Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

has anyone managed to pay for private school on a lowish salary? I am so worried about ds going to state school

916 replies

unhw · 16/08/2023 19:31

Me and ex are divorced. DS is 3.5. Ex pays me 700 a month, he never sees DS so obviously that amount would change if he did start to see him.

I have been to some schools near here to look at them because if ds does go to a private school then I would want him to go to the nursery part too, from the word go. At the moment he goes to a nursery near the house which is average at best, despite an outstanding ofstead rating.

The schools are awful. There are so many kids. Barely any smartly dressed. Seems to be no order and organisation. Pick up is 3:20 (?!) so god knows what would happen to my job.

I really really want him to go to private school and the one I’ve seen is around 18k a year for primary. Has anyone done this on a low salary and if so how? Did you move house or downsize etc. I don’t want to do anything extreme but my priority is this and I would do what it takes it there’s a way.

OP posts:
SurreyPsych · 18/08/2023 16:54

8ahwe · 18/08/2023 16:30

i will say poorer pupils can really struggle at independent schools, when the other children have huge expensive houses, multiple cars, expensive holidays, endless trips out etc. They can feel very left out.

My child went to a state school in Richmond (SW London) and we were one of these poorer families. Kids ALWAYS made comments about us living in a flat. Some showed complete shock when coming for play dates :D

Same child now goes to a private school in Surrey and we get similar comments about our modest house compared to their mansions. (We live in a terraced house and a child was surprised when my son told him that our house is only a section of the row) :D

I don’t think this is a private Vs state school thing. I think this is a rich Vs anyone else thing.

That said, as parents, it’s our job to realise our position of multiple privileged and to educate our children about difference so they don’t grow up crippled by insecurity. My son feels no more “left out” financially than he feels “left out” when playing sport with more able kids, or playing in the orchestra with kids in higher grades. He just accepts the differences and knows that we all exist along many spectrums. We don’t give financial status more weight than any other difference when carving out a sense of character. If anything, we focus on how much more we have than most… even as a “poorer” family.

Manthide · 18/08/2023 16:50

8ahwe · 18/08/2023 16:30

i will say poorer pupils can really struggle at independent schools, when the other children have huge expensive houses, multiple cars, expensive holidays, endless trips out etc. They can feel very left out.

Dd3 does struggle a bit with it but generally she accepts that that's life! She really wanted to go there and we explained how difficult it would be financially. She is one of the brightest girls in her year ( has got the academic excellence prize every year) and is also talented musically. She doesn't feel out of place.

Manthide · 18/08/2023 16:44

BooneyBeautiful · 18/08/2023 15:47

I am amazed you can afford private schools on universal credit. Did all your DC get a bursary?

The last two did but when the eldest two went we didn't even think of applying for a bursary and we had both of them there at the same time ( one school year apart). We weren't on benefits when they went but I wasn't working and husband was on about £45k (they left school 12 years ago).
It has been a struggle with the last two (ds left 2 years ago and dd3 going into year 11). I work part-time as I'm going blind and dh has decided not to do anything work wise! Every penny goes on petrol to school etc but dd3 decided that's what she wants. Her sisters do help if really necessary but otherwise we just grit our teeth and get on with it.

Mirabai · 18/08/2023 16:42

8ahwe · 18/08/2023 16:30

i will say poorer pupils can really struggle at independent schools, when the other children have huge expensive houses, multiple cars, expensive holidays, endless trips out etc. They can feel very left out.

That may be your personal experience it’s not everyone’s.

8ahwe · 18/08/2023 16:30

i will say poorer pupils can really struggle at independent schools, when the other children have huge expensive houses, multiple cars, expensive holidays, endless trips out etc. They can feel very left out.

Eaudesud · 18/08/2023 16:10

Perhapsqforshort · 18/08/2023 16:04

I am a teacher in one of those lowly state primary schools. I have also tutored for 3 different families whose children attended private primary schools. All I can say is, none of those 6 children were achieving anywhere near their potential despite the exorbitant fees their parents were paying for them and if I were those parents, I'd be livid. Private schools are not automatically better than state schools. Poor teaching is poor teaching no matter how fancy the building may be.

