Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Carers didnt turn up for morning call till 12.55pm.

111 replies

patsy999 · 16/08/2023 19:16

Is it worth complaining to social services about this? I have a 30 min care call in the morning and today I couldn't even have a shower as they were so late and i had an appointment at home at 1pm.
Not a single one of the carers can drive which is hopeless, as they use public transport to get to each call.
Plus, they only speak very basic English, so it's hard to communicate with them.
I'm only 55 and disabled. so goodness knows how the elderly are left.

OP posts:
Trinity65 · 17/08/2023 12:16

DarkPsy · 16/08/2023 21:43

Have a look at direct payments from your local council op. They pay you direct so you can then source and hire your own private carer.

I clean for a disabled lady who is having the same problem. The carers turn up at 8pm to put her to bed then don't come back until 10am the next morning. She is not incontinent, but is unable to get herself in and out of bed so is having to hold it for 14 hours or more. When she complained to the carers they told her to just wear a pad. It's heart breaking.

Indeed

I care for a lady in an ad-hoc way (when her regular carer is off or wants a holiday etc) and this is what occurs here.
I do the hours, fill in a time sheet and the local Borough pay Me for said hours.

LakieLady · 17/08/2023 12:01

Dymaxion · 16/08/2023 20:47

I'm only 55 and disabled. so goodness knows how the elderly are left.

Honestly most won't get a bath or a shower at home more than once in a blue moon, if ever. Those in residential settings might fare slightly better being allocated a bath or a shower at least once a week if staffing allows. Those with a live in carer might get one every day, but the cost of that sort of care isn't within most peoples reach.

If that's what's happening generally, it's appalling.

At the home where my friend works, she gives every resident under her care a shower when she's on the morning shift. It may be a very quick shower, but they get one. But I wonder, having read this, how typical that is, and how many of her colleagues aren't bothering when they're supposed to shower residents?

They also get a shower if they crap themselves. Every room has an en suite accessible shower.

Friend is incredibly diligent though, so it wouldn't surprise me if the level of care she gives is unusual. Her attitude is that she should give residents the same standard of care that she would give her own mum or dad, if they were still alive. And for that she gets £11.26 an hour, which is a few pence more than most of her colleagues. She gets the extra because she has a professional qualification of some sort, possibly from when she worked as an HCA/phlebotomist at a GP surgery.

I think it's absolutely disgusting that they are so poorly paid, and indicates utter contempt for the old and frail. And I'm very relieved that both my DPs died before they needed to go into care, although they weren't far from that point.

Dooooooooo · 17/08/2023 11:48

Some families can be so rude and unhelpful. I totally understand that it is hard accepting your relative needs care, and they may be struggling a lot with the pressure.
However whilst I've had many lovely, understanding and supportive families, I've had certain ones bark at me like I'm some sort of maid/skivvy, 'why has this not been done (exactly how I like it), not even a hello, just 'you're late ', or expecting me to clean up after them, not the clients, but them. No way.

Gladtoblasto · 17/08/2023 11:47

Please do raise it. You shouldn't be waiting till lunch time for support x

WetBandits · 17/08/2023 11:43

MillWood85 · 17/08/2023 10:27

I used to work in care before burning out. They may well have had an emergency that morning and couldn't convey that to you? I attended an early morning visit once and ended up having to call an ambulance that took 3 hours to arrive. The rest of my visits that morning just weren't attended as there was no one else to do them, and I found it horribly upsetting but I couldn't leave someone alone and on the floor that had had a stroke.

As a one off, I would note it. As a regular occurrence, contact the care company and say it's not acceptable.

This also happened to me at 6am on Boxing Day one year. First client of the day had had a stroke in the night, the ambulance fortunately ‘only’ took about 45 minutes to arrive, but the care coordinator didn’t bother to let my other seven morning clients know that I was held up with an emergency, so I was met by each client with accusations that I was late because I was hungover (spoiler: I wasn’t!)

