Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

People that go on about dieting and weight

89 replies

Catwiththecream · 16/08/2023 00:01

Aibu to think this is just a big social no no? Before I start it's worth me saying I am not on a diet. I'm a size 6 and for my height and activity level this is entirely sustainable. This post isn't about me just not wanting to hear about diets but rather and observation that generally this topic of conversation is awful. I have really noticed recently how depressing it is to be around people that constantly go on about dieting and who monitor food. Just the other day I was at one of my fiancées relatives houses for dinner and from the moment we stepped foot inside all conversations seemed to go back to weight and dieting. It started when I mentioned that I'd donated a lot of my old summer clothes this year and been wearing the same things over and over ( the conversation was about a bootfair me and fiancée did before starting to pack our stuff up to move house ). His relatives response was 'well you can at your size'. Fair enough, most would see this as a compliment I suppose and I'm not thin skinned enough to say this is a problem but what followed was 'it must take a lot of work though, we aren't eating lunch at the moment'. I never know what to say to these sort of conversations, especially as the 'we' she was referring to was her, her dh and her daughter ( adult ) living with them. It would be so rude of me to comment and also I'm there to have a nice time with them not give a shit about how many calories they're allowing themselves that week. So the conversation about bootfairs and clearing out cupboards had made its way to weight territory. Next was dinner, this time another guest discarded of the fat on their meat and made a point of mentioning it when it could have just been left on the side of their plate so everyone else eating could enjoy the meal, but no instead it was 'I had to cut the fat off! Way too much'. Again, what do you say to that? Dessert time we are all asked how much we want as the chocolate torte is being cut into slices, que the 'oh no that's way too big less please' comments whilst the tiniest, borderline insulting slither is cut of an indulgent but lovely cake someone has made about bought along. All night conversation naturally goes back to people's weight no matter how it starts...'saw Teresa today, she's doing well, you actually wouldn't recognise her'...and it doesn't end there. In my office today as we all eat lunch at our desks the conversation inevitably drifts onto what we're all eating, whether it's healthy, so and so has cut down on cheese, on the other side of the room we have someone just eating salad. I don't care what anyone eats or weighs, it's none of my business & I don't want to ever talk or hear about what people are eating either. I feel sorry for anyone trying to lose weight in the room when these conversations are bought up but it surprises me how common place they are. Aibu? Is it okay to talk about weight/fat/diets so much or does it just make everyone feel miserable and awkward like it does with me? How do you shut down the conversation or divert off it when it keeps going back there? It drives me mad!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Catwiththecream · 18/08/2023 22:51

Cupcakekiller · 18/08/2023 22:12

You're imposing your own discomfort onto others. A lot of people will find it comforting to engage with others who struggle. I say deal with your own issues about this and examine why it bothers you so much. 🤷🏻‍♀️You can't police other people's conversations and dictate what you think is worthy of discussion.

Oh god nooo I would never actually impose it or police it hence why I'm here to vent lol. I was just wondering if I'm alone with how I feel but it seems some people feel the same as me and others not so much. I don't mind conversations about weight or dieting in the rught context but regularly having it bought up is off putting for most in a social setting surrounded by eating and not kind on those who are sensitive about it. I'd never actually say anything though so you do have a point!

OP posts:
Nightmusic · 18/08/2023 22:28

This is probably me some times, but I do find people (especially at work) so like to question what you're eating so it does lead to it. I'm not overweight, I calorie count and I really struggle with my weight. 'Thin' people can struggle just as much with themselves as people are objectively larger.

Cupcakekiller · 18/08/2023 22:12

You're imposing your own discomfort onto others. A lot of people will find it comforting to engage with others who struggle. I say deal with your own issues about this and examine why it bothers you so much. 🤷🏻‍♀️You can't police other people's conversations and dictate what you think is worthy of discussion.

Sandytoesbeachywaves · 18/08/2023 20:14

Op a lot of people really struggle with weight long term.

You're a size 6 so you are slim and it sounds as though you have your food and activity level under control, which is great.

The calories in calories out doesn't come easily for some people to be at/stay at a weight they're happy and comfortable with. Therefore they're regularly on a 'diet' or being good or cutting back or whatever..

It is a bit boring and tiresome but it's just one of those things. Not really doing you any harm.

Nopenopenopenopenopenope · 18/08/2023 20:02

I'd probably try to just say "mm-hmm" and try to move on to something else tbh. It bothers me as well for different reasons but it's become very noticable how often this subject is broached out of nowhere.

Catwiththecream · 18/08/2023 19:37

More interesting replies thank you. Its not that it bores me, I'm boring a lot of the time I expect and agree that other topics are boring and I'd never ever have an issue with say people's new born babies. My issue is that weight is so inflammatory and makes everyone miserable or uncomfortable, generally making anyone slim feel that they have to be silent to prevent causing offence and those who aren't feeling like they can't relax and just eat. It's really sad and sometimes I think people bring it up to either feel superior or make a dig although not always. Also you never know what someone's background is with food, it's just not a good idea!

