch?v=eOR2GdZ1mVk

Absolutely NO Misogyny here...

SequinsandStiIettos · 18/08/2023 21:55

Conchita wasn't on RPDR obvs but I was pointing out that facial hair can also be part of the persona.
From all the names above, I loved Choriza May, a Spanish-British drag act. The name just tickled me. Then Ella Vaday, Cheddar Gorgeous and Farrah Moan.

The drag King Elvis Herselvis's name is inspired.

SequinsandStiIettos · 18/08/2023 21:44

Only people who are exhibitionist/autogynephilic/out to shock need you to react.
All performers want to be seen and appreciated - that's neither unusual nor unacceptable. Even those of us who are not performers like to have our egos stroked from time to time.
Whilst I don't particularly need attention or validation from those around me, it's nice to have a compliment or a thank you, akin to applause i'm never going to get applause in my job Grin

I like to geek out so I spent some time looking at drag artist names.
From 514 names, you can say that 10 are misogynist (Cheryl Hole, A'Whora, Kandy Ho, Maxi Shield, Cookie Kunty, Ginger Bitch, Pandora Boxx, Penny Tration, Ginger Minj, Juice Boxx)
Sister Fibrosis, JonBenet Blonde, Detox Icunt and Bitch on Arrival all had to change/modify their names. The worst of those imo is disablist not misogynist.

I like puns as I've said, including user names on here (SuePerbly etc). It harks back to days of supply teaching when the paper registers you'd get back would inevitably have Ben Dover, Theresa Green, Annette Curtain, Hugh Jarse and Phil McCrackin written on them in juvenile script.

From 514 performers on RPDR, many names aren't puns at all. The UK and Australian drag acts seem to like plays on words more than the States.
The majority of these have nothing to do with female genitalia or slurs against women. Many are lame/forced however and even RuPaul has been WTF.

For anyone who is interested otherwise move on Grin sashay away
Brand names: Minnie Cooper, Jan Sport, Brita Filter (latter two had to drop surname on RPDR)
Drugs: Kita Mean, Crystal Methyd
Objects: Barbie Q, Plastique Tiara (oof!) Elektra Fence
Foods: Tia Kofi, Baga Chipz, Shuga Cain, Kim Chi, Sminty Drop, Black Peppa
Places: Cheddar Gorgeous, Brooke Lynn Hytes, River Medway, Monet X Change
Not female: Yuri Guaii, Faux Fur, Sum Ting Wong
Not out: Heidi N Closet, Charlie Hides
Personality: Ivana Vamp, Imaa Queen, Mimi Imfurst, Amadiva

There are plays on female celebrities other than Cheryl Cole (who incidentally was on the panel when Cheryl Hole performed).
These include: Tina Burner, Enorma Jean, Choriza May, Kendall Gender and Rachel McAdamsApple (the latter was a one-off).

In the vein of Scissor Sisters icon Ana Matronic: Farrah Moan, Charity Kase, Gia Metric, Minty Fresh, Elektra Shock, Hannah Conda

In the vein of Friends fictional Helena Handbasket: Ella Vaday, Courtney Act, Kitty Scott-Claus, Aubrey Haive, Rita Menu,

Performers like Danny Beard and Conchita Wurst were hirsute
Joe Black, Derrick Barry, Lawrence Chaney all used own names. Bob the drag queen thought it was funny (audience member hadn't heard their name and thought they were called Kate before descending on Bob)
Vanessa Williams chose the name Vanquisha De House for her alter ego

StephanieSuperpowers · 18/08/2023 15:58

I don't really care what people do in their private lives but I don't necessarily want to see it or be party to it.

Unfortunately, they really, really need you to see it and react to fully enjoy it.

LivStanshall · 18/08/2023 15:56

I'm not a fan. I don't like pantomime either. I agree it is misogynistic and mocks women. I'll add in Grayson Perry and his ridiculous outfits as well, I don't really care what people do in their private lives but I don't necessarily want to see it or be party to it.

LoobyDop · 18/08/2023 15:13

Dame Edna was far more about satirising petty snobbery than gender. Although a big part of her act was the in-joke with the audience that she was the most delicate, feminine example of a woman you could ever possibly encounter, and wasn’t it sad for the poor ladies who couldn’t quite compete, bless them. But the joke was the absurdity of a man in a dress saying that. You weren’t supposed to believe it. She also only ever referred to sex in the context of laughing at male sexual appetites. The character herself was generally bemused and often disgusted by the concept. Not in any way the same as the kind of drag acts mentioned here.

SequinsandStiIettos · 18/08/2023 14:50

Watched it (well the parts Cheryl was in). They came, they cooked, they lost. Were they entertaining in this? Not especially, I laughed once when they said "Magic! Magic!" when the pudding was so set, it could be lifted. But that's a personality thing rather than a drag thing. Lily Savage before Paul decided to retire her, was very funny, went on This Morning etc
And they didn't once think they were actually women. and neither do all drag artists. RuPaul is very clear on who he is. So is The Vivienne.
And none are based on actual women which was my point earlier. I don't see appropriation if the characters couldn't be further than the reality. I'm trying to think of any women who are similar (apart from the OTT nature of duck face selfies) and can only think of Gemma Collins...who is playing a character/parody of herself in The GC and knows exactly what she's doing.

TooBigForMyBoots · 18/08/2023 14:44

I love it. I've seen some amazing drag acts over the years.

Nanny0gg · 18/08/2023 14:34

DustyLee123 · 17/08/2023 07:10

It’s no different to men who used to dress up and mock women in the 70’s, like Les Dawson. Except they knew they were not women.

Them I found funny. Also Dame Edna and Lily Savage who were incredibly witty and were channelling women they actually knew/had observed. And they didn't once think they were actually women.
Not so much Danny La Rue and as for today's current crop, they are too sexually explicit. And none are based on actual women.

Runnersandtoms · 18/08/2023 14:32

I remember giggling over panto dames and the two Ronnies dressed up as cleaning ladies etc when I was a kid. And when my kids were younger we'd have a giggle when my son and daughter wore each others pjs because my big chunky boy shaped boy looked so incongruous in pink frills.

I do think that's very different from the drag acts who are getting a lot of airtime wearing outrageous, sexualised outfits and using names relating to sex and female body parts.

I think it's partly about the sexualisation of it and the disrespect towards women, and it's also because back in the day nobody was pretending Ronnie Barker was actually a woman because he put on a flowery dress and fake boobs. Ok the old silly drag was a bit disrespectful towards women but they were equally disrespectful towards, say opticians or estate agents when doing a skit about them. It wasn't about misogyny. And often they'd talk about how put upon women were by men at the time etc.

SequinsandStiIettos · 18/08/2023 14:13

I was thinking more Blankety Blank etc
Barry Humphries was a legend.

Carsarelife · 18/08/2023 14:11

I absolutely hate it. Horrible. Not even funny or relateable

Swipe left for the next trending thread