Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

has anyone managed to pay for private school on a lowish salary? I am so worried about ds going to state school

916 replies

unhw · 16/08/2023 19:31

Me and ex are divorced. DS is 3.5. Ex pays me 700 a month, he never sees DS so obviously that amount would change if he did start to see him.

I have been to some schools near here to look at them because if ds does go to a private school then I would want him to go to the nursery part too, from the word go. At the moment he goes to a nursery near the house which is average at best, despite an outstanding ofstead rating.

The schools are awful. There are so many kids. Barely any smartly dressed. Seems to be no order and organisation. Pick up is 3:20 (?!) so god knows what would happen to my job.

I really really want him to go to private school and the one I’ve seen is around 18k a year for primary. Has anyone done this on a low salary and if so how? Did you move house or downsize etc. I don’t want to do anything extreme but my priority is this and I would do what it takes it there’s a way.

OP posts:
lovewoola · 16/08/2023 21:56

@saffy2 I don't think it's low but it's certainly not exceptionally well off!!

saffy2 · 16/08/2023 21:56

Ilikepinacoladass · 16/08/2023 21:49

45k between two of you is definitely low - especially if you're in a city?

Are you both full time? That's only just above the London minimum wage, and below the London living wage if you are..

Not in London, the uk is very large, I don’t know why you’ve assumed I’m in London 😂
I am in the south east though. No not both full time, I’m self employed and we have young children. We live very well, we do not struggle. That’s why I wouldn’t class is as a low income. If we were on a low income I would expect to be struggling to pay things and feed the kids. And we are not entitled to any benefits, which are there to supplement people on low incomes…I’ve used them before when I was on a low income.
people’s view on low incomes really are quite weird and I genuinely think maybe because people just haven’t experienced what a low income actually looks like. 76k isn’t it.
neither is my pretty comfortable lifestyle. 🤷🏽‍♀️ this entire thread is absolutely bonkers. People trying to defend some bat shit woman thinking she’s on a low income when she’s a very high earned 🤦🏽‍♀️🤷🏽‍♀️

Hibiscrubbed · 16/08/2023 21:54

arethereanyleftatall · 16/08/2023 21:46

I'm really intrigued which career would offer a £76k salary to someone who didn't know primary schools finish at 3.20, has zero critical thinking skills, and is basically clueless.

Nastiness because posters are triggered by the subject matter, is so deeply unhelpful. But classic Mumsnet, I guess.

Canaryinawharf · 16/08/2023 21:52

@Womencanlift that's great, and I bet wouldn't have achieved the same in private school. If you take out parental education and income I honestly think private schools have worse outcomes.

Hibiscrubbed · 16/08/2023 21:51

TooOldForThisNonsense · 16/08/2023 21:32

Nonsense. My son has got straight As in all his National 5 and higher exams in a middling state school. What have I got to be resentful of? In fact I’m super proud of him because he’s bloody worked for it and not been spoon fed and just had money thrown at his education.

But you’re being scornful… ‘spoon fed’, ‘just had money thrown…’ can’t you see that?

The kids getting good results in private schools are getting top results themselves too, no one is sitting their exams for them.

Your son has done excellently. But so have kids in private schools.

Zanatdy · 16/08/2023 21:50

Itsnotrightbutitsok · 16/08/2023 21:44

If you’re on £65k and take away the fees of £18k you’re still left with £47k a year - surely that’s more than enough.

How much is your rent/mortgage?

I have never been to private school so I’m not sure but you need to look into seeing how much extra you’ll have to pay out for things like trips and clubs etc.

You’re on a very high income and at the minute your getting £700 a month maintenance so if you saved that along with the difference between your current and future salary you’ll have enough to pay the first year outright within a couple of months.

I’m on 61k and no chance I could pay 18k fees. 65k isn’t take home salary, you’re in higher tax band, probably paying out a good few hundred in pension etc. The £700 a month is good, but it could stop tomorrow

saffy2 · 16/08/2023 21:50

lovewoola · 16/08/2023 21:38

@saffy2 what the poster is saying is someone earning 76k in a single income household is taking home approx 4.4k. Which is the equivalent to a duel parent household each earning 33k each & of course they would also qualify for child benefit.

But it’s not equivalent, a dual income household will be serving more people. It is her and one child. And she earns very very highly.
it is madness to describe earning 76k as low. And when you factor that she is financing only one adult and one child with that very very high income…she’s exceptionally well off.

Ilikepinacoladass · 16/08/2023 21:49

saffy2 · 16/08/2023 20:57

As a household we earn £45k a year. Two of us. Together. And I wouldn’t even class us a low income household 😂😂😂😂😂😂 it is absolutely bat shit crazy that this woman earns 76k alone and thinks she’s on a ‘lowish’ income. She’s extremely privileged and extremely deluded.

