Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Toddler having a huge tantrum...just interested, nothing more

90 replies

PoshPineapple · 15/08/2023 16:45

So, outside Hobbycraft earlier and a lady came out of the shop with a beetroot red, apoplectic toddler in her arms - the screams were pretty ear piercing to be honest!

Mum calmly straps toddler into her car seat and leaves the door slight ajar but stays outside the car herself. Mum largely ignores the scream-fest but periodically pops her head in and repeatedly says "we'll go back inside when you've calmed down" and the like.

I thought "how calmly Mum is dealing with this". However, a couple of other women were walking back to their car, and as they passed me I heard one of them remark "Oh god, that poor child, that woman needs reporting, it's almost neglect" "How can people treat their kids like that" etc.

It dawned on me just how very different every parent parents. I was genuinely admiring of Mum to have calmly removed her daughter from a distressing situation and let her simply ride it out without any fuss or drama, yet these other women obviously regarded it as near-on child abuse.

I know there's no wrong or right, but it's got me pondering and I'm genuinely curious how you would have regarded this?

OP posts:
Hibiscrubbed · 15/08/2023 19:12

I completely and utterly ignore tantrums. If he’s safe, not disturbing anyone and not breaking anything, I will walk away and leave him to it. He will come over to me when he’s finished and we’ll have a cuddle and move on. As a result, he’s only had about four. This is likely luck as well as temperament on his part.

One was in a shop when he was sick and very tired and I carried him outside, plonked him on the floor and let him get it out of his system. An old woman going past on a scooter told him to ‘shut the fuck up.’ 😂

I think that woman dealt with it brilliantly. Really calmly. The silly women walking past were stupid.

Blueuggboots · 15/08/2023 19:11

I would have smiled at her and given her encouragement such as "gosh, it's hard isn't it? You're doing a great job" or the like.

crostini · 15/08/2023 19:11

A lot of toddlers will not allow you to hold or cuddle them in the middle of a tantrum. They can't hear anything you're saying because they're screaming so loud.
People saying, cuddle them etc have not dealt with a certain caliber of tantrum.
We cuddle and talk it through after, but yes, tantrums for us are about making sure they're safe and waiting for it to pass. I don't try and rush the tantrum though, I let them get it out their system in their own time.

LuvSmallDogs · 15/08/2023 19:08

When my autistic son gets upset when we're out and about, I put him in his SEN buggy and move it back and forth while saying "it's ok I know it's hard". He uses his buggy as a safe space when we're out and about, and wants to go in it when he's overwhelmed. He doesn't want cuddles or kisses when he's upset, he pushes people out of his personal space or worse...

In a way, what this mum did is quite similar. She took her child to a "home from home" safe space wjere they couldn't hurt themselves or other to calm down, and reassured the child that they could go back when they had calmed down.

coxesorangepippin · 15/08/2023 19:06

I'd do what the mum did, only I'd just go home, not back in the shop

They're too little to get the whole psychology of that

JayJayEl · 15/08/2023 19:05

This just popped up on 'Trending' not long after my two year old has just had his first ever "proper" tantrum. Ha! My partner and I responded in much the same way as the parent you described in the OP, and now my toddler is with his other parent, happily eating his tea. (Luckily I'd made double so it didn't matter too much that the kitchen is wearing his first portion! 🙈) In my opinion, the other women sound like judgemental twats.

LaTartine · 15/08/2023 19:03

MyrrAgain · 15/08/2023 18:56

Imaginary non-existent children are always easier to parent than the real ones.
So yes, these people were tests.

Haha ain't that the truth!

MyrrAgain · 15/08/2023 18:57

*twats 🤦‍♀️

MyrrAgain · 15/08/2023 18:56

Imaginary non-existent children are always easier to parent than the real ones.
So yes, these people were tests.

LaTartine · 15/08/2023 18:54

calmcoco · 15/08/2023 18:48

Obviously everything is child specific. You keep going on about 'cuddling' but that's only if it suits a particular kid, for example.

I work with people who display challenging behaviour. This is a completely inappropriate comparison. A toddler having a tantrum is not displaying challenging behaviour, they're displaying developmentally appropriate behaviour.

If someone parented toddlers in the way a professional would deal with people who display challenging behaviour that would be all sorts of wrong.

