Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Waiting to have children

243 replies

puffincarpet · 16/08/2023 11:47

This is more of a question of opinion than an AIBU.

Women have a lot of plates to spin these days, balancing career, social life, family life, children. It's a lot, and women do bear the brunt of it all. Something has to slip for women, it doesn't usually for men. It is very challenging as often if you want to have children, your career does need to hit pause for a few years, or you battle on through and try and spin both plates at once (which can happen, but is tough). I wanted to open up with this because I am not criticising women that choose to wait to have children for any reason, whether they don't want kids yet, want to wait until they are older for career reasons, whether it is down to finances, support networks, childcare, whatever.

I think it is now more of a societal belief that having children below 30 is young. Not medically, just within society. So many people wait until they are 30+, going in to mid 30s, because they are told they are young. I am 30, expecting a baby, and being told I am a "young mum".

AIBU in thinking that people need to also take in to consideration the risks associated with becoming pregnant 35+ (including higher miscarriage risk, birth defect risk), as well as thinking about what happens if you don't get pregnant very easily?
TTC isn't a lightening quick process, it can take a while, and if you have complications or require fertility support, you might have a bit of a lengthy timeline ahead and at that age your body clock is ticking, whether we like it or not. I do know a few women that waited until they were in their mid 30s to start trying, because they felt like it was "the done thing nowadays", and in short they said they regret waiting as long as they did.

This is just an opinion thread. Ultimately it is up to every women what age they do want children, don't want children, there are so many things to consider including finances, support, and so on...but should people have more of an awareness of the full picture and possibilities, rather than society painting a picture of under 30s being young mums?

FWIW, the reason I am thinking about this this morning is that know of people that aren't planning on trying for children until they are in their mid - late thirties purely because they feel like they'd be classed as a young mum if they had children now. No other contributing factors, they have said they can afford a child, aren't bothered about taking time away from work. Want to be a mum, but don't want to be seen as a young mum. They're very open about this belief on social media too.

OP posts:
SouthLondonMum22 · 17/08/2023 14:09

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Why would we want to go back to how things were 40-50 years ago? Especially for women.

There's a reason why we've moved on from that. There's also the fact that things are so much more expensive now too.

Wolfparty · 17/08/2023 14:06

40/50 years ago most women were done breeding my age 30

Presumably only those with reliable contraception?

Roselee1 · 17/08/2023 14:02

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

puffincarpet · 17/08/2023 12:17

*Is it a middle class catchment area ?

I know DH cousin had her only at 41 - thing still weren't great set up - her Mum told my MIL family members had been really off with her being such an old mother but DH workplace ( mostly middle class ) women are regularly 38-43 age range and live in areas were that's normal.*

No it isn't, to be honest there are a lot of social housing properties nearby. Ours is ex-council (hasn't been council since the 90s I think, when everyone was allowed to buy them).

My favourite part is the OP calling you out on this, despite the fact you're actually on the same side of this argument!

This isn't an argument and I'm not calling anyone out on anything. This was an open discussion of opinion. I didn't know if the PP was replying to me or somebody else, I was simply sharing that a household income of £850 per month isn't enough to get by. At no point have I said on this thread "are you struggling and living month to month?? Well buckle up buttercup because you need to have a child NOW and make it work" as so many people seem to be assuming.

OP posts:
Hubblebubble · 17/08/2023 11:35

@Possimpible I know its not typical. I got really lucky in that I nabbed one of the fully remote jobs post covid and live in a part of the UK with very cheap houses. More so than national average. Sadly things are shifting to hybrid only, so many won't have this opportunity

Hubblebubble · 17/08/2023 11:32

@Possimpible under 30 and a single parent

Possimpible · 17/08/2023 11:05

Hubblebubble · 17/08/2023 10:48

@Possimpible I live a decent life on one income with one child, no UC because of my savings. But I work full time and own my own house outright.

That's nice for you, are you also under 30 and supporting a non-working partner too? As that's what we're talking about. If so, again well done, but that's not really typical. You've likely either got a huge salary, have had help from parents, or a large inheritance.

