Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

We should abolish military specific ‘offense’

57 replies

Theworried2 · 15/08/2023 20:59

Watching the new Channel 5 show ‘Court Martial: Soldiers behind bars’ has made me think how unjust it is that soldiers are locked up for things that would not be an offence in civilian life like going AWOL or being drunk at work.
Surely soldiers should get the same rights as normal civilians and only ever be jailed for civilian crimes.
To be clear, those who commit murder as a soldier should be jailed as it is a civilian crime too, but those who go on AWOL for example should not as this would not be a crime in normal life.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Tippley · 16/08/2023 11:05

DownNative · 16/08/2023 10:42

Now that is an OTT reaction.

Ex-military are veterans and civilians. Nothing at all wrong with that. In terms of domestic terrorism, its problematic to refuse to view yourself as a civilian and this is an issue we're still dealing with.

International Humanitarian Law takes prominence. The distinction is, therefore, important.

I don't refuse to view myself as a Civilian, I even said that in my post. I class myself as a veteran because I'm proud of my service and its absolutely shaped who I am. This doesn't affect anyone else and doesn't affect anything that could be complicated by referring to myself as such- ie I am not doing anything or behaving in a way because of how I class myself. I can't speak for anyone else but everyone I know feels the same, they understand that legally they are a Civilian but choose to view themselves as veterans. Now do fuck off.

DownNative · 16/08/2023 10:42

Tippley · 16/08/2023 09:48

Every veteran I know personally all agree that veterans are civilians. Indeed, under International Humanitarian Law, they ARE civilians since they're no longer in the armed forces.

The legal definition and how you view yourself are 2 separate things. I am legally a civilian and recognise this, I'll always be a veteran though and I don't see why you feel the need to point out the obvious when you haven't served yourself. What a sad and pathetic comment aimed at trying to bring someone down and civvysplain something.

Now that is an OTT reaction.

Ex-military are veterans and civilians. Nothing at all wrong with that. In terms of domestic terrorism, its problematic to refuse to view yourself as a civilian and this is an issue we're still dealing with.

International Humanitarian Law takes prominence. The distinction is, therefore, important.

asecretslob · 16/08/2023 10:09

@Tippley well said ! I really hate it when people quote what their friends say or their husband say as if that gives them a valid opinion when they haven't done the thing themselves

AuntieJune · 16/08/2023 09:53

There are plenty of jobs where being drunk at work could land you in prison - anything involving machinery or driving for example.

Plenty more jobs require you to behave a certain way - you probably wouldn't have police, judges, teachers, local politicians etc turning a blind eye to cannabis, going dogging etc.

They're military, not civilian. They need to follow the disciplinary rules they signed up for. If you could go awol without consequences then you'd lose half the battleforce whenever they were called on to do something unpleasant.

Tippley · 16/08/2023 09:48

Every veteran I know personally all agree that veterans are civilians. Indeed, under International Humanitarian Law, they ARE civilians since they're no longer in the armed forces.

The legal definition and how you view yourself are 2 separate things. I am legally a civilian and recognise this, I'll always be a veteran though and I don't see why you feel the need to point out the obvious when you haven't served yourself. What a sad and pathetic comment aimed at trying to bring someone down and civvysplain something.

asecretslob · 16/08/2023 09:47

You might technically be a civilian but you will never be a civvy

popcornfrenzy · 16/08/2023 09:44

@DownNative I completed 2 tours of Op Telic (Iraq) I spent 11 months of my life in a shithole desert.

I don't particularly care what we're classed as under any law. I won't ever think of myself as a civvy, I'm ex-military.

Many of the values and standard learnt in the army underpin my life as a single mother of 2.

DownNative · 16/08/2023 09:38

popcornfrenzy · 16/08/2023 09:25

Ex-soldier here - the rules are something you sign up to. I signed up for 22 years but didn't complete and signed off earlier.

It may shock you to know that many soldiers are drunk at work when in peacetime but during ops they tend to be dry (unless you can get your hands on whatever alcohol you can find)

I enjoyed my time in the military - it's certainly set me up for life in terms of pension, transferable skills and a certain level of pride which has helped with getting civvy jobs.

I'll never be a civvy I'm a veteran who served my country.

Respect to you for your service! Were you part of OP Herrick or anything like that?

In my family, we've WW1, WW2, OP Banner, BAOR, OP Granby and OP Herrick (I think!).

Every veteran I know personally all agree that veterans are civilians. Indeed, under International Humanitarian Law, they ARE civilians since they're no longer in the armed forces.

Fieldofbrokenpromises · 16/08/2023 09:35

UABU and ridiculous

popcornfrenzy · 16/08/2023 09:25

Ex-soldier here - the rules are something you sign up to. I signed up for 22 years but didn't complete and signed off earlier.

It may shock you to know that many soldiers are drunk at work when in peacetime but during ops they tend to be dry (unless you can get your hands on whatever alcohol you can find)

I enjoyed my time in the military - it's certainly set me up for life in terms of pension, transferable skills and a certain level of pride which has helped with getting civvy jobs.

