Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

who is being unreasonable? new job and children

692 replies

interestingly8 · 16/08/2023 07:27

Would like to keep this unbiased if possible.

Sarah and Ben have two children together and are separated. Ben is now married to Claire (B&C also now have young children of their own).

S&Bs children stay with B&C 2 nights one week and 3 the next currently. The week with 3 nights is over the weekend and the week with 2 is during the week.

Ben works, Claire is a SAHM and Sarah has been studying for the past number of years around her part time job.

Sarah has now qualified and is beginning a new job which will involve shift work meaning the her and Ben's children's normal contact schedule will need to change and follow Sarah's shift patterns rather than set days that they now have. This will inc upping contact to 3 nights every week whilst Sarah works. Ben is saying this is not possible as he's already arranged his work around the schedule they have had for years and cannot change this dependant on Sarah's shifts for that week. He has agreed to up contact to 3 nights per week but has said these must be set days.

Sarah has suggested Claire help if Ben is not around on one of the days, Claire has said no and agrees with Ben the contact schedule should remain the same as its what everyone has worked around for years Inc the children.

Who is being unreasonable?

Sarah for saying contact needs to follow her shifts instead of being set from now on and if Ben can't do that maybe Claire could help out. YANBU

Ben and Claire for insisting contact should follow the same schedule as normal and be set, not change week by week (although they do agree to up to 3 nights per week). YABU

OP posts:
jannier · 16/08/2023 20:38

1967buglet · 16/08/2023 15:56

I really disagree with this. She is involved. She is the stepmum.

You don’t marry someone with kids without the expectation that someday, you might have to parent those kids, or that parenting schedule could change. Things happen. It is not the same as marrying someone without children whatsover. what would happen if Ben died? Would his kids go into care because it is nothing to do with her?

If Ben died Claire would have no right to custody which would solely fall to Sarah she could try to fight for it. Sarah could also put the child into the care system.
Nobody has said that Claire does not parent the children....actually it says Ben has no childcare issue as Claire does it....but is it right for the children's mother to automatically assume Claire will also provide her free childcare. Why isn't Sarah looking at childcare options. What if Claire needs to go back to work is she supposed to put her needs and those of her household behind Sarah's?

jannier · 16/08/2023 20:31

1967buglet · 16/08/2023 15:42

She had a plan to take care of it. It didn’t work out. She needs some flexiblity for a while to get established. Things happen.

I suppose really, if it it so much trouble for Ben to do this, he can have the kids full time then and he and Claire can raise all the kids. Sarah can then get on with it and benefit from her education.

Claire married Ben knowing he had kids. People saying it isn’t her problem, well , it is. It is something all three have to figure out.

What was her plan to take care of it? Oh yes tell Ben his new wife is doing it......what happens if the new wife has her own plans for career or life? I'm fully if you take on a partner with children you take the children but not that the ex can then dump their agreed commitment on you. If you decide to have children some things are given up working nights when you're a single parent being one.

DrSbaitso · 16/08/2023 20:15

Shuggie1234 · 16/08/2023 20:14

So obvious OP is Sarah. You are unreasonable expectating step
mum to provide care when you are working and also to expect them to fit around different days every week.

So obvious OP is Sarah.

Yes, it would be hard to have missed that by now.

DrSbaitso · 16/08/2023 20:14

BadLad · 16/08/2023 20:13

Sometimes I read threads in Relationships where a couple is splitting up, and the wife wants never to speak to her husband again. Other posters say something like “You have children together - there’s no way you can avoid speaking to him altogether.”

And I always want to say “Well, there is one way”.

You may have spotted a gap in the market. Maybe this is Sarah's new job. It explains the unpredictable hours.

Shuggie1234 · 16/08/2023 20:14

So obvious OP is Sarah. You are unreasonable expectating step
mum to provide care when you are working and also to expect them to fit around different days every week.

BadLad · 16/08/2023 20:13

DrSbaitso · 16/08/2023 20:07

Well, that's one option.

Sometimes I read threads in Relationships where a couple is splitting up, and the wife wants never to speak to her husband again. Other posters say something like “You have children together - there’s no way you can avoid speaking to him altogether.”

And I always want to say “Well, there is one way”.

howshouldibehave · 16/08/2023 20:07

BadLad · 16/08/2023 20:03

The solution is from the Wise Woman in Blackadder the 2nd

😂

DrSbaitso · 16/08/2023 20:07

BadLad · 16/08/2023 20:03

The solution is from the Wise Woman in Blackadder the 2nd

Well, that's one option.