OP posts:
Cupcakekiller · 18/08/2023 16:39

If your friends bore you, maybe get different friends you have more in common with? Every topic of conversation could be deemed to be boring if it's something you're not interested in.

SuperBurgers · 18/08/2023 16:29

FerryPink · 18/08/2023 13:42

I've lost a stone and a half in the last 3 months without having discussed it with anyone at all (because I find it boring tbh) but if, for instance, I was being pressed to have cake /pudding etc then I might feel I needed to as a way to ask the person I was with to support my efforts by not pressing.

But mostly what struck me while have been overweight is how many people want to give me unsolicited diet /health advice (my weight gain was steroid induced, I was always slim - size 8- before then and am not struggling to lose the weight now although I am just making sure I don't over indulge)

I have to say though as a slim person I never really discussed weight but always felt I had to be polite and humour others if they brought it up, as maybe it really did matter to them.

Alright, dont go on about it

FerryPink · 18/08/2023 13:42

I've lost a stone and a half in the last 3 months without having discussed it with anyone at all (because I find it boring tbh) but if, for instance, I was being pressed to have cake /pudding etc then I might feel I needed to as a way to ask the person I was with to support my efforts by not pressing.

But mostly what struck me while have been overweight is how many people want to give me unsolicited diet /health advice (my weight gain was steroid induced, I was always slim - size 8- before then and am not struggling to lose the weight now although I am just making sure I don't over indulge)

I have to say though as a slim person I never really discussed weight but always felt I had to be polite and humour others if they brought it up, as maybe it really did matter to them.

MeadowCS · 18/08/2023 13:28

I hate this too, I’ve actually had to point out to my female relatives on DMs side that every time we meet up, they will bring up dieting, weight loss, etc. or DM will constantly make jokes about how she is too fat to be doing this or that. Advocating diets where you only eat soup for 2 weeks or other unhealthy weight loss fixes.

None of us are particularly large, all sitting around a 12-14 but all being over 5ft9 this isn’t large so it’s crazy that this is such a fixation.

This has been the case my entire life (I’m now 30) and I do think it has affected my relationship with food. I have let them know that I find it exhausting and I don’t want to constantly think about food but they literally can’t help themselves.

If I eventually have a child I’m going to be really firm on it not being brought up.

MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 18/08/2023 13:13

I find steps more boring than diet/ food, I really couldn't give a toss how many steps someone has done, I just zone out .

LivStanshall · 18/08/2023 02:43

I agree. Had dinner with friends tonight, all very slim, and they went on about weight, dieting and how many steps they had done on this day and that. I'm not so slim anymore and one of them actually asked me how much I weighed, needles to say I didn't tell her. I shut the conversation down after a while but I thought it was both inane and boring.

TheBerry · 17/08/2023 10:26

I mean it’s pretty tedious when someone goes on and on about ANY topic, really. It’s not unique to dieting.

GarlicGrace · 17/08/2023 03:51

I like @Normalweirdo's approach! I'm far more interested in this than everybody's daily struggles with their self-hatred ... some replies in this thread are heartbreaking to read, and it really upsets me that we live in a society which makes people feel so bad for no reason.

Adding my own bit of vulnerability here, I'm a recovered anorexic. While I've had decades to work out my feelings around this whole topic and am now pretty resilient, eating disorders are addictions with the same risk of relapse as any other addiction. Being with a group of diet obsessives is comparable to an ex-heroin addict in a group of junkies. Even this much later (decades), it can tip me into a binge/starve cycle which I then have to therapise myself through. Hence why I rarely read diet/weight topics!

It could be very dangerous for someone recently recovered or in recovery. Unfortunately, everyone who's going on about their weight, size or eating is in active addiction, so they're likely to resent anybody saying they're 'triggered' because they've worked to get rid of the problem.

Switching it round to a more theoretical discussion is far more likely to shut them up 😄 That may well be because they don't want to think about why they're obsessed/addicted, or that they're suffering from social manipulation, but never mind that! And if one or two of them are interested, so much the better. It's the first step to freedom.

electriclight · 17/08/2023 02:58

Any conversation is boring and/or triggering if you can't relate to it.

People bore on about their kids, their hobbies, their latest relationship dramas, how often they go to the gym, their dog, their home refurb.

I can't see how a diet is that much different really. Change the subject.

MoominFeatures · 16/08/2023 22:43

duvetdayy · 16/08/2023 09:18

YANBU and I actually think it’s bang out of order. I had an eating disorder and never went on about food like this. I am mostly recovered now but if I had to listen to this I would find it very difficult.

^ This. I’m hypersensitive to, and HATE, this topic it when it comes up to the point that I tend to manufacture an excuse to take myself away from it whenever it does.

MantaKay · 16/08/2023 22:11

Talking about diet is of no interest to you in the same way someone who doesn't have children nor doesn't want them would not be interested in talking about parenting.
When there is a group, there is a conversation topic. Sometimes it is great, sometimes not. Met friends fort lunch today, all they could talk about was the World Cup.
So what?