45k between two of you is definitely low - especially if you're in a city?

Are you both full time? That's only just above the London minimum wage, and below the London living wage if you are..

Womencanlift · 16/08/2023 21:49

unhw · 16/08/2023 19:50

@paddleboarder12 what would that achieve though? We are currently in a ‘good’ area. I genuinely haven’t come across any decent state schools

This is where your posts jumped the shark. If you haven’t come across any decent state school then you obviously have not looked far enough. Do you honestly think all successful people went private?

The pretty standard comprehensive I attended has produced an Oscar winner, a west end theatre star, a premier league football manger and a newsreader. I went there and from the start of September will earn just below the magical MN six figure salary. Seems pretty decent to me

Zanatdy · 16/08/2023 21:48

Low salary you’d be silly to pay private for primary. Cheaper to move house closer to better schools

Butterflyfluff · 16/08/2023 21:47

If you’re on £65k and take away the fees of £18k you’re still left with £47k a year - surely that’s more than enough.

Dear God - have you not heard of income tax!

arethereanyleftatall · 16/08/2023 21:46

I'm really intrigued which career would offer a £76k salary to someone who didn't know primary schools finish at 3.20, has zero critical thinking skills, and is basically clueless.

lovewoola · 16/08/2023 21:45

@Honeychickpea no they aren't always wealthy. Plus holiday homes generally puts people in the wealthy category

Yalta · 16/08/2023 21:44

no, I think private school offers a more rounded education and gives children a better chance in life. So I’d like to do that for my son if I possibly can

I can honestly say that is total BS.

both of mine went to state primaries and a Couple of friends sent their children to private primaries. There didn’t seem much between them.
Except one of the ones who sent her child to the private primary ended up having to get a tutor as they were so far behind and most of the other parents were paying for a tutor as well. That is why the results the school got when pupils left were quite good

one thing to look out for is checking the results that pupils get when they go to a certain school, state schools or private they are both guilty of doing this.
Are the parents paying for tutors and that is why the marks the schools get are so good.

Ultimately you have to choose the school that will suit your ds. You have to forget about uniforms and how things look but really know what your ds is like and choose a school where he will thrive and that doesn’t necessarily mean a school with fewer pupils. He might need the noise and not being completely supervised every minute of the day to really find his feet

My ds went to a primary in special measures. Everyone I told that he went to this school looked at me as though I was mad. The reputation this school had wasn’t great but it had a new HT a new cohort of teachers hand picked by the new head and mega money thrown at it and although the head was brand new to the school in the September, The whole school had a lovely feel to it. By the time ds left it has gone to outstanding and the catchment area was gradually closing.

Itsnotrightbutitsok · 16/08/2023 21:44

If you’re on £65k and take away the fees of £18k you’re still left with £47k a year - surely that’s more than enough.

How much is your rent/mortgage?

I have never been to private school so I’m not sure but you need to look into seeing how much extra you’ll have to pay out for things like trips and clubs etc.

You’re on a very high income and at the minute your getting £700 a month maintenance so if you saved that along with the difference between your current and future salary you’ll have enough to pay the first year outright within a couple of months.

Clearevening · 16/08/2023 21:42

Clearevening
If you're going to do it I'd start private school from the very beginning, personally. Not put them in state ed. until end of primary.

It sounds as if you're unable to manage that, though. You should research more state schools and widen your search.

Why? Plenty of people send their dc state for primary and transfer private for secondary. Odd comment to make.

dc?

Not at all odd. The usual benefits of a private education are also important, and useful, in the formative years. Some also find the transition from state to private, or private to state, a difficult transition, particularly at secondary age. There is a difference.

My children have been privately educated from the beginning, nursery through prep, then secondary, as was I (though I also boarded for a while).

Sorry, I've lost who that was to tag.

Honeychickpea · 16/08/2023 21:42

lovewoola · 16/08/2023 21:05

@Fallingthroughclouds it's completely normal for gps to pay for private school, even more so if they are wealthy.

Only if they are wealthy. And in the OP's case they would have to be wealthy emough to do it for all their grandchildren.

lovewoola · 16/08/2023 21:38

@saffy2 what the poster is saying is someone earning 76k in a single income household is taking home approx 4.4k. Which is the equivalent to a duel parent household each earning 33k each & of course they would also qualify for child benefit.

WhalePolo · 16/08/2023 21:38

@unhw

I’d say research your private school very carefully and don’t assume it’s better than state. Many private schools are struggling and are trying hard to ‘sell’ themselves. ISI inspection reports tend to be kinder than OFSTED.

I think a good state school will often teach the academic side of things well because they have a large class they need to progress. Private schools are sometimes a bit behind on the latest ideas.

I think a private school will often offer a big range of extra activities which could work well for you as you are working.

