Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Left 5yo alone in a restaurant for 2 minutes

567 replies

Havanawinter · 16/08/2023 20:03

I was in a chain restaurant with DS today who is 5, 6 in November. After the waitress had taken our order I went to the loo, leaving DS happily colouring at the table. Before I left I told the woman at the table next to us (who had young children) that I was nipping to the loo and could she please keep half an eye on DS.

When I arrived back at the table literally 2 minutes later I was basically chastised by the waitress for leaving. “I didn’t know if you were coming back for him! I was so worried!” Which seems a bit far fetched considering I’d also left my phone, purse, keys and bag of shopping on the table. She huffed at me again and left, but I could see her taking to her colleagues across the room about it. That was the end of the whole thing but it left me feeling a bit weird, it never even occurred to me that I was doing something wrong but now I’m wondering if my behaviour was unreasonable? Honest opinions welcome!

OP posts:
WhisperingHi · 17/08/2023 19:08

My child is the same age and I'd have taken him with me. It's just not worth the risk.

Reugny · 17/08/2023 19:05

Kitcaterpillar · 17/08/2023 18:57

It really didn't, no, because it's so tremendously unlikely. Two mums in a cafe and one of them happens to be a child trafficker on her lunch break.

And I actually think that's quite a mad thing to teach your children when they are basically safe. Children aren't routinely being abducted by strangers in the UK.

Children in my neck of the woods are extremely more likely to be helped out of danger by strangers, than abducted by them.

JusthereforXmas · 17/08/2023 18:58

Misspiggy1012 · 17/08/2023 18:37

Did it occur to anyone else that this child could have been stolen by the person who was asked to watch him. There's been kids stolen and sold by perverts and sold out to other perverts. It's a horrible thought but always my first one. I've always told my kids to stay close because someone might steal you. Think about the kids that have just disappeared and even two Drs couldn't have a meal and come back to find their daughter Safe in her holiday hotel in the Algarve. So food for thought 🤔 be a safe mum and take them with you. Good luck 🍀 with all your future endeavours

wow... how do you make it through life?

Kitcaterpillar · 17/08/2023 18:57

Misspiggy1012 · 17/08/2023 18:37

Did it occur to anyone else that this child could have been stolen by the person who was asked to watch him. There's been kids stolen and sold by perverts and sold out to other perverts. It's a horrible thought but always my first one. I've always told my kids to stay close because someone might steal you. Think about the kids that have just disappeared and even two Drs couldn't have a meal and come back to find their daughter Safe in her holiday hotel in the Algarve. So food for thought 🤔 be a safe mum and take them with you. Good luck 🍀 with all your future endeavours

It really didn't, no, because it's so tremendously unlikely. Two mums in a cafe and one of them happens to be a child trafficker on her lunch break.

And I actually think that's quite a mad thing to teach your children when they are basically safe. Children aren't routinely being abducted by strangers in the UK.

sillyuniforms · 17/08/2023 18:56

@AnObserverInThisDarkWorld
I agree that ratios are 1-3 for rainbows but do you sit and stare at all three intently every second you have them.
Or do you have maybe 6 of them doing something whist two adults chat & set up / clean down etc. You may even leave the room to nip to the loo? Whilst another watches for 3 for 5 mins?

Misspiggy1012 · 17/08/2023 18:37

Did it occur to anyone else that this child could have been stolen by the person who was asked to watch him. There's been kids stolen and sold by perverts and sold out to other perverts. It's a horrible thought but always my first one. I've always told my kids to stay close because someone might steal you. Think about the kids that have just disappeared and even two Drs couldn't have a meal and come back to find their daughter Safe in her holiday hotel in the Algarve. So food for thought 🤔 be a safe mum and take them with you. Good luck 🍀 with all your future endeavours

Perky1 · 17/08/2023 18:24

Given the circumstances I think you did nothing wrong. If it was after dark at a petrol station and you were popping to loo I think that would be different but in a cafe with a lady happy to keep an eye on child is fine. Chances of lady being a psycho pretty non-existent IMO.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 17/08/2023 18:22

Angelil · 17/08/2023 18:16

My point being that children of that age are not INHERENTLY incapable and yet on this thread/in the UK they are being treated as such.

Well sure but it doesn’t really get us anywhere does it? The UK isn’t going to suddenly turn collectivist rather than individualist, adhere to strict and rigid parenting and solve crime, even if British 4 year olds are more capable than their parents think.

Angelil · 17/08/2023 18:16

fitzwilliamdarcy · 17/08/2023 17:22

Japanese children are expected to adhere to rigid behavioural standards from a young age, and Japan has a low crime rate.

The UK is somewhat different.

My point being that children of that age are not INHERENTLY incapable and yet on this thread/in the UK they are being treated as such.

