Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

has anyone managed to pay for private school on a lowish salary? I am so worried about ds going to state school

916 replies

unhw · 16/08/2023 19:31

Me and ex are divorced. DS is 3.5. Ex pays me 700 a month, he never sees DS so obviously that amount would change if he did start to see him.

I have been to some schools near here to look at them because if ds does go to a private school then I would want him to go to the nursery part too, from the word go. At the moment he goes to a nursery near the house which is average at best, despite an outstanding ofstead rating.

The schools are awful. There are so many kids. Barely any smartly dressed. Seems to be no order and organisation. Pick up is 3:20 (?!) so god knows what would happen to my job.

I really really want him to go to private school and the one I’ve seen is around 18k a year for primary. Has anyone done this on a low salary and if so how? Did you move house or downsize etc. I don’t want to do anything extreme but my priority is this and I would do what it takes it there’s a way.

OP posts:
LalaPaloosa · 18/08/2023 08:23

Ilikepinacoladass · 18/08/2023 08:12

I'm assuming they are keen for people not to struggle paying the fees / drop out halfway, so yeh they'd be wanting to warn people off who seem at risk of this.

Of course private prep school isn't 'neccessary', but I'd be surprised if the school said 'there's absolutely no advantage to them coming here over a state school, it's literally money down the drain.'

If you read my post, I didn’t say she said “there’s absolutely no advantage to them coming here over a state school, it’s literally money down the drain.” I’m not sure where you got that.

In my view, the headmistress was being kind. She made one comment about not doing it if finances will be a problem. State schools weren’t mentioned at all.

Packageholiday · 18/08/2023 08:22

@Pinkapie @Butterflyfluff

I disagree whole heartedly.
Unless it's somewhere in with extraordinary wealth most local independents are much more wealth varied places.

Packageholiday · 18/08/2023 08:20

@BelleShazzasFeast.
Thanks that's interesting.
I'm selfishly thinking of myself and not op (sorry) the school I'm thinking of is not selective at all and it would be from secondary school.

Grew about private school summation as well. It's all swings and roundabouts.

Pinkapie · 18/08/2023 08:17

Butterflyfluff · 16/08/2023 19:39

I strongly believe that if you can’t afford the lifestyle that goes with private schooling, then you shouldn’t do it.

Nothing worse than being the kid who can’t join in with anything that has a cost because there’s no money left after paying the basic fees.

Yes! This! Do you really want your child to be the one that can't afford to participate in trips, extra curricular activities.
I don't think you can judge a school by the neatness of young kids, maybe you visited when they had just had forest school or PE.

NameChange30 · 18/08/2023 08:12

"We are currently in a ‘good’ area. I genuinely haven’t come across any decent state schools"

If you genuinely think this, your priorities are all wrong. State schools are woefully underfunded but many (if not most) primary schools have lots of positives even though they're obviously not perfect.

You may prefer a private school education and that's fine, but please don't be so dismissive about state schools.

It sounds as if your main issue is class sizes? Since there are 30 children in a state primary school class, and usually many fewer children in a private school class.

Maybe you could think longer term and research private secondary schools with bursaries, scholarships and/or lower fees, relocate if necessary, and look at the primary schools (state and private) in the area. I would definitely prioritise secondary if I were you, start saving for it now. Much better for DC to move from state to private than the other way around. You could also consider state for KS1 (R-Y2) and then private for KS2 and up (Y3 onwards). Do be aware, though, as PPs have pointed out, that private school holidays are much longer so it's a significant extra expense / hassle for you. It's easier to arrange childcare for an older child or to let them occupy themselves while you are WFH. Another reason to save private school until he's older.

Ilikepinacoladass · 18/08/2023 08:12

LalaPaloosa · 17/08/2023 23:11

My child is in private prep school. At the information day for the school we ending up choosing, the headmistress said to all the parents - if this will be a stretch for you financially, don’t do it. Save for high school. It’s not necessary. I hope that gives you some kind of comfort.

If this will be a stretch, save for high school. It’s not just the school fees, it’s after school clubs, instruments, excursions, fundraising, dress up days. In year 6 there is a week long ski trip. Its a big financial commitment

I'm assuming they are keen for people not to struggle paying the fees / drop out halfway, so yeh they'd be wanting to warn people off who seem at risk of this.

Of course private prep school isn't 'neccessary', but I'd be surprised if the school said 'there's absolutely no advantage to them coming here over a state school, it's literally money down the drain.'

itgetsthehoseagain · 18/08/2023 08:10

OP, a teacher friend I know used to describe the local private schools as the place where their own teachers (she worked in a state comp) who left because of conduct or competency issues ended up.
Teachers at private schools also don't need a teaching qualification.
I would save some tuition money over the next few years. Then, if your DC ends up being a potential university candidate, throw that money at extra tuition come GCSEs and A levels.
In my experience, state schools are brilliant because of the threat of OFSTED - they have to demonstrate 'value added', will identify any weak areas, particularly in English and Maths, and then throw their own money at tuition, timetable alterations, even (at my friend's school) paying staff to teach extra sessions after school. There are study clubs, activity clubs...admittedly this is all in your DC's future rather than the present, but it's worth knowing that the grass can be very, very green in the state sector.
Falling into the wrong crowd would be my only concern, but this is the case with private schools too - and the pressures there, as other PPs have said, can be remarkable. And imagine being the one who can't afford the bi-annual school trip to Vermont/San Francisco/Venice/the moon.
For me it would be state school with strong parental boundaries all the way! And save for future tuition if university moves into view!