Thetigerdrankmywine · 16/08/2023 22:04

I don't talk about dieting and have never dieted. However, it did dawn on me a while ago that I've never truly been happy with my body, even though I'm the same size I was 20 years ago (but saggier) and objectively, it's a decent body: tall, slim, curves. But in my 20s, I hated my pot belly. Then 30s my post baby hips and thighs. In my 40s, the sag, although my thighs are looking good .

Not only that, I've realised how much time I spend thinking about what I eat- if I have x, then I won't have y. Having a few drinks on Fri, so no cakes/ biscuits for a few days. Can't exercise next week, so no crisps etc. I don't think dh wastes any time on this bollocks.

I always though I had a healthy relationship with food and my body, but then, I was a teenager in the 90s and those messages really seem to have stuck, in a way I thought I was immune to.

squashi · 16/08/2023 21:55

YANBU, I think it's boring too - no need to talk about your weight or diet unless anyone has specifically shown interest & you want to engage.

Normalweirdo · 16/08/2023 21:47

I usually come back with "I wonder what it is that makes us all so obsessed with body shape and dieting, do you think it's upbringing or media or social circle?" I've found some conversation quite interesting but people rarely discuss dieting in front of me now as I find the phyco/social aspects of it way more interesting than the calorie counting.

verdantverdure · 16/08/2023 15:36

We've been living in diet culture for so long that we probably don't even recognise that we have disordered eating, really wrong ideas about healthy eating and that yoyo dieting has become a way of life.

Noodge · 16/08/2023 15:24

'I don't want to talk about it so let's talk about it' Wink no, I see where you're coming from.

I also think 'I am happy with my body and not dieting' would have made the point you were trying to make in a less inflammatory way than stating your body size.

I don't agree regarding your opinion however. I actually find it quite interesting as a topic to be honest.

SOME things regarding it are tedious. If it is literally ALL someone talks about-a friend did this on a night out once and I still remember it 20 years later because the night was so boring. Her chosen subject was the fact that she was quite fat and as a teen she used to eat lots of cheese and onion pasties because being savoury, she thought they were healthy and that her Mother should have stopped her doing that. But she said this in various ways literally ALLLL night. I could not get a different subject out of her at all.

On the whole, I find it interesting for a couple of reasons-one being I know a fair bit about nutrition and diets and weight management. Not an expert by any stretch but I am interested in it and read a lot-so if people want to talk about it I will engage. Another being, I am a counsellor and have had a lot of clients (as well as friends) with eating disorders and body issues and I can often offer some help and advice. As PPs have pointed out, dieting, weight management and all that surrounds it can seem an insurmountable problem for people that takes over their lives. We have to live within our bodies and when we're unhappy with them it can be difficult to enjoy much else. Over (as well as under, obviously) eating is an emotional issue most common in women but that can affect everyone. I think It's quite fascinating really as well as very sad.

I find a lot of subject boring and any subject is boring if it is laboured and droned on about for hours and repeatedly, but as far as subject matter goes, I don't think this is a boring one, It's nuanced and can lead to a lot of other topics of conversation. Of course you can nod, smile and change the subject, or you could talk about your diet in terms of health rather than weight, or you could offer some admiration for people's trying to change themselves for their better.

PrrrplePineapple · 16/08/2023 14:13

KimberleyClark · 16/08/2023 10:08

What does irritate me is my naturally slim friends who go on about how gorgeous fat people are and how I don't need to lose any weight.

They just don’t want you to be slim like them!

No, this poster is lucky enough to have friends who don't define her(?) worth by the size of her body or what she looks like, and try to do their best to make sure she never feels like she has to change who she is because they think she's wonderful just as she is.

If you genuinely believe what you posted, I'm sorry someone's made you feel that way and recommend you find more friends with the above attitude instead. They're out there and they're great people.

KimberleyClark · 16/08/2023 14:00

MrsMorrisey · 16/08/2023 13:23

Larger people probably feel self conscious around you OP.

They may bring it up a lot because they are embarrassed about their weight but are trying to let you know that they are trying to lose weight so you don't judge them.
You probably don't but they may think you will do unless they point it out first.

This.

pollykitty · 16/08/2023 13:38

You’re right, it is really boring. I’m overweight at the moment and trying to lose it, but never talk about it. I don’t want to and I don’t use it as an excuse when eating or drinking. I find it so tiresome when people say no dessert I’m dieting. What wrong with just ‘No thank you’ I’m a person who was a ‘normal’ weight until about age 40 and then just piled it on. It’s been interesting watching people’s reactions to me change over the years, I remember the first time someone called me fat as an insult and I was like, ‘wow’. I didn’t care but it opened my eyes to the verbal abuse people think is acceptable. I happen to also be very strong and flexible underneath my fat and have watched many thinner and younger women in classes (pilates/yoga/dance) I take try to hide their amazement at how I can move. Fat judging and shaming is truly lame but talking about my fat is just as boring.

Swipe left for the next trending thread