Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that this cannot be justifiable?! Insurance

81 replies

PyongyangKipperbang · 15/08/2023 12:36

I stayed with the same car insurance for three years as the price was about the same as when I did price comparison, had had good service from them and it had some good extras. ,

This year, nothing changed except another years no claims, and they have tripled the price! Its almost £1500! I know that sometimes renewals get loaded as some people are just lazy and dont bother changing, and in fairness I might have done the same if the increase was roughly in line with inflation (although would have checked others just in case) , but that much is just ridiculous surely no one would go for it?!

I am 50, no claims or convictions, same car as last year so no change there, there is literally no reason why it would go up. I wondered if it was my age but I cant see that turning 50 should have that much of an impact and I have done price comparison and that is coming out roughly (well a little more) than last year, so if it is my age no other insurance companies are bothered! Obviously will be changing. But when I called they said that it was "industry standard" increase and were adamant that that was the only price they could quote. Got the impression when I said what prices I had had from comparison websites that they thought I was lying to try and get them to lower their price!

OP posts:
Summerrainagain1 · 15/08/2023 18:13

I thought this was just a known thing that all insurers do. They make money on people not bothering to keep an eye on their policy renewal and pricing. It sounds excessive yes, but just shop around for something else. Even calling them normally brings down the price, at least a bit.

toomanydicksonthedancefloor1 · 15/08/2023 18:11

Is it a Land Rover? Insurance companies are just starting to pass on massive increases for LR cars. Their keyless entry systems make the cars ridiculously easy to steal. We are a small independent motor trader and we keep all LRs locked up behind locked gates and in a locked garage at all times unless a customer wants to see it. Some of the big insurance companies, I think it was Aviva I heard mentioned, are just about to impose a 15% excess on any claims involving theft of Land Rovers, this is on a motor trade policy.

A friend of ours has a 'collectors' insurance policy to cover his collection of prestige cars which includes Ferrari, Bentley, McLaren, Porsche. The only exclusion on his policy is no single car over £1,000,000 and no Land Rovers!

So I imagine these increases are about to filter in to the consumer insurance industry too. It's disgusting and Land Rover should be forced to rectify this issue.

If it's not a Land Rover do you mind me asking what type of car it is?

LittleLegsKeepGoing · 15/08/2023 18:05

My renewal quote was double this year compared with last year. That's not in keeping with inflation at all and at least 6 other insurance companies quoted me at a more reasonable rate that was around what I expected the inflation linked price to be.

Unsurprisingly I've switched and frankly I'll never return to that insurer even if they suddenly become the cheapest in the future.

Defiantlynot41 · 15/08/2023 18:05

Sorry, cocked up the link there, try this one www.moneysavingexpert.com/insurance/car-insurance/

Defiantlynot41 · 15/08/2023 18:04

I'd really, really recommend everyone goes to the Martin Lewis site and uses his method https://www.moneysavingexpert.com/insurance/car-insurance/]

It's the best way to ensure you have the best price.

It might surprise most people to know that in the UK, most motor insurers make a loss or break even most years, and insurers pay out millions every day.

Fightyouforthatpie · 15/08/2023 17:51

PearTreeBoat · 15/08/2023 14:23

It's due to how insurance works.

The high street insurance companies have underwriters who are in effect setting the insurance prices for the companies.

Insurance is all about risk, they are not saying all of a sudden they think you are much more likely to have an accident than you were last year. In simple terms the underwriters will look at what claims the insurance company had to payout for and therefore determine the risk (or likelihood) of claims within those categories again.

For example if the insurance company had had a lot of claims from females, 48-52, driving a similar class car to you and living within the same rough geographical area then the risk/likelihood of other females 48-52 in the same area with similar cars making a claim is higher.

Obviously each insurance company is risk assessed based on their own claims hence the disparity in the quotes from different companies.

Nice theory but isn't it odd how all this results in everyone getting quoted a big increase? It's almost as if they all decided it was time to make a bit more money.

FatherJackHackettsUnderpantsHamper · 15/08/2023 17:51

It's wrong that they all take advantage of people who either don't have time or even know how to check that they're getting a good deal.

I rather suspect that a lot of insurance companies' models have it firmly baked in to their calculations that they fully expect to massively exploit elderly, disabled and other vulnerable people. It's disgusting.

