Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

has anyone managed to pay for private school on a lowish salary? I am so worried about ds going to state school

916 replies

unhw · 16/08/2023 19:31

Me and ex are divorced. DS is 3.5. Ex pays me 700 a month, he never sees DS so obviously that amount would change if he did start to see him.

I have been to some schools near here to look at them because if ds does go to a private school then I would want him to go to the nursery part too, from the word go. At the moment he goes to a nursery near the house which is average at best, despite an outstanding ofstead rating.

The schools are awful. There are so many kids. Barely any smartly dressed. Seems to be no order and organisation. Pick up is 3:20 (?!) so god knows what would happen to my job.

I really really want him to go to private school and the one I’ve seen is around 18k a year for primary. Has anyone done this on a low salary and if so how? Did you move house or downsize etc. I don’t want to do anything extreme but my priority is this and I would do what it takes it there’s a way.

OP posts:
Mirabai · 19/08/2023 14:45

Eaudesud · 19/08/2023 14:02

Far from being 'fucked up', it is an approach which sees decent education as a human right for all, and not a commodity the wealthy can secure privilieged access to.

Whether you regard it as a human right or not, it’s not free for vast areas of the world. People throughout the developing world are working, saving, studying, travelling, leaving their countries, to get access to good education they have to pay for. Which you, with your western, entitled, cloth-ear dismiss as “the wealthy securing privilege”.

Saschka · 19/08/2023 14:43

Mirabai · 19/08/2023 12:34

Richer people try to purchase educational advantage in various ways to get their children into contention for things later in life that they wouldn't otherwise be able to access on 'raw' merit. That sits at the bottom of this. But applies to catchment areas and tutoring too. There is some hypocrisy about this. We can debate whether it's fair or not somewhere else, but at least let's be honest there are several ways richer families attempt to buy better outcomes.

This is such a fucked up approach to education. You realise that entire continents - India, Africa, China, S.America - education is valued for its own sake and as a way out of poverty. To improve and enrich live. Not simply for “rich” people.

This smacks of someone simply doesn’t understand the value of education nor indeed the value placed on it globally.

Education that costs £25-45k per year is not “a route out of poverty” - as you see here, even somebody earning £76k per year can’t afford it. It is a way of entrenching privilege, and ensuring that only the very rich get the benefits of networking with other very rich people (parents arranging internships for their children’s friends that a state school child is shut out from, for example).

Good, well-funded state education is a way of lifting children out of poverty - even if you are on FSM, you can go to an excellent state school, and end up at Oxbridge if you are bright enough and work hard. The issue is that our funding and resources mean that this isn’t available to all children in all areas.

We have excellent state primary schools locally (I genuinely do not know why you’d go private around here except for snobbery, the state school academic outcomes are better than the private schools’), but not every area is that fortunate.

Moglet4 · 19/08/2023 14:42

Eaudesud · 19/08/2023 10:54

😂Many, every day, for over 30 years.

But my point was more about schools, and their responsibilities in respect of confidence and attitudes of superiority.

I find it rather sad that your experience of kids from private schools is that the ‘vast majority’ turn out up their own arses. Fortunately, that’s not been my experience of private school pupils at all.

Moglet4 · 19/08/2023 14:39

Krystall · 19/08/2023 09:45

We are a boarding school, it doesn’t mean day pupils hang around until 6pm. We provide late stay care but that is booked and paid for separately. I think our day fees are average and it would be £19k per year between years 3 and 8 (inclusive).

Unfortunately, in some parts of the country that is the average for a local private school- not all, obviously (my kids’ school is considerably less)!

merr1goround · 19/08/2023 14:35

@SpaceRaiders Wow!

I don't know anything about this at all! Thanks for the insight

rossie21 · 19/08/2023 14:08

My grandkids went to a state faith school which also took children not of that faith. They had a very good academic level.
In any case I’d be saving for secondary private school.

