Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Toddler having a huge tantrum...just interested, nothing more

90 replies

PoshPineapple · 15/08/2023 16:45

So, outside Hobbycraft earlier and a lady came out of the shop with a beetroot red, apoplectic toddler in her arms - the screams were pretty ear piercing to be honest!

Mum calmly straps toddler into her car seat and leaves the door slight ajar but stays outside the car herself. Mum largely ignores the scream-fest but periodically pops her head in and repeatedly says "we'll go back inside when you've calmed down" and the like.

I thought "how calmly Mum is dealing with this". However, a couple of other women were walking back to their car, and as they passed me I heard one of them remark "Oh god, that poor child, that woman needs reporting, it's almost neglect" "How can people treat their kids like that" etc.

It dawned on me just how very different every parent parents. I was genuinely admiring of Mum to have calmly removed her daughter from a distressing situation and let her simply ride it out without any fuss or drama, yet these other women obviously regarded it as near-on child abuse.

I know there's no wrong or right, but it's got me pondering and I'm genuinely curious how you would have regarded this?

OP posts:
ALifeofChaos · 15/08/2023 18:17

I used to wonder how anyone could do that.

Like @Bubop said - best to hold or be near them.

I always soothed my first.

Second one is completely different. If I try that she gets madder ans sometimes more dangerousto herself throwing her head back to the floor! Actually wants her own space even if she's looking like she's possessed on the floor!

The anount of times I feel I must be failing her because she doesn't want comfort during a tantrum...

Hummusanddipdip · 15/08/2023 18:14

I'm with pps, I think she did excellent especially strapping a tantruming toddler in, keeping her cool and being reasonable. Those passersby were rude and judgemental, toddlers are hard work and completely unreasonable when in that stage of a tantrum, everyone has to do their best to survive those days.

I've been known to pick ds up by his waistband when he's having a tantrum in a shop, mean I know but it's enough to snap him out because it's a shock to go from on the floor to floating and he ends up laughing after a while and we can talk.

calmcoco · 15/08/2023 18:13

LaTartine · 15/08/2023 18:10

She didn't ignore, she checked in on him calmly.
Coldness is your projection.
Likelihood is you would be kicked or punched if you cuddle a tantrumming toddler.
Why would you cuddle an angry person?
Plus they need to learn self regulation, allow them space

Coldness is simply my description. My view is that is an unhelpfully cold response.

I chose to do it differently.

I managed without getting kicked or hit!

Mummy08m · 15/08/2023 18:10

Mummy08m · 15/08/2023 18:09

Yanbu OP in that there's more than one good way to deal with tantrums and Car Mum's way isn't abusive or neglectful or anything like that.

However it's not my preferred way. My preferred way is to lean in and try and understand what dd wants. I can't understand at first because she's screaming so much she can't articulate the words properly. So she forces herself to calm down to say it clearly (whew, the worst is over). Then depending what it is, if it's actually a fairly reasonable or harmless thing then I give her the thing. If it's not then I try to explain (briefly) why I can't, which sometimes reignites the tantrum but usually at a reduced magnitude.

However I do have a short temper myself so if I just can't stay calm enough to do my Plan A then Car Mum's method is my Plan B.

Ps I completely understand though that some methods just don't work for kids with certain SEN.

10HailMarys · 15/08/2023 18:10

When you’re overwhelmed, tired and angry, your family don’t ignore you until you’ve ‘calmed down’, do they?

If I expressed my feelings by hurling myself on the floor, screaming and kicking and refusing to listen to anything anyone said (and carried on screaming even when the exact thing I had been screaming about was sorted for me, which I have witnessed toddlers do many times) then yes, I would absolutely expect my family to ignore me until I’d calmed down.