WetBandits · 17/08/2023 11:37

I’d absolutely call their office and complain. It won’t be the carers’ fault, it will undoubtedly be whoever planned their rota.

I worked in domiciliary care while I was at uni and I remember getting a phone call from the coordinator one morning asking me where I was and why I wasn’t at Mr X’s house yet as he’d called. I explained that I had been given back to back calls since 6am with no travel time in between, and it was usually at least 5-10 minutes’ drive between clients. Mr X had an 8am call and lived seven miles away from my previous client, whose call was due to finish at 8am. On a school morning. In a city.

Carers and service users are set up to fail by care coordinators who don’t seem to have any idea that carers cannot teleport several miles! I was of the opinion that my clients deserved their full calls and whatever they wanted to achieve during those calls (be that a bath or shower, hair wash, breakfast, meds) so I never rushed, and was then always late to my next calls as I had no travel time factored into my rota. We all complained about it but nothing was ever done, we just got a bollocking for being ‘late’.

I’m sorry that this is still happening and that you have fallen victim to it. Please complain or nothing will ever change Sad

sadaboutmycat · 17/08/2023 11:28

I would speak to the registered manager at the care company first. They should be able to sort this so it doesn't happen again.
It's on them which staff go to which service user, not the care staff.

Dooooooooo · 17/08/2023 11:13

Thank you xx

Summerrainagain1 · 17/08/2023 10:28

calmcoco · 16/08/2023 19:34

Who are you complaining about?

The carers who are underpaid and told who to visit in what order?
The managers who assign the rotas with too few resources to deliver what is needed?
The council who commission the services at impossible prices?
The government who are responsible?

This Not a single one of the carers can drive which is hopeless, as they use public transport to get to each call.
Plus, they only speak very basic English, so it's hard to communicate with them. is not the carers' fault and is by the by.

Caring is a grossly underpaid job.

It is shit for you, I understand that, but both you AND the carers are in this position because the government won't find it properly.

This.

Complain, but focus on complaining about the provision, not the carers themselves. It's not their fault.

MillWood85 · 17/08/2023 10:27

I used to work in care before burning out. They may well have had an emergency that morning and couldn't convey that to you? I attended an early morning visit once and ended up having to call an ambulance that took 3 hours to arrive. The rest of my visits that morning just weren't attended as there was no one else to do them, and I found it horribly upsetting but I couldn't leave someone alone and on the floor that had had a stroke.

As a one off, I would note it. As a regular occurrence, contact the care company and say it's not acceptable.

willingtolearn · 17/08/2023 10:24

@Dooooooooo and other carers on this thread - Thank you so much for the difficult and underappreciated work that you do.

I think care is in an impossible situation. The amount of money that the general public is prepared to pay through tax for social care is inadequate for the amount of needs that exists and is only going to grow.

Care costs are expensive to deliver and expensive to manage. The demands on care staff are huge - for a low paid job you are expected to:

Be able to drive, own a car and afford to run it (getting more expensive by the day - and you will need commuting insurance)
Keep up to date with every growing training - often in your own time
Work a difficult shift pattern that does not necessarily fit into your own life and family time
Do endless overtime that you may not want to do or that costs you in family time/childcare/travelling costs
Have excellent communication, negotiation and interpersonal skills to deal with clients who are often frightened, unwell or deteriorating in mental state
Have endless patience in the face of clients and family who may complain endlessly about trivial things or things that are not in your control
Have excellent time management - in fact if you could have a tardis or time turner so you could manipulate time that would really help
Be physically fit and robust despite the job being quite hazardous to your health in many ways
Understand complex care needs with often multiple medications and health conditions that are never fully explained to you

And yet it is apparently 'unskilled work'