I used the word challenging to describe the behaviour of the children I care for with SEN, they are people .
The behaviour is challenging to manage, the toddlers behaviour was challenging.
Its not a nasty thing to call either age appropriate or unregulated emotions challenging.
its the end result on those around them.

Obviously you just wanted to say she was wrong but have nothing different to offer.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 15/08/2023 18:53

calmcoco · 15/08/2023 18:04

They feel angry, scared and overwhelmed due to emotional disregulation. Which is why staying outside the car, ignoring, being cold is the wrong approach IMO.

I think warmth is better than coldness.

If I'd tried picking up and cuddling DD when she was like that, I'd have ended up with a broken nose and probably dropped her on her head in the process.

She wore an old fashioned set of reins as she was a flight risk at the best of times and sometimes I'd have to lift from behind and carry her out of harm's way, place her down somewhere safe (whilst remaining out of range of angry feet and head) and let it run its course. She'd then benefit from the release of hormones from crying, the physical effort and quiet resolution - and I'd benefit from having handled the situation with my nasal cartilage still intact.

Some people do not do being smothered and trapped. I don't want to be grabbed and constricted when I'm angry, frustrated or freaking out about something, either.

WutheredOut · 15/08/2023 18:49

I once had that toddler and one day I was in a shop just desperately trying to jeep calm.

He was screaming the place down… land had escaped from his buggy

An older lady walked up to us bent down to his level and said ‘this isn’t very kind your poor mummy is doing her very best’, and then she strapped him back into his buggy

he was so shocked by the whole thing I didn’t hear a peep out of him again.

Angels live amongst us!

calmcoco · 15/08/2023 18:48

LaTartine · 15/08/2023 18:34

I asked what you would do differently though?
Cuddle them, talk to them?

I've never met a toddler in many years of parenting who was full on tantrumming who would have been eased with cuddling.
They weren't a bit miffed, they were beetroot red and screaming.

I work with people who display challenging behaviour .
Never approach an angry person who has lost control, make them as safe as you can, ensure your own safety.
Reassure them you are nearby, allow the feelings to be expressed and then discuss, comfort etc.
I'm genuinely interested as to how or why you did things differently?

Obviously everything is child specific. You keep going on about 'cuddling' but that's only if it suits a particular kid, for example.

I work with people who display challenging behaviour. This is a completely inappropriate comparison. A toddler having a tantrum is not displaying challenging behaviour, they're displaying developmentally appropriate behaviour.

If someone parented toddlers in the way a professional would deal with people who display challenging behaviour that would be all sorts of wrong.

whatwhatinthebutt · 15/08/2023 18:45

Children are challenging, they don't understand or care about what we do. So it happens frequently that they get like that, and how you deal with it depends on how the day is going

.One day you're that woman - I sat with mine for ten minutes in a shop explaining why she cannot have a toy or a treat every time we enter a shop.

Another day it could become a huge stress and you burst and shout at them.

LaTartine · 15/08/2023 18:34

calmcoco · 15/08/2023 18:24

I can't see the point of labouring it.

People parent differently is the message of the thread.

I asked what you would do differently though?
Cuddle them, talk to them?

I've never met a toddler in many years of parenting who was full on tantrumming who would have been eased with cuddling.
They weren't a bit miffed, they were beetroot red and screaming.

I work with people who display challenging behaviour .
Never approach an angry person who has lost control, make them as safe as you can, ensure your own safety.
Reassure them you are nearby, allow the feelings to be expressed and then discuss, comfort etc.
I'm genuinely interested as to how or why you did things differently?

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 15/08/2023 18:28

AnotherVice · 15/08/2023 17:45

@Merapi well quite, leaving the shop and going for a little walk rather than wrestling them into a car seat. They only 'calm down' when they're exhausted and defeated.

ROFL at being able to take a tantrumming toddler 'for a little walk'.

If they're ok to walk, holding hands, then it's not a tantrum.

Jamtartforme · 15/08/2023 18:27

ChekhovsMum · 15/08/2023 17:31

Nope. When you’re overwhelmed, tired and angry, your family don’t ignore you until you’ve ‘calmed down’, do they? Because calming down in that scenario would mean swallowing your emotions and never really dealing with them, and you wouldn’t learn much except that you couldn’t have feelings around those people. I don’t think it’s the way to react to a tantrum at all.

