Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To go and spend the weekend with my friend under these circumstances?

108 replies

beyondtherebound · 17/08/2023 04:43

Used to have a FWB situation with a man over a period of about 5 years. It started as sex, but over the years, the benefits became very much secondary to the friendship, and he became one of my closest friends. We did sometimes get silly after a few drinks, but not that often in the end.

Then he got into a serious relationship and distanced himself. I've been there myself the other way around. So I was a bit miffed but I understood and was happy he was happy.

I haven't heard from him in 6 months and he called me out the blue to meet for a drink yesterday.

Turns out his GF had upped and left him over night, a couple of weeks back. He came home from a work trip and all her stuff was gone. It sounds horrendous.

Without a doubt he called me thinking a rebound shag would make him feel better (I don't judge him for that, it's very normal to want validation and intimacy a break-up) but instead I forced him to sit down and talk, and he ended up just pouring his heart out for hours. He's completely heartbroken.

I felt absolutely nothing for him except empathy and sadness as his friend. He'd clearly not had a good chance to talk it through with anyone and was so confused and in pain. He's not been eating or sleeping well. I've never seen him like this. Needless to say he didn't get anything from me except a lot of hugs and a listening ear.

He's got to go and cat sit for his parents in Devon for the weekend and asked if I'd go with him, as he was dreading being there alone.

I don't have anything else on and he clearly needs someone to drag him out the house for some air, make sure he eats some proper dinner and let him talk and cry and muddle through it all.

Our relationship has two such distinct sides to it though, that I'm torn.

The friend side of me feels like it's absolutely the right thing to do. He's very dear to me and he's in pain and I'd do it for any one of my female friends, even if they'd been a rubbish friend while they'd been loved-up. I have no doubt that just being there for some company and to make sure he's not wallowing, will absolutely help him get through the worst of it.

The side of me that used to sleep with him though, and knows he also thinks a rebound shag will make him feel better, feels a bit icky about it (although I've got no right to be self righteous about it as I've called on him for the same reason before).

I realise I don't have to sleep with him even if I do go, so it's not the act of it itself, but more just feeling that that part of our past makes it feel a bit less 'above board', to go and spend the weekend with him.

OP posts:
Brightandshining · 17/08/2023 11:17

Id go if thats what you want to do. Just be aware he might come on to you and come up with a plan of how you will respond. Friends are important whatever their gender. And as you've said you've come onto him for similar reasons i understand that you know he might do the same to you and its no insult. As long as you are sure you trust him enough that he'd accept rejection and just value your being there anyway.

BetterWithPockets · 17/08/2023 11:12

Would you want to go, OP, if you knew there’d be no expectation of sex? If so, I’d be up front with him and go.

Idontgiveashitanymore · 17/08/2023 11:11

Just tell him you’re not having sex with him then ask him if he still wants you to go !

Grimchmas · 17/08/2023 10:41

On the suicide thing - I say this as somebody who has lost a brother to suicide - it is NOT the responsibility of women to prevent men from killing themselves.

Sorry if that sounds blunt, but I think it's important to remember.

OP, I don't think you should go. He's single now, and I think taking you along with him is just surrogating in a friend/fb rather than getting used to being single.

DryIce · 17/08/2023 10:38

I think I'd go, assuming you want to of course - taking all the other complications out of it.

Yes, he used you as a booty call - but there seems precedent in your relationship for that kind of overture, and he doesn't seem to have reacted negatively when it didn't happen. I wouldn't let solely pride over this stop me going.

As you say, there's two parts to your relationships - I'd go, making it clear I was there in the friend part capacity, not the sex part. I'd probably be more inclined to do it for a male firend tbh, as they often have less emotional support in general and he may genuinely not have anyone else to support him.

But again, I don't think you're obliged. I think either option is acceptable morally and friendship-wise , so really the only question is - do you want to?

chimamandafan · 17/08/2023 10:35

If it suited me, and if I fancied a few days in Devon. and maybe some swimming and sightseeing (on my own, possibly) I'd go because that would mean there was something to be gained from the trip apart from offering support. Make sure that if absolutely necessary you have the money to come back under your own steam if things go pear-shaped. (I'm assuming he'll drive you down.)

Before going I'd make it clear that sex was not on offer now or ever, and that you want separate rooms and absolutely no expectation from him that you'll sleep with him. If you feel you might be tempted after a few drinks to offer him a consolation shag, don't go, you'll regret it bitterly. Also make it clear that you don't plan to sit around the house all weekend while he weeps about the woman he liked more than you.

Others have already pointed out that he dropped your friendship when it suited him and now wants to resume when it suits him. It's not on. You're not a support bot. Be different from now on: do what suits you around him.

Rewis · 17/08/2023 10:27

I think this is exactly how fwb go. You hook up, when one person meets someone else you take a step back, when you're single again you approach the fwb to see if they are available to continue. Keep this going until one breaks it off completely.

I do think it's unrealistic to keep a genuine friendship with someone you've had fwb thing for 5 years while they're in a relationship. And I'm a but dubious about a meaningful deep friendship with someone you're hooking up with. I truly think men and women can be friends but usually if there is no sex involved.

I'd go if I was open to starting a fwb. I wouldn't go to just be a shoulder to cry on for the whole weekend. If this was someone I was in a platonic friendship with then yes. But an ex-fwb nah.

ohwhatadustyanswer · 17/08/2023 10:23

I’d probably go because a weekend in the Devon countryside in the sunshine sounds nice. I would make clear it was friends-only and possibly feel a bit guilty using him for a free summer break.

