Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

has anyone managed to pay for private school on a lowish salary? I am so worried about ds going to state school

916 replies

unhw · 16/08/2023 19:31

Me and ex are divorced. DS is 3.5. Ex pays me 700 a month, he never sees DS so obviously that amount would change if he did start to see him.

I have been to some schools near here to look at them because if ds does go to a private school then I would want him to go to the nursery part too, from the word go. At the moment he goes to a nursery near the house which is average at best, despite an outstanding ofstead rating.

The schools are awful. There are so many kids. Barely any smartly dressed. Seems to be no order and organisation. Pick up is 3:20 (?!) so god knows what would happen to my job.

I really really want him to go to private school and the one I’ve seen is around 18k a year for primary. Has anyone done this on a low salary and if so how? Did you move house or downsize etc. I don’t want to do anything extreme but my priority is this and I would do what it takes it there’s a way.

OP posts:
Fupoffyagrasshole · 18/08/2023 09:51

absolute snob tbh

WineNoMore20 · 18/08/2023 09:45

I too am a single parent and earn at a similar level,
the only way I could keep working at pay for wrap around care was to move to an interest only mortgage for a while.
now my son is nearing teenage I have moved back to a repayment- but I am only just keeping up with costs associated with a state school- so private would be impossible. Affordability will depend on your other outgoings. The only people I know on similar salaries that pay for schooling do so with inter generational wealth.

Manthide · 18/08/2023 09:44

Densol57 · 16/08/2023 19:56

The way you view those state schooled children is the way the rich private schooled children will view your child 😢

Id definitely move to the best area you can afford. You have a decent salary but its not a private school salary in my view.

My 4dc all went to private secondary school, ds was a day boy at a boarding school. We are on universal credit. I don't think they were/are looked down on by anyone ( dd3 is just entering y11). On the contrary all positively contributed to the school and were active participants in school life. Eldest two are Cambridge graduates, ds was put in the pool but missed out ( probably due to covid) as he is amazingly bright and they are now recommending dd3 considers Oxbridge as she is expected to get all 9s next year.

Echio · 18/08/2023 09:40

Okay, the OP has made several fatal flaws alienating (more than half) of mums net.

That aside, she's asking about the finances of state school and just how much you sacrifice for your child when it's something you strongly believe in.

For my mind, the earnings are not enough. School fees increase every year/at every key stage milestone. The stress this would put on this family is huge, and I would be concerned the dynamic between parent and child could suffer because the sacrifice is especially high. I'd be thinking - find a small state school (eg if you move rural) which echoes the smaller feeling that private schools have, and buy in some wraparound care from a nanny and get them to do all the fancy activities you think you'd be missing out on - the horse riding, swimming, archery, ballet, whatever.

If everything's going well and you've put aside a decent chunk you can move at secondary.

Videogame0 · 18/08/2023 09:26

I know one single mum whose child goes to private school on a 100% bursary, so it’s possible.

Dazedandmore · 18/08/2023 09:25

So practically speaking, you will spend 30k before tax on school and will vae 35k left this is around 1.8 net a month and then you have 700 from ex so total of 2.5k.

Out of these 2.5k it depends how much you pay for your house. If you have around 1.5k left you can live fine-ish, if your house and bills are more than 1k, it will be a stretch even if your parents help you out.

It's definitely doable with this salary in my opinion and if this is what you think is the right thing for your child - do it!

Terfarina · 18/08/2023 09:24

Get a grip.

Private education is immoral. If everyone used state schools then governments would be motivated to make sure they were all good. Private education - and private healthcare - allows them to run services that the majority rely on into the ground.

all kids matter - even those who aren’t so smarty dressed!