It’s a meaningless comparison anyway because an adult’s and a toddler’s brain simply do not work in the same way. A toddler will throw a massive screaming snot-faced tantrum because the bloody sky is the wrong colour for them, and nothing you do or say will actually help them because all they want to do is scream. They’re not looking for your comfort or a nice chat about their feelings and they don’t have the mental capacity for reasoning. They just want to shout and be angry until they’ve got it all out. So just letting them carry on yelling with minimal intervention and away from other people is actually the best thing to do. They’re not swallowing their feelings at all. They’re being allowed to express them loudly and at length.

LaTartine · 15/08/2023 18:10

calmcoco · 15/08/2023 18:04

They feel angry, scared and overwhelmed due to emotional disregulation. Which is why staying outside the car, ignoring, being cold is the wrong approach IMO.

I think warmth is better than coldness.

She didn't ignore, she checked in on him calmly.
Coldness is your projection.
Likelihood is you would be kicked or punched if you cuddle a tantrumming toddler.
Why would you cuddle an angry person?
Plus they need to learn self regulation, allow them space

Mummy08m · 15/08/2023 18:09

Yanbu OP in that there's more than one good way to deal with tantrums and Car Mum's way isn't abusive or neglectful or anything like that.

However it's not my preferred way. My preferred way is to lean in and try and understand what dd wants. I can't understand at first because she's screaming so much she can't articulate the words properly. So she forces herself to calm down to say it clearly (whew, the worst is over). Then depending what it is, if it's actually a fairly reasonable or harmless thing then I give her the thing. If it's not then I try to explain (briefly) why I can't, which sometimes reignites the tantrum but usually at a reduced magnitude.

However I do have a short temper myself so if I just can't stay calm enough to do my Plan A then Car Mum's method is my Plan B.

VibrantGreen · 15/08/2023 18:05

DS’s tantrums were like a wave, peaked in the middle and then calmed down.

I couldn’t do anything to stop the storm, I kept him safe and once the storm passed we cuddled and moved on.

You tell me to cuddle him, calm him during the eye of the storm, unless you’ve had a DC who has had tantrums on such a scale, please don’t offer your (possibly well meaning, but most probably ‘judgy’) advice!

Elizadoloads · 15/08/2023 18:04

I work in retail so regularly see toddlers throwing tantrums. I've noticed that it's always my work colleagues who haven't had children yet that are the most Judgmental with all their Id never let my future perfect children act like that comments. Stupid Twats.

calmcoco · 15/08/2023 18:04

They feel angry, scared and overwhelmed due to emotional disregulation. Which is why staying outside the car, ignoring, being cold is the wrong approach IMO.

I think warmth is better than coldness.

VibrantGreen · 15/08/2023 17:59

DS also used to have night terrors!

2am screaming, nothing and I mean NOTHING would sooth him. And again, if I tried to sooth it exacerbated the screaming.

Fucking awful times.

DS is now 16, diagnosed with ADHD a couple of years ago. Thankfully tantrums are a thing of the past.

LaTartine · 15/08/2023 17:59

ChekhovsMum · 15/08/2023 17:31

Nope. When you’re overwhelmed, tired and angry, your family don’t ignore you until you’ve ‘calmed down’, do they? Because calming down in that scenario would mean swallowing your emotions and never really dealing with them, and you wouldn’t learn much except that you couldn’t have feelings around those people. I don’t think it’s the way to react to a tantrum at all.

I disagree
Allow the child their anger, don't invalidate it by trying to talk to them or calm them.
They feel angry, scared and overwhelmed due to emotional disregulation.
Keep them safe,your self safe and wait.
Once they calm down, then acknowledge their feelings.
Crikey if you were angry or upset would you want someone in your face.
Give them space.

calmcoco · 15/08/2023 17:58

Merapi · 15/08/2023 17:48

Toddlers in the middle of a tantrum cannot process anything at all, let alone their own feelings. There is no reasoning with a toddler. You have to calmly wait for the storm to be over, largely because they are screaming so loudly they can't hear you.

With all due respect, toddlers do have to learn to control their emotions, and that they cannot always have what they want. They have to learn that no amount of tantrumming will get them their own way. They need to learn to control their feelings.

