Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU about DD's gym knicker "shorts"?

379 replies

RiderGirl · 16/08/2023 10:44

DD is just turned 13 and has taken to wearing "shorts" that I can only describe as looking like 1980's gym knickers in length, the literally sit in the crease of her buttocks. AIBU in saying that she isn't allowed to step outside the house wearing them? We keep falling out about it but I think they're wildly inappropriate!! To make it worse she wears them with a large t shirt and it just looks like she's in a t shirt and pants 🙈

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Mooshamoo · 17/08/2023 14:27

It IS to do with the amount of flesh that we expose.

If a woman shows her vulva and bottom , a man will get sexually aroused. That is biology.

Tabitha005 · 17/08/2023 14:03

DisquietintheRanks · 17/08/2023 13:42

No, I think its fine to require everyone above toddler age to keep their arse and genitals hidden.

Better get onto the fashion industry then 'cos they're churning out a hella lot of togs that don't conform. Consumer demand - whether driven by celebrity culture, media content, changing tastes, relaxing permissibility, sexual and identity politics or anything else - also needs the email, too.

I also think it's interesting that, at the same time as women and girls are choosing arse-baring, vulva-showcasing shorts, they're also reaching for the oversized baggy pants and jeans of the 1990s as well. My goddaughter and her friends will wear tiny shorts one day then TLC-style baggy cargo pants or roomy Evisu-style jeans with a little crop top or bralette under an oversized zip-up hoodie that must ALWAYS be worn off the shoulders as though it's about to slip off altogether.

I think young women are enjoying being able to choose whether to cover up or show some flesh in a way that wasn't necessarily 'in style' when I was in my teens - the late 80s were when Lycra was having its heyday and everything had to be close-fitting, although we did catch a break when Bros came on the scene and we all went crackers for baggy jeans, oversized white t-shirts and bomber jackets.

I think, to a certain extent, mainstream fashion is a bit less slavish to trends these days - in as much as I don't see one overriding, defining 'look' among young women now.... and maybe it's a bit 'blander', perhaps than I was enjoying in my teens but many of the young people I know don't go out to clubs and, if they do, the dress code is way more relaxed now. I guess the irony is that although 'fast fashion' exists, it's TOO fast to enable the evolvement of trends and styles that stick around for any length of time.

idebtiy · 17/08/2023 13:57

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines. Previously banned poster.

Dogsaresooomucheasier · 17/08/2023 13:50

I think if you fight it you’ll make the matter worse! Maybe point out you can see a spot on her bum or something if it troubles you that much 😂

Tabitha005 · 17/08/2023 13:48

@Jellycatspyjamas well, yeah, as the parent, you can obviously police your daughter's clothing choices so are you gonna chuck out the Nike Pros?

DisquietintheRanks · 17/08/2023 13:42

Tabitha005 · 17/08/2023 13:02

Well, quite, but that's exactly the point, isn't it? Because it is, indeed, MEN who 'can't control' themselves why should women change our habits and choices if our clothing makes not a snot of difference to the amount of violence and aggression metered out to us by males? What difference does it make if we're fully naked or covered from head to toe if we're going to be raped or sexually harrassed anyway? We may as well employ full agency to enjoy our sartorial choices in any case.

Why does it fall to us to cover up or ensure we're not showing more than the requisite amount of flesh if any at all? What length of shorts or skirt IS acceptable? I'm recalling here, those old photos from the early 20th century showing a man measuring the length of women's bathing costumes to ensure they weren't 'indecent'. That very word; 'indecent' has changed in meaning and shifted perspective constantly - what's permissible now would have got us hanged or drowned two hundred years ago - and still WOULD in some parts of the world. And clothing IS indivisible in those parts of the world from the woman wearing it. The very nature of some clothing being the entire reason women are even permitted out of the home. So, clothes are political and cultural and imbued by religious meaning and interpretation. Unfortunately, they are not 'just' clothes for a great many women.

There are plenty of men who find nuns insanely alluring and they're not showing any flesh whatsoever. I mean, if men can get all horny over a woman showing NO flesh then perhaps we should all be covered from head to toe all the time, right?

It's down to men to police and moderate their behaviours - their own AND those of their kin. It's down to women to wear whatever the fuck we like and not be subjugated by the oppressive patriarchial systems that would demonise any of us for the threads of cloth we choose to wear.

And ALL women have a part to play in this. By telling our daughters to cover aren't we effectively enabling and strengthening those patriarchal chains of bondage that get us labelled as 'sluts' or 'slags'? Those descriptors have NO male counterparts for the very good reason that men are not subjected to the same pressures of bodily shame that have been handed down to us generation after generation.

I read another thread on Mumsnet earlier where a poster said her own daughters had called her a 'slut'. Frankly, I'd be worrying way more about why young women are using that word at all than whether their shorts are 'too' short.

No, I think its fine to require everyone above toddler age to keep their arse and genitals hidden.

Jellycatspyjamas · 17/08/2023 13:31

Because it is, indeed, MEN who 'can't control' themselves why should women change our habits and choices if our clothing makes not a snot of difference to the amount of violence and aggression metered out to us by males?

