Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Help! Someone who’s good at maths, how much do I owe ExH?

171 replies

PuddleCake · 16/08/2023 14:57

I’ve sold family home and we are splitting the profit (just the profit, not my equity) 70/30 to me. Ex and I have come up with different calculations….

House sold for 710k

I bought it for 327k (this included mortgage of 175k, I have £155k left to pay on it). Ex wasn’t on mortgage and didn’t put any money into sale.

I've spent 100k on renovations, this includes all legal and estate agents fees

Ex spent 27k on renovations

I owe ex 7k from previous house renovation

OP posts:
Starseeking · 16/08/2023 17:37

DancingToMyTune · 16/08/2023 16:19

Capital gains tax should also be deducted from the total value of the house, before splitting it.

No, it shouldn't. CHT doesn't apply to a principal private residence, which in the absence of information otherwise, I'm assuming this was the family PPR.

Ambi · 16/08/2023 17:36

I didn't read the full thread, pleased my answers matched with other posters.

Ambi · 16/08/2023 17:32

I got the £110.8k as per previous posters.

Sale 710 - 327 = 383 profit
less renov 127k spends = 256k.
30% 76.8k to him,
70% 179.2 to you

His = 76.8 profit share + 27 renov +7 payback = 110.8 to him.

Yours = 179.20 profit share + 100 renov - 7 payback = 272.20 to you.
Then, there is is the mortgage equity to you = 327 - 155 = 172 = total of 444.20

Yalta · 16/08/2023 17:32

Because it is profit you are splitting then you have to deduct / repay the renovation costs and the outstanding mortgage and op’s equity first.

A lot of people are only taking account of the initial deposit and forgetting that the mortgage payments went partly to paying off the mortgage so the equity is the initial cost of the house less the outstanding mortgage

Also at the end when you add up who gets what, to check you are correct it has to add up to £710,000.

titchy · 16/08/2023 17:30

I think everyone has over-complicated it.

Profit is simply 710 - 327, minus all costs which will include mortgage repayments (not mentioned), the 100 you put in, the 27 he put in and selling costs.

30% of that figure to him, plus the 7 that you already owed him.

TiaraBoo · 16/08/2023 17:29

My calculation:
The whole house was yours when you bought it, so profit is 710-327=383k

30% of 383k = £114.9k
minus half of renovations you paid (-50k)
plus half of his renovations (+13.5k)
plus 7k you owe him (+7k)

Total = £85,400

Takoneko · 16/08/2023 17:25

I’m not happy with my previous answers at all and realise my sums were way off somewhere. (Will teach me for not writing things down properly) Blush

I feel like like I’ve clarified my thinking a lot.

The OP had 46% equity when she bought the place. 46% of the new price is therefore her equity, so that’s roughly £327k. We put that to one side in OP’s pot.

Then the bank is owed £155k. That leaves £228k to be split 70/30 giving the ex £68.4k plus the 7k he is owed, so £75.4k.

OR

You take the OP’s £100k out of that £228k and give it to her and the ex’s £27k and give that back to him, leaving £101k profit to be split. The ex would then get £33.3k in addition to his £27k from earlier plus the £7k the OP owes him giving £67.3k.

OP, I think you are being more than generous.

Yalta · 16/08/2023 17:23

EeesandWhizz

There is only £155000 remaining on the mortgage so her equity is £327000-£155000 = 172,000

Don’t forget she has been making mortgage payments each month which has chipped away at the outstanding mortgage

WinchSparkle80 · 16/08/2023 17:22

Could be something like this?

Help! Someone who’s good at maths, how much do I owe ExH?
WhythefuxdidI · 16/08/2023 17:21

If you treat the 7K separately, you would then have £172,200 left.

JenniferBarkley · 16/08/2023 17:20

JenniferBarkley · 16/08/2023 15:53

Very approx:

You put in a deposit of £152K = 46.48%
46.48% of £710K = 330K

£330K equity + £100K investment = £430K

£27K to him

£710K sale - £155K mortgage - £430K to OP - £27K to ex = £98K to split

50% = £49K. So, to allow for £7K to ex, £42K to OP and £56K to ex

So, OP: 430 + 42 = £472K
Ex: £27K + £56K = £83K
Plus 155 to the bank

You could adjust this for the 70/30 split on the balance.