Badbudgeter · 17/08/2023 10:22

I do think the system needs an overhaul. This isn't directed at the OP but I'd always encourage people to consider where they live especially as they grow older and care needs increase. I live rurally and it's a real struggle for people to stay in their homes as there is limited care available and it is expensive comparitively. Mileage could be £10+, paid 30 minutes of travel time £6 ish so it's expensive before they walk in the door. Fine if you are self funding and can pay a carer 2-3 hours a day at a rate of £20 ish an hour. If it's a 15 minute slot funded by the LA you've got no chance and will end up waiting for a crisis or dependent on family.

bounce89 · 17/08/2023 10:16

@patsy999

Please do contact the office and discuss how you would like things to go moving forward. They can only make adjustments if they know what the issues are, it doesn't have to be that you're complaining about the carer (unless that is what you feel you need to do if the care you are receiving is not adequate).
They may change the time that you usually have or ask the carers to contact you to let you know if they're running late.
Where we are we are quite rural so mainly have drivers, I'm not sure how anyone would manage on public transport getting between calls.

Could you look on indeed for care companies that offer travel pay and mileage in your area and then request a change in care providers?
I know this isn't something you should have to do but I guess the care providers that offer this are more likely to have better time slots available due to having more people that drive?

Dooooooooo · 17/08/2023 09:57

I remember on one day I was given 12 morning visits, some several miles apart, it was ridiculous. I arrived for the last call at 11.35am. Understandably one family complained.
The rota can be an issue because a lot of people like certain times, like 9am. However you can't be in several places at 9am, you have to try and fit everything in as best you can. Also if you're new it's tough until you get to know what times the clients like. Some care coordinators will randomly allocate times, for instance they will send you to Maureen at 7am, you arrive and Maureen will still be asleep and will shout at you for arriving so early and family will complain, even though you were just following your rota. It's tough sometimes.

Rocknrollstar · 17/08/2023 09:55

We had to deal with this all the time for my mother. Agencies do not have extra staff so if someone is off ill or on holiday the other workers have to fit their calls in to the day. They aren’t paid enough to run cars and sometimes they get to someone who needs extra time. Eg my mother had a stroke and the carers phoned us and 999 but wouldn’t leave until she was in the ambulance. However, it is very difficult for those, like yourself, who are left hanging on. We had many occasions when mum would call us at 10.00am to say she still hadn’t had a cup of tea or breakfast and hadn’t had a shower. I used to dash over and do the breakfast and pray the carers would eventually turn up to give her a shower. Changing agencies won’t give a better service, I’m afraid. My mother had difficulty understanding the English of her carers but we discovered that several of them were highly educated. One spoke 5 languages and had lived in Sweden and France. Being a carer is the only job many of them can get. But some of them really do care about the people they visit.

Willowow · 17/08/2023 09:51

I would raise it but their may be an exceptional reason they were so late. For example if someone ahead of you was unwell and they needed to wait with them for an ambulance. Or perhaps somebody called in sick that day and the workload was doubled for someone else as a result.

Perhaps you would feel better if you found out a specific reason.

That said I also echo others comments. It's poorly paid work that is also very emotionally and physically draining. People who can drive, speak good English or have the option to pursue further qualifications would probably be better off doing something else. Unfortunately where something is grossly underfunded and undervalued this is going to impact the service no matter how much the individual staff put in.

Sorry this happened it must have left you feeling very helpless x

Dooooooooo · 17/08/2023 09:48

I am one of a small number of white British carers in my company, many are on sponsorship, however they can speak an acceptable level of English, companies should be ensuring a certain level of competence in English before employing people.

Dooooooooo · 17/08/2023 09:46

I work in domiciliary care and agree 12:55 is not acceptable, I'm sorry this happened to you. Is it a regular thing?
The carers or office should have contacted you to let you know. However a lot of carers will have been expected to squeeze in 10 morning visits, some are a few miles apart, and zero travel time in between.
I have a bicycle as I don't drive, the max I have to cycle is 15 minutes between each call. Some of our carers walk (not very quickly either) and can take 30+ minutes between each call, honestly don't know how they do it. The system needs an overhaul.
However I am sorry this happened to you. Hopefully it won't happen again.

patsy999 · 17/08/2023 09:42

I am very isolated, which was my point. Some days i only see the carers.

