Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Carers didnt turn up for morning call till 12.55pm.

111 replies

patsy999 · 16/08/2023 19:16

Is it worth complaining to social services about this? I have a 30 min care call in the morning and today I couldn't even have a shower as they were so late and i had an appointment at home at 1pm.
Not a single one of the carers can drive which is hopeless, as they use public transport to get to each call.
Plus, they only speak very basic English, so it's hard to communicate with them.
I'm only 55 and disabled. so goodness knows how the elderly are left.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
NewName122 · 18/08/2023 10:57

My friends work don't do it on purpose it is purely down to staffing issues and not enough carers who drive. But if you don't complain they won't ever get better.

NewName122 · 18/08/2023 10:55

Someone close to me works in the office of a care company, doing the rotas amongst other things. I hear stories like yours all the time, people getting their visit so late or ridiculously early so they get put to bed in the day. Do complain, the CQC are on their backs constantly to improve, well they are this company anyway.

Cornettoninja · 18/08/2023 09:47

@JudgeRudy

Doubling down = committing more strongly to a position.

In this case, I can see what you’re trying to communicate but your refusal to see how it’s being done in a way that’s really quite patronising and offensive. You’re acknowledging that your position doesn’t cover all people in a particular role but then re-emphasising sweeping, derogatory statements about whole groups of people.

Good for you if you continue to work in the field whilst training others, however, that doesn’t make you immune to conceit and a tendency to look down on others which is how your words come across.

Theres really no need to defend your occupation against the ‘teaching vs doing’ comment. It was only to illustrate that sweeping statements provoke responses. I knew what I was doing and given you posted you can’t see why your statements might be interpreted in a way other than your intention it might be helpful for you to understand.

Fwiw in recent years I have seen a number of employers push to assist their staff with gaining qualifications and skills in core subjects. There are very few people who aren’t capable of learning and it’s often not down to an individuals abilities.

Badbudgeter · 18/08/2023 09:29

Nat6999 · 18/08/2023 02:44

It's time caring was turned into a full profession with training on a par with nursing, it's no longer just washing, dressing, feeding & toileting, there are so many other aspects to it. Having seen exh carers walk in, practically throw a sandwich at him & leave in what should have been a double handed 20 minute call or leave him on the floor because they can't pick him up because they haven't got a lifting certificate, it just isn't good enough. Having a proper training system could actually save the NHS money in the long term, it would keep people who are being cared for out of hospital. Even something as simple as testing urine if the client is ill, spotting urine infections early can stop people ending up in hospital, if there were more fully trained carers who had more time to spend with their clients, clients would receive better care, there would be a reduction in hospital admissions & bed blocking. Caring needs to be made more attractive, make the training partly what nurses do on their course & if at any time a fully trained carer wishes to become a nurse, enable them to do a shorter degree course.

I’d agree. Not sure if it’s similar in other places but in my area the reablement team/ carers are really good. They are employed directly by the council and use the council pool cars so the cost is much higher per visit. They work with a view to people regaining as much independence as possible which saves money in the long run.

It’s impossible to get council employed carers if you have a long term condition or are just on a gradual decline. I think it would be better to bring it in house and pay people fairly, providing vehicles, paid travel time as you would expect for pretty much any other job.

Nat6999 · 18/08/2023 02:44

It's time caring was turned into a full profession with training on a par with nursing, it's no longer just washing, dressing, feeding & toileting, there are so many other aspects to it. Having seen exh carers walk in, practically throw a sandwich at him & leave in what should have been a double handed 20 minute call or leave him on the floor because they can't pick him up because they haven't got a lifting certificate, it just isn't good enough. Having a proper training system could actually save the NHS money in the long term, it would keep people who are being cared for out of hospital. Even something as simple as testing urine if the client is ill, spotting urine infections early can stop people ending up in hospital, if there were more fully trained carers who had more time to spend with their clients, clients would receive better care, there would be a reduction in hospital admissions & bed blocking. Caring needs to be made more attractive, make the training partly what nurses do on their course & if at any time a fully trained carer wishes to become a nurse, enable them to do a shorter degree course.

hopsalong · 17/08/2023 21:38

Horrible for you, and I think worth complaining about if the terms of the contract have been broken.

But, yes, in a larger picture the whole situation is unstable and ultimately fucked. The money isn't there in the system for someone (with fluent English, among other things) to come and give you a shower every morning for the next few decades, if this is a permanent disability. If it's a temporary one, then I think complaining might be more productive. Hopefully, at least in your lifetime (though probably not in our children's) the welfare state will exist in a vestigial enough form to keep you clean, eg by offering a shower a few times a week at whatever time can be managed. After that, it seems as if we'll be back to the least humane and generous, but most basic position: either you wash yourself, your family do it for you, or you use money you've saved, inherited or earn to pay someone to do it.

JudgeRudy · 17/08/2023 19:54

Cornettoninja · 17/08/2023 18:32

@JudgeRudy it very much reads like you’re doubling down. What you think you’re implying and what is actually being communicated doesn’t really match up.