TinyTear · 18/08/2023 08:10

RoseslnTheHospital · 16/08/2023 21:10

@cheekyduck "Mine were learning French, having music lessons, having authors come in to give talks, access to a huge library, all before they were even 5 at Pre-Prep."

The state primary my children attend does French, music lessons, authors coming in to give talks, a big library...... I don't think that's massively unusual, at least not in the south east of England.

yep, state primary here kids do

coding
french
latin
music
author visits
musician visits
sang at the royal albert hall
shakespeare workshops
science visits

and all for £5 contribution at most for certain trips

Araminta1003 · 18/08/2023 08:08

I think you are being unrealistic. Save the money and put him in state primary and save up for private secondary when it actually matters more - the best time to spend is years 9-11. Year 7 and 8 if you must. You can get some good saving rates right now.
At primary level, spend 30 minutes a day reading, doing maths etc and maybe some French, job done. And practise ball skills and manners. One to one from an engaged parent is what makes all the difference to a child’s life, not private school. Especially if you have an outstanding option, they don’t just dish those out- those schools are tracked to progress the kids from their innate ability. Private schools are often not held to account.

BelleShazzasFeast · 18/08/2023 08:08

Packageholiday · 18/08/2023 06:55

@Krystall what if that property was their incomes source though

My experience is that they will accept this if everything else stacks up - and, most importantly, if the school wants your child enough to accept it. Schools don't just give money to anyone who rocks up and says they can't afford it. Bursaries are thin on the ground at 'ordinary' independent schools, as they simply don't have the funds for them, especially not at the moment. Big-name schools offer more and/or larger bursaries. However, they are very, very strict about how they are allocated. In the end, it does come down to whether your child has as much to offer them as they have to offer your child. This is normally something 'special' (academic/sport/music/drama/art). These things only really become evident at 13, hence there's very little money on offer until then.

Leaving money aside, the ignorance on this thread (and most threads about independent schools) is outstanding. I wouldn't presume to generalise about state schools or the pupils who attend them, as I have no personal experience of them. Yet people make the most astounding generalisations about people who go/went to private schools when they have no personal experience of them - all this stuff about how they can't talk to people in the real world, have mental health problems, can't cope when they're not spoon fed, everyone has second homes and endless holidays and so on is complete shite.

mamamamamamamamamamachameleon · 18/08/2023 08:07

Butterflyfluff · 16/08/2023 19:39

I strongly believe that if you can’t afford the lifestyle that goes with private schooling, then you shouldn’t do it.

Nothing worse than being the kid who can’t join in with anything that has a cost because there’s no money left after paying the basic fees.

This

Mamma2017 · 18/08/2023 08:04

This is ridiculous. You are judgmental and completely delusional. You reference flimsy judgemental reasons why your child shouldn’t go to state school. You put private schools on some pedestal and all this us about is you trying to ‘keep up with the Jones’. Probably like your parents have by the sounds of it. Drop the judgment about state schools, stop being snobbish, stop modelling this awful attitude to your child because they will pick up on it. Many many successful people went to state school. I was a straight A student got A-levels and a degree and am in a professional career all after state school education. You will break your back financially sending them to private school where the fees DO go up over time. And what if your ex wants contact and drops the money he pays you? State schools are the most positive and reasonable option for you.

Kindling1970 · 18/08/2023 07:55

I work in a university with lots of students who went to private school and it ain’t all that. Most of them feel unbearable pressure to do well academically as so much money was put in to their education, especially if their parents aren’t rich. Spending so much on education is basically saying to your kid you are an investment, I want to see a return. We find the private school children tend to have much worse mental health issues. Also there’s something about going to state school that allows kids to experience and be around people from all walks of life. Friends of mine who went to private school find it hard to integrate with anyone who isn’t like them and really aren’t steer smart at all

ComradeTrostsky · 18/08/2023 07:54

I meant bursary not nursery

ComradeTrostsky · 18/08/2023 07:51

OP have you actually done any research about private schools? Research published this year has stated that private schools are no better than public in terms of education. They also tend to lack diversity and the teachers are no better educated ( I know private school teachers). What are you going to do about the long holidays in terms of care? And what about the expensive school trips? And one of the reasons why private school children tend to do well is all the extra curricular activities they do, which tend to be very expensive. How will you pay for all of those? You cannot rely on your parents for all of this, you have no idea what their future holds plus they may limit it if they’re concerned about their other grandchildren.