That’s because adults don’t have tantrums over a cat only having 4 legs. There’s nothing to work through with a toddler and they won’t understand emotion-speak anyway. I just let DD thrash around on her bed and told her I would give her a cuddle when she was ready.

IceReckon · 15/08/2023 18:26

I would think it was a bit uncaring, but that's coming from the experience of 2 children who wouldn't scream like that in a tantrum, and one child who does but has significant learning difficulties and autism.

So my first thought if the mum wasn't able to calm the child to that extent and the child is in a proper meltdown would be why isn't she bothering to help the child through it, however I can see why if someone has had a child where they act like that through bad behaviour rather than genuine distress then they wouldn't view it the same? Just haven't come across that with ours.

Cowlover89 · 15/08/2023 18:26

She did the right thing.

calmcoco · 15/08/2023 18:24

LaTartine · 15/08/2023 18:18

If the toddler was having a full on tantrum it's likely they would be hit or kicked.

She made him safe, allowed him to express his emotions and was calm.

What would you have done?
Cuddle -likely whack in the face plus it is invalidating their feelings.

I can't see the point of labouring it.

People parent differently is the message of the thread.

Pufflebow · 15/08/2023 18:21

The passers by are idiots

there are children actually being abused, letting a child calm down, wether you agree with the ‘time out’ sort of parenting style or not is not abuse and it’s ridiculous to say otherwise.

even saying you feel sorry for the kid is a bit much. Who knows what’s been happening. Maybe mum normally gentle parents (though of course if she does lots will be quick to judge that too) but maybe she’s got nothing left in the tank, and just staying calm, slightly removed from the noise and anxiety of it, outside of the car is all she can manage right now. Who knows. So I’d mind my own business, but I’d lean more to your opinion op.

10HailMarys · 15/08/2023 18:20

Mummy08m · 15/08/2023 18:09

Yanbu OP in that there's more than one good way to deal with tantrums and Car Mum's way isn't abusive or neglectful or anything like that.

However it's not my preferred way. My preferred way is to lean in and try and understand what dd wants. I can't understand at first because she's screaming so much she can't articulate the words properly. So she forces herself to calm down to say it clearly (whew, the worst is over). Then depending what it is, if it's actually a fairly reasonable or harmless thing then I give her the thing. If it's not then I try to explain (briefly) why I can't, which sometimes reignites the tantrum but usually at a reduced magnitude.

However I do have a short temper myself so if I just can't stay calm enough to do my Plan A then Car Mum's method is my Plan B.

We don’t know what happened before Car Mum put her child in the car, though, do we? She may well have tried your Plan A and the car thing was her Plan B too.

I think the vast majority of parents probably do try to establish why the child is upset and attempt to explain why that can’t be fixed for them before they have to resort to the Plan B.

LaTartine · 15/08/2023 18:19

ALifeofChaos · 15/08/2023 18:17

I used to wonder how anyone could do that.

Like @Bubop said - best to hold or be near them.

I always soothed my first.

Second one is completely different. If I try that she gets madder ans sometimes more dangerousto herself throwing her head back to the floor! Actually wants her own space even if she's looking like she's possessed on the floor!

The anount of times I feel I must be failing her because she doesn't want comfort during a tantrum...

Oh gosh the toddler head butt as well.
Ouch -eye watering!

VibrantGreen · 15/08/2023 18:19

calmcoco · 15/08/2023 18:13

Coldness is simply my description. My view is that is an unhelpfully cold response.

I chose to do it differently.

I managed without getting kicked or hit!

Good for you and I mean that.

That wouldn’t have worked for DS though.

I don’t class the response as cold, I class it as calmly taking control of the situation, even with the judgement of others.

Some toddlers DO calm down with a cuddle or a hug, for others this would likely (and in DS’s case) make the situation much worse and prolong the tantrum. THAT’s what happened in our case.

It doesn’t make you a better parent, it’s because our DC are very different.

LaTartine · 15/08/2023 18:18

calmcoco · 15/08/2023 18:13

Coldness is simply my description. My view is that is an unhelpfully cold response.

I chose to do it differently.

I managed without getting kicked or hit!

If the toddler was having a full on tantrum it's likely they would be hit or kicked.

She made him safe, allowed him to express his emotions and was calm.

What would you have done?
Cuddle -likely whack in the face plus it is invalidating their feelings.