You’re not giving any parameters for what counts as poorly educated or unskilled nor are you recognising that softer skills are important and often innate in good carers.

it’d be easy for me to sit and start bleeting about ‘if you can’t do it, teach it’ but that would be rude and potentially hurtful too wouldn’t it?

?? No idea what doubling down means in this context. l mean poorly educated/unskilled in the general workplace sense. So lack of basic functional skills and qualifications in maths, English and IT. The sort of things an employer might look for. l dont make the rules.
I'm sure many carers have excellent soft skills. Plenty don't.
As for the teaching, I did 'do it'. I still do. That's why I was employed to pass on my skills and expertise to other carers/patients. I earn more money teaching than doing.

Dooooooooo · 17/08/2023 18:59

I am a part-time Care Assistant who is highly educated, we have a mixed bag, a lot of my colleagues have university-level qualifications, some don't have any.

Cornettoninja · 17/08/2023 18:32

@JudgeRudy it very much reads like you’re doubling down. What you think you’re implying and what is actually being communicated doesn’t really match up.

You’re not giving any parameters for what counts as poorly educated or unskilled nor are you recognising that softer skills are important and often innate in good carers.

it’d be easy for me to sit and start bleeting about ‘if you can’t do it, teach it’ but that would be rude and potentially hurtful too wouldn’t it?

JudgeRudy · 17/08/2023 17:47

bounce89 · 17/08/2023 00:25

@JudgeRudy
I find that quite rude and incorrect. Most of the people that I work with are nurses that left the profession, some are mums that find they can work late so as to suit their children's needs.
We don't have a care shortage due to carers being to thick to work somewhere else, we have a shortage because people like you think that we're the bottom of the chain and it makes people embarrassed to work in care.

I can tell you that today I made a difference, I held a ladies hand while she passed away, I supported her family.
I helped an elderly mother support her nearly elderly son with the care that she can no longer provide herself
I made every person that I saw today smile, I made them feel heard, they felt supported.

I'm not in the job because I'm thick, I'm in the job because if I can make one persons day better then it's worth the long hours and crap pay.

The majority of carers are not 'opted out' nurses. The majority of carers aren't well educated. Id guess we have a shortage of good care workers because it's relatively poorly paid nothing to do with what you believe my opinion is.
I have no idea who people like me are. I have not implied you are thick, but inevitably some carers are. I have worked as a trainer with this group with many providers. I stand by my view that the majority of carers are poorly educated with limited skills. That doesn't imply I think they are bottom of any chain.
I'm glad you get to make a difference to people lives. I do too.

DinnaeFashYersel · 17/08/2023 15:14

Complain each and every time. Its not acceptable and if you don't complain it doesn't get logged and then it becomes standard practice.

Keep a log and if it continues go to your MP

You shouldn't be treated like this.

saraclara · 17/08/2023 15:12

And still, the vast majority of posters are coming here to say "poor carers" and barely a one to have any sympathy for OP, who's alone, isolated and not receiving the care she desperately needs.

If she calls the care service, she's not making a personal complsint about the carers. She's complaining to the management of the company providing the care. And she needs to.

Seriously, it's like haven't anyone here can imagine what it's like for OP. Ffs use your imagination, have some empathy, and stop using her thread to tell her (or at least imply) that she's unreasonable to complain that she's been left unfed and untoileted from the night before until after 1pm.

It doesn't matter how bad things are for care agencies, these situations need to be logged for anyone to eventually take any notice.

As had been said by a care manager on this thread, this is a safeguarding issue. No food, no drunk, no toileting, no personal care. Who would accept that for themselves, for their child, or for a loved one?

girlfriend44 · 17/08/2023 15:08

Kendodd · 17/08/2023 15:05

As bad as the situation is now, I think it's set to get a whole lot worse in the coming two decades. And as much as I blame the government/Brexit (rightly) I don't know how any government will cope with a top heavy population needing care and fewer and fewer working age people to provide it.

Agree, but its been like this for a few years now always plenty of jobs in care.

ASCCM · 17/08/2023 15:08

Do you use a Direct payment to organise the carers yourself or do the local authority organise your package of care?

Timed calls are almost impossible to get right but this seems completely unreasonable especially if they didn't contact you to let you know they were going to be late.

Do you have a designated case worker? i would call them directly if you can

Cornettoninja · 17/08/2023 15:05

Moneynewpence · 17/08/2023 15:00

Complain to the care company first, then social services if no joy.

I would add in your local MP if you’re inclined/feel able @patsy999. This is a huge problem and so many affected are simply unable to use their voice to inform the people in the positions to influence.

Kendodd · 17/08/2023 15:05

As bad as the situation is now, I think it's set to get a whole lot worse in the coming two decades. And as much as I blame the government/Brexit (rightly) I don't know how any government will cope with a top heavy population needing care and fewer and fewer working age people to provide it.

Moneynewpence · 17/08/2023 15:02

Trinity65 · 17/08/2023 12:32

How bloody RUDE are you?!!

I am educated thank you very much!

Quite. Care work is very skilled.

Moneynewpence · 17/08/2023 15:00

Complain to the care company first, then social services if no joy.