Eaudesud · 19/08/2023 14:02

Mirabai · 19/08/2023 12:34

Richer people try to purchase educational advantage in various ways to get their children into contention for things later in life that they wouldn't otherwise be able to access on 'raw' merit. That sits at the bottom of this. But applies to catchment areas and tutoring too. There is some hypocrisy about this. We can debate whether it's fair or not somewhere else, but at least let's be honest there are several ways richer families attempt to buy better outcomes.

This is such a fucked up approach to education. You realise that entire continents - India, Africa, China, S.America - education is valued for its own sake and as a way out of poverty. To improve and enrich live. Not simply for “rich” people.

This smacks of someone simply doesn’t understand the value of education nor indeed the value placed on it globally.

Far from being 'fucked up', it is an approach which sees decent education as a human right for all, and not a commodity the wealthy can secure privilieged access to.

corblimeylove · 19/08/2023 13:44

My experience, 3 dc all went pretty much all the way through in private ds had 1 reception year at local village school, he was in a class of 33 and it was way too much for him, he had been there 6 months and they didn't know that he could already read, not their fault but he was unable to concentrate with the amount of distraction. He needed a smaller class size and a more structured environment. They all ended up in the same senior school, fees now in excess of 30k. It is a large school, mostly borders but quite a large day house. 1st dc was awarded 90% bursary 2nd 100% and 3rd 105% grandparents pay for any trips (have to be approved by bursar) in a school of 1200 there are about 350 in receipt of a bursary, so a little over 1 in 4. Both DDs also won scholarships for music which meant that their music lessons were paid for by the school. Meals included (pretty good by all accounts) and there are many free clubs that they could go to after school. Having been the product of an awful comprehensive education I wanted better for them. Not ashamed to say it. My school was unable to switch from the days of corporal punishment to other means of discipline. I had so many lessons that were ruined by truly awful behaviour. I left with no qualifications. I had to educate myself and now have a degree. But I know so many who simply did not reach their potential. At the dcs school any misbehaviour could result in expulsion no messing about. The children know they are lucky to go there and have a confidence and ambition that is nurtured. Hard work is expected and rewarded.

Mirabai · 19/08/2023 12:34

Richer people try to purchase educational advantage in various ways to get their children into contention for things later in life that they wouldn't otherwise be able to access on 'raw' merit. That sits at the bottom of this. But applies to catchment areas and tutoring too. There is some hypocrisy about this. We can debate whether it's fair or not somewhere else, but at least let's be honest there are several ways richer families attempt to buy better outcomes.

This is such a fucked up approach to education. You realise that entire continents - India, Africa, China, S.America - education is valued for its own sake and as a way out of poverty. To improve and enrich live. Not simply for “rich” people.

This smacks of someone simply doesn’t understand the value of education nor indeed the value placed on it globally.

Manthide · 19/08/2023 12:02

SurreyPsych · 19/08/2023 11:52

@Manthide you sound like a brilliant parent. Your children are lucky to have your support

Thanks, I've really done my best - unfortunately I didn't choose the best father for them and life has been an uphill struggle.

Eaudesud · 19/08/2023 12:01

Wenfy · 19/08/2023 11:30

My dd was treated like this at an outstanding State Primary alongside two other disabled children. It’s very, very common for SEN students to be bullied at State Schools. My DD had the fortune to he academic too and so she was snapped up by a local private primary who then went above and beyond to get her the help and treatment she needed - they did indeed tap into her likes, realised she was competitive and channelled it in sports and academics. The other children (who I still see) had more profound disabilities for which private wasn’t suitable
and their parents pulled them out of school completely to homeschool - both of them said most of the kids they met through various homeschooling groups were disabled. Various groups were thousands of kids strong and most of the children were disabled.

So State Schools ARE failing. It’s just not transparent.