BadLad · 16/08/2023 20:03

Olive19741205 · 16/08/2023 19:28

And when it was pointed out that the kids would stay with their other parent...we had another death. 😂

The solution is from the Wise Woman in Blackadder the 2nd

Olive19741205 · 16/08/2023 19:28

BadLad · 16/08/2023 17:55

The “What if”s have expanded to Ben dying.

Wonder if anyone will actually suggest that as a solution.

And when it was pointed out that the kids would stay with their other parent...we had another death. 😂

MeetMyCat · 16/08/2023 18:35

BadLad · 16/08/2023 17:55

The “What if”s have expanded to Ben dying.

Wonder if anyone will actually suggest that as a solution.

But it’s Sarah’s shifts that are causing the problem … !!

BadLad · 16/08/2023 17:55

The “What if”s have expanded to Ben dying.

Wonder if anyone will actually suggest that as a solution.

Caprisunny · 16/08/2023 17:51

1967buglet · 16/08/2023 17:16

Child maintenance has nothing to do with visitation arrangements and custodial arrangements? I don’t buy that. I would think that if Ben made less, or Sarah made more, the custodial arrangements might be quite different, no?

No child maintenance is not linked to ‘visitation’. Not as in, if you don’t pay you have right to see the child.

Is linked to custodial arrangements, in a way.

It’s based on the non resident parents income. Their income. Not their partners. And how many nights they have the child.

No, custody arrangements wouldn’t be made differently if Ben made less and Sarah made more. It’s not the one with lowest income that gets the kids.

However often each of them have them would be up to them to decide between them and they can’t decide it can go to court. But the court doesn’t give the lowest earner custody.

notlucreziaborgia · 16/08/2023 17:32

1967buglet · 16/08/2023 17:29

And because people just accept things how they are, don’t think about it, and don’t give a s*, is why we have a poor maintenance system, children in poverty, and some real problems with misogyny. Do you not realise that the law at its highest level IS philosophy?

Of course, considering that my degree is in law and I worked in the field.

The law, at least in democratic societies, doesn’t seek to govern every aspect of a persons life. It seeks to strike a balance that best serves society as a whole whilst respecting individual freedom. People are free to lobby for change, but there’s a difference between that and lobbying petty diktats on mumsnet.

1967buglet · 16/08/2023 17:29

notlucreziaborgia · 16/08/2023 17:25

It really doesn’t matter whether you consider it illogical or not. You are of course free to consider it as illogical as you like, but that doesn’t make it any less the law.

if a non custodial parent doesn’t earn then they are not liable to pay maintenance.

As far as philosophical notions of right and wrong, should and shouldn’t go - within the law those are subjective judgements to be made by individuals. You can have lots of ideas as to what I should or shouldn’t be doing, for example, but I don’t consider myself philosophically obliged to give a shit.

And because people just accept things how they are, don’t think about it, and don’t give a s*, is why we have a poor maintenance system, children in poverty, and some real problems with misogyny. Do you not realise that the law at its highest level IS philosophy?

notlucreziaborgia · 16/08/2023 17:25

1967buglet · 16/08/2023 16:57

So basically once divorced, fathers are not responsible for their ex’s children if they don’t earn. I suppose one gambit can be to not earn for a year or two, hiding some assets, have it declared you don’t have to pay maintenance, and then moving away so you cannot be found. And we have the Daily Mail screaming about all those single mums on benefit whilst dad is no where to be seen.

And I said your logic, because the law is often illogical. Some have said the law is an ass. (not my quote…I think it was Charles Dickens, which considering he wrote about poverty seems somehow appropriate).

It really doesn’t matter whether you consider it illogical or not. You are of course free to consider it as illogical as you like, but that doesn’t make it any less the law.

if a non custodial parent doesn’t earn then they are not liable to pay maintenance.

As far as philosophical notions of right and wrong, should and shouldn’t go - within the law those are subjective judgements to be made by individuals. You can have lots of ideas as to what I should or shouldn’t be doing, for example, but I don’t consider myself philosophically obliged to give a shit.

Resilience · 16/08/2023 17:23

I don't think anyone is being unreasonable in this scenario to be honest. Everyone's perspective is reasonable for their own situation. The question is what level of compromise is reasonable on all sides to provide the most stability for the DC.

I no longer work shifts but I used to and they were different each week. However, it was a rolling shift pattern, so I always knew what shift would be on what day even if lates was Tuesday one week and Thursday the next. My shift pattern could be viewed 12 months in advance. If this is the case then I don't think it's unreasonable for Sarah to ask for some flexibility. Ben & Clare will know well in advance what days they're having the DC and can plan accordingly. If I were Ben that's what I'd do rather than ask Sarah to find a CM etc as I'd consider a home setting among family for my DC preferable. However, if Sarah doesn't know from one week to the next (e.g. the rota isn't decided until the start of each week), then that's clearly an unreasonable expectation.

