Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

People that go on about dieting and weight

89 replies

Catwiththecream · 16/08/2023 00:01

Aibu to think this is just a big social no no? Before I start it's worth me saying I am not on a diet. I'm a size 6 and for my height and activity level this is entirely sustainable. This post isn't about me just not wanting to hear about diets but rather and observation that generally this topic of conversation is awful. I have really noticed recently how depressing it is to be around people that constantly go on about dieting and who monitor food. Just the other day I was at one of my fiancées relatives houses for dinner and from the moment we stepped foot inside all conversations seemed to go back to weight and dieting. It started when I mentioned that I'd donated a lot of my old summer clothes this year and been wearing the same things over and over ( the conversation was about a bootfair me and fiancée did before starting to pack our stuff up to move house ). His relatives response was 'well you can at your size'. Fair enough, most would see this as a compliment I suppose and I'm not thin skinned enough to say this is a problem but what followed was 'it must take a lot of work though, we aren't eating lunch at the moment'. I never know what to say to these sort of conversations, especially as the 'we' she was referring to was her, her dh and her daughter ( adult ) living with them. It would be so rude of me to comment and also I'm there to have a nice time with them not give a shit about how many calories they're allowing themselves that week. So the conversation about bootfairs and clearing out cupboards had made its way to weight territory. Next was dinner, this time another guest discarded of the fat on their meat and made a point of mentioning it when it could have just been left on the side of their plate so everyone else eating could enjoy the meal, but no instead it was 'I had to cut the fat off! Way too much'. Again, what do you say to that? Dessert time we are all asked how much we want as the chocolate torte is being cut into slices, que the 'oh no that's way too big less please' comments whilst the tiniest, borderline insulting slither is cut of an indulgent but lovely cake someone has made about bought along. All night conversation naturally goes back to people's weight no matter how it starts...'saw Teresa today, she's doing well, you actually wouldn't recognise her'...and it doesn't end there. In my office today as we all eat lunch at our desks the conversation inevitably drifts onto what we're all eating, whether it's healthy, so and so has cut down on cheese, on the other side of the room we have someone just eating salad. I don't care what anyone eats or weighs, it's none of my business & I don't want to ever talk or hear about what people are eating either. I feel sorry for anyone trying to lose weight in the room when these conversations are bought up but it surprises me how common place they are. Aibu? Is it okay to talk about weight/fat/diets so much or does it just make everyone feel miserable and awkward like it does with me? How do you shut down the conversation or divert off it when it keeps going back there? It drives me mad!

OP posts:
MrsMorrisey · 16/08/2023 13:23

Larger people probably feel self conscious around you OP.

They may bring it up a lot because they are embarrassed about their weight but are trying to let you know that they are trying to lose weight so you don't judge them.
You probably don't but they may think you will do unless they point it out first.

DivingForLove · 16/08/2023 12:12

@UmbrellaSoldiers i could have written your post - and the others on this thread from women who’ve struggled all their lives. And before anyone tells me I’m beautiful - no I’m not. I don’t suit being fat at all, I look fucking awful and I hate it. I hate living my life constantly judged. It sucks. I’ve wasted 30 fucking years living like this - and missed so many life opportunities because of it.

It sucks 😢

PecanButter50 · 16/08/2023 12:05

I'm fat. The reasons for it are complex. I have been a binge eater since childhood , full on ED territory since as long as I can remember.

My sister is afraid of getting fat, and often talks about how bad or good she is being with food. I did challenge her on this once and she said "but all this never mention weight is why you're fat!" She must have a different set of memories from me is all I can say. I remember my father telling me how ugly I was, how he was disgusted by the sight of me, how nobody would want me, calling me names and shouting at me, threatening to throw me out of the house of starve me for being greedy. How after a sexual assault it was "well be flattered, they think you're an attractive woman." I don't think he realised it wasn't the first SA I had endured, that as a both young child and older child I had been molested, so I don't see what looks has to do with it .

