Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

has anyone managed to pay for private school on a lowish salary? I am so worried about ds going to state school

916 replies

unhw · 16/08/2023 19:31

Me and ex are divorced. DS is 3.5. Ex pays me 700 a month, he never sees DS so obviously that amount would change if he did start to see him.

I have been to some schools near here to look at them because if ds does go to a private school then I would want him to go to the nursery part too, from the word go. At the moment he goes to a nursery near the house which is average at best, despite an outstanding ofstead rating.

The schools are awful. There are so many kids. Barely any smartly dressed. Seems to be no order and organisation. Pick up is 3:20 (?!) so god knows what would happen to my job.

I really really want him to go to private school and the one I’ve seen is around 18k a year for primary. Has anyone done this on a low salary and if so how? Did you move house or downsize etc. I don’t want to do anything extreme but my priority is this and I would do what it takes it there’s a way.

OP posts:
redskytwonight · 17/08/2023 09:19

unhw · 16/08/2023 20:41

@nameitagain because I am moving to a four day week to have a day with ds

Well, not reducing your days would seem to be an obvious answer to making private school fees more achievable. (Even if you just save a lot of the money in the younger years)

Although, you've hit upon one of the conundrums of this situation . You really value private school but you also value time with DS. And putting him in an 8am-6pm school won't give you an awful lot of time with him during the week once he gets to school age.

Mirabai · 17/08/2023 09:12

You cannot seriously think that no state school in the land is good enough for your precious?

She didn’t say that did she? Just that the ones round her are shit.

Krystall · 17/08/2023 09:08

unhw · 16/08/2023 20:12

@PeelingWallpaperFlakyPaint thank you, I didn’t know that would be possible. How would I approach that? Literally just say I am desperate to send him to the school and is there anything they could do?

I work in the finance department of a fairly large private school. We do not consider bursaries for anybody under the age of 7 and nobody below the age of 10 has a scholarship, even then the scholarships are only around 5% for that age.

Back to bursaries, firstly your income would be too high for us to consider it, we also include savings, investments and realisable assets, not just salaries. And if the child has two living parents then we would only assess on both incomes, we are not going to give a mother a bursary just because father doesn’t want to pay fees. Based on what you have said, I think it would be very very unlikely you would get a bursary.

Anyway like most people on the thread I think you are being ridiculous and just the worst kind of snob. You cannot seriously think that no state school in the land is good enough for your precious? We take pupils from reception and the very little ones look like right little scruff pots when I see them in the dining room. Cute. But scruffy.

Spywoman · 17/08/2023 09:08

I seriously wouldn't waste money on private junior school fees. I'd send them to tutors to get them into the private secondary school you want them to go to. Find the best tutors in your area when they're in year 4 and get them to the level. It's not that hard if they're reasonably bright. It will save you squillions compared to private primary education.

It will give you time to save up for the private secondary fees, which I do think are worth every penny. My son did this and I love the fact he can mix with anyone because he's got experience of knowing all kinds of people. I didn't do the private tutoring, I taught him myself but in retrospect that was a bit mad as he just scraped in.

MrsSamR · 17/08/2023 09:04

Jumbojade · 17/08/2023 00:04

So your ds is 3.5 and you want him to start nursery at a Private School? Doesn’t make sense, that you are only now going to be cutting down a day at work, to spend with him? Won’t he be attending 5 days from next month?

This is what I don't understand - if OP wants her son to go all the way through from nursery shouldn't he already be there now? My DD turned 3 in May and is starting the nursery at her Prep school next month but there are children who have been there since they were 2.

Userhay · 17/08/2023 08:45

no longer, sadly!

Userhay · 17/08/2023 08:44

@Bunnycat101 that bursary is no longer sadly but it made a huge difference for several years. One child still has a large bursary. But fees just go up and up each year as they climb the school and as fees rise with inflation (or wildly beyond inflation).

If I knew then what I know now I might have cherry picked one of the best state secondary schools (somewhere like Pate’s) and made sure we lived nearby and the children were well supported in primary school to be prepared for the 11+. But hindsight is a wonderful thing. As it is, my children are happy and doing really well academically. So I don’t beat myself up about the choices I made that led us here.

Bunnycat101 · 17/08/2023 08:34

@Userhay that bursary really is very significant then- that’s a pretty amazing discount. I hope it all continues to work out for you.

FairAcre · 17/08/2023 08:26

EmmaGrundyForPM · 16/08/2023 19:36

To be honest, you sound like a snob. You talk about the children in the local school being badly dressed. Surely your priority should be how good the education is.

In terms of after school care, if there's no after school club then use a childminder.

This

Userhay · 17/08/2023 08:21

On the opening hours…. Our school also operates until 6pm. HOWEVER, not all children cope with that and almost none stay that late every single day. My dc stay late twice a week and that’s enough. Any more and they get too tired - this was especially true in the pre prep (reception to year 2).