BlastedIce · 17/08/2023 18:00

WonderingWanda · 17/08/2023 14:17

What a load of drama, if she was that worried surely she could have asked him where his Mummy was, at which point I assume your ds or the lady next to you would have said 'she's just nipped to the toilet'. To be honest it sounds more like the lady you asked to watch him was a bit judgey and told the waitress, who also decided to be a bit judgey and tell you off.

Exactly, he’s 5 not 6 months, she just wanted to judge and assert some authority she thinks she has.

BlastedIce · 17/08/2023 17:58

DameCurlyBassey · 17/08/2023 17:32

I wouldn’t trust anyone with kids In my care. So no sleepovers. There are so many other exciting ways for kids to have fun together so they’re not missing out. That will horrify many of you but I really don’t care. As I mentioned before I have seen and experienced too much, unfortunately. The worst probably won’t happen to your kids but it definitely could happen. Sadly, it happened to Connie Gent and her poor parents.

You are setting your children up for a lot of future anxiety issues.

BlastedIce · 17/08/2023 17:57

Nevermay · 17/08/2023 17:20

reasonable? what would you do if he didn't come back? if she choked? if a woman turned up and claimed to be the mother? if a different man turned up and said he was the father? If the child screamed out "stranger! stranger!" when you tried to speak to them? If the original man claimed you were trying to abduct his child? If the child had stolen property with them and was being followed by police? If the child had chicken pox or invisible infectious disease? If the management said the child had to leave the premises? If there was a fire alarm? if the child picked up a knife? If the child wet themselves or soiled themselves? If the child was stealing from other customers? If the child dropped and broke a plate? If the child fell and broke an arm? If the child was sick? If the child started crying? If the child came into contact with an allergen? If the child had an asthma attack? I could go on and on and on,

I think it is totally irresponsible to agree to this, or to ask anyone else to do it

Dear god!

that’s the most whataboutery I’ve ever seen!

You forgot about, what if there was a volcano!

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

Roselee1 · 17/08/2023 17:40

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

AnObserverInThisDarkWorld · 17/08/2023 17:38

DameCurlyBassey · 17/08/2023 17:32

I wouldn’t trust anyone with kids In my care. So no sleepovers. There are so many other exciting ways for kids to have fun together so they’re not missing out. That will horrify many of you but I really don’t care. As I mentioned before I have seen and experienced too much, unfortunately. The worst probably won’t happen to your kids but it definitely could happen. Sadly, it happened to Connie Gent and her poor parents.

Then your poor children are missing out if you won't even let them go on sleepovers and camps with organisations like Guides and Scouts.

They most definitely are missing out. The bonding and experiences and learning from even one night away without parents is so different to a day trip

AnObserverInThisDarkWorld · 17/08/2023 17:36

VinEtFromage · 17/08/2023 15:58

@AnObserverInThisDarkWorld

i doubt she genuinely thought that, given the OP was just a few minutes, had left her bag etc at the table. She was just being rude & ridiculous.

There is no 'poor woman' about the waitress. She just wanted to have a go at the OP.

Yes, because whilst OP wasn't there the waitress KNEW she was only gone for a few minutes

Couldn't possibly have left the phone she wouldn't use anymore and a bag behind when running away from HER OWN CHILD

She wasn't having a go, she expressed concern and then went to alert colleagues they could stand down from panic stations

Nevermay · 17/08/2023 17:35

Goldbar · 17/08/2023 17:31

A lot of these could happen on playdates/trips out with DC and friends. Some are quite frankly fantastical. A very little bit of common sense would resolve most of them 🙄.

If the child had chicken pox or another infectious disease, for instance... well, no shit, my DC and I would probably catch it. Same as we would from an infected child running around in the soft play.

but if it is friends on a trip out, you know them, you know the parents, and you know what your e being held responsible for

DameCurlyBassey · 17/08/2023 17:32

AnObserverInThisDarkWorld · 17/08/2023 15:29

As a Girlguiding volunteer let me assure you that 5 year old Rainbows are NOT loosely supervised.
You can't take Rainbows out with less than enough adults for 1 to 3 girls. And you would NEVER leave a Rainbow alone without a DBSed adult (not even a parent helper, to be alone they have to be DBS cleared)
Even at Brownie age your Risk Assessment would most likely say they couldn't be left alone, unless you were somewhere that was privately booked, they couldn't leave and for maybe a couple of minutes and only then maybe at the upper aged end

I wouldn’t trust anyone with kids In my care. So no sleepovers. There are so many other exciting ways for kids to have fun together so they’re not missing out. That will horrify many of you but I really don’t care. As I mentioned before I have seen and experienced too much, unfortunately. The worst probably won’t happen to your kids but it definitely could happen. Sadly, it happened to Connie Gent and her poor parents.