OP posts:
MimiGC · 17/08/2023 09:34

I am shocked by a previous poster who said it is 'by the by' if you are sent a carer who doesn't speak English well enough for you to be able to communicate with them. Disabled and elderly people need to be able to communicate with those who come into their homes to provide care for them. How can their needs be properly met otherwise? And for some,who are very isolated, that may be the only person they see all day. How would you like it?!

Badbudgeter · 17/08/2023 09:15

WomblingTree86 · 17/08/2023 06:07

Profits have been up for most companies.

I think many companies have gotten pickier about their clients. Especially those receiving council funded care. It used to be that if you got to a client and they had had a toileting accident you could be there ages cleaning client, remaking bed etc. You’d only be paid for their allotted time though so you’re working for free for that extra half an hour. This is why people quit and are better off working in Tesco’s or whatever. You get paid for your whole shift.

I think now companies are much more likely to hand back care contracts back for, or refuse, clients who take up extra time or who live somewhere challenging. In a way this is a good thing carers should be paid for the hours worked (including travel). There should be realistic assessments as to what peoples care needs actually are and how much time that will take rather than expecting carers to work for free and everyone further down the list to accept delays.

The downside is those who are the most vulnerable/ have the most challenging needs often can not find care. There’s lots of stories about people stuck in hospitals/ care homes/ heavily dependent on family as they just can’t find carers. Reality is you could find carers if you paid enough plus travel time/ expenses but it would be really expensive and people/ councils don’t want/ can’t afford to pay.

WomblingTree86 · 17/08/2023 06:07

calmcoco · 17/08/2023 00:59

In my area many are going bust which is causing yet more problems.

Profits have been up for most companies.

Crazydoglady1980 · 17/08/2023 05:54

bounce89 · 17/08/2023 00:25

@JudgeRudy
I find that quite rude and incorrect. Most of the people that I work with are nurses that left the profession, some are mums that find they can work late so as to suit their children's needs.
We don't have a care shortage due to carers being to thick to work somewhere else, we have a shortage because people like you think that we're the bottom of the chain and it makes people embarrassed to work in care.

I can tell you that today I made a difference, I held a ladies hand while she passed away, I supported her family.
I helped an elderly mother support her nearly elderly son with the care that she can no longer provide herself
I made every person that I saw today smile, I made them feel heard, they felt supported.

I'm not in the job because I'm thick, I'm in the job because if I can make one persons day better then it's worth the long hours and crap pay.

And unfortunately for every one person like you, there will be two who get in and out as quickly as possible, turn up and have no idea what is in the care plan, or moan about the work the whole time they are providing care.
It shouldn’t be a competition about whose needs are more important, the carer or the carees, and while carers can change their jobs, move to a different profession etc, disabled people still need care and many will need it for the rest of their life. Being a carer is a job, for the person receiving care this is their life!

Beetham · 17/08/2023 01:02

Hi OP, I'm the registered manager of a domiciliary care organisation (mainly supporting people with learning disabilities but also some people who have only physical disabilities). You should absolutely raise this with your provider. As well as a quality issue this is also a safeguarding issue, in my local authority his would be reported (no details just the number of incidents of this type) on our quarterly safeguarding report to the local authority. It would also be included in our CQC provider report.

For some people this is a (completely unacceptable) inconvenience, for others it could be catastrophic for example if they had fallen, not been supported to take vital medications, had been left to soil themselves etc. Yes the care sector is in absolute shambles but you do deserve better and one very small thing that contributes to better care is more accurate data on where things have fallen short.

calmcoco · 17/08/2023 00:59

WomblingTree86 · 17/08/2023 00:45

I think that the companies providing care are often profit making organisations too actually and while the carera aren't paid much the companies themselves are often making a lot of money.

In my area many are going bust which is causing yet more problems.