Userhay · 17/08/2023 08:18

@Bunnycat101 A combination of bursary support, a smidge of grandparent support and working it out year to year. I will freelance if I need to earn slightly more (but that’s complicated). One child had a huge bursary so I only paid £4k a year. But bursaries are reviewed every year so I never take them for granted and next year one moves school and won’t have a bursary. Lots of my friends work at the school and get 50% off the fees.

Honestly, if I sat down and looked at the fees in the next 5-10 years I’d probably cry but year to year I’ve worked it out. The academic and pastoral provision is fantastic.

My dc are happy and love school life. It’s worth it for me.

We have very low living costs (on purpose - chose a smallish house rather than a larger house with a larger mortgage) and run one old but economical car. Holidays are camping or going to stay with friends.

The only “luxuries” I pay for are music lessons and swimming lessons.

BibbleandSqwauk · 17/08/2023 08:16

As always on these threads, it's mostly anecdata and generalisations. People confidently asserting that private schools finish at 3.15...mine stays open til 6. Private schools are no better than state .that depends on the individual schools. Good kids with good parents will do well anywhere..unless they have SEN or some other issue which an overcrowded state system can't manage. Private schools kick out the less academic..mine doesn't. OP I think your finances would be ok, though I question the point of dropping to 4 days at this stage. As for the rest, it's all about the individual particular schools you are looking at on both sides and the aptitude and personality of your child. Find out as much as you can. Lots do transfer to private at y3 or y7 so you could do that and save hard in the interim.

jeaux90 · 17/08/2023 08:10

OP I'm a lone parent but earn 6 figures. My DD14 went state primary then private secondary.

I do the school fee plan, I pay monthly and that's about 2k.

Only you know if you can afford it.
Private school at secondary level makes a massive difference.

I had a live in nanny for primary years, lots of others had a child minder for school pick ups until 6pm... but I had to travel for work.

There are so many different levers you can pull to make it work but only you know if you can afford it.

Schoolchoicesucks · 17/08/2023 08:07

PeelingWallpaperFlakyPaint · 16/08/2023 20:10

Hi op. I worked in several private schools.

Have a visit and meeting with the heads at several schools and ask what discount is available. Negotiate. Offer to get involved in the life of the school and volunteer. Is your child smart? Good at music/art/sport/drama? Tell them your child will be happy to play in the school sports team/orchestra etc etc etc, and is impeccably behaved!

Some schools will say no, some will say yes.

Good luck.

The child is 3.5
Do schools really offer discounts for budding 3 year old actors or cricketers?

ChocBanana · 17/08/2023 08:04

@WellPlaced I hope your kids never end up in an academy then. I work in schools. Yes, technically private schools can employ unqualified teachers. But in my not inconsiderable experience, they don’t, or if they do they are qualified in what they teach, just not with a teaching degree. I know a sports teacher who has coached at county level for 15 years. He has a degree in Sport Science, just not a teaching degree.

In contrast, my friend’s son is an “unqualified teacher” at our local comp. He teaches Yr 7 and 8 maths despite only having a GCSE in it himself. He got a job as a technician in the drama department but has been given extra responsibilities he’s not actually qualified to be doing.

And considering that the Government has every intention of making sure ALL schools are academies by 2030, unqualified teachers will become the norm, because they’re cheaper, and qualified teachers will be employed in purely advisory or supervisory roles, maybe one qualified teacher for every 3/4 unqualified. Trust me on this one, it’s something I know a lot about.

F0RBIDDEN · 17/08/2023 08:00

I have friends with kids in private school, each year they are tested for hours and the ones who aren't good enough get chucked out. Just because you pay it doesn't mean they let you stay. They often moan about how much stress the kids are under and it leaves me wondering why they would pay for that ??

Bunnycat101 · 17/08/2023 07:58

@Userhay even with significant bursaries how did you mange that? I’m curious as as you say on paper it absolutely shouldn’t work financially.

Summerrainagain1 · 17/08/2023 07:53

Agree this all aounds snobby. £76k a low salary, scruffy kids, how will your darling possibly learn with all those children etc. I sounds like you've come from a wealth background and expect things a certain way but now can't really afford that lifestyle.

But to your OP - Noone here can tell you if you can afford it. Sit down, write a bidget and figure out what you'd have to do to pay the fees. Then decide whether that's worth it to you.

I should let you know btw, as you seem to be unaware, that the vast majority of the population of this country (and the rest of the world for that matter) don't go to private school and do - somehow - manage to learn just fine!

WellPlaced · 17/08/2023 07:50

Also, it may just be me, but I prefer my children’s teachers to actually be qualified to teach.

Userhay · 17/08/2023 07:50

@ChocBanana 100% this. My salary is about the same as yours - I don’t work for because of caring commitments but I have 2 dc at private schools. On paper it doesn’t work but I manage. And like you, my dc are at the schools they’re at because of circumstance - they are the right schools for them. Also both been given generous bursaries (from year 3) because they are very academic and musical.

But on paper if I asked AIBU to think I can afford private school for 2 dc, the answer would be a resounding no!

