Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

who is being unreasonable? new job and children

692 replies

interestingly8 · 16/08/2023 07:27

Would like to keep this unbiased if possible.

Sarah and Ben have two children together and are separated. Ben is now married to Claire (B&C also now have young children of their own).

S&Bs children stay with B&C 2 nights one week and 3 the next currently. The week with 3 nights is over the weekend and the week with 2 is during the week.

Ben works, Claire is a SAHM and Sarah has been studying for the past number of years around her part time job.

Sarah has now qualified and is beginning a new job which will involve shift work meaning the her and Ben's children's normal contact schedule will need to change and follow Sarah's shift patterns rather than set days that they now have. This will inc upping contact to 3 nights every week whilst Sarah works. Ben is saying this is not possible as he's already arranged his work around the schedule they have had for years and cannot change this dependant on Sarah's shifts for that week. He has agreed to up contact to 3 nights per week but has said these must be set days.

Sarah has suggested Claire help if Ben is not around on one of the days, Claire has said no and agrees with Ben the contact schedule should remain the same as its what everyone has worked around for years Inc the children.

Who is being unreasonable?

Sarah for saying contact needs to follow her shifts instead of being set from now on and if Ben can't do that maybe Claire could help out. YANBU

Ben and Claire for insisting contact should follow the same schedule as normal and be set, not change week by week (although they do agree to up to 3 nights per week). YABU

OP posts:
babbscrabbs · 18/08/2023 16:47

I'm afraid you are U - if I were Claire I wouldn't want to have to chop and change my plans week from week to accommodate my stepkids either.

rmdbsmummy · 18/08/2023 16:46

You choose to marry and have children with someone who already has children then your choosing to take said children on as your own unless you plan on being a wicked stepmother

Mostlyoblivious · 18/08/2023 16:44

You need to get a firmer working pattern. Assuming you’re NHS then perhaps start with bank work so you have a bit more control over the days or approach your new employer and make the request.
I see why you may think your ex H is being frustrating (probably mixed in with other times he has been frustrating) but he has a point - the children need some stability and one job shouldn’t but 6 people (not including yourself) into a state of flux.

rmdbsmummy · 18/08/2023 16:43

Does that mean seeing as she has them the majority of the time that dad is going to cough up towards childcare fees?

rmdbsmummy · 18/08/2023 16:41

Finally a sensible rather than spiteful reply!

rmdbsmummy · 18/08/2023 16:39

But then people slate women who are unable to work a job around childcare and manage in a one income household. On top of this the father and his new Mrs are treating the kids as an inconvenience separate to the family when in actual fact the kids should have the same right to be with their father and by extension their stepparent as the father and stepparents kids do

Backagain23 · 18/08/2023 16:25

Well this is a peach of a thread.
Team Claire all the way. I'd not be tying the lives of my children to a string being pulled by my husband's ex's manager either. No chance.
OP has decided that unpredictable shifts are fine and dandy for her older children to work around but she doesn't get to make that decision for another woman's very young children.
Ben has said he will have the kids more but it's unreasonable to expect everyone else's lives to revolve around the circus OP has chosen for herself.

BarbieWorldFantastic · 18/08/2023 16:00

Julietta05 · 18/08/2023 15:17

I think this type of a problem is not for AIBU vote. It is really complex issue. Some people will consider it only from the perspective of Sarah, some from perspective of children.
I can totally understand Sarah, who studied and spent number of years achieving qualifications. Possibly she even made that decision when she was with Ben, so it was almost their decision to go down that path. I also understand that there are professions where there is no flexibility and when you start you need to follow the shift pattern (one being police officer). So now Sarah may feel stuck, possibly with the student loan debt and no prospect of development. I think that requires careful consideration as oppose to mumsnet bias judgement. There is no right or wrong here.

Sarah literally said she started doing it when she had a different fiancé and he was going to support her.
It was nothing to do with Ben.

Northernladdette · 18/08/2023 15:26

It’s Claire I feel sorry for, no one knows how to spell her name 😂

Julietta05 · 18/08/2023 15:17

I think this type of a problem is not for AIBU vote. It is really complex issue. Some people will consider it only from the perspective of Sarah, some from perspective of children.
I can totally understand Sarah, who studied and spent number of years achieving qualifications. Possibly she even made that decision when she was with Ben, so it was almost their decision to go down that path. I also understand that there are professions where there is no flexibility and when you start you need to follow the shift pattern (one being police officer). So now Sarah may feel stuck, possibly with the student loan debt and no prospect of development. I think that requires careful consideration as oppose to mumsnet bias judgement. There is no right or wrong here.

aSofaNearYou · 18/08/2023 15:09

Sarah as being unreasonable. And this thread has been a doozy for unreasonable expectations of step parents from a few familiar posters 🤣

Tiredhotmess · 18/08/2023 15:08

I think Sarah is being unreasonable and really should have thought about this before taking on the new job. Ben and Claire have offered a compromise of having the children for 3 nights every week; it is not Claire's responsibility to look after Sarah's children on her own when Ben is working, especially when she has young children of her own to look after too. Sarah needs to find alternative childcare on the days/nights that Ben is unavailable.

Imisssleep2 · 18/08/2023 15:02

Ps I don't think Claire should be expected to take some care for children that aren't hers when she has her own as well. I would say no in her shoes too

Imisssleep2 · 18/08/2023 15:01

I think it's unreasonable to expect at least 4 other people (plus b and c children) to panda to your work schedule. Take them up on the offer of a third night, but if it doesn fit with sarahs work schedule it is down to sarah to sort other arrangements, ie a babysitter or other family.