Manthide · 18/08/2023 09:22

MissMarianHalcombe · 17/08/2023 18:33

I have a good friend who scrimped & saved to put both her children through private schools. Mine both went to state for lots of reasons. I’d be wary of expecting private in giving them a better start in life. It doesn’t always equate with better exam results or wider experiences. Both mine got better grades & are currently in higher paying jobs than her children (they’re all adults now) I don’t think she regrets her choice & neither do I. Most parents do what they think is the right thing for their child. All I’m trying to point out is that a private education doesn’t automatically mean better. I would add I worked for a teaching union for a short while & some of the private schools I came across had shockingly low standards in what they’d expect in qualifications for the teaching staff, mainly so they could pay them less. Clearly there are many great private schools as there are state.

I do think most children do fine whether they go state or private. My eldest two dd went private for secondary and it was a struggle. They both ended up at Cambridge and have good jobs. The main difference appeared to be the University they went to eg dd2's friend went to Edge Hill but has a good job in the sector she wanted.

Andthereyougo · 18/08/2023 09:21

Sorry, can’t read whole thread as I’m way behind today already , hope this hasn’t already been posted.
https://educational-grants.org/find-charity/?page=4
There might be more, just Google. Be very certain of financial obligations you’re taking on though.

Find a Charity - ETF

https://educational-grants.org/find-charity/?page=4

Motherofwildlings · 18/08/2023 09:17

Have you thought about a Montessori school Op? It won’t solve your issue of finishing times, however they are usually that little bit cheaper than your average prep-unless you live in Windsor because that’s the only free Montessori school.

BillyNotQuiteNoMates · 18/08/2023 09:11

I know people who have done it. Go in and have an honest conversation with them. What have you got to lose?
They may have schemes and scholarships available. The ones near me do.

ComradeTrostsky · 18/08/2023 09:11

Kazzybingbong · 18/08/2023 09:01

You don’t have to teach them directly or even set them up with tasks all the time. Learning happens in everything they do. As they get older, they will learn independently using resources to research what they’re interested in themselves.
Younger kids learn through play mostly.

You don’t have to follow the curriculum and education can happen whenever you want - between 5 and 8 if that suits but as I said, they’re learning all the time anyway.

I’ve just written my report for our 7 year old and I’d say only about 5% was sit down learning with workbooks. The rest is mostly discovery from doing things herself and from activities we’ve done together.

if your kid has written a song about Squishmallows, that’s literacy, if they’ve built a Lego set, that’s numeracy, if they make slime, that’s science.

Basically, home education is everything that school isn’t. I hope that helps!

I get all that but how can you do all of those things if you’re also working? I know home education is often about getting out and exploring and such, but you can’t do those things if you’re working from home at the same time?

FoodFann · 18/08/2023 09:10

PermanentTemporary · 16/08/2023 20:08

I do remember that feeling of terror when little ds in his teeny cardigan and curly hair was deposited in what seemed like chaos; we arrived early to pick him up ad the teacher told us he'd been hit by another child that day. It was a bad moment.

However, I am a massive fan of a proper British state primary school, at least the way they used to be. Tbh we should be a lot prouder of them than we seem to be. They were firmly based on principles of child development and the importance of freeform play. I held my nerve and ds was very happy there. He's 19 now and of course from this end I'm certain it was the right choice. A big influence on me was the peer group, and a proactive group of parents who did a lot of reading to the children, increased the music at the school etc. Do you have local friends whose children you like? Are they all going to private school - is that the problem?

I think on your salary your most realistic options are 1. Wait for secondary 2. Retrain and teach at a private school to get money off fees.

Your evidence is 15 years out of date. State primaries are under funded, under staffed, over crowded and suffering due to a lack of SEN support. It’s chaos. I am a primary state school teacher (ofsted good) and there’s absolutely no chance my DD will be going to state. Times have changed @PermanentTemporary, and I fully understand OP’s concerns. As it happens, many of my colleagues send their kids to private too.

MinimalistMe · 18/08/2023 09:10

OP I've only read your posts but can tell from those that you've had some crazy replies.

I'm just here to say, if you can find a way to do it, then definitely do it. I would do it in a heartbeat if I could. No point in pretending that state schools are just as good. Hope you find a way.

