Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Don’t want husband to take kids 7 hr drive away

181 replies

Purpleplanes · 16/08/2023 22:26

Would be good to get some general views on this. My husband wants to visit his sister who lives a 7 hour drive up north from us. He has suggested that as he has more leave to take from work he could go and visit and stay with her for a week and take our kids with him who are aged 1 and 3 years old. Unfortunately I don’t have much leave available to take and I could only visit for a weekend instead.

i feel im being unreasonable but I really don’t feel comfortable with my 2 small kids being so far away from me and for so long. I know they are with my husband but still just feels so far away 😢. It is causing me lots of anxiety. My husband and kids could possibly fly up north which would reduce travel time but I feel overwhelmed the thought of him trying to manage our two small kids at an airport on his own and then hiring a car at the other side and then continuing their travels….feels really overwhelming. I’m wondering how others would feel in this situation? I think I’d feel much more comfortable them going alone in a couple of years and when the kids are older and their behaviour is more predictable etc. they just seem so young. Thanks

OP posts:
pikkumyy77 · 18/08/2023 17:04

I’m in the US where we fairly often drive seven plus hours but solo driving with a one year old and a three year old is an entirely different kettle of fish. Unless he plans to dive all night while they sleep he will be stopping every few hours for diaper changes and feeding. So 7 hours could rasily become 9-10. How is he going to juggle them with bathroom breaks and rest stops just solo?

If we are really talking a 1 year old (not 1.5) the recommendations (at least here) are not to keep them in the car seat for such an extended period of time anyway as 3 little bones, ligaments, snd muscles are not designed for sitting for an extended period with the neck/head not supported.

It is a bad idea—this has nothing to do with male parent vs female parent. He does not have the awareness or skills to realize how difficult a solo trip with such young children will be. Flying up would be far more manageable.

Mummaoffour1234 · 18/08/2023 17:03

It doesn’t matter whether other people think this is reasonable or not. If you don’t feel comfortable you have a right to say so.

GreyCarpet · 18/08/2023 16:54

Dramatic · 18/08/2023 14:28

I don't understand how it's abnormal? I mean what if you just don't have anywhere for your kids to go? I had no grandparents, no aunts and uncles that could have cared for me, where exactly would I have gone?

My children have stayed at my parents house for 2 nights in a row (and lots of times for just one night) but I don't see how it's "abnormal" if there is nowhere for your child to go 🤔

Or how it would be bad for anyone.

AuntMarch · 18/08/2023 14:35

I think the journey time is the issue to me, rather than the distance. I'd agree begrudgingly if they flew. I wouldn't want to do that drive with 2 children and no adult in the car that could help entertain them. Driving over night isn't really an option if you're going to solo parent the next day.

Dramatic · 18/08/2023 14:28

Longagonow96 · 18/08/2023 11:02

Massively abnormal and not very good for most people either.

I don't understand how it's abnormal? I mean what if you just don't have anywhere for your kids to go? I had no grandparents, no aunts and uncles that could have cared for me, where exactly would I have gone?

My children have stayed at my parents house for 2 nights in a row (and lots of times for just one night) but I don't see how it's "abnormal" if there is nowhere for your child to go 🤔

Peony654 · 18/08/2023 14:25

Loz2323 · 18/08/2023 08:26

Wow, then why even have kids with a man you obviously do not trust or have any respect for.

I know, that's insane. And a recipe for a marriage breakup, that complete lack of trust and faith that an adult who is just as much their parent could look after their own children.

Elly46 · 18/08/2023 14:20

Libelula21 · 16/08/2023 22:52

I think I might go against the majority view here, as I think dealing with a 1yo and a 3yo is a lot. I think we’d need more info tbh:

  • how good is he at spending time with the two of them without you generally? Does he do this often?
  • how good is his sister with kids? Does she have kids of her own? Does she live somewhere remote?
  • are your children easy children, or do they have any extra needs? Is the younger one teething?

I think a week is quite a long time to be apart from a 1 year old, but maybe that’s because motherhood didn’t come early or easily to me!