Snobbiness from other private school Mum’s tends to be if they perceive another child to be badly behaved or upsetting their own child. I do think it can be quite difficult to ‘get along’ with the other Mums. You are almost forced to be in close contact and it’s difficult to escape if you’d rather keep away from anyone!

Private didn’t suit my DD and she did better in state where she had to ‘go with the flow’. It was less intense for her in terms of friendships and they were firmer with her behaviour. However I think DS might suit private as he is quiet and ‘good’.

SensitiveB · 16/08/2023 21:37

Butterflyfluff · 16/08/2023 19:39

I strongly believe that if you can’t afford the lifestyle that goes with private schooling, then you shouldn’t do it.

Nothing worse than being the kid who can’t join in with anything that has a cost because there’s no money left after paying the basic fees.

I don’t personally agree with this, one of my friends was on a full bursary and I’m sure plenty more had help and to be honest not one person thought about it or cared. We were all equal . Same at DS’ school and if I ever thought he was getting in any way entitled like that or spoiled I’d move him! Plenty of his friends are in army houses or more modest and some stately homes and I really don’t think it matters to them and nor should it .

Maria1982 · 16/08/2023 21:32

unhw · 16/08/2023 19:55

@RoseslnTheHospital no they won’t contribute at all as they say it wouldn’t be fair on other grandchildren. They’ve said they would sort all the ‘nice’ bits though.

Well I’m sorry but that doesn’t make much sense. If they have money and they can help, why not help you with money rather than the extras? Makes no sense to me

(and yes I hear you, they want to be fair to other grandchildren. But they have different circumstances, right ?)

TooOldForThisNonsense · 16/08/2023 21:32

Hibiscrubbed · 16/08/2023 21:28

Simply because they can’t afford it, and dress up their resentment that some can and do with scorn over the whole sector. Some of course do have a vehement rejection of ‘elite’ education. But we live in a world where it exists, so…

It is almost as divisive as feeding threads.

In my experience, private schools are largely better than state (certainly where I live), because they can afford to be. There’s some things some private schools don’t do as well as state, such as supporting some kids with additional needs, but the one I’ve found for my children is incredible with children with all needs. Even though it’s not relevant for us. It gets excellent results and doesn’t exclude ‘different’ children in order to do so.

If you can manage it, I would.

Nonsense. My son has got straight As in all his National 5 and higher exams in a middling state school. What have I got to be resentful of? In fact I’m super proud of him because he’s bloody worked for it and not been spoon fed and just had money thrown at his education.

saffy2 · 16/08/2023 21:30

Augend23 · 16/08/2023 21:14

The average full time salary is just under £30k now, so two average incomes would give a household income of £60k, or around £1900 each assuming a 5% pension contribution and a student loan.

Assuming the same thing on a salary of £76k, that's £3900, or almost the same amount as two people earning 30k in spite of her salary being £16k more. I don't think this is wrong - we tax on an individual basis in the UK not a household basis and I don't have a problem with that. But it does mean single parent households have similar problems to single income households but without the choices that go alongside it.

The minimum wage for a 40 hour week is now £21k, so £45k for a two income household is only a little over two full-time minimum wage incomes - so while it's great that you feel comfortable on that, it seems quite feasible some households won't.

We can afford our mortgage, bills, food, car,
clothes and holidays. People on a low income can’t afford that. If you really think during a cost of living crisis where people can’t afford to feed their kids or heat their homes that a lady on her own earning 76k to pay for her and one child is on a low income then I’m sorry but you’re as mad as she is. She is NOT on a low income, by any stretch of the imagination. She is exceptionally privileged.
a low income family struggle to feed their kids, put shoes on their kids feet. You know how I know…because I’ve been there. As a single parent to one child…and I was not privileged and I did not earn 76k and I used food banks and I often went without food to feed my child. It’s absolutely ridiculously disgusting that anybody would describe earning 76k as a low income. This entire thread is absolute madness.

Hibiscrubbed · 16/08/2023 21:28

unhw · 16/08/2023 20:45

Really not sure why people are so offended by me simply asking how I could do something to give my ds the best start in life. Some of the posts are crazy.

Simply because they can’t afford it, and dress up their resentment that some can and do with scorn over the whole sector. Some of course do have a vehement rejection of ‘elite’ education. But we live in a world where it exists, so…

It is almost as divisive as feeding threads.

In my experience, private schools are largely better than state (certainly where I live), because they can afford to be. There’s some things some private schools don’t do as well as state, such as supporting some kids with additional needs, but the one I’ve found for my children is incredible with children with all needs. Even though it’s not relevant for us. It gets excellent results and doesn’t exclude ‘different’ children in order to do so.

If you can manage it, I would.

lovewoola · 16/08/2023 21:28

@3pm my colleague has put her 5 yr old on a waiting list to start tutoring in yr 4. How mental is that a 3 yr waiting list!