Cornettoninja · 17/08/2023 14:58

JudgeRudy · 17/08/2023 00:12

I don't think the majority of carers 'choose' this field as such. They're often poorly educated with minimal skills so their choices are fewer. Maybe they prefer it to hospitality or retail. I doubt they're chosing it over say working as an astrophysicist or pop star.

You’d be wrong.

I choose to work and qualify in care work leaving due to a combination of burn out, shocking shift patterns (I’ve literally done 56hrs on the trot through ‘sleep ins’ supporting night staff) and low remuneration over a decade ago. To think things are worse now is almost incomprehensible.

There are many people who ‘end up’ in care but ime they don’t last long because generally you really can’t hack it unless you’re motivated to make someone else’s life better/easier. The people who genuinely love their work and wouldn’t want to do anything else.

calmcoco · 17/08/2023 14:14

MimiGC · 17/08/2023 09:34

I am shocked by a previous poster who said it is 'by the by' if you are sent a carer who doesn't speak English well enough for you to be able to communicate with them. Disabled and elderly people need to be able to communicate with those who come into their homes to provide care for them. How can their needs be properly met otherwise? And for some,who are very isolated, that may be the only person they see all day. How would you like it?!

Hi @MimiGC it was I who used the term 'by the by'. It was about the carers using buses as well as the English.

My point is there are very high staff shortages in the care sector. The days of companies specifying 'own car' are gone - they take who they can. You can't blame the carer for their situation - the company selects them.

Special thanks to everyone who voted for Brexit for making the staffing situation so much worse.

I don't need a lecture about the importance of care - I just don't think it is the fault of the individual carers. The whole system is fucked. The Tories have run it right into the ground, it wasn't great in 2010 but it was a hell of a lot better.

girlfriend44 · 17/08/2023 13:59

LakieLady · 17/08/2023 12:01

If that's what's happening generally, it's appalling.

At the home where my friend works, she gives every resident under her care a shower when she's on the morning shift. It may be a very quick shower, but they get one. But I wonder, having read this, how typical that is, and how many of her colleagues aren't bothering when they're supposed to shower residents?

They also get a shower if they crap themselves. Every room has an en suite accessible shower.

Friend is incredibly diligent though, so it wouldn't surprise me if the level of care she gives is unusual. Her attitude is that she should give residents the same standard of care that she would give her own mum or dad, if they were still alive. And for that she gets £11.26 an hour, which is a few pence more than most of her colleagues. She gets the extra because she has a professional qualification of some sort, possibly from when she worked as an HCA/phlebotomist at a GP surgery.

I think it's absolutely disgusting that they are so poorly paid, and indicates utter contempt for the old and frail. And I'm very relieved that both my DPs died before they needed to go into care, although they weren't far from that point.

its depends what type of care home your in, mine got a shower every other day and was well looked after and respected till the end.

Trinity65 · 17/08/2023 12:32

JudgeRudy · 17/08/2023 00:12

I don't think the majority of carers 'choose' this field as such. They're often poorly educated with minimal skills so their choices are fewer. Maybe they prefer it to hospitality or retail. I doubt they're chosing it over say working as an astrophysicist or pop star.

How bloody RUDE are you?!!

I am educated thank you very much!

Nat6999 · 17/08/2023 12:31

My exh has carers 4 times a day supposedly to fit in with his medication schedule, often his first call doesn't turn up till 10.00am, his lunch one will turn up at 11.30am, tea at 3.30pm & bed at 6.00pm, none of which fit in with a minimum of 4 hours between medication doses. Yet he gets told off if he does his medication himself. He has also had times when they have given his bedtime medications at breakfast by mistake & he has had to go 36 hours without the strong medication he has to take for his pain, muscle spasms & sleep which left him in agony.

nadine90 · 17/08/2023 12:28

worriedatwork123 · 16/08/2023 22:01

replies are shocking actually - complain to the government? Be grateful? wtf?

of course social care needs a massive overhaul but OP is a person who has not had her care this morning and there's posters here implying she should be grateful
anyone even wants to deal with her at all - it's disgraceful. We should all raise our expectations and complain every single time something is unacceptable and accept no less. This is how we will achieve change.

OP yes complain - there's supposed to be an open door policy between care provider so you can raise a concern and see if they can reassure you. Was it a one off, will it happen again etc.

The care agency has agreed to take your care hours so they have a responsibility to make sure they fulfill the contract

Absolutely.
The system is broken. It is due to underfunding and understaffing. Complaints are evidence of this and highlight where and why changes are needed.

DisquietintheRanks · 17/08/2023 12:28

MimiGC · 17/08/2023 09:34

I am shocked by a previous poster who said it is 'by the by' if you are sent a carer who doesn't speak English well enough for you to be able to communicate with them. Disabled and elderly people need to be able to communicate with those who come into their homes to provide care for them. How can their needs be properly met otherwise? And for some,who are very isolated, that may be the only person they see all day. How would you like it?!

But the choice isn't between someone who can speak English well and drive and someone who can't. The choice is often between someone with poor English and no car and no one at all. So unless you are suggesting that British people are forced into care work then many carers will be coming from abroad.