This^. Trip sounds great but often the reality is different to what is envisioned

AtLeastThreeDrinks · 18/08/2023 14:09

I would not brave a 7hr drive solo with two littluns, that sounds like hell. Maybe we’ve got a difficult kid but long journeys require one driver and one chief entertainer! I also wouldn’t want to be apart from my 1yo for a week. I don’t think that’s so unusual, although the answers here are making me wonder! Certainly my friends with young children wouldn’t choose it.

Would your H consider taking just the 3yo? Much more manageable.

GreyCarpet · 18/08/2023 13:28

Atthe · 18/08/2023 10:23

That’s great that it worked for you and of course it’s possible for it to work. And there is absolutely nothing wrong with having that time apart if everyone is comfortable it it.

I also think it can be a important to acknowledge that not all mums are ok with it and separation can be difficult! I found a lot of the posts quite invalidating of this experience. As a western society we tend to push the narrative that mothers shouldn’t be too attached to their babies and should encourage independence as soon as possible. Unfortunately that goes against our nature and can often feel uncomfortable. This is also ok. So I don’t think it’s unreasonable to not want to be away from your babies for that long with that amount of distance, if you are not fully comfortable with it. If you are great, but doesn’t mean everyone will be or should be.

Oh, I agree.

But an awful lot of posters have also suggested what he wants to do is unreasonable, that no one else would he comfortable with it either, that dad's aren't as capable and will palm the children off on his sister, that it will be too much for him. And those just aren't necessarily true either.

Littlemisslaughalot · 18/08/2023 13:14

WandaWonder · 16/08/2023 22:39

Why do you get to dictate? He is not suggesting anything wrong

This is a bit uncalled for, she's not dictating anything and has said she knows her feelings are unreasonable, she's clearly looking for reassurance.

LittleMonks11 · 18/08/2023 11:07

Purpleplanes · 16/08/2023 22:40

Thanks everyone. We have clashed a lot in the past about views on safety with the kids and I guess when I think of them going I just feel overwhelmed at the idea of them possibly getting hurt or harm coming to them in some way due to his very lax approach with things and not watching them properly. It’s hard isn’t it to know if he is genuinely being too lax or if I’m being overly anxious/cautious. Maybe a bit of both

Can you give some examples of his lax approach to safety and not watching properly? Might help to clear up whether you are over anxious or have just cause?

roarrfeckingroar · 18/08/2023 11:04

My STBXP is taking our 2 year old up north tomorrow to see friends. I'm looking forward to it because it's a quiet weekend for me just with the baby. It's also lovely for them to have time together just the two of them.

Feelings aren't unreasonable, but it isn't something I think most people would be bothered by... is there a particular reason?

Longagonow96 · 18/08/2023 11:02

Hufflepods · 17/08/2023 13:56

@Dramatic In fact I didn't spend a single night away from my parents til I was 11 and had a one night sleepover at my friend's house (who lived in the same street as us. I probably only slept away from them 5 nights before I moved out at 17, I don't see that as an abnormal situation?

It is an abnormal situation really though.

Massively abnormal and not very good for most people either.

Longagonow96 · 18/08/2023 11:01

Amethys · 16/08/2023 22:44

YANBU. Mumsnet is very ‘anti’ the idea that the mum has a closer bond with young children than the dad, even though it’s blindingly obvious.

I think the dad is being very selfish suggesting this. You’ll miss them, they’ll miss you even more, the children won’t sleep well, all of you will be stressed and for what? So he can prance about showing off to his sister how he can parent alone?

I would never have allowed DH to take our DC anywhere overnight without me under age three.

"Allowed"? Sounds like someone is desperately trying to pretend she's indispensable.

Distinguishedandmature · 18/08/2023 10:58

Could you take unpaid leave?

whatdoidonowffs · 18/08/2023 10:47

user1496146479 · 18/08/2023 10:44

Unbelievable reading that people wouldn't 'allow' their DH to bring their kids away!
Assuming parental right etc, your wishes don't trump your husbands!!