I'll never be a civvy I'm a veteran who served my country.

Tippley · 16/08/2023 09:10

There need to be strict and enforceable rules in the military. Guessing you haven't ever served, but these are made very clear to you, there are now plenty of ways to seek support and to avoid falling foul of these. YABU.

asecretslob · 16/08/2023 09:06

@Thesenderofthiscard how offensive what do you do that is so vital to society

PuttingDownRoots · 16/08/2023 07:20

Without Colchester... these would be sacking offences. What good would that do? All that money training someone, a steady background for them.. then thrown away after a bit of stupidity?

BygoneDays · 16/08/2023 07:20

Thesenderofthiscard · 15/08/2023 23:19

Being drunk when you have a weapon =
very fucking dangerous, risking their lives and others.
Most soldiers aren’t the brightest bulbs, that’s why they’re in the army when they have no qualifications, no other path, get in trouble etc they’re young people who wouldn’t get anywhere in real life.
rules are needed to keep them from messing up.

My soldier son has just completed his PhD after leaving the army a few years ago. I think the army has changed from when you were reading your brother’s comics.

BygoneDays · 16/08/2023 07:17

everybody in the army will disagree with you.

CasperGutman · 16/08/2023 07:15

Yes, they're punitive rules. But they're supposed to be. Punishment is ultimately necessary for military personnel to be ready to perform with discipline in wartime.

The point of the military is to go into battle and fight, and potentially die. Discipline must be practiced and learned and internalised in preparation for this. How well do you think it would go if soldiers in peacetime were allowed to behave like any other workers, then as soon as fighting started the command structure suddenly started expecting unquestioning discipline?

DownNative · 16/08/2023 06:53

Thesenderofthiscard · 15/08/2023 23:19

Being drunk when you have a weapon =
very fucking dangerous, risking their lives and others.
Most soldiers aren’t the brightest bulbs, that’s why they’re in the army when they have no qualifications, no other path, get in trouble etc they’re young people who wouldn’t get anywhere in real life.
rules are needed to keep them from messing up.

Clueless. Recruits can and do learn trades whilst in the army. For example, those who join transport regiments will most of the time walk into civvy HGV driving jobs given their qualifications.

And so on.

DownNative · 16/08/2023 06:50

No, because soldiers are NOT civilians. Under International Humanitarian Law a civilian is anyone who is not in the military.

So, police officers ARE civilians whereas soldiers are NOT.

Yes, I was a PADs Brat.

Justbecause19 · 16/08/2023 06:45

This post can't be real Confused, I suggest your child doesn't sign up to the military Op. I'm serving and not even going to try and explain

lunaalice · 15/08/2023 23:35

Thesenderofthiscard · 15/08/2023 23:19

Being drunk when you have a weapon =
very fucking dangerous, risking their lives and others.
Most soldiers aren’t the brightest bulbs, that’s why they’re in the army when they have no qualifications, no other path, get in trouble etc they’re young people who wouldn’t get anywhere in real life.
rules are needed to keep them from messing up.

Sounds harsh but DH recruits Royal Marines. Most of the time he sends them to the Army Recruitment office.

guiltyfeethavegotnorythym · 15/08/2023 23:33

Thesenderofthiscard · 15/08/2023 23:19

Being drunk when you have a weapon =
very fucking dangerous, risking their lives and others.
Most soldiers aren’t the brightest bulbs, that’s why they’re in the army when they have no qualifications, no other path, get in trouble etc they’re young people who wouldn’t get anywhere in real life.
rules are needed to keep them from messing up.

That's just not true , there are many professions in the armed forces , most soldiers do have qualifications and studied for their jobs . You clearly don't have a clue .

lunaalice · 15/08/2023 23:32

The certainly don't look after the families and we aren't one big family.?

Thedogscollar · 15/08/2023 23:28

Thesenderofthiscard · 15/08/2023 23:19

Being drunk when you have a weapon =
very fucking dangerous, risking their lives and others.
Most soldiers aren’t the brightest bulbs, that’s why they’re in the army when they have no qualifications, no other path, get in trouble etc they’re young people who wouldn’t get anywhere in real life.
rules are needed to keep them from messing up.

Good enough to protect the likes of you though.
How fucking rude and patronising are you?

Thesenderofthiscard · 15/08/2023 23:19

Being drunk when you have a weapon =
very fucking dangerous, risking their lives and others.
Most soldiers aren’t the brightest bulbs, that’s why they’re in the army when they have no qualifications, no other path, get in trouble etc they’re young people who wouldn’t get anywhere in real life.
rules are needed to keep them from messing up.

Thesenderofthiscard · 15/08/2023 23:16

It’s not ‘real’ jail. They get a chance to sort themselves.
Plentynof people get arrested for being drunk, fighting, attacking people etc
etc