Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

People that go on about dieting and weight

89 replies

Catwiththecream · 16/08/2023 00:01

Aibu to think this is just a big social no no? Before I start it's worth me saying I am not on a diet. I'm a size 6 and for my height and activity level this is entirely sustainable. This post isn't about me just not wanting to hear about diets but rather and observation that generally this topic of conversation is awful. I have really noticed recently how depressing it is to be around people that constantly go on about dieting and who monitor food. Just the other day I was at one of my fiancées relatives houses for dinner and from the moment we stepped foot inside all conversations seemed to go back to weight and dieting. It started when I mentioned that I'd donated a lot of my old summer clothes this year and been wearing the same things over and over ( the conversation was about a bootfair me and fiancée did before starting to pack our stuff up to move house ). His relatives response was 'well you can at your size'. Fair enough, most would see this as a compliment I suppose and I'm not thin skinned enough to say this is a problem but what followed was 'it must take a lot of work though, we aren't eating lunch at the moment'. I never know what to say to these sort of conversations, especially as the 'we' she was referring to was her, her dh and her daughter ( adult ) living with them. It would be so rude of me to comment and also I'm there to have a nice time with them not give a shit about how many calories they're allowing themselves that week. So the conversation about bootfairs and clearing out cupboards had made its way to weight territory. Next was dinner, this time another guest discarded of the fat on their meat and made a point of mentioning it when it could have just been left on the side of their plate so everyone else eating could enjoy the meal, but no instead it was 'I had to cut the fat off! Way too much'. Again, what do you say to that? Dessert time we are all asked how much we want as the chocolate torte is being cut into slices, que the 'oh no that's way too big less please' comments whilst the tiniest, borderline insulting slither is cut of an indulgent but lovely cake someone has made about bought along. All night conversation naturally goes back to people's weight no matter how it starts...'saw Teresa today, she's doing well, you actually wouldn't recognise her'...and it doesn't end there. In my office today as we all eat lunch at our desks the conversation inevitably drifts onto what we're all eating, whether it's healthy, so and so has cut down on cheese, on the other side of the room we have someone just eating salad. I don't care what anyone eats or weighs, it's none of my business & I don't want to ever talk or hear about what people are eating either. I feel sorry for anyone trying to lose weight in the room when these conversations are bought up but it surprises me how common place they are. Aibu? Is it okay to talk about weight/fat/diets so much or does it just make everyone feel miserable and awkward like it does with me? How do you shut down the conversation or divert off it when it keeps going back there? It drives me mad!

OP posts:
WhisperingHi · 16/08/2023 09:46

I don't know. Isn't it 1) idle chit chat, the same way someone may go on about the gym (boring but harmless). Or 2) a symptom of society getting more and more unhealthy and trying to do something to help that (albeit diets often don't work in the long run).

I have a family member like this and it's dull and I do find myself rolling my eyes. But I'm not convinced it's about sex, I know men who don't stop going on about protein and the gym. It's the same stuff to me.

Vallmo47 · 16/08/2023 09:40

@UmbrellaSoldiers
Your post resonates with me SO much. That is exactly it.
FYI… you are beautiful and kick ass in every way.

Vallmo47 · 16/08/2023 09:35

I do agree that topic is like walking on little pebble stones surrounded by hot lava Op. I have worked my ass off and lost over 4 stone that I gained due to medication mainly. I’ve been everything between a size 8 and a size 18 in my life so seen judgment and comments both sides. When slim I wasn’t really allowed an opinion and had to walk on eggshells as to not offend others. When big, all of the talk constantly turned to how many calories was in this and that. It’s harder to be big than slim though trust me because you’re always on edge - you feel like you’re being watched, you couldn’t possibly ask for a decent slice of the cake (instead you go and buy it in secret afterwards and scoff the lot- that’s not everyone, but it was certainly me 😂). Slim people might be bored with the chat but at least they’re not walking around constantly feeling judged.
If I were you, I’d gently say “could we talk about something other than diets, we’re all beautiful and kick ass in every way. Let’s all have a day off!”
Granted, I understand this would come off a lot better from a bigger person. Maybe have a quiet word with one of them sometime and confide that you find diet and calorie talk triggering because you knew someone with an eating disorder once. See if that changes the situation.

Women simply cannot win- like someone else has said it seems to be the go to conversation as a common mutual most women struggle with.
Someone I know said I was the “worst type of person” for having lost 4 stone and kept it off - because what’s her excuse when I have a thyroid disorder and mental health issues? If I can lose the weight she literally has no excuse!
Needless to say I don’t see her often.

JaceLancs · 16/08/2023 09:35

I don’t find this at all - in my workplace no one talks about diets - we all eat lunch together and the most mention of food might be things like ‘oohh that looks nice’ or recipe suggestions - mainly female workplace ages from 20 ish to 60+
people comment on my yellow sticker haul but mostly we are too busy chatting about other things
met a friend for breakfast yesterday we both had bacon sandwiches - I took some fat off mine as I don’t like the taste of texture but no mention was made of anything else

UmbrellaSoldiers · 16/08/2023 09:34

I'm fat. I feel horrible about myself all the time. I hate my reflection, I hate choosing clothes to wear. I'm disgusting and fat.