Ah, but apparently it's in order to 'avoid the drug dealers'.🙄

Perhapsqforshort · 18/08/2023 16:04

I am a teacher in one of those lowly state primary schools. I have also tutored for 3 different families whose children attended private primary schools. All I can say is, none of those 6 children were achieving anywhere near their potential despite the exorbitant fees their parents were paying for them and if I were those parents, I'd be livid. Private schools are not automatically better than state schools. Poor teaching is poor teaching no matter how fancy the building may be.

purser25 · 18/08/2023 15:54

A young child can’t really enjoy themselves at school if they have to look smart all the time. They will all get dirty and covered in paint felt tips school dinner etc whatever school they are at. Don’t be a snob

Kindling1970 · 18/08/2023 15:53

I think it might be a myth that private school teaching is better. Smaller classes yes but a friend of mine was a language teacher at a very expensive private school and didn't have one teaching qualification to her name. Would never happen in a state school. She also told me that if the school thought a pupil wasn't going to get an A in their exam, they would make them sit it privately so the poorer grade wouldn't show up on their statistics. I also feel that a lot of private school kids would probably get perfectly fine marks in a state school because they have parents with the money for tutors etc. A tutor seems cheaper and more effective in my opinion.

Also wanted to point out that another male friend of mine worked in a private girls school and told me he was never CRB checked so could have had anything on his record and still worked there. This would never happen in a state school as they are so heavily regulated.

BooneyBeautiful · 18/08/2023 15:47

Manthide · 18/08/2023 09:44

My 4dc all went to private secondary school, ds was a day boy at a boarding school. We are on universal credit. I don't think they were/are looked down on by anyone ( dd3 is just entering y11). On the contrary all positively contributed to the school and were active participants in school life. Eldest two are Cambridge graduates, ds was put in the pool but missed out ( probably due to covid) as he is amazingly bright and they are now recommending dd3 considers Oxbridge as she is expected to get all 9s next year.

I am amazed you can afford private schools on universal credit. Did all your DC get a bursary?

BooneyBeautiful · 18/08/2023 15:44

RiverLen · 18/08/2023 10:13

All grammar schools are free in Kent.

As far as I am aware, ALL grammar schools are state funded, but obviously not available in all areas. We don't have any in our immediate area, but there are three a bit further out which are all easily accessible by public transport.

BooneyBeautiful · 18/08/2023 15:36

Toomuchtrouble4me · 17/08/2023 21:45

I agree, if you are only going to do 1, do the prep, then a good state secondary. They will be ahead of the curriculum and very well trained to get homework done and able to communicate well, it gives them a great start and they will be so well trained they will just continue to thrive in a decent state.

Yes, I think a good foundation for children is always important. I always wanted to send my two DC to a Montessori pre-school (my DM said her DF was a great supporter of Montessori), but the nearest one was about five miles away so I would have had to drive them backwards and forwards which would have involved extra cost. They ended up going to the pre-school in the next road to where we lived which was much easier as I could walk them there and it worked out well anyway because they then started primary school with lots of children they already knew.

Howmuchfurther · 18/08/2023 14:59

ScottishWaylander · 18/08/2023 14:31

Totally.

State schools are immoral.

Mummyof32023 · 18/08/2023 14:53

Your right she does sound like a snob. Get over yourself and send to state school because you ever be able to send to private

appleyshampoo · 18/08/2023 14:41

Private education is immoral. If everyone used state schools then governments would be motivated to make sure they were all good.

Motivated to make sure they were all good? Smile
I don't think anything would change, and similar disparities, regional, socioeconomic and so on would still exist.

It's not going to happen in any case, everyone using state schools, so pointless to debate.

ScottishWaylander · 18/08/2023 14:31

Terfarina · 18/08/2023 09:24

Get a grip.

Private education is immoral. If everyone used state schools then governments would be motivated to make sure they were all good. Private education - and private healthcare - allows them to run services that the majority rely on into the ground.

all kids matter - even those who aren’t so smarty dressed!

Totally.

Doone21 · 18/08/2023 14:25

I'm very suspicious of your post. It's just deluded.
Do you seriously think that's a good idea on low income?
It's not the posh school that makes a difference to success in life It's everything else, attitude, aptitude, happiness, discipline organisation. Its not just fees you pay for It's the uniform, trips, clubs, activities, all of which you won't have money for and your kid will feel worse.
Most important is to send kid to local school and make local friends, if you have extravagant tastes then look at private or grammar later on. Use the money you save to fund kids to do what they love: tennis, chinese , violin, whatever

Orangemoon8 · 18/08/2023 13:59

Gmary20 · 18/08/2023 13:26

Lots of people on here will undoubtedly be angry at your post and call you a snob for wanting to send your kids to a private school, they are probably either jealous or have a chip on their shoulder. But the reality is many state schools are terrible where bad behaviour and poor parental eggagement and support for teachers, leads to out of controll classrooms where nobody learns.

This however is dependant on the area you live in. Middle class areas with a wide selection of good primary schools will usually have good state school options that are not too different in the quality of the education that private schools.

The main difference however comes at secondary level, as their intake is wider and even state schools in middle class areas will have a large proportion of difficult children who's parents don't value education which disrupts learning for all of the children and can actually lead to quite dangerous classroom environments (especially in cities). Plus, depending on your area, many of the children could well be the sort of children you don't want your child associating with (drug dealers, gang members etc). Some areas (more rural areas) will have perfectly good state schools that don't have these sorts of issues, but again it depends where you live.