All of which means nothing if it's not mutually agreed and upheld willingly. It would require high levels of organisation and communication to work well without the DC feeling pulled from pillar to post. If that's not a given, outsourcing or using a friend is the better (and less stressful) option.

Dixiechickonhols · 16/08/2023 17:21

It seems likely that Claire will be going back to work. Op says she has a career. The children are only 1 and 3 she might still be on mat leave for all Sarah knows eg if she’s tacked on annual leave.

1967buglet · 16/08/2023 17:16

Caprisunny · 16/08/2023 17:00

Yes non resident parents can and do avoid paying maintenance.

Yes we know that a lot of the time things that ‘single mum households’ are blamed for are actually the daily of an absent parent.

Yes child maintenance is a flawed system. That’s not the issue. It has nothing to do with this issue.

Child maintenance has nothing to do with visitation arrangements and custodial arrangements? I don’t buy that. I would think that if Ben made less, or Sarah made more, the custodial arrangements might be quite different, no?

rookiemere · 16/08/2023 17:12

sweeneytoddsrazor · 16/08/2023 17:08

Maybe the traumatised children of divorced dead parents who died in two separate incidents (unless it was in a violent fight about contact arrangements)

I suppose a duel at dawn to sort out flexibility might possibly result in the death of both parents.

Grin
1967buglet · 16/08/2023 17:11

spitefulandbadgrammar · 16/08/2023 16:49

Maybe the traumatised children of divorced dead parents who died in two separate incidents (unless it was in a violent fight about contact arrangements) might choose to live with a relative and not their former stepmother and two half siblings whose needs at 18 months and 3 are wildly incompatible with their own, and maybe also random speculation about the OP and the father of her children both dying doesn’t actually help her to figure all this out?

I said upthread that Ben should be more flexible as Sarah did something to improve her lot and those of her children (and Ben too), and was very surprised at the response.

You can talk about singular situations and their solutions, but behind the proffered solutions on the forum are social norms/philosophical warrants. Sometimes teasing those out and confronting them and even challenging them when they are unhelpful helps us make better decisions.

sweeneytoddsrazor · 16/08/2023 17:08

Maybe the traumatised children of divorced dead parents who died in two separate incidents (unless it was in a violent fight about contact arrangements)

I suppose a duel at dawn to sort out flexibility might possibly result in the death of both parents.

Caprisunny · 16/08/2023 17:00

1967buglet · 16/08/2023 16:57

So basically once divorced, fathers are not responsible for their ex’s children if they don’t earn. I suppose one gambit can be to not earn for a year or two, hiding some assets, have it declared you don’t have to pay maintenance, and then moving away so you cannot be found. And we have the Daily Mail screaming about all those single mums on benefit whilst dad is no where to be seen.

And I said your logic, because the law is often illogical. Some have said the law is an ass. (not my quote…I think it was Charles Dickens, which considering he wrote about poverty seems somehow appropriate).

Yes non resident parents can and do avoid paying maintenance.

Yes we know that a lot of the time things that ‘single mum households’ are blamed for are actually the daily of an absent parent.

Yes child maintenance is a flawed system. That’s not the issue. It has nothing to do with this issue.

1967buglet · 16/08/2023 17:00

yogasaurus · 16/08/2023 16:47

Yes, that is exactly what would happen in the UK. Are you not familiar with the maintenance process in the UK? You would be awarded a nominal amount if the NRP claimed benefits

‘social norms’.. more theorising. Odd that someone who chose ‘not to parent’ as ‘it sounded very hard, relentless work and very expensive’ is giving SP’s such a hard time, fairly hypocritical.

Yes, I chose not to parent because I had to raise my brother from the age of 11. My mother was chronically ill and in and out of hospital. I watched my father work 60 hour weeks paying hospital bills (in the States), and trying to cope. It is very expensive, and it is hard relentless work. Are you satisfied now?

1967buglet · 16/08/2023 16:57

notlucreziaborgia · 16/08/2023 16:44

Correct. If he claimed benefits he would pay a nominal amount from those, but if he didn’t claim then he wouldn’t be liable to pay maintenance.

isn’t ‘her logic’ by the way, it’s the actual law.

So basically once divorced, fathers are not responsible for their ex’s children if they don’t earn. I suppose one gambit can be to not earn for a year or two, hiding some assets, have it declared you don’t have to pay maintenance, and then moving away so you cannot be found. And we have the Daily Mail screaming about all those single mums on benefit whilst dad is no where to be seen.

And I said your logic, because the law is often illogical. Some have said the law is an ass. (not my quote…I think it was Charles Dickens, which considering he wrote about poverty seems somehow appropriate).