Motherofhallion5 · 17/08/2023 07:46

There are no private schools in our small city or even near enough to commute to so obviously all 3 kids went to state school.
Same primary school for all 3 & 3 different state secondary schools. Oldest has now left school and is at Yale.

His state school, where almost 30% of kids are on free school meals, was amazing at helping him with the application. Another one of their pupils got in to Yale this year. Also as we are on a combined income of £60k we don’t pay a penny for his tuition; accommodation or food. He will not owe anything in student loans and is having the most amazing time in the US.

Don’t write off state schools.

WellPlaced · 17/08/2023 07:46

Having posted upthread about my own children’s achievements following state school education I would just like to add that I am also quite anti private school education and always have been.

My job requires me to visit a different school every week, both private and state.

I think private schools give children a slanted view of the world and state schools prepare them for reality.

Many parents obviously prefer to protect their children from this reality.

TreadSoftlyOnMyDreams · 17/08/2023 07:40

I'm going to buck the trend and say it's doable in the absence of any useful financial info.
Your ex gives you £8600 pa - that's half the fees
Your take home after tax is £46k, deduct your share of the fees and you are left with £3117 pm
The rest of your outgoings you haven't shared so only you know if you have a mortgage of £500 or £2500.

Both of my kids are at private school all the way through. They are there because our financial circumstances permit it and the level of additional educational support they get there that's needed. I went to state school and my husband went to state primary. Class sizes are smaller yes but they grow much bigger as they get older. Don't assume such tiny ratios all the way through.

All nurseries are chaotic - they should be. Small children aren't designed to sit in one place and look forward to a whiteboard. They will all be doing activities and often these will
Be different at the same time. One group will be building something while another will be dressing up and doing drama. They will all be learning from each other and the teacher in short bursts. A good school will have them all in comfy practical clothes that can be washed after paint, puke and inevitable toilet accidents. I'd run a mile from a school with a "smart" nursery uniform because it will cost you a bleddy fortune even with a second hand shop which we make extensive use of. They grow so quickly the clothes are often near perfect

Both of us earn significantly more than you, it's still a financial struggle but we skip holidays, drive one ancient car, contain our costs as much as possible. We are better off than most parents at the school I suspect and yes there is a small percentage who are v v well off and everyone assumes that's the case for all parents at all private schools. We have a nice life, I am not complaining but the fees rise significantly every year and Labour are promising change on private school fees. The worst thing is knowing you want to vote in the political party who is going to make your life significantly harder!! I couldn't bring myself to vote for Boris last time.
School hols are 16 weeks. You can cover 4 maybe? Camps are £25+ a day right now so that's £125+ per month.

Lots of kids join the prep in year 5. It gets them up to speed for entrance exams and/or 11+ depending on where you live. I would save hard for secondary school and extra support if needed at primary. Take your ex's money and bank it for the future. If needs be tell him. If he's a wanker who will decide you don't need it then don't.

You have a decent salary which will hopefully grow over time. Enjoy your sons childhood with him. Volunteer with the school, fundraise for them, buy kumon maths lessons, extra tuition, music lessons for a scholarship if needs be. Your son has already lost one parent, don't make your life a grindstone of stress and worry and endless childcare because you've created a millstone around your neck.

ChocBanana · 17/08/2023 07:40

Not all children in private schools are posh - and in fact, many are in private school because the state system has let them down.
In our case, I don’t want to go into too much detail because it will identify me, but my eldest was going to state, but we got none of the schools we applied for (all within half a mile of our house). We applied specifically for certain schools because our daughter has ASD and couldn’t have coped in a big one.
Instead we were given a failing, four form entry four miles away and when we visited, the head said “We only get the ones that all the others can’t fit in. We’re like clearing for 4 year olds” and various other negative things.
I told him my child was academic and he said “They all say that” and he didn’t stream children because “90% would be in the bottom stream, so what’s the point?”
My daughter then went on to get three academic scholarships before Year 7.so she is academic, after all.
And we had no grounds for appeal because the council had provided a suitable place that we couldn’t prove was out of reach as we both drove.
You can’t appeal on the grounds of just not liking a school.
So, had the state system not let us down, then we would never have been private school parents.
But it was an option for us so we took it. And I don’t think there are many parents in that situation who, if it was remotely possible, wouldn’t do the same.

PollyPut · 17/08/2023 07:38

unhw · 16/08/2023 19:43

When I said not smartly dressed I didn’t mean it in a nasty way, I just meant it seems none of the staff have time to focus on the kids properly, in the same way they would in a private school

It's not the staff's job to focus on what the pupils wear, it's the parents job.

When looking around schools I remember one in particular that mentioned shoes being muddy or with a bit of paint on were the signs of pupils getting on and doing things, and making the most of school. It made sense.

Blazers look smart but they're totally impractical for art or football at lunchtime.

As long as the children are wearing clothes that fit and follow the rules I wouldn't focus on that in particular.

Staff are there to educate and provide pastoral support and guidance. Not make sure the children look smart.

I would suggest you have a good look at the secondaries in your area and see whether you can find any you like. If not, move