Your children shouldn't have to have their routine disrupted every week either tbh.

Str3bor · 18/08/2023 14:58

Haven’t read all the posts yet but my ex works shifts so I have to work around him and it pisses me off big time as he only has the kids on his days off but I have to sort childcare for when I go to work. I also have 2 weekends on the run without the kids and then 6 weeks until the next kid free weekend. It’s a nightmare to plan anything and the kids don’t know if they are coming or going.

that being said I put up with it because I want the kids to have a relationship with their dad, wether it’s convenient for me or not I believe it’s the best thing for them. They go to their dads to spend time with him and I don’t see the point in them having set days and he’s in work/nights and they have to stay at GP’s. I would rather they just be with me and then see their dad on his days off. Would just be nice if he helped out a bit in the 6 weeks holidays and had them a bit more.

Lorey82 · 18/08/2023 14:58

It sounds difficult for both parties, the best solution would be for Sarah to work 24/30 hours a week (probably 2-3 shifts if NHS) and apply for them to be on set days (which thankfully NHS seem much more amenable to these days) and then perhaps for Claire to help out in the mean time. To be honest very much doubt Sarah’s overall net income will end up much different whether she does 24 or 37 hours a week, especially once UC, deductions, etc taken into account but will make sorting out childcare so much easier

Flufferz · 18/08/2023 14:41

As a shift worker I know how hard shift work is around childcare. Ultimately I changed jobs to a Monday to Friday 9/5 loosing 32% of my income and then having to fork out nursery costs. It’s not great but i had to.

Expecting B&C to not be able to plan anything, ever because of your shifts is totally unreasonable.

I don’t think you were unreasonable to ask C, but she is not unreasonable saying know. There is a big difference in the children’s ages so they would not just all occupy each other and C wouldn’t want to be limited by school times.

For colleagues I know who work shifts and juggle childcare use a mixture of the following: Before and after school clubs, child minders, nannys, grandparents and annual leave for days they are really stuck.

If you have set days the kids are with B&C say Sun, Mon, Tues, that leaves you 3 week days for a child minder/nanny. Saturday would be more difficult maybe a grandparent but if not see if Saturday could be a non working day every week.

Make a flexiable working request for example that you work every Sunday but no Saturdays. You only work early or late shifts so you only need childcare one end of the day. You only work nights on the nights kids are with B.

BarbieWorldFantastic · 18/08/2023 14:35

stichguru · 18/08/2023 14:28

The two parents of the children need to sort this out. If Ben and Sarah were still together then one of 4 things would need to happen:

  1. Ben would have to negotiate flexible working around Sarah's changing shifts
  2. Sarah would have to arrange her shifts around Ben's work
  3. They would have to pay for childcare at times both of them would be working
  4. One of them would have to change jobs to fit better with childcare availability.

Frankly, the fact they are separated doesn't change any of this. They have kids together they have to work together to make it work!

Frankly it changes everything that they are separated.
He now has another wife and 2 other kids to also think about.
Sarah should of thought a bit harder about how she was going to negotiate childcare doing shift work.
Ben is now doing 6/14 days ….. 1 day off 50:50.
Sarahs shifts are her problem.

stichguru · 18/08/2023 14:28

The two parents of the children need to sort this out. If Ben and Sarah were still together then one of 4 things would need to happen:

  1. Ben would have to negotiate flexible working around Sarah's changing shifts
  2. Sarah would have to arrange her shifts around Ben's work
  3. They would have to pay for childcare at times both of them would be working
  4. One of them would have to change jobs to fit better with childcare availability.

Frankly, the fact they are separated doesn't change any of this. They have kids together they have to work together to make it work!

MrsB74 · 18/08/2023 14:06

I haven’t read the whole thread, but would say that I completely understand Sarah asking her ex and partner to help because that was the obvious solution. I’m a step mum and would have (and did) helped if I could. That said, if they can’t adjust their schedules, then she’ll have to sort other childcare. No amount of arguing will change anything and just impact the children.

MichelleScarn · 18/08/2023 13:03

Sarah has clearly worked really hard to qualify for this new job that's going to improve her children's lives potentially and bring her joy and satisfaction. Well done Sarah. It would be great if B and C could be more accommodating.
So is the consensus that Ben who am assuming clearly worked hard when he was with Sarah, when she was a SAHM of her choosing, a 'shit dad' for doing so, and Sarah is now a wonderful person for 'working hard' and he's still a shit dad for not facilitating her choice this time?

MichelleScarn · 18/08/2023 12:53

Samlewis96 · 18/08/2023 12:17

Well Sarah could just send her kids to live with their father then it would be his problem.

That could work, at least then Ben and Claire could build a routine that wasnt ever changing, am familiar with the nightmare of shift work!
Would Sarah, Ben, Claire and of course the kids be happy with that?

SpinalFap12 · 18/08/2023 12:50

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

SpinalFap12 · 18/08/2023 12:42

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Samlewis96 · 18/08/2023 12:17

YouJustDoYou · 16/08/2023 07:36

This. Shift work is so, so tricky to work around when children are involved, and taking up a job with such unknown hours and expecting everyone else to work around that isn't viable.

Well Sarah could just send her kids to live with their father then it would be his problem.

Swipe left for the next trending thread