I also remember the constant dieting in my teens and twenties and the self induced purges after bingeing.

roundtable · 16/08/2023 12:00

I think lots of people talk about their topics of interest over and over without realising to be honest. If I go in the staffroom, which is very rare now as the conversations ate just too ernest for me - I want a bit of light relief while I eat, different people bang on about the same things each day. The diet people, the horse people, the dog people, the I hate my husband/in-laws/kids etc people, the woe is me people... you get my drift. I'd leave the staffroom drained.

Contrast to friends, we might talk about things like that but not for long and the conversations move on and not obsessive on one topic.

The moral of the story is - keep conversations varied and balance the deep with the light hearted please! Whether that's diet or horses or anything else😁

PecanButter50 · 16/08/2023 11:58

JudyGemstone · 16/08/2023 06:24

YANBU OP - I’ve wanted to say this many times when the group chat comes back yet again to food/dieting/weight.

I think about saying ‘come on, we’re all intelligent, professional women with lots of interesting things to talk about, why are we discussing this yet again?’

next time I’m going to, fuck it!

Yes to this.

puffincarpet · 16/08/2023 11:56

I'll be honest, I didn't read all of your OP due to the lack of paragraphs.

Talking about dieting and weight all of the time is boring. Fair enough to talk about it once in a while (not in front of children, I refuse to have weight-obsessive conversations around kids because of the example it sets) but talking about it regularly is irritating. There are family members that bring up weight, or people's weight, every time I see them. I have outrightly told them that it's a bit sad that they always find ways to bring conversations back round to weight and I don't want to talk about it.

Some people are obsessive about their weight. DH is one of them because he was raised by a man with body dysmorphia, who made him start "working out" under the age of 10. He is aware that he talks about it too much and I do pull him up on it.

Alphabetica · 16/08/2023 11:43

luckylavender · 16/08/2023 10:55

I think a lot of topics of conversation are boring honestly.

Same. It's no more boring than everyone talking about their cockapoo puppies or their toddlers or their house sale. It's not something I talk about lots but at times in your life it's more relevant than others. I don't think some of the pps' comments about skinny people complaining are fair. I'm a size bigger after children and have struggled to shift it. It really affects how I feel about myself and how I dress. If you want to go from a 10 to an 8 or 12 to a 10, that's as valid as desiring to be a 14 when you're a 16.

Hufflepods · 16/08/2023 11:24

I’m really surprised so many people voted YABU! Clearly all the lurkers are the ones starting these conversations.

VeridicalVagabond · 16/08/2023 11:17

I lost a substantial amount of weight over the last year and it drove me bloody mad people going on and on about diet and exercise. People wanted to do nothing but talk about it with me, when I was living it and all I wanted to do was talk about literally anything else. It's so dull.

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 16/08/2023 11:04

YANBU. It's a topic I find hard to always resist, but I agree that it would be better for everyone if we didn't talk about it very much.

I know there's an argument that people like a supportive conversation about it, because sometimes it's good to feel others are in the same boat. But in reality it mostly just perpetuates self-criticism and promotes weight loss as some kind of almost universal, rather miserable female hobby.

tt9 · 16/08/2023 11:03

@Catwiththecream I really hope you ate the rest of the chocolate torte. shame to let such a dessert go to waste.

Catwiththecream · 16/08/2023 11:03

Thank you for a your replies! Lots of interesting views. Apologies if mentioning my size seemed a bit off, I did so purely to make it clear that I'm not coming at this from the point of view of someone on a diet trying to avoid these conversations for that reason especially as it makes others feel rubbish no matter what I say in response, hence not liking the conversation to go there at all. I do take on the point raised that maybe I am hyper vigilant with what is said though and why people have these conversations, I think I'll carry on with how I am at the moment and just try to socialise more with people who don't always bring diets up and keep meals with those who do in moderation as it gets on my nerves so much. For those who have mentioned being on diets and bringing these topics up themselves I do get what you're saying and wish you all the best with whatever goals you're aiming for x

OP posts:
luckylavender · 16/08/2023 10:55

I think a lot of topics of conversation are boring honestly.