Unless you get a nursery (only 1% of them are awarded annually) I don’t think you can afford this. You need to look at other schools. There are lots of good public schools around, lots and lots of them.

primoseyellow · 18/08/2023 07:51

@Butterflyfluff I was just thinking this, a child will feel like the 'poor' kid and I know a few adults with this complex.
Can you afford to pay for a tutor when it gets to exams?

My friends son goes to private, not Eton or Charterhouse etc but a more bog standard one and the families lifestyles are still something else. Second homes, holidays abroad (nothing fancy , but abroad 3 times a year).

To be honest a private education doesn't guarantee anything, I know ,many successful people who have had state educations and are very successful .

user1492757084 · 18/08/2023 07:50

Look into bursaries.
Can you work for the school and obtain lower fees?
Have you looked at all other schools including religious based ones?
Can you move to where the schools are better?
Would your parents be open to giving you a loan should you ever be unable to meet the fees?

Weedoormatnomore · 18/08/2023 07:49

I did for a year but only because I realised that the preschool was cheaper than childminders as I just needed term time and there was no government help then. A lot of schools offer wrap around childcare now. Only you know what your cash flow is so only you can make the decision.

Shihtzulover · 18/08/2023 07:48

So you are not sure if that 11k reduction in salary will make it or break it? That only leaves you with 7k fees.

i am interested to know what kind of job pays you a fairly good salary where you can drop a day a week and also be lacking in common sense.

It sounds to me as though you could afford it but then it depends on your disposable income. You would possibly need to cut back on your outgoings.

Then you need to ask yourself can you sustain this until he is 18? It can be difficult for a child to be taken from a private to a state school.

Then consider all of the extras. Yes you say your parents will help but only as much as they help with other grandchildren. Uniforms, school trips and lunches can be three times as much.

It can give better outcomes in life but usually because they come from privileged backgrounds rather than a quality of education.

You need to research these state schools more and actually visit them, look at their results, speak to parents of the children that go there. Make an educated decision.

Packageholiday · 18/08/2023 07:21

@Krystall maybe i should take a punt then we are under 65 but do have 2nd properly

Krystall · 18/08/2023 07:18

Packageholiday · 18/08/2023 06:55

@Krystall what if that property was their incomes source though

To be honest bursary process is not so prescribed as to cover every single situation and I don’t recall anybody with a multi property portfolio applying for a bursary.

Rottweilermummy · 18/08/2023 07:04

Are any of the schools you looked at church schools you don't necessarily have to be particularly religious but it helps if your child is going to be involved and taught aspects of religion2, I just found they are usually better and people from all religions wanted to send their children to the schools my lads went to more than standard state schools is this an option for you?

onetimeonlyipromise · 18/08/2023 06:55

I spent a long time debating this when it came to my DD’s school selection.

For me, the big issues that made me go for state school were;

  • if I have a change in financial circumstances, not only would i have to worry about mortgage, etc, but I’d probably need to remove her from private school pretty sharpish, leaving her to join whichever state school had capacity, and with her having to get to know children who had spent years together. It also traps me in my job and prevents me making any sort of big change;
  • whilst I would have loved longer school holidays, I would have spend so much extra money on school fees, I would have had to work them, so wouldn’t have been able to spend them with her;
  • the breakfast club started at 8am. Local state school starts at 7.30;
  • extras (stationary, lunches, music, clubs, exams) all required funds, so the actual annual cost would likely be several thousand more than predicted, and the fees increased, not only with inflation, but also increases with the age of the child.
  • when I had a tour of the private school we were considering, I didn’t actually like it that much.

Dig around to find out academic results of the primary schools and try not to let first impressions commit you to paying £126,000 (plus extras and inflation) unless you really need to.

Packageholiday · 18/08/2023 06:55

@Krystall what if that property was their incomes source though

Krystall · 18/08/2023 06:53

Packageholiday · 17/08/2023 21:08

@Krystall can you elaborate please under what circumstances to you think bursary is allowed please.

What earning threshold, would they expect you too remortgage.

I understand they probably go quite deep, do they kill at bank accounts?..if two families were earning the same what woud swing it?

The bursary application process is extremely thorough and may even involve a home visit. It requires full disclosure of financial situation, not just employment earnings and as I have said, it will be of both parents, whether they are together or divorced / separated / never married. If we do not get the information required from one of the parents, the bursary application would be declined.

If there is one child, a combined income greater than £65k would rule them out. Again, whether the parents are together or not. We wouldn’t expect people to remortgage, but it they have a second home or other significant assets that could be sold, then that would be considered. I don’t know what you mean by “kill at bank accounts”, I maybe am getting old but that is a new expression to me.

The parent should apply for the bursary at the same time they apply for the place. If there is competition for bursaries, performance in entrance exams will come into it. This is why we don’t award bursaries to anybody under 7.