Us fatties can't win. If I say yes to a second bottle of wine and a sharing platter, then I feel horribly guilty and am sure everyone around me is thinking "no wonder she is so fat". If I abstain from food and drink people think I am boring, and "who is she kidding she obviously doesn't usually abstain from anything". If I mention dieting, it's a social faux pas.

It is on my mind ALL THE TIME. Every photo of myself I am analysing to see how awful I look. Every shop window I walk past I try not to see my reflection because it's so gross.

So, I am always on a diet, always trying to lose weight, always trying to feel better about myself. And I fail, over and over. I have psychological and medical reasons for being fat, I also love food, find exercise painful and boring, and eat for every emotion I experience. The power of the "fuck it I'll always be fat, might as well enjoy life" is strong.

If I am talking about being on a diet in public it is for the following reasons:

I am apologising to those around me for having to be with someone so gross and fat as me, and I am letting them know I am aware of it and trying to fix it.

I am seeking support from others who are also dieting and who may have the same emotional struggles with it I do.

I am reminding myself that I am trying to fix it

I'm crying out for help and for someone to tell me that I am ok as I am

It's exhausting being fat and unhappy. We are shamed over and over in the media, by strangers, by friends, by the constant "just eat less and move more". Exhausting.

edenhills · 16/08/2023 09:29

I'm quite happy to talk to a friend about this if they are very overweight and want to make positive changes in their life. However it is very tedious otherwise. I have 5 friends who I meet up with regularly, 3 of us are overweight and three are fairly skinny. It is always the skinny ones talking about fad diets etc and how much weight they have put on. The rest of us just roll our eyes.

Ricochetsandwhich · 16/08/2023 09:26

Food is one of the most enjoyable aspects of life.

Trying to maintain / get to, a healthy weight is a massive challenge for many of us

If it’s in your head most of the time it’s perfectly normal for comments to slip out now and then, or for you to want to talk about it sometimes with likeminded people. An awareness that not everyone feels the same is important though and there is a time and a place. No one wants a meal ruined by someone banging on about its calorie overload!

That said I also agree with others who have mentioned the examples you have given are perfectly normal comments and don’t show an obsession with food. If anything op you seen to be hyper vigilant where food is talked about, sorry.

KimberleyClark · 16/08/2023 09:25

I am trying to lose weight at the moment - I need to, I am 5ft 2 and my starting weight was 12 stone. But I try not to bore people, especially not size 6 people.

doroda · 16/08/2023 09:18

Yoyoban · 16/08/2023 03:42

But most of your examples aren't actually about dieting/weight - the fact that you perceive them as such makes me wonder if you actually have an eating disorder and you just find any food related conversation triggering.

Cutting off the fat is just discussing tastes / meat quality, indicating what size piece of a dessert you'd like is completely normal and benign and to do with current appetite / taste for sweet things. If someone's appearance has changed that much that they're virtually unrecognisable of course people are going to find that comment-worthy, it doesn't imply any judgement.

Yep, this.

duvetdayy · 16/08/2023 09:18

YANBU and I actually think it’s bang out of order. I had an eating disorder and never went on about food like this. I am mostly recovered now but if I had to listen to this I would find it very difficult.

napody · 16/08/2023 09:17

GarlicGrace · 16/08/2023 00:22

It's social enforcement. Women are supposed to be anxious about their bodies, to keep themselves hungry, and to police other women. It's fucking mind-numbing, and quite upsetting to see it in action.

But while we're here ... let me just say "we've forgotten what a healthy weight looks like", "massive salad", "keto" and "vanity sizing" 😉

This!
I think if you are trying to eat healthier its totally counter productive to talk constantly about what you're depriving yourself of, too.

sadaboutmycat · 16/08/2023 09:15

CallieQ · 16/08/2023 00:40

Easy for you to talk size 6

My thoughts entirely.
I don't talk about it all the time, but I have had to restrict my eating my entire life or I would have increased in size year on year. At 60 I still battle it. CICO is not identical in everyone.
I cannot imagine the ease of having lived a life where I don't gain weight eating what other people eat.
This is what is indoctrinated into society: that if person A can stay the same on XYZ calories then so can person B. It's rubbish. There are so many variances.
I used to own a newsagent back in the day. I remember the school bus load coming in. Skinny girl A would buy 4 chocolate bars, eat 2 before she left the shop, and be surrounded by fawning boys. Bigger girl B would buy 1, and be jeered at for being "a fat pig".
That's the issue.

SuperBurgers · 16/08/2023 09:09

Yeah boring but you did feel the need to let everyone here know you're a size 6, so I also think its really easy to bemoan struggling women when its not an issue you have and are clearly somewhat smug about.

lovewoola · 16/08/2023 07:11

It's boring & I can't stand the faux bird like appetites. Just give me a massive portion & shut up!