One doesn't need to spend very long on the SEN boards to understand that Private Education has little to offer many SEN families, for two objective reasons: how market-based admissions works in respect of high needs children, and the fact that the SEND Code of Practice does not apply to the private sector (unless listed in section 41 of the C&F Act), so unlike the state sector, there is no obligation to make best endeavours to meet special needs.

Better funding for state SEN provision is the answer whilst the law remains as it is.

Manthide · 19/08/2023 11:58

hookiewookie29 · 19/08/2023 11:20

Just to add....
My friend has just taken her son out of a private school and put him back into state school
She chose a private school because of smaller classes, and thought he would 'grow' better- our local comp has 1800 kids.She also thought he'd be more focused on- he's not sporty but the school promised they'd 'tap into' his likes and encourage them to grow....
Nope- been there 3 years and nothing,despite Mum being in touch with them many times about it.
And he was bullied and picked on. 8 different kids picked on him constantly, telling him to kill himself, shoot himself in the head,cos nobody liked him.....the main instigator got excluded....and the other kids just turned on him even more 'because it was his fault that their mate got excluded ' The head actually said that he couldn't be expected to exclude them all, so she basically had no choice but to pull him out.
Our local school is big,sometimes the kids look like a shower of shit but they're an outstanding school and the kids get excellent results.
Please also ask your child if they actually want to go to private school. They may not be as keen as you....

I took ds to a number of private/ public school open days when he was about 8/9 to see what he thought. He immediately decided he wanted to go to one of them. I told him there would be entrance exams and as he only managed to learn to read when he was 7 and had had extensive speech therapy - and an ISP he would have to work hard for them. We started doing Bond books every day and in y6 he took entrance exams to both schools. He was awarded a 100% bursary to both and chose the single sex school. He has ASD and was being bullied at state school. Apart from a couple of issues which were handled sensitively by the school he thrived there. He was never sporty (he has bilateral sensory processing disorder) but he was encouraged to have a go and found his sports. They encouraged his music - he was not enjoying violin at the time - and ended up head of orchestra and number one violin whilst also achieving the top grade in piano. My proudest moment was when he achieved distinction in his grade 8 (gold) LAMDA and gave a speech at dd2's wedding. It's not for everyone but it was the best thing I did for ds ( now 20).

SurreyPsych · 19/08/2023 11:52

@Manthide you sound like a brilliant parent. Your children are lucky to have your support

Manthide · 19/08/2023 11:33

SurreyPsych · 18/08/2023 23:08

Oh my goodness, some of the comments on this thread are absolute tosh, I expect the OP is long gone, but if not, or for anyone interested, I can offer my family’s experience to clear up some of the misinformation.

It is likely to differ by school, but a) my son had to pass entrance exams to secure his place b) a bursary is income related and a scholarship is awarded on merit (you can have both) c) our award includes aspects of his uniform, trips, lunches and school bus d) extra curricular clubs are largely included and therefore no additional charge (other than mandarin etc which he doesn’t do) e) I pay separately for peri instrumental lessons and english speaking board exams f) I am financially assessed annually. Full financial disclosure is required and I am expected to update with changes throughout the year if relevant g) my son is incredibly happy there despite h) he goes to school from 8-5 (compulsory school day until 4 and clubs or homework until 5).

The schooling experience is entirely different from state imo. It is intense. Lots of formal assessments. Lots of homework. I chose this environment because it suits my child’s character but if it didn’t I would have chosen another school. His happiness matters above all else, but education is very important to me and I believe it will open doors for him, whether or not he achieves high grades, the work ethic/ discipline will take him a long way.

My son joined for junior school. It was my intention from reception and I spent two years preparing and researching schools, financial assistance, tutoring etc. we also moved area as part of this.

I understand why a lot of posters are saying this is not possible, and I assume that is because they haven’t done it, but in my experience it is.