GreekGod · 16/08/2023 10:50

I hate any weight related topics for discussion. It never ends good. I only tell very close friends and never in a group setting. It’s such a personal issue. Recently had a dinner party in my home where this came up and losing holiday weight. Six friends of my DH and their wives. Became a bashing match between two of the wives- made me feel very uncomfortable in my own home. I kept changing the subject and the two of them kept bringing it back to weight. Awful. DH and his friends disappeared outside - of course they did.

Giantpig · 16/08/2023 10:27

Tippley · 16/08/2023 10:23

I don't think it's just asking for a small portion though it's when anyone of any weight feel the need to explain in depth why they're ordering it and usually passing comment on what others are eating. It's boring! It's different if someone is asking for support, or if they're proud of the adjustments they've made but invariably it's not the case.

People do it because they don’t want everyone to be judging them for being fat and greedy. If there wasn’t such an obsession with, and premium placed on being thin in society (massively policed by women judging each other) then women wouldn’t talk about it all the time.

ManateeFair · 16/08/2023 10:23

Personally, I don't mind it BUT it's still a topic I would try to avoid banging on about because I know that for a lot of people it can be a difficult, depressing or even dangerous subject.

I wouldn't get into a discussion about dieting/weight in (for example) an open-plan office or in a group where I don't know everyone really well. I mean, on a basic level it's a bit boring for most people. But more importantly, so many people have anxieties and insecurities and body image worries or disordered eating issues that I think it's best avoided for that reason, and also, it's quite off-putting if you're all sitting there having lunch and someone is going on about how many calories there are in everything and how they couldn't possibly eat that pudding you've ordered because it's 'fattening'.

Basically it's a really loaded subject, and I'd only really engage in conversation about it with a couple of very long-standing friends who I know are on the same page as me.

Equally annoying, though, are the vehemently anti-diet people who can't see someone eating a salad or necking a protein shake without starting a long lecture about the evils of diet culture and telling you to go and eat some chips. I used to work with one of those and she was hard work, I must say.

Tippley · 16/08/2023 10:23

Giantpig · 16/08/2023 10:18

I don’t think women can win- if they are fat and NOT on a diet/ashamed of themselves/eat a lot in public etc people shame them (see the many threads on here about people ‘spilling over plane seats’, being ‘grossly fat’ and the apparent dangers of body positivity etc)…

but if they try and not fall into that trap by mentioning their diet/asking for small portions/making a point of eating healthy food then they are apparently boring and mind numbing.

So- the only acceptable thing is for fat women to hate themselves and diet and restrict what they eat but to do it all in silence, and not ask for a small portion of pudding in case it bores people.

I don't think it's just asking for a small portion though it's when anyone of any weight feel the need to explain in depth why they're ordering it and usually passing comment on what others are eating. It's boring! It's different if someone is asking for support, or if they're proud of the adjustments they've made but invariably it's not the case.

Tippley · 16/08/2023 10:21

I find it interesting when people are into health overall and talk about their sport or hiking or whatever else, or if they cook interesting balanced meals but yes people going on about calories and whatever else is very tedious. The only time I personally mention anything to do with this is when people moaning about calorie counting say how lucky I am for being a healthy weight and physically fit. Its not luck though, I consciously eat a balanced diet and I enjoy exercise, I just don't harp on about it!

Giantpig · 16/08/2023 10:18

I don’t think women can win- if they are fat and NOT on a diet/ashamed of themselves/eat a lot in public etc people shame them (see the many threads on here about people ‘spilling over plane seats’, being ‘grossly fat’ and the apparent dangers of body positivity etc)…

but if they try and not fall into that trap by mentioning their diet/asking for small portions/making a point of eating healthy food then they are apparently boring and mind numbing.

So- the only acceptable thing is for fat women to hate themselves and diet and restrict what they eat but to do it all in silence, and not ask for a small portion of pudding in case it bores people.