Re the other discussion going on, just because other parents at drop-off look 40+ doesn't mean they were older parents than average. They could have been first time parents at 31, onto their second child at 36, and dropping them off for year 1 at 41!

MeadAndPie · 17/08/2023 10:51

puffincarpet · 17/08/2023 08:48

where do you live? the average age of a FTP is still the low 30s so it's odd that the majority of your peers are 40 plus.

Cornwall

Is it a middle class catchment area ?

I know DH cousin had her only at 41 - thing still weren't great set up - her Mum told my MIL family members had been really off with her being such an old mother but DH workplace ( mostly middle class ) women are regularly 38-43 age range and live in areas were that's normal.

Hubblebubble · 17/08/2023 10:48

@Possimpible I live a decent life on one income with one child, no UC because of my savings. But I work full time and own my own house outright.

Possimpible · 17/08/2023 10:44

Goldencup · 17/08/2023 08:48

£850 for 2 adults and a baby should be doable no ?
I think you would also get CHB at this income point, maybe some UC- I am not sure.
Utilities what £200 ?
I would think food £350-400
So that leaves £200-250 for spends, of course you would need to be careful, free church baby groups and council swimming pool. Maybe 2nd hand clothes ( we were given loads) our cot was handed down, I was lucky my parents bought me the pram. A coffee out was a once a week treat, I took sandwiches everywhere.

Back in my day we walked 10 miles to school, uphill both ways... I'm surprised to see you actually would be entitled to child benefit and UC at this wage level - about £300 a month at a very rough calculation. (Assuming no savings which isn't a position I'd ever want to be in). Which would cover your council tax, a bill you conveniently forgot to consider. You also forgot home insurance, life insurance/critical illness, internet, TV licence, mobile phone bill (maybe not an essential 20 years ago but it is now), car payment/public transport for the working partner to get to work. Even a council swim is £5. It may be 'doable' (I doubt it) but it's not a life I'd want to live, counting every penny, no holidays, no days out, not even Netflix. Grim. My favourite part is the OP calling you out on this, despite the fact you're actually on the same side of this argument!

But anyway, I digress. The point is, living a decent lifestyle on one income is not really possible these days.

PartingGift · 17/08/2023 09:35

You've been lucky OP. Good for you.

I didn't meet my DH until I was 29. No way I would have had a baby with him, or anyone, after less than a year.

SallyWD · 17/08/2023 09:34

I had my first at 35 but would happily have had children in my 20s. I really wanted to in fact. However, life didn't work out that way. I had one relationship in my 20s which I realised afterwards wasn't healthy and it didn't work out.
I met DH when I was nearly 30. He was younger. It took 5 years for us to be in a place where he'd agree to having children. It all worked out in the end but I didn't actively want or choose to start my family at 35.
People always say women are delaying motherhood because they want to establish careers and be financially secure. I'm sure many do and I'm sure that's sensible. However, I know quite a few women who would love to have children, who've reached their late 30s and 40s and not had them. In every single case it's nothing to do with careers but the fact they haven't found the right man. They've had relationships but realised their partners either don't want children or wouldn't be good fathers. I've seen relationships break down and they've tried to find suitable men in their 30s to have a family with. Often they don't! I have a friend now who's 43, still trying to find a man to father her children. Most of these women don't want to do it alone with a sperm donor.
I don't like the notion that all women are choosing to delay motherhood to late 30s or 40s when I've seen so many women who would have loved to have children earlier.

DisquietintheRanks · 17/08/2023 09:11

If considering "all the possibilities" includes thinking about what life might be like breeding with someone unsuitable and with precarious finances/housing then yes, absolutely.

lovewoola · 17/08/2023 08:58

Cornwall

the "oldest" places are London eg Kensington & Chelsea so that's definitely unusual.

puffincarpet · 17/08/2023 08:52

£850 for 2 adults and a baby should be doable no ?
I think you would also get CHB at this income point, maybe some UC- I am not sure.
Utilities what £200 ?
I would think food £350-400
So that leaves £200-250 for spends, of course you would need to be careful, free church baby groups and council swimming pool. Maybe 2nd hand clothes ( we were given loads) our cot was handed down, I was lucky my parents bought me the pram. A coffee out was a once a week treat, I took sandwiches everywhere.