Goldbar · 17/08/2023 17:31

Nevermay · 17/08/2023 17:20

reasonable? what would you do if he didn't come back? if she choked? if a woman turned up and claimed to be the mother? if a different man turned up and said he was the father? If the child screamed out "stranger! stranger!" when you tried to speak to them? If the original man claimed you were trying to abduct his child? If the child had stolen property with them and was being followed by police? If the child had chicken pox or invisible infectious disease? If the management said the child had to leave the premises? If there was a fire alarm? if the child picked up a knife? If the child wet themselves or soiled themselves? If the child was stealing from other customers? If the child dropped and broke a plate? If the child fell and broke an arm? If the child was sick? If the child started crying? If the child came into contact with an allergen? If the child had an asthma attack? I could go on and on and on,

I think it is totally irresponsible to agree to this, or to ask anyone else to do it

A lot of these could happen on playdates/trips out with DC and friends. Some are quite frankly fantastical. A very little bit of common sense would resolve most of them 🙄.

If the child had chicken pox or another infectious disease, for instance... well, no shit, my DC and I would probably catch it. Same as we would from an infected child running around in the soft play.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 17/08/2023 17:22

Japanese children are expected to adhere to rigid behavioural standards from a young age, and Japan has a low crime rate.

The UK is somewhat different.

Nevermay · 17/08/2023 17:20

Astrabees · 17/08/2023 15:56

I have often been asked to keep an eye on a child while a parent nips to the toilet ( usually by a father with a little daughter) Of course I always agree, seems perfectly reasonable to me.

reasonable? what would you do if he didn't come back? if she choked? if a woman turned up and claimed to be the mother? if a different man turned up and said he was the father? If the child screamed out "stranger! stranger!" when you tried to speak to them? If the original man claimed you were trying to abduct his child? If the child had stolen property with them and was being followed by police? If the child had chicken pox or invisible infectious disease? If the management said the child had to leave the premises? If there was a fire alarm? if the child picked up a knife? If the child wet themselves or soiled themselves? If the child was stealing from other customers? If the child dropped and broke a plate? If the child fell and broke an arm? If the child was sick? If the child started crying? If the child came into contact with an allergen? If the child had an asthma attack? I could go on and on and on,

I think it is totally irresponsible to agree to this, or to ask anyone else to do it

Angelil · 17/08/2023 16:50

As indeed, closer to home, do the Dutch:

https://dutchreview.com/expat/how-the-dutch-raise-kids/

I live in NL and you regularly see kids biking alone to school from age 10 or so, and playing out without an adult (in small groups of kids) from younger than that.

children-running-outside

How the Dutch raise their kids to be independent | DutchReview

How the Dutch raise kids to be pretty independent and make their own choices. Between all that hagelslag and fietsen are some parental lessons to pick up.

https://dutchreview.com/expat/how-the-dutch-raise-kids/

Angelil · 17/08/2023 16:40

I’m also apparently in the minority here. I have a very mature nearly 5yo who behaves very responsibly the vast majority of the time. He also has a baby brother (nearly 6mo) whom he adores and behaves very responsibly towards. You would all HATE me for what I did the other day. We were out and about in a well-to-do tourist town with a low crime rate (think e.g. Harrogate or Guildford or Bath, but none of those) a couple of weeks ago when said child decided he needed to pee. No way was I going to let him pee on the street so I headed for the tourist information office (already in our sights) thinking they would either have loos or be able to direct me to the nearest. As it happened there were public loos just outside. The gents were on one side of the tourist office and the ladies on the other. However, both were down a set of steps that I could not have accessed with the sleeping baby in the buggy. So I asked my son if he would be OK with going into the ladies’ toilet on his own and doing his pee there and he said yes (would never have sent him alone if he was not happy to go; he is very independent though and will happily sit on his own on public transport where I can see him, walk ahead of me on the pavement when outside etc. He is not a clingy child). I therefore stationed myself with the buggy at the top of the steps and told him there would be other mummies and children in there and that if anyone asked he was to tell them his mummy and baby brother were waiting for him outside. If anyone had e.g. attempted to abduct him from the toilets I would have seen as I was waiting right outside. As it was, he was back in under 2 minutes (…probably didn’t wash his hands 😛) and was thrilled to have had a little independence. This isn’t something I would routinely do (normally I always take him) but in this case it fitted the situation.

This is actually what worries me about this thread…the near-total lack of critical thinking and risk assessment based on the individual child, location and situation. This arguably has as far-reaching implications as not allowing children to develop independence does.

User1145 · 17/08/2023 16:18

VinEtFromage · 17/08/2023 16:04

@User1145

and how many of them are stranger kidnaps, in the U.K., in a cafe, sitting next to a woman & her kids?!?!?!

i predict exactly ZERO,but do feel free to link to any you can dredge up.

The OP asked for honest opinions and that I shared, you don't need to quote me and respond to anything. Enjoy your day!

LookingForRubies · 17/08/2023 16:16

Leaving valuables is a bit silly however. Far more likely an opportunistic thief snatching a phone, than a child!