Absolute nonsense on this thread! And then we wonder why men cannot/won't parent... likely because their wives etc won't let them
Hmm

This

user1496146479 · 18/08/2023 10:44

Unbelievable reading that people wouldn't 'allow' their DH to bring their kids away!
Assuming parental right etc, your wishes don't trump your husbands!!

Absolute nonsense on this thread! And then we wonder why men cannot/won't parent... likely because their wives etc won't let them
Hmm

K4tM · 18/08/2023 10:44

I would have really struggled without mine at that age, but that was me, not them. They would have been fine. Think it was just my hormones.

I still miss them now when they’re away, but it’s not the same. And anyway, we can text and talk on the phone.

I honestly think you just have to trust their dad, crack on with work and pampering yourself and they’ll be back before you know. Also, you can video call even with the little one. It will be fine.

Atthe · 18/08/2023 10:23

That’s great that it worked for you and of course it’s possible for it to work. And there is absolutely nothing wrong with having that time apart if everyone is comfortable it it.

I also think it can be a important to acknowledge that not all mums are ok with it and separation can be difficult! I found a lot of the posts quite invalidating of this experience. As a western society we tend to push the narrative that mothers shouldn’t be too attached to their babies and should encourage independence as soon as possible. Unfortunately that goes against our nature and can often feel uncomfortable. This is also ok. So I don’t think it’s unreasonable to not want to be away from your babies for that long with that amount of distance, if you are not fully comfortable with it. If you are great, but doesn’t mean everyone will be or should be.

GreyCarpet · 18/08/2023 10:10

Atthe · 18/08/2023 05:56

I’m quite surprised with the responses you’ve gotten. I’m wondering how many who have commented quite harshly currently have children that age! My LO is 2 and I wouldn’t feel comfortable being away from her for a week, with that distance and definitely wouldn’t at 1! I’m not sure any of mums I know would either. Have you been able to talk to your husband about how you feel?

Well, mine aren't that age now but I know that I'd have been fine with leaving mine with their dad for a week at that age because I did.

I didn't occur to le.once to be concerned about how he'd cope because he was their dad. I did the lion's share of daytime parenting because he worked full time and I worked 2 days a week (my daughter was just coming up to one) so I filled him in on a couple.of things he might not have been as familiar with amd decided he'd work out the rest, which he did.

I had a lovely week away that I really benefitted from and he amd the children really benefitted from their time together too.

I'm pretty sure, if it had been the OP talking about taking the children away for a week, no one would be questioning her ability to cope or suggesting she was doing it to show off 🙄

Loz2323 · 18/08/2023 08:26

Amethys · 16/08/2023 22:44

YANBU. Mumsnet is very ‘anti’ the idea that the mum has a closer bond with young children than the dad, even though it’s blindingly obvious.

I think the dad is being very selfish suggesting this. You’ll miss them, they’ll miss you even more, the children won’t sleep well, all of you will be stressed and for what? So he can prance about showing off to his sister how he can parent alone?

I would never have allowed DH to take our DC anywhere overnight without me under age three.

Wow, then why even have kids with a man you obviously do not trust or have any respect for.

Atthe · 18/08/2023 05:56

I’m quite surprised with the responses you’ve gotten. I’m wondering how many who have commented quite harshly currently have children that age! My LO is 2 and I wouldn’t feel comfortable being away from her for a week, with that distance and definitely wouldn’t at 1! I’m not sure any of mums I know would either. Have you been able to talk to your husband about how you feel?

Hufflepods · 17/08/2023 13:56

@Dramatic In fact I didn't spend a single night away from my parents til I was 11 and had a one night sleepover at my friend's house (who lived in the same street as us. I probably only slept away from them 5 nights before I moved out at 17, I don't see that as an abnormal situation?

It is an abnormal situation really though.

romdowa · 17/08/2023 12:56

Yanbu and for us it just wouldn't happen, I wouldn't be without my ds for a week and thankfully my husband would never ask me to be away from him for that long

LittleMonks11 · 17/08/2023 12:39

People seem to be presuming OP wants to be separated from them and 'enjoy some me time'. It doesn't sound like she does. Everyone's different.