The operative word there is “women”, we’re talking about children here - 12 and 13 year old girls. As a woman I can make an informed choice about what I wear, I can get myself out of tricky or threatening situations caused by those predatory men - I know what they look like, how they operate. My 12 year old daughter doesn’t, it’s not unreasonable to curb her clothing choices while she learns.

Premfove · 17/08/2023 13:27

YANBU. I'm working at a University campus this week and I'm 😳at what some young women are walking around in. At 13 I would be horrified. I'm no prude and am only early 30's but what on earth has happened in the past 5-10 years? Instagram has been very, very bad for young girls. On one hand I admire their confidence, I'm seeing girls of all shapes and sizes wearing shorts like that and pastel leggings with the outline of their vag and arse on full display - there's no way my friends and I would have felt able to do that regardless of our size, but on the other hand I find it a bit depressing that the sexualisation of girls seems to be getting worse and worse, despite feminist gains in other areas.

I'm hoping that by the time my daughter is 13 (six years or so) there will have been a backlash against this trashy trend. This insidious social media psyop that wearing revealing clothes is somehow "empowering" is bullshit anti-feminism IMO.

Tabitha005 · 17/08/2023 13:10

The above sentence was meant to read; "I mean, if men can get all horny over a woman showing NO flesh then perhaps we should all be UNCOVERED from head to toe all the time, right?'

Tabitha005 · 17/08/2023 13:02

Jellycatspyjamas · 17/08/2023 12:06

I'd be chastising myself for doing so because it's ALL connected to the way women have been harrassed, assaulted and even murdered for the clothes we wear and the amount of flesh we expose.

Women are harassed, assaulted and murdered because they are women, nothing to do with the amount of flesh we expose, that just provides a handy excuse for men who can’t control their sexualised aggression towards women and girls.

I don’t want my child to find herself in a situation she can’t handle, so I don’t let her wear revealing, sexualised clothes. There’s absolutely no reason for a child to be wearing form fitting, tight clothes revealing her arse and vulva, and I’m not about to allow her to be fodder for predatory men to gaze upon, at best.

Well, quite, but that's exactly the point, isn't it? Because it is, indeed, MEN who 'can't control' themselves why should women change our habits and choices if our clothing makes not a snot of difference to the amount of violence and aggression metered out to us by males? What difference does it make if we're fully naked or covered from head to toe if we're going to be raped or sexually harrassed anyway? We may as well employ full agency to enjoy our sartorial choices in any case.

Why does it fall to us to cover up or ensure we're not showing more than the requisite amount of flesh if any at all? What length of shorts or skirt IS acceptable? I'm recalling here, those old photos from the early 20th century showing a man measuring the length of women's bathing costumes to ensure they weren't 'indecent'. That very word; 'indecent' has changed in meaning and shifted perspective constantly - what's permissible now would have got us hanged or drowned two hundred years ago - and still WOULD in some parts of the world. And clothing IS indivisible in those parts of the world from the woman wearing it. The very nature of some clothing being the entire reason women are even permitted out of the home. So, clothes are political and cultural and imbued by religious meaning and interpretation. Unfortunately, they are not 'just' clothes for a great many women.

There are plenty of men who find nuns insanely alluring and they're not showing any flesh whatsoever. I mean, if men can get all horny over a woman showing NO flesh then perhaps we should all be covered from head to toe all the time, right?

It's down to men to police and moderate their behaviours - their own AND those of their kin. It's down to women to wear whatever the fuck we like and not be subjugated by the oppressive patriarchial systems that would demonise any of us for the threads of cloth we choose to wear.

And ALL women have a part to play in this. By telling our daughters to cover aren't we effectively enabling and strengthening those patriarchal chains of bondage that get us labelled as 'sluts' or 'slags'? Those descriptors have NO male counterparts for the very good reason that men are not subjected to the same pressures of bodily shame that have been handed down to us generation after generation.

I read another thread on Mumsnet earlier where a poster said her own daughters had called her a 'slut'. Frankly, I'd be worrying way more about why young women are using that word at all than whether their shorts are 'too' short.

Bbq1 · 17/08/2023 13:01

Back in the nineties i wore basques, tiny skirts, see through clothing and often underwear as outer wear...huge difference being I was early twenties then not 13.

Tabitha005 · 17/08/2023 12:31

@KimberleyClark - I wore VERY short skirts when I was a young teenager way back in the late 80s. I don't honestly see the difference. Remember Madonna videos in the 80s? Lots of girls, including me, were copying her look and wearing lacy underwear as 'clothing' - I remember being especially fond of a cream lace basque-style top that showed quite a lot of my burgeoning cleavage!

I think there's always a bit of the old 'do as I say, not as I do' that goes on between generations, and when I look back at photos of my mother and her incredibly short mini skirts and mini dresses in the 1960s, I'm really glad she never read me the riot act on what I was wearing in the 1980s or I'm quite sure I would have accused her of being a bit of a hypocrite!

manchesterbreak · 17/08/2023 12:17

@DisquietintheRanks she's wearing running shorts not a strap on. Do I think men wear tight fitting shorts.? Yes they do.