Pineapples198 · 18/08/2023 09:08

3:20 / 3:15 is standard pick up time. I imagine this would be the same for a private school. A lot of schools run after school clubs or have a club that collects from them and is run somewhere else, but often they won’t start at age 4. Your best bet might be a childminder.

in terms of the salary - most private schools offer a bursary if you are on a low income. So the lower the income the less fees you pay. Their website should tell you what this is.
I was looking at a private school for DS for high school, anything under £30k was a 100% bursary (ie free) that being said to gain entry he would have to pass the entrance exam and have 2/3 interviews before being offered a place. I’m not sure what the intake procedure is for young children. but would be worth checking with the school. The thing that put me off going private was the additional costs. I spoke to people who already have their children in private school and even if you get a lot of help with fees you aren’t helped with anything else. So expensive uniforms, expensive extra curriculars and trips, things that you might not be able to keep up with and your child might end up looking or feeling out of place.
Best thing to do is contact your local private school by email and ask all the questions.

Eaudesud · 18/08/2023 09:07

BooneyBeautiful · 17/08/2023 21:41

Interesting. A doctor (GP) friend of mine paid for all her four children to go to a private primary (prep) school which resulted in them all passing their 11+ (they obviously may have also passed at a state primary school) and then going onto a state grammar school. We don't have any grammar schools in our immediate area, but there are a few a bit further afield. They have all done well for themselves.

This is the problem in Britain, really isn't it. We like to pretend we are a meritocracy, but in truth, richer people purchase educational advantage for their children. Private education, tutoring, catchment areas etc.

Skyblue18 · 18/08/2023 09:07

Also on reflection, unless ex DH has problems, eg drugs, alcohol, mental health issues etc, my first priority would be sorting out the issues as to why DS has no relationship with his father. In the long term as he grows up this wiil affect him far more than choice of school.

AThousandStarlings · 18/08/2023 09:04

OP this is the wrong forum to post on my lovely. Heartbreaking when we might struggle to provide what we want for our children. Its really hard to send a child to private school and costs are the main factor, parents often make so many sacrifices ..... it can be done but it isn't easy. Firstly bursaries are like 'gold' dust and their award is very selective (there's often another connection to the child that gets the school bursary- viz a viz the family. Eg staff, alumni. So are unlikely to get one from the outset, if you are incredibly incredibly lucky you may find you are helped a little once your child is at the school - but v rare). Scholarships often offer very small fee discounts so some of the awards are such a small dent in costs. Its just so expensive that parents at private schools don't like lots of bursaries going out - as the money has to be found to pay for them ie. they see themselves as paying for others and yet have had to make lots of sacrifices themselves. Its quite a sensitive issue). If you are a teacher/have a job (IT, school nurse etc) at a particular private school you might find that a % discount is available on fees as an employment benefit. Also some parents carefully dip in and out of the state and private sectors. Eg state until 7 years old, then entry to an academic private primary (lots of tutoring, smaller classes, wrap around child care, inclusive actives), and then sit the 11 plus into a state grammar school and stay possibly until 16years when they transfer into a massive private school for sixth form ie 2 years of a-levels (for the amazing facilities, network connections and support into University). This way you 'only' pay for a certain number of years of private. If your parents or grandparents can contribute it is often an incredible and generous gift and there are massive massive numbers of children in the private school who are paid for by grandparents, it can help with inheritance tax, (but again this tends to be talked about very discreetly). Grandparents sometimes turn up at the ballet show, harvest festiival, Christmas fair, carol service etc which makes it such a lovely inclusive family experience. The other point is that whilst private schools seem to charge fees that are similar there is variation. Look closely. Some of the day schools are less, and some private schools include everything in your fees (breakfast club, afterschool activities.after care unless its by a specialist outside provider, food etc) and other charge everything as extra. Annual rises in fees have to be priced in - e.g. this year a private primary in our borough raised their fees by 10%. Having said all of that - there are really really lovely state schools, you just need to do more looking or move, and its possible to do lots of activities with outside providers (e.g. take your child to a music lesson etc - its just that private schools do a lot of that in house so its convenient) and your child would grow up with a good group of 'local' friends for life. Many of the private schools contain internationals or pupils with parents who are not local.