You need to take them away from the source of temptation (which this woman did), you need to put them in a safe environment where they won't hurt themselves or others while thrashing about (which this woman did), and you then need to stand close by calmy waiting for the hurricane to die down (which is what the woman was doing).

What you describe is only one way to respond to tantrums.

There are other ways that maintain an emotional connection.

FabFitFifties · 15/08/2023 17:54

I'd assume mam was doing the best she could in a stressful situation - personally I would rather sit in the car with the child and offer comfort and distraction, but I wouldn't judge this mam - it might of been the only way she could stay calm herself.

Merapi · 15/08/2023 17:48

ChekhovsMum · 15/08/2023 17:31

Nope. When you’re overwhelmed, tired and angry, your family don’t ignore you until you’ve ‘calmed down’, do they? Because calming down in that scenario would mean swallowing your emotions and never really dealing with them, and you wouldn’t learn much except that you couldn’t have feelings around those people. I don’t think it’s the way to react to a tantrum at all.

Toddlers in the middle of a tantrum cannot process anything at all, let alone their own feelings. There is no reasoning with a toddler. You have to calmly wait for the storm to be over, largely because they are screaming so loudly they can't hear you.

With all due respect, toddlers do have to learn to control their emotions, and that they cannot always have what they want. They have to learn that no amount of tantrumming will get them their own way. They need to learn to control their feelings.

You need to take them away from the source of temptation (which this woman did), you need to put them in a safe environment where they won't hurt themselves or others while thrashing about (which this woman did), and you then need to stand close by calmy waiting for the hurricane to die down (which is what the woman was doing).

VibrantGreen · 15/08/2023 17:48

I’ve had the same when DS used to have mammoth tantrums, so I would have felt for her and walked on by with no judgement.

I used to get ‘the look’ too from some passers-by, I used to zone out from all around me as I knew people would be staring. I would remain calm until the tantrum passed. No amount of talking would have made a difference to DS though, he just had to calm down by himself, then peace resumed.

Bubop · 15/08/2023 17:48

I think it would have been better to hold the child or sit next to them whilst they were upset (depending on personality of the child). But I think the women who commented were massively overreacting.

AnotherVice · 15/08/2023 17:45

@Merapi well quite, leaving the shop and going for a little walk rather than wrestling them into a car seat. They only 'calm down' when they're exhausted and defeated.

PoshPineapple · 15/08/2023 17:45

@ChekhovsMum

Again, out of curiosity what would you have done in this environment and situation? I honestly don't think I would have known what else to do but this, with any of mine.

OP posts:
LaTartine · 15/08/2023 17:43

calmcoco · 15/08/2023 17:23

This description from @AnotherVice punishment, isolation and restraint is brutally phrased but accurate.

I just don't get this
What punishment?
Isolation -she remained nearby and interacted
Restraint -it's a car park, should the child have been allowed to run off?

PoshPineapple · 15/08/2023 17:38

@Perfectweatherforducks

True enough and a good point.

OP posts:
funinthesun19 · 15/08/2023 17:37

She put her dd in a safe place to ride out her big tantrum. Somewhere where she can’t run on to the road or throw something in the shop while she’s in that angry zone. Somewhere away from other people who might have stook their oar in or complained. She handled it perfectly.

PoshPineapple · 15/08/2023 17:36

@CoodleMoodle

he was like an angry bloody octopus

This made me laugh. A lot! 😂

OP posts:
ChekhovsMum · 15/08/2023 17:31

Nope. When you’re overwhelmed, tired and angry, your family don’t ignore you until you’ve ‘calmed down’, do they? Because calming down in that scenario would mean swallowing your emotions and never really dealing with them, and you wouldn’t learn much except that you couldn’t have feelings around those people. I don’t think it’s the way to react to a tantrum at all.

calmcoco · 15/08/2023 17:23

This description from @AnotherVice punishment, isolation and restraint is brutally phrased but accurate.

Swipe left for the next trending thread