Depending on your area, I would say private primary isn't really worth it and I would save money for secondary. I am staying this btw as a teacher with experience working in both private and state, primary and secondary schools.

The op is a snob. She is ‘so worried’ about sending her child to state. That’s just offensive, what does she think will happen? I went to private school and wasn’t at all worried about sending my dc state, because I’m not a snob. Their school is lovely, so nurturing and caring, and my children are growing up accepting of everyone, unlike the op!

appleyshampoo · 18/08/2023 13:46

Lots of people on here will undoubtedly be angry at your post and call you a snob for wanting to send your kids to a private school, they are probably either jealous or have a chip on their shoulder.

I don't think people are jealous, and many of us have been to private school and/or privately educate our children (my early years prep education is part of my happiest memories of childhood).

It's the horrible snobby attitude, about the appearance of the state school children, etc, that has annoyed people. Also describing her income as low (over 80k with contributions from the child's father) has irritated many.

Bookloverjay · 18/08/2023 13:34

KeepSmiling89 · 18/08/2023 10:08

Exactly this!

How children are dressed when they go to nursery isn't down to the education provider - it's down to their parents...and most parents don't send their children to nursery in their Sunday best because, surprise surprise, KIDS GET DIRTY AND MESSY!!
I often come home to see my 20 month DD covered in pen after she's spent the day with my mum, but I would still give my mum an Outstanding Offstead report because DD has had a fun day playing and colouring (even if it is on her own clothes instead of the paper!)

OP, I'm with some other posters on here, you're a snob and I feel bad for your child if they don't meet up to your private education standards.

My mum used to say, a mucky kid is a happy kid.

Mine went to school all clean and tidy and came home looking like they'd been dragged through the hedge backwards.

Krystall · 18/08/2023 13:28

Well I work at a private school so I definitely don’t have a problem with it. However I found OP’s post very snobby, nothing to do with the private school part of it, it was the attitude towards state education and young children’s outfits that was the snobby and offensive part.

Gmary20 · 18/08/2023 13:26

Lots of people on here will undoubtedly be angry at your post and call you a snob for wanting to send your kids to a private school, they are probably either jealous or have a chip on their shoulder. But the reality is many state schools are terrible where bad behaviour and poor parental eggagement and support for teachers, leads to out of controll classrooms where nobody learns.

This however is dependant on the area you live in. Middle class areas with a wide selection of good primary schools will usually have good state school options that are not too different in the quality of the education that private schools.

The main difference however comes at secondary level, as their intake is wider and even state schools in middle class areas will have a large proportion of difficult children who's parents don't value education which disrupts learning for all of the children and can actually lead to quite dangerous classroom environments (especially in cities). Plus, depending on your area, many of the children could well be the sort of children you don't want your child associating with (drug dealers, gang members etc). Some areas (more rural areas) will have perfectly good state schools that don't have these sorts of issues, but again it depends where you live.

Depending on your area, I would say private primary isn't really worth it and I would save money for secondary. I am staying this btw as a teacher with experience working in both private and state, primary and secondary schools.

Krystall · 18/08/2023 13:23

merr1goround · 18/08/2023 13:02

What kind of financial assessment do private schools make?

What do they / can they look at? What do they have access to or ask for?

We would look at just about everything. All assets, borrowings, income and expenses. The parents, both parents, need to provide the supporting evidence. If evidence is not provided or if as I have mentioned, they are separated and the other parent does not provide their evidence, then it will be declined. It is an extremely rigorous process.

ididntwanttodoit · 18/08/2023 13:20

Don't be scared of state schooling. You would be surprised by how well qualified many of the staff are (in some cases, because of LEA employment regulations, they are better qualified than in independent schools, who are entitled to employ anyone they want, qualified or not). Kids in state schools tend to do as well as they want to do - if they don't succeed, it's because they didn't put in the effort: they aren't "hothoused" in the way some privately education kids are. At the same time, if they show willing, teachers are generally supportive. BTW, research suggests that small class sizes don't necessarily lead to better results. However, it sounds as though it is the social rather than the academic aspect you are worried about. That being the case, there's not a lot you can do - the sooner your kids begin to understand social/economic inequity, the more well-rounded they will be as individuals.

Skyblue18 · 18/08/2023 13:18

SurreyPsych · 18/08/2023 13:10

She hasn’t asked for people’s thoughts on this, though. She’s asked for opinions on private schooling.

SO intrusive to ask questions like this. Mumsnetters are wild.

It wasn't a question, it was an opinion🙄