Loverofoxbowlakes · 18/08/2023 09:02

unhw · 16/08/2023 19:46

@Clefable yes because surely you’d pull a child up on that? It seems they are just free to roam and no structure. It worries me as ds has already got a home without his dad around so I want his school life to be as calm and focused as possible.

Early Years education is just that though - learning is child-led and they are very much encouraged to be free-roaming. As they progress it becomes more structured and adult-led.

You can't afford private education op. Maintenance can stop completely and is a real ball-ache to chase. Many private parents don't put kids in fee-paying school until secondary age as the outcomes before then are similar.

cloudydays2 · 18/08/2023 09:02

Private school doesn't always mean the best option? better dressed also doesn't mean that the kids are nicer either. My partner was bullied horrendously in private school due to his parents not being as well off as others. Maybe look at reviews for state schools rather than looking at what the children are dressed like.

Kazzybingbong · 18/08/2023 09:01

ComradeTrostsky · 18/08/2023 08:53

Could you explain a bit more please? I couldn’t see how I could focus on my job whilst also answering children’s questions, setting them up with tasks, sorting their breaks, and actually teaching them about various subjects.

You don’t have to teach them directly or even set them up with tasks all the time. Learning happens in everything they do. As they get older, they will learn independently using resources to research what they’re interested in themselves.
Younger kids learn through play mostly.

You don’t have to follow the curriculum and education can happen whenever you want - between 5 and 8 if that suits but as I said, they’re learning all the time anyway.

I’ve just written my report for our 7 year old and I’d say only about 5% was sit down learning with workbooks. The rest is mostly discovery from doing things herself and from activities we’ve done together.

if your kid has written a song about Squishmallows, that’s literacy, if they’ve built a Lego set, that’s numeracy, if they make slime, that’s science.

Basically, home education is everything that school isn’t. I hope that helps!

OutwiththeOutCrowd · 18/08/2023 09:00

From my admittedly limited experience the difference between state and private education is really not that great. It's talked up but I've watched my DS in both systems and did not think the 'extras' of the private system amounted to very much at all. If you don't go private I don't think you need to be overcome by FOMO.

Sometimes there's an idea that there is more extra-curricular enrichment in a private school but - again this is just my experience - students doing well in sport or music are usually being given extensive training elsewhere even if the school tries to indicate it was all down to them on social media.

Just a bit cynical here about the whole business!

Notjustabrunette · 18/08/2023 08:59

Before you decide that the private school is ‘better’ check the ofstead reports. Reasons being, a friend of mine was fixated on her DC going to private school, which turned out to of had a terrible report. The local primary was rated as outstanding. Once her child had started school she had a lot of issues and constantly complained about it. Friends with kids at the state school raved about how good it is. So my advice is do your research, which would be more in-depth than looking at how children are dressed.
on anther note, I lived abroad for a number of years in a country where private was the only option for non-locals. Unfortunately if a parent lost their job, their child would need to pulled out of school. It’s a long term commitment starting with the private system at primary.

SpaceRaiders · 18/08/2023 08:59

Both mine are at prep. It’s definitely manageable on a single salary. Although my first thought is you’ve gone for a school with all the bells and whistles, 6k a term won’t leave you much of a buffer should fees rise as they’re expected to in the coming years.

Ignore the ignorance on this thread. Not every prep school is the same, bullying exists everywhere, not every family is uber wealthy most are hard working and self funding school fees out of income. Bursaries are available but rare at prep. DD’s friend has secured 100% bursary at Y7 as parents are on a modest income, so it’s not completely uncommon.

Traxz · 18/08/2023 08:58

unhw · 16/08/2023 19:47

@paddleboarder12 i currently earn ok (76k) but this will drop to 65 soon.

What do you do @unhw

Swipe left for the next trending thread