This is similar to ds's public school. He had an academic scholarship (20%) and a bursary to cover the rest of the fees. His award included uniform, lunch, extra curricular, music theory, rowing, some trips etc but we paid for LAMDA and violin lessons. (He also had piano lessons outside of school). School bus was not included but ds chose to cycle there and back (about 18 miles altogether) to save money. He is now at university.
Dd3's private school (y11) is not quite as generous. She has a 100% bursary which includes lunch, uniform and ipad but a lot of other items have to be paid for (I could possibly ask for help but generally choose to pay rather than beg). She also does LAMDA which is more expensive at her school than it was at ds's. Music theory would also have been extra but she did it as part of her external piano lessons ( much cheaper than school) and she also does ballet and modern not in school because of the much higher costs.

SternJosie · 19/08/2023 11:32

£65k is £3800 a month ish, if no pension contribution.

You'd need to put £1500 a month of that towards school fees. And increase that every year, as the fees rise. And keep your fingers tightly crossed you never face disability or redundancy.

So you'd be left with £2300 a month. Personally I wouldn't even consider maintenance as it's too unreliable.

Only you know it you can manage that op. Seems bonkers to me though.

Wenfy · 19/08/2023 11:30

hookiewookie29 · 19/08/2023 11:20

Just to add....
My friend has just taken her son out of a private school and put him back into state school
She chose a private school because of smaller classes, and thought he would 'grow' better- our local comp has 1800 kids.She also thought he'd be more focused on- he's not sporty but the school promised they'd 'tap into' his likes and encourage them to grow....
Nope- been there 3 years and nothing,despite Mum being in touch with them many times about it.
And he was bullied and picked on. 8 different kids picked on him constantly, telling him to kill himself, shoot himself in the head,cos nobody liked him.....the main instigator got excluded....and the other kids just turned on him even more 'because it was his fault that their mate got excluded ' The head actually said that he couldn't be expected to exclude them all, so she basically had no choice but to pull him out.
Our local school is big,sometimes the kids look like a shower of shit but they're an outstanding school and the kids get excellent results.
Please also ask your child if they actually want to go to private school. They may not be as keen as you....

My dd was treated like this at an outstanding State Primary alongside two other disabled children. It’s very, very common for SEN students to be bullied at State Schools. My DD had the fortune to he academic too and so she was snapped up by a local private primary who then went above and beyond to get her the help and treatment she needed - they did indeed tap into her likes, realised she was competitive and channelled it in sports and academics. The other children (who I still see) had more profound disabilities for which private wasn’t suitable
and their parents pulled them out of school completely to homeschool - both of them said most of the kids they met through various homeschooling groups were disabled. Various groups were thousands of kids strong and most of the children were disabled.

So State Schools ARE failing. It’s just not transparent.

hookiewookie29 · 19/08/2023 11:20

Just to add....
My friend has just taken her son out of a private school and put him back into state school
She chose a private school because of smaller classes, and thought he would 'grow' better- our local comp has 1800 kids.She also thought he'd be more focused on- he's not sporty but the school promised they'd 'tap into' his likes and encourage them to grow....
Nope- been there 3 years and nothing,despite Mum being in touch with them many times about it.
And he was bullied and picked on. 8 different kids picked on him constantly, telling him to kill himself, shoot himself in the head,cos nobody liked him.....the main instigator got excluded....and the other kids just turned on him even more 'because it was his fault that their mate got excluded ' The head actually said that he couldn't be expected to exclude them all, so she basically had no choice but to pull him out.
Our local school is big,sometimes the kids look like a shower of shit but they're an outstanding school and the kids get excellent results.
Please also ask your child if they actually want to go to private school. They may not be as keen as you....

Eaudesud · 19/08/2023 10:54

Moglet4 · 19/08/2023 09:19

I wonder how many people from private schools you’ve met? We’re not talking public schools here, just a local independent. They do generally produce adults who are confident and able to perform well in interviews, for example. This doesn’t mean that they disparage others who have had fewer opportunities, though

😂Many, every day, for over 30 years.