I'm not saying she should wear them in saying she's not the issue.

Disturbia81 · 17/08/2023 12:16

Wallywobbles · 17/08/2023 11:32

I've said to my teens are you sure you want to be wank fodder for old men. It does the trick as a rule.

Exactly

Jellycatspyjamas · 17/08/2023 12:06

I'd be chastising myself for doing so because it's ALL connected to the way women have been harrassed, assaulted and even murdered for the clothes we wear and the amount of flesh we expose.

Women are harassed, assaulted and murdered because they are women, nothing to do with the amount of flesh we expose, that just provides a handy excuse for men who can’t control their sexualised aggression towards women and girls.

I don’t want my child to find herself in a situation she can’t handle, so I don’t let her wear revealing, sexualised clothes. There’s absolutely no reason for a child to be wearing form fitting, tight clothes revealing her arse and vulva, and I’m not about to allow her to be fodder for predatory men to gaze upon, at best.

Lemieux7 · 17/08/2023 11:37

ASCCM · 17/08/2023 10:38

I don't let me daughters go out with their arse hanging out. I want them to have more respect for themselves and not look cheap and nasty. It's completely unnecessary. Step DD's mum gives zero fucks about her daughters looking like cheap chavs, but i make them change before we go out if i can see arse cheeks.

Wow. Where to even start with this??

Wallywobbles · 17/08/2023 11:32

I've said to my teens are you sure you want to be wank fodder for old men. It does the trick as a rule.

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 17/08/2023 11:14

TheaBrandt · 17/08/2023 06:58

We didn’t allow Dd to wear them but our ring doorbell informed us she had taken them with her and changed at a mates house. So “not allowing” a 14 year old to do something is easier said than done.

So did you call her, tell her you were on your way to pick her up, and remove any privileges as punishment?

KimberleyClark · 17/08/2023 10:46

Tabitha005 · 16/08/2023 11:30

Of all the things to consider, here, the male response is the least of them, in my view. It's not down to females to police what we wear because men can't control their own impulses to comment or leer at us.

Whilst I would agree that my own 'prejudice' towards young girls in very revealing clothing is also driven by thousands of years of patriarchial norms, I'm trying to change. Even as I would be tempted to tell my own daughter, if I even had kids, to wear something less revealing, I'd be chastising myself for doing so because it's ALL connected to the way women have been harrassed, assaulted and even murdered for the clothes we wear and the amount of flesh we expose.

There may also come a time when OP's daughter will feel very differently about her body as she ages so having the confidence and enjoyment of it now is a precious thing. OP, of course, can have their own opinion as her parent but I'd be mindful of the messages we send to young women over the clothing they wear because so much of it is driven by the subjugation of females as a response to the male gaze.

But don’t you think it’s sad that 13-14 year olds feel the need to wear such revealing clothing?

enchantedsquirrelwood · 17/08/2023 10:39

IhaveanewTVnow · 17/08/2023 08:07

irrelevant to this debate.

Why is it irrelevant? So if she goes for a run in them it's ok and no man is going to look at her, but if she wears them to walk it isn't?

There's a magical difference between running in them and walking in them?

I don't know if I saw the wrong thing, but they said Nike pro and I've since looked them up and I really can't see the issue. But then I do lots of exercise and see lots of women (and girls) in short and longer shorts as well as leggings so it's normal for me. Admittedly I don't like the really clingy leggings in flesh colour as they make it look like you're not wearing anything at all but that's not what we are talking about here.

ASCCM · 17/08/2023 10:38

I don't let me daughters go out with their arse hanging out. I want them to have more respect for themselves and not look cheap and nasty. It's completely unnecessary. Step DD's mum gives zero fucks about her daughters looking like cheap chavs, but i make them change before we go out if i can see arse cheeks.

enchantedsquirrelwood · 17/08/2023 10:35

AlfietheSchnauzer · 16/08/2023 18:00

No OP, I would not (and will not) allow my DD to go outside dressed like a prostitute

Gym shorts really don't make you look like a prostitute!

CoffeeWithCheese · 17/08/2023 09:50

Difference between male and female clothing standards?! I was on the tram at the weekend and there was a guy who sat opposite me and DH, manspreading to fuck so the fabric around his shorts legs was really splayed out around his crotch and because of how short and baggy the shorts were - you could see his fucking ballsack hanging out of the side of his pants. He clearly gave zero fucks. Or all the blokes walking around topless the second the sun appears at all - and never particularly prime specimens of male physique either. Difference is that society isn't poised to jump on men who cross some kind of arbitrary morality line in the same way it is with women.

So don't try to paint men as some kind of bastions of demure purity.

Summer in the UK will be over with in a few weeks anyway so I refuse to get het up about girls wearing short shorts - the temperature and pissing rain will sort that out soon enough.

advicelast · 17/08/2023 09:11

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

DoraSpenlow · 17/08/2023 09:11

*see