I'm not sure who this is in response to but most rental prices for a 2 or 3 bed property are around 1k per month in my area minimum, if you have a mortgage it is lower but still somewhere around £700 - £900 depending on who you have your mortgage with. Utilities for the average household at the moment are somewhere like £200 - £300 I think.
These days £850 a month wouldn't even touch the sides. There's also petrol, car insurance and MOT, tax, etc. We have horrendous public transport services so having a car is essential, although it is better in other parts of the country.
Council tax for our band is £160 per month.

OP posts:
puffincarpet · 17/08/2023 08:48

where do you live? the average age of a FTP is still the low 30s so it's odd that the majority of your peers are 40 plus.

Cornwall

OP posts:
Goldencup · 17/08/2023 08:48

£850 for 2 adults and a baby should be doable no ?
I think you would also get CHB at this income point, maybe some UC- I am not sure.
Utilities what £200 ?
I would think food £350-400
So that leaves £200-250 for spends, of course you would need to be careful, free church baby groups and council swimming pool. Maybe 2nd hand clothes ( we were given loads) our cot was handed down, I was lucky my parents bought me the pram. A coffee out was a once a week treat, I took sandwiches everywhere.

lovewoola · 17/08/2023 08:38

@puffincarpet where do you live? the average age of a FTP is still the low 30s so it's odd that the majority of your peers are 40 plus.

puffincarpet · 17/08/2023 08:34

For what it's worth I really don't think I'm a young Mum. I think having two children around 30 (or even one) is pretty standard. That's why it surprises me that I have been described as a young Mum...because 30 isn't young!

OP posts:
puffincarpet · 17/08/2023 08:33

Although since she started school I have noticed I am one of the youngest parents at drop off, that was quite surprising as I feel quite old now at 33

Yes I'm one of the younger parents at drop off too and I've always been surprised by it, most are 40+

OP posts:
Possimpible · 17/08/2023 08:10

Goldencup · 17/08/2023 07:47

My DB has just bought a 3 bedroom house for £180K in the NW it is possible.

£180k with a 10% deposit would be over 1k a month mortgage alone. Average salary would leave you with approx 1k left over (depending on where you live and if you contribute to a pension, could be £850). We could not live on one salary on this mortgage. Council tax, bills, food, dog food would wipe this out before we had any enjoyment in life. Maybe people who really want kids are willing to make this sacrifice. Lots of us aren't

Panda89 · 17/08/2023 08:03

I was 26 and DH was 23 when we had our DD. I’ve never been referred to as a young mum, and don’t consider myself one.

Although since she started school I have noticed I am one of the youngest parents at drop off, that was quite surprising as I feel quite old now at 33 😂

littleboymama · 17/08/2023 07:56

I can’t understand this obsession with worrying about when other people decide/can to have children.

There is always the “I’m so glad I had my child at 16 and can live my best life as my children will be teenagers when I’m 30 so I can enjoy myself” or “I’m so glad I had my children at 35 because I was financially secure and enjoyed my teenage years.

I think everyone’s circumstances are so different and most people (not all) will be glad that they had their children when they did because that’s their individual experience.

Also it’s not very black and white either, I had losses in my mid 20’s (finally had my son at 27) whereas there are woman having children at 40 plus who have never had a miscarriage.

At 27 I was the youngest in my antenatal group, but I still wouldn’t say 27 is a young mum. Not to offend you, but 30 is definitely not a young mum x

lovewoola · 17/08/2023 07:54

I think the ideal timing is to have your DCs when your parents have paid off their mortgage and/ or retired.

Lots of people don't live near their parents or their parents have health issues, I don't understand why the above should be the main factor? Certainly in my part of London I'm lucky to have parents close but it's because I'm a Londoner. Not to mention many in London are 1st gen immigrants so parents could be in another country.

lovewoola · 17/08/2023 07:49

@Goldencup more anecdotes, Im talking statistically & statistically it's got harder....

Swipe left for the next trending thread