JudyGemstone · 16/08/2023 06:24

YANBU OP - I’ve wanted to say this many times when the group chat comes back yet again to food/dieting/weight.

I think about saying ‘come on, we’re all intelligent, professional women with lots of interesting things to talk about, why are we discussing this yet again?’

next time I’m going to, fuck it!

WWYDIYWMRN · 16/08/2023 06:12

I used to work with someone like that. Thin but went on and on about her weight, calories, what she was eating, how unhealthy fat people are and how she needed to lose weight. I'm about 3-4 sizes bigger than her and it started to really annoy me, especially will all the hints about how unhealthy I am.

But we won't mention the fact she smokes cigarettes, and drinks every night.

condition · 16/08/2023 06:05

What's even worse is when someone gets fixated on Tim Spector's approach and starts talking about feeding their gut bacteria like they're pets.

No I don't want to think about what goes on in your colon, particularly over lunch!

WandaWonder · 16/08/2023 04:32

I don't get people talking to me directly about food/dieting but I feel the same for any topic of conversation that never changes if someone was into a hobby, the latest movie, their upcoming holiday if they constantly talked about the same thing regardless of that the topic was I would get very bored

I do not do that to other people I talk about a variety of things but OP your post does come across as you have food issues yourself, this could be wrong but like a lot of posts it may be the way it is written or of course the was I am reading it

But I do not get random comments from people usually at work 'do you know how many calories is in that?' or 'you should only eat one of those it is 10g of fat' or whatever, unless you are asked why the need to comment?

Threenow · 16/08/2023 04:29

YANBU - it's mega boring

PlinkPlonkFizz · 16/08/2023 04:22

Yoyoban · 16/08/2023 03:42

But most of your examples aren't actually about dieting/weight - the fact that you perceive them as such makes me wonder if you actually have an eating disorder and you just find any food related conversation triggering.

Cutting off the fat is just discussing tastes / meat quality, indicating what size piece of a dessert you'd like is completely normal and benign and to do with current appetite / taste for sweet things. If someone's appearance has changed that much that they're virtually unrecognisable of course people are going to find that comment-worthy, it doesn't imply any judgement.

This.

3rdtimemumma · 16/08/2023 04:18

Yoyoban · 16/08/2023 03:42

But most of your examples aren't actually about dieting/weight - the fact that you perceive them as such makes me wonder if you actually have an eating disorder and you just find any food related conversation triggering.

Cutting off the fat is just discussing tastes / meat quality, indicating what size piece of a dessert you'd like is completely normal and benign and to do with current appetite / taste for sweet things. If someone's appearance has changed that much that they're virtually unrecognisable of course people are going to find that comment-worthy, it doesn't imply any judgement.

I agree with this. A lot of the examples aren't weight-related. In my husband's family, the meat quality is always a topic. The meat is fatty, delicious, grissley. It's often a way someone explains why they didn't eat all of it. Same with pudding, people have a small sliver because main was filling/ delicious/ or pudding is rich. Nothing weight-related. Often health-related, not weight-related when discussing what we're eating. Interesting you view it that way. We used to play "guess the ingredients" or "guess the salt content" in the office at work with bought stuff. It was just a silly laugh. No judgement there.

Yoyoban · 16/08/2023 03:42

But most of your examples aren't actually about dieting/weight - the fact that you perceive them as such makes me wonder if you actually have an eating disorder and you just find any food related conversation triggering.

Cutting off the fat is just discussing tastes / meat quality, indicating what size piece of a dessert you'd like is completely normal and benign and to do with current appetite / taste for sweet things. If someone's appearance has changed that much that they're virtually unrecognisable of course people are going to find that comment-worthy, it doesn't imply any judgement.

electriclight · 16/08/2023 03:25

Trying to lose weight is very consuming. It is on your mind at all times and especially at mealtimes. Sometimes it helps to discuss it with people who are going through the same thing, or to ask advice from people who have healthy relationships with food. I suppose it must be boring for people who can't join in or relate. But then so is anything that you're not interested in - sport, soaps, politics.

VashtaNerada · 16/08/2023 02:19

As someone who is overweight I’d hate it if someone much thinner than me kept talking about it, I find that very rude. I sometimes bring up the topic myself because I feel that others may be judging me for what I do or don’t eat in front of them. But yes, any topic that’s talked about for too long is going to be boring for anyone else who doesn’t have much to add.

JudgeRudy · 16/08/2023 01:37

I agree weight and diet is a hot topic for a lot of people but I think you tend to be aware of something more if it's of no interest to you because it either bores or irritates you. Women often talk about their children/grandchildren. Once in relationships people moan about partners and singletons or newly paired talk more about fancying someone/sex/what a text meant etc....these are subjects that unite us. I dare say you have a topic that others really don't care about. Maybe your pet cat, Harry Potter, Taylor Swift, or how Julie from accounts makes your day a nightmare.
But yes, it is hard if every conversation seems to come back to this. It would frustrate me

Swipe left for the next trending thread