GigiGrey · 16/08/2023 10:12

It's not fair for people to say that the OP is bragging or it's easy for her to moan about people discussing diets because she's a size 6. I've found in groups like this unwanted attention is often turned onto the smaller people. I had previously been very ill prior to starting a new job and had dropped from a size 10 to a 6 in a very short space of time (not ED related - I have no issues around discussion about food etc). On starting my new job I quickly realised that the dominant, daily topic of conversation in this office was diets. They were several members of staff who were constantly on diets and trying to lose weight - a few months into the job a set of scales appeared and they would weigh themselves daily and spend hours chatting about their weight. I kept a distance from this, never commented on any of it and was not part of it. However, it wasn't long before comments like "Gigi you musn't ever eat", "what have you got for lunch today?" "do you even eat breakfast?" "it won't be long before me and Gigi can share clothes" started. I was being encouraged to get on the scales in front of everyone. If someone brought a treat into the office there was pressure for me to take the first portion, to the point where if I said no, it would be dumped in front of me anyway. It got to a stage where I would sit on a bench outside and eat my lunch rather than in front of them as the ring leader of this group would watch me like a hawk and flag up to everyone when I was eating, shouting across the office to me to ask what it was.

At the size that I was I did not look healthy. I didn't tell them that I hadn't always been this size and that I was trying to gain weight following a really scary period of bad health, it wasn't any of their business. But when your the "skinny" person in a room full of obsessives like this, you're often seen as fair game for people to comment on your body and use you as a comparison tool. It's tedious, and boring and really frustrating being dragged into conversations like this, especially when the conversation you were initially having has nothing to do with diets and weight.

KimberleyClark · 16/08/2023 10:08

What does irritate me is my naturally slim friends who go on about how gorgeous fat people are and how I don't need to lose any weight.

They just don’t want you to be slim like them!

catsandkid · 16/08/2023 10:08

sadaboutmycat · 16/08/2023 09:15

My thoughts entirely.
I don't talk about it all the time, but I have had to restrict my eating my entire life or I would have increased in size year on year. At 60 I still battle it. CICO is not identical in everyone.
I cannot imagine the ease of having lived a life where I don't gain weight eating what other people eat.
This is what is indoctrinated into society: that if person A can stay the same on XYZ calories then so can person B. It's rubbish. There are so many variances.
I used to own a newsagent back in the day. I remember the school bus load coming in. Skinny girl A would buy 4 chocolate bars, eat 2 before she left the shop, and be surrounded by fawning boys. Bigger girl B would buy 1, and be jeered at for being "a fat pig".
That's the issue.

This!

If you are a natural size 6 that can pretty much eat whatever you like (within reason) and don't have to consciously consider what you are eating, the macros, the calories etc. then you likely don't appreciate how consuming dieting can be.

I'm similar to PP. I am a size 10/12 but aim for a 10. I have to think about what I eat every day if I want to stay my current size and in the healthy BMI range. I'm short so my TDEE is pretty low, compared to a taller person. It means my portions always need to be a bit smaller than average and I also have digestive issues so have to avoid trigger foods there too. It does make mealtimes pretty focused on the food and its impact on my body and its helpful to chat about that sometimes to offload!

I would genuinely love to not think about food so much. I hate how much space it occupies in my mind.

greentealeave · 16/08/2023 10:04

This reply has been deleted

This user is a troll so we have deleted their posts and threads.

Almosthadenoughacademic · 16/08/2023 09:49

It is difficult but if you are somebody who struggles to maintain a healthy weight and/or has issues around food, it does become a focus. I try not to talk about it too much, unless I'm with people in the same boat. What does irritate me is my naturally slim friends who go on about how gorgeous fat people are and how I don't need to lose any weight. I am on blood pressure and cholesterol meds, both probably impacted by me carrying extra weight for much of my adult life. I've been between 11'and a half and 13 stone during my 40s and 50s - late 50s now and at the lighter end - but I'm also short so don't carry weight well.

DinnaeFashYersel · 16/08/2023 09:49

I was going to take my mother and MIL out for dinner this week and decided not to because I couldn't bear another meal where they both sit there

  • complaining about how much weight they've put on recently (both sizes 10s
  • talking about how they have skipped breakfast and skimped on lunch in order to eat this dinner
  • refuse a starter because they are dieting
  • complain about the size of the main course and don't finish it
  • order a pudding - and then complain about how much weight they will put on because of it.
Swipe left for the next trending thread