But my point was more about schools, and their responsibilities in respect of confidence and attitudes of superiority.

Walkaround · 19/08/2023 10:07

Except in this case, what the OP is complaining about is “learning through play.” She is therefore objecting to the teaching method used in the early years foundation stage in state primary schools.

Wenfy · 19/08/2023 10:02

Eaudesud · 19/08/2023 09:09

To be fair, OP listed avoiding scruffy children as a fairly significant part of her motivation.

Richer people try to purchase educational advantage in various ways to get their children into contention for things later in life that they wouldn't otherwise be able to access on 'raw' merit. That sits at the bottom of this. But applies to catchment areas and tutoring too. There is some hypocrisy about this. We can debate whether it's fair or not somewhere else, but at least let's be honest there are several ways richer families attempt to buy better outcomes.

The question of 'confidence' is a tricky one as that can translate into a not very nice disdain for poorer people, and a belief that a privilieged education is somehow a reflection of their superior abilities, rather than superior life chances, in the vast majority of cases.

Perhaps schools could aim to inculcate humility rather than confidence, and help students to appreciate that many of those who have not had the same life chances and attend state schools, are more talented than themselves, but receive fewer opportunities?

The lack of confidence in kids that go to State schools in the UK is a uniquely British thing. It doesn’t exist in India - where despite having a huge private school market, government school pupils (often educated in classes of 100!) with a single teacher teaching multiple years) still emerge confident and well prepared for work. It doesn’t exist in Australia or the US or Europe either.

I think it exists in the Uk only because there is an over-tolerance of disruptive pupils in this country - by both parents and teachers and the government. I don’t know what the answer is: in India a disruptive pupil would be expelled and their parents expected to manage them . In France, however, kids are expected to be unruly and the discipline enforced is excessive but it still doesn’t work and there is an element of parental responsibility that is given.

Walkaround · 19/08/2023 09:50

And day fees in a boarding school are, on average, considerably higher than day fees in a day school.

Walkaround · 19/08/2023 09:49

She wants her child to stay until 6pm.

Krystall · 19/08/2023 09:45

Walkaround · 19/08/2023 09:33

@Moglet4 - 🤣. She said in one of her posts that the one she’d looked at was a boarding school, hence enabling day children to stay until 6pm, so not your average local independent. £18k a year at primary is also not “average.”

We are a boarding school, it doesn’t mean day pupils hang around until 6pm. We provide late stay care but that is booked and paid for separately. I think our day fees are average and it would be £19k per year between years 3 and 8 (inclusive).

Walkaround · 19/08/2023 09:33

@Moglet4 - 🤣. She said in one of her posts that the one she’d looked at was a boarding school, hence enabling day children to stay until 6pm, so not your average local independent. £18k a year at primary is also not “average.”

Moglet4 · 19/08/2023 09:19

Eaudesud · 19/08/2023 09:09

To be fair, OP listed avoiding scruffy children as a fairly significant part of her motivation.

Richer people try to purchase educational advantage in various ways to get their children into contention for things later in life that they wouldn't otherwise be able to access on 'raw' merit. That sits at the bottom of this. But applies to catchment areas and tutoring too. There is some hypocrisy about this. We can debate whether it's fair or not somewhere else, but at least let's be honest there are several ways richer families attempt to buy better outcomes.

The question of 'confidence' is a tricky one as that can translate into a not very nice disdain for poorer people, and a belief that a privilieged education is somehow a reflection of their superior abilities, rather than superior life chances, in the vast majority of cases.

Perhaps schools could aim to inculcate humility rather than confidence, and help students to appreciate that many of those who have not had the same life chances and attend state schools, are more talented than themselves, but receive fewer opportunities?

I wonder how many people from private schools you’ve met? We’re not talking public schools here, just a local independent. They do generally produce adults who are confident and able to perform well in interviews, for example. This doesn’t mean that they disparage others who have had fewer opportunities, though

Swipe left for the next trending thread