PrrrplePineapple · 17/08/2023 10:23

I wouldn't. You don't really want to go but feel like you should by the sound of it. But he had no such feelings when he dropped you like a hot potato once he got into this relationship. If he cared about you as a friend, he would have stayed in touch and made time for you throughout his relationship. You owe him nothing on the friendship front, you've already done enough. He is using you as emotional support and will drop you again when he gets what he wants. Do not feel bad about drawing a boundary and leaving him to deal with it in hs own time.

Highdaysandholidays1 · 17/08/2023 10:14

I wouldn't go. I'd go for my best friend, but then she wouldn't drop me for 6 months and then turn up again when her partner dumped her. Far too available, you aren't his best friend, it's just not an equal friendship and I don't think he'd do the same for you, if his girlfriend was still around and you had been dumped. you probably wouldn't have even got a phone call.

Whatswhatwhichiswhich · 17/08/2023 10:14

A weekend supporting your friend through his breakup sounds like a lovely thing to do. There doesn’t need to be any sex if you don’t want there to be, you don’t even have to share the same bed.

HarridanHarvestingHeldaBeans · 17/08/2023 10:13

I think that your relationship has changed, and that it would be unwise to carry on as if it hadn't. When you had sex for comfort/validation after a breakup, he was up for that, right? So no problem there. Has it ever happened before that you haven't wanted to when he is stressed or needed comfort?

I think that if you go, he will expect sex. I also think that you have moved on from having occasional sex with him. It might be a good idea, as others have said, to make it very clear if you don't intend for there to be any more sex in your relationship. Would it be possible to gather a few of his friends around him to maybe visit for the day at the weekend? So it's a bit less intimate and potentially less awkward if you do decide to go?

SunRainStorm · 17/08/2023 09:51

I mean he's hardly committed a faux pas by calling a former FWB for a shag after six months. Isn't that the whole point of FWB?

It sounds like the lines are blurred for you because he also wants deep emotional support. FWB is usually about keeping it light and complication free.

Marmite17 · 17/08/2023 09:43

I would go. You've said you enjoy spending time with him and he doesn't sound like a rapist! Just see where it goes relationship wise.

SpongeBobJudgeyPants · 17/08/2023 09:41

beyondtherebound · 17/08/2023 04:57

Would you say the same if it were a female friend though? (Just curious).

Cleaning the house, mowing the lawn, watching TV this weekend otherwise. Nothing exciting!

@beyondtherebound I would absolutely say the same if the female friend was someone I'd had a sexual relationship with in the past. I think the sex bit has complicated this for you, and is difficult in some ways to tease out from the friendship part.

AtrociousCircumstance · 17/08/2023 09:35

Yeah you may just feel used whether there’s sex or not. Because you are being used. He dumped you for six months and didn’t give you a second thought. Now he’s calling on you like a service provider.

Deathbyfluffy · 17/08/2023 09:29

Good to see people being so kind - I bet if it was a woman they’d be flocking to help 🙄

Good on you for being there - I’d go but make it clear nothing sexual is going to happen.

readbooksdrinktea · 17/08/2023 09:24

beyondtherebound · 17/08/2023 08:52

He has done the same for me in the same circumstances!

Then I would go.

Asmrmebaby · 17/08/2023 09:24

I think just do what you want to do. There is no "right" or "wrong". You've said you'd do the same for a female friend and you've said he's even done the same for you so go with it as long as you won't feel pressured into anything you are not comfortable with.

Blinkinbloodyhayfever · 17/08/2023 09:23

I would go, just make it clear that the relationship is platonic. I think its important that everyone knows where they stand, particularly from a female safety pov.

80s · 17/08/2023 09:22

It's only two days? Could you arrange to phone for an hour both days?

Grimbelina · 17/08/2023 09:21

Go, but make sure you are clear with him before you go that you won't sleep with him... and also that you can get yourself home if you need to leave earlier than planned.

Zimunya · 17/08/2023 09:17

I would go - whatever the history - you are friends, and friends support each other. However, I would be entitely clear ahead of time that you are travelling as a friend, and there is absolitely no chance of any shenanigans occurring. I admire you for being the bigger person here.

Murrain · 17/08/2023 09:17

beyondtherebound · 17/08/2023 09:05

This is what I’m struggling with.

He is one of my favourite people to spend time with and someone I love dearly and has supported me through so many things both practically and emotionally.

But he’s also a man who called me after 6 months wanting a shag.

That’s the truth of it really. They’re two entirely separate but entirely true statements.

So you do actually want to go, but feel you shouldn’t want to, because he dropped you for six months and now thinks you’re a sure thing weekend booty call, even though you acknowledge you’ve done the same thing with him?

hygieneversusplanet · 17/08/2023 09:16

The friend side of me feels like it's absolutely the right thing to do. He's very dear to me and he's in pain and I'd do it for any one of my female friends, even if they'd been a rubbish friend while they'd been loved-up. I have no doubt that just being there for some company and to make sure he's not wallowing, will absolutely help him get through the worst of it.

That's understandable. I am wondering though - does this man have no other friends? No other male friends? Yes, he's distanced himself but didn't he have any other friends before besides you?