Also, probably better to remove the 127 for renovations at the start.

I do think you need to protect your deposit in the form of taking 46.5pc of the equity before you consider any other splitting.

WhythefuxdidI · 16/08/2023 17:19

I make it £74,700 to him and £174,300 to you.

Value now-purchase price= uplift in value, so 710-327 =383K

Uplift in value- renovation costs= profit
383-(100+27) = 256K

I then took off the 7K you owe him, but actually, that's nothing to do with this house, so it could be done separately...the difference in amounts is shown below:

256-7= 249K

249K÷100 = 2.45K

2.49K × 70 = 174,300

2.49K×30 = 74,700

But, (and this is probably the corect way to deal with the 7K from another property) if you don't inc the 7K you owe him from the other house, both your shares of the equity are higher, so:

256K÷ 100 = 2.56K

2.56K × 70 = 179,200

2.56K × 30 = 76, 800

Then you'd need to pay him his other monies owed on top, so he would end up with:

76800 + 7000 = £83,800

HMW1906 · 16/08/2023 17:18

My maths isn’t great but I think it’s £101,000 profit so taking into consideration the amounts spent on renovations and what you owe ex I think you get £163,700, ex gets £64,300.

Parky04 · 16/08/2023 17:18

No idea, I only got a CSE grade 3 in maths!

winelove · 16/08/2023 17:16

Sale of house = 710,000
Less Mort )155k) = 550,000 pot

You extras
100,000 reno costs
152,000 original deposit
20,000 paying off mort
= 272,000

His extras
27,000 reno
7,000 reno
= 34,0000

550k pot

1st £278,000 to you
2nd £34,000 to him

Leaves £244,00 to be divided 70/30
Him: £73,200 + his £34k = 107,200
You: £170,800 + £272,000 = £442,800

Though I think you are being too generous. I would just give him the £34k

EeesandWhizz · 16/08/2023 17:15

Well I would say

710 - 155 remaining mortgage paid off leaves

555 cash, of which you paid 152 deposit + 100 renovations and he paid 27, so you both get your money back leaving

276 to split 70:30, so

193.2 you and 82.8 him

then you pay him the 7 debt leaving

you with £186,200
him with £ 89,800

Is there a prize for the winning answer?

BadNomad · 16/08/2023 17:15

I would just give him back the £34k for the renovations. You don't owe him for the work he put in any more than he owes you for any cooking/cleaning you did for him.

Yalta · 16/08/2023 17:12

Sold price is 710000
your equity in the house money through deposit and mortgage payments is the £172000
you then put in another £100000
So you get the first £272000

He gets back his £27000

And the mortgage company get their. £155000

so in total you have to split the remaining £256000 70/30

So you get £179200 and he gets £76800 profit

you walk away with your equity £172000, the £100,000 you put in for renovations and your 70% of the profit £179200 less £7000 that you owe him = £444200

He walks away with his £27000 and
30% of the profit £76800 plus the £7000 you owe him. = £110800

and the mortgage company are repaid their £155000

Cosycardigans · 16/08/2023 17:07

I would also subtract all interest you've paid on the mortgage and will be roughly paying on the rest, from the total profit before splitting it

Silvers11 · 16/08/2023 17:04

The house cost £327K and it was sold for £710K. .

Your equity when you bought it ( your deposit) was £152K You still owe £155K on the Mortgage, so that needs to come off. Available cash is now down to £710K - £152K ( not profit) and minus the £155k to pay off the Mortgage. Now down to £403K

You owe your ex £7k as well, so that comes off the £403K - which leaves £396K

70% = £277,200 and 30% is £118,800

You get £277200 plus your deposit of £152K = £429200

Your ex gets £125,800

This ignores the money you both put in on renovations, which seems slightly fairer if you were both together when the renovations were done. Not clear about the money you owe your ex and whether the money owed is part of the £27k he put in on renovations, in which case it may not be payable either

If it was me, this is the one that I would consider as fair.

