Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

High school or home ed?

32 replies

Mountainhowl · 16/08/2023 15:04

Our eldest will be going into year 6 this year, so there's been lots of talk around high schools recently, and I'm really undecided about what direction to go for him (undiagnosed but almost guaranteed ADHD, school haven't been overly helpful with moving forward with a diagnosis so far, I suspect it's not a priority as he isn't any 'trouble')

We have 2 local options, one that we are in catchment for which is known to be not great, not awful but not great, the other is locally known as the better school, but we would have to pay £200+ a term for the bus, and more worryingly - they are advertising vacancies for a good amount of core subject teachers, and have been for some time.

My lad is very much into what he's into and puts minimum effort into everything that doesn't interest him. He wants to work with computers in some capacity, and is also quite into history and some science (fossils etc, so tied in with history). He stims whenever he's concentrating (humming, so not subtle) and is quite behind his peers in some respects (he's a wizz on a pc but shite at sports for example) and he's quite a sensitive lad.

Quite honestly I think the kids at high school will eat him alive, but I also know he is going to struggle with the expectations of high school, so many more subjects, homework etc. I think he is especially going to struggle to keep up if he doesn't have actual regular teachers for the important subjects!

My thinking is that it almost seems like a waste of 5 years of his life for him to go there every day and probably take the bare minimum away from it, when we could tailor his education to cover the core subjects then focus on what he's actually interested in and/or good at.

But I'm also aware that just by going to school he may be exposed to subjects/ideas that he didn't think he would enjoy but actually does.

But also - AI could be changing the computer/coding industry in the next couple of years (or already is in some cases), would school curriculums adapt to this like we potentially could? I have no idea how we would but the flexibility to do so would be there...

I would just send him off and see how he does, but by that point we'll have spent £500+ on uniform, bus pass etc, that money is then gone as can't be used to buy courses or things to supplement his home learning.

Time wise we could make HE work, his younger brother would be starting primary as he is starting high school, we both work from home and OH would do the majority of the teaching, with the plan to supplement with courses and online tutors where needed.

I've looked at the online schools but unfortunately we are far too poor for these 😂

Sorry it's long, didn't want to drop feed!

Everything seems to lean towards HE but I'm worried we will be making the wrong decision and potentially ruining his life if we don't do a good job of it! AIBU to think HE is a good idea?

OP posts:
Mountainhowl · 16/08/2023 15:28

anothermnuser123 · 16/08/2023 15:21

Do you have time in the day to be out and about? A big chunk of home ed, and what sounds like it would be beneficial to your DS, is the social side. Getting out and meeting others, doing classes, finding interests.

I think a lot of people think home ed is sitting in your house 9-3 doing school work, but where you benefit most is the community, the ability to arrange things yourself once into the swing of it, and really find their interests.

If you cant do this I would personally think about how you would fulfil the social side.

Join some home ed facebook groups, see if you can join some meet ups and talk to local people home educating to see what your area is like before making decisions. Depending on where you live, some areas are fantastic and have such a great community, others have far less. Its worth doing a little research for your area.

We could definitely work around groups, me and my partner are mostly interchangeable at work, I'm just faster/enjoy it more so do the bulk, but if there were things going on outside the house he would just work instead (I'm the driver and he's a bit socially awkward 😂)

We did go to 'HE' groups when he was younger, put in quotation marks because he was 2/3 as where the majority of the kids 😂 we all just planned to HE, though I chickened out by school age.

He did thrive during lockdown, went from struggling through biff & chip to reading harry potter with confidence, and we mostly unschooled then because we had a newborn too, he just did the bare minimum online work (our primary were very relaxed), so I think the relaxed set up of HE would suit him far better than high school (and we don't want any more children 😂)

OP posts:
anothermnuser123 · 16/08/2023 15:24

I will also say towards the upper end of home ed, it gets pricey. GCSEs can be costly, A levels even more so, so definitely consider this too. Check out your local area, where are exam centres, will you need to travel. You may think it is a way off but it soon comes around and the good thing with home ed is the ability to do exams at your pace, my youngest started hers at 14 to spread them out a bit. Helps spreading the cost and the studying.

anothermnuser123 · 16/08/2023 15:21

Do you have time in the day to be out and about? A big chunk of home ed, and what sounds like it would be beneficial to your DS, is the social side. Getting out and meeting others, doing classes, finding interests.

I think a lot of people think home ed is sitting in your house 9-3 doing school work, but where you benefit most is the community, the ability to arrange things yourself once into the swing of it, and really find their interests.

If you cant do this I would personally think about how you would fulfil the social side.

Join some home ed facebook groups, see if you can join some meet ups and talk to local people home educating to see what your area is like before making decisions. Depending on where you live, some areas are fantastic and have such a great community, others have far less. Its worth doing a little research for your area.

Mountainhowl · 16/08/2023 15:20

Sirzy · 16/08/2023 15:13

How will you afford enrichment chances and down the line exam fees?

i am all for home Ed and it’s on the cards for ds if things go badly with school but it needs a lot of time and planning and realistically to ensure opportunities aren’t limited won’t come cheap.

have you spoken to the sencos at the schools which are options?

That is my other concern, we aren't massively high income and not a huge amount is disposable, but my thinking was for the amount the primary want for 3 nights away we could go as a family for a cheap few days away, and from what I remember of high school trips that is definitely the case!

There are obviously other smaller trips but it's usually only one a term I think? Which we could afford to do (and would be paying for at school anyway)

I'm not sure what else would need paying for outside of courses/tuition. We would get him into a club of some sort for socialising, this we could afford with the money saved on the buss pass

Exam fees I do expect to be much better off by then all going well! Obviously not a guarantee but if I'm not I'll be very pissed off with myself 😂

OP posts:
Sirzy · 16/08/2023 15:13

How will you afford enrichment chances and down the line exam fees?

i am all for home Ed and it’s on the cards for ds if things go badly with school but it needs a lot of time and planning and realistically to ensure opportunities aren’t limited won’t come cheap.

have you spoken to the sencos at the schools which are options?

Mountainhowl · 16/08/2023 15:09

Hufflepods · 16/08/2023 15:08

I don't think it is particularly useful to home educate while working full time.

Technically I work full time he works a few hours a week in our business and does most of the home stuff

OP posts:
Hufflepods · 16/08/2023 15:08

I don't think it is particularly useful to home educate while working full time.