Silvers11 · 16/08/2023 16:56

Silvers11 · 16/08/2023 16:38

There are different ways to work this out though - but this is one

OK - you bought the house for £327K - but £175K was a mortgage, so the equity you had at that point ( your deposit) was £152k. You also spent 100K on renovations, which may or may not have contributed to the current value of the house. You have also paid off £20k of the Mortgage since you bought it. Your input to the EQUITY in the house is therefore £152K + 100K +20k = 272K.

Your Partner paid 27K for renovations - so that is his input to the equity

You sold the House for £710K - but you still owe £155k on the mortgage, so once that is paid off the available actual cash is 710k-155k = £555K

Your Equity is £272K. Your partners is 27K. The two together is 299K

The amount left to be divided as profit is £555K - £299K = £256K

70% is £179,200 and 30% is £76,800

So you should get £179,200 + £272,000 = £451,200

Your OH should get £76,800 + £27000 = £103,800

But as I say, there are other ways of looking at this - will post another calculation shortly

I forgot the £7k you owe your ex - so the totals above should be £7k less for you = £444K and your partner gets £7k more = £110, 800

Takoneko · 16/08/2023 16:49

Loloj · 16/08/2023 16:29

I don’t think so.
The £27k he put in and the and the £100k OP put in for renovations have to be taken off

£710k selling price - £327k = £383k Is price difference in property from then to now
minus renovations of £100k (OP’s cost)
minus renovations of £27k (exDP cost)
= £256k profit.

The £256k profit split 70/30 is £179.2k for OP and £76.8k for exDP. OP can pay him the £7k owed on top.

This doesn’t take into account who was paying mortgage. Nor does it take into account stamp duty and estate agent fees if when the house was bought/ being sold. But if a 70/30 split on profit is agreed as fair then this is how I would calculate it.

Its interesting that this comes out so close to the figure I reached when method feels so different.

What about the 155k that the bank is owed?

I’m also not sure why the 127k gets deducted from the profit calculations. If they aren’t part of the profit then each investor should get back their original investment before calculating profit, surely? By taking it out of the profit calculation you are awarding all of it to the OP even though she only made 100k of the 127k investment.

I think either, you take it from the profit and give each person what they put in and split what’s left 70/30 after deducting that and the OP’s 46% equity and the 155k mortgage. Or both parties write off their investment, include the 127k in the profit calculations and split that (again minus the remaining mortgage and OP’s equity) 70/30. Both of these give similar figures of just over 80k to the ex so it makes little real difference in the end.

JudgeRudy · 16/08/2023 16:48

Current value is 710, was 327 so appreciation is 710-327=383
Out of that youre 'owed' 100 from your input (renovations/fees) and he's owed 27+7 = 34, so 383- 100(yours)- 34(his) = 249 net profit.
Your mortgage is your affair as is any borrowing he has.
You get 70% of net profit which is 249 × .7= 174.3 k plus your owed 100 is 274.3
He gets 30%, so 249 x .3 = 74.7
Plus the 27 and 7 =108.70

274.3 + 108.7 = 383
Offer him 100k

I don't think you can include the owed mortgage any more than you can include any loans he had (or interest you owe) for the renovations he did/payed for or was owed.
No idea where your 30/70 figures came from but that's what I'd go with.

mirax · 16/08/2023 16:48

LemonTT · 16/08/2023 15:49

I think you need to see a solicitor and take advice on what you should give him and on what basis.

There is a risk that you are acknowledging he has a claim to the property and unless that is specifically defined you might the giving him justification to pursue more.

The only sensible advice so far. Op, you are in danger of giving away far too much!

tt9 · 16/08/2023 16:47

let me see..
so you put in deposit of 152 + spent 100 on renovations.
he spent 27 + you owe him 7

if profit = 710 - (327+127) = 256

if you split that 70:30 --> 179200 to you 76800 (+7k) to your ex DP

but I think this is unfair to you unless he has been paying all the bills and helping with mortgage

more fair would be: you give him 34,000 and tell him to go away. he lived in your house rent free. and now he wants money as well. amazing

Swipe left for the next trending thread