FatherJackHackettsUnderpantsHamper · 15/08/2023 17:49

This gives some rationale to the massive price hikes. A Core Operating Ratio (COR) of more than 100% means they're losing money. 106% = £1.06 spent for every £1 premium paid.

I've heard these claims before. If this is the case, why do they bother staying in the market at all? And why the discrepancy between different companies? Why are the unknown ones so desperate to grab your custom from another company if your being with them will lose them money?

I'd understand it a lot more if they treated your first year as a loss-leader and then tried to keep you loyal for the next 40 years with reasonable small annual increases until they got to a sustainable level; but we all know that, for whatever reason, they prefer to kill the golden goose and drive you away after the first year, then spend loads of money in advertising and admin in getting new customers for their one single year with them.

Ffsmakeitstop · 15/08/2023 17:45

I've had this with car breakdown cover. Whichever one we're with every time it's due to renew it goes up at least double. I always ring, one year I managed to get family cover for £18 a month with an extra 3 months free because I have no problems swapping. It's wrong that they all take advantage of people who either don't have time or even know how to check that they're getting a good deal.

FatherJackHackettsUnderpantsHamper · 15/08/2023 17:43

If you're in a position to be able to pay annually, when you take out the policy and they say "We have a helpful auto-renew feature, to avoid you running the risk of not being insured when the policy expires", make sure you tell them to remove this and not to store your card details.

We all know what they're like and how contemptuous they are of loyal customers, so no point in putting the power in their hands to do it again by default next year - make them at least work to keep your custom, and not just assume that it's theirs by rights.

Greendoorsaremyfavourite · 15/08/2023 17:27

https://www.insurancetimes.co.uk/news/tough-2023-predicted-for-motor-insurance-market-as-high-cor-forecast/1444822.article

This gives some rationale to the massive price hikes. A Core Operating Ratio (COR) of more than 100% means they're losing money. 106% = £1.06 spent for every £1 premium paid.

It's not just the vehicle costs that have to be taken into account...there are injury and credit hire costs which cause the costs to sky rocket too.

fragmented broken pricing piggy

‘Tough’ 2023 predicted for motor insurance market as high COR forecast

'This is undeniably a tough time to be a motor insurer,' says business management consultant firm

https://www.insurancetimes.co.uk/news/tough-2023-predicted-for-motor-insurance-market-as-high-cor-forecast/1444822.article

enchantedsquirrelwood · 15/08/2023 17:18

I had this a few years ago with my home insurance. I phoned them up and they knocked a lot off; I said "please don't do this again because I WILL phone and I WILL leave if you offer me an unreasonable price again".

Who knows if they put a note on my account but the following year the premium was reasonable, maybe an extra £50 for the year. So it is worth calling.

I did notice it went up by quite a lot again this year (in June) - whereas the car insurance went down (Feb) but my car is quite old now. Our other car renewal is due in September so we'll see what happens with that one.

itsgettingweird · 15/08/2023 17:15

My last car insurance company did this. They said if I didn't want to continue with them to cancel via online.

I couldn't cancel via online because their crap!

I found a cheaper one (they were all 10% higher but like you say inflation)

I rang to cancel.

They wouldn't cancel and kept asking me loads of questions about my renewal quotes elsewhere. I to,d them I'd already renewed and just wanted to cancel for next year before the first of next month so it was in time.

It was relentless. My mum had just died and I didn't want the hassle.

In the end I told them if they cared what my renewals were they should have done a proper assessment of the costs and not just assumed they could increase and I'd stay with them and if they could offer me at a level that I've renewed at elsewhere they should have tripled the cost!

The woman still wouldn't cancel unless I gave them my renewal price elsewhere and kept going on about how I had a cooling off period and I could cancel the other policy.

In the end I told them I refused to answer, was recording this message, deleting the direct debit and if they continued to ask me personal questions and didn't cancel I would be reporting them to the ombudsman.

And hung up!

This year I got a quote with the current one that was inline with inflation and only found 1 more cheaper (by £5) so wasn't worth the hassle of changing!

FatherJackHackettsUnderpantsHamper · 15/08/2023 17:00

Mine was Admiral too (see post at 15:38). I haven’t shopped around yet because it is a multi policy so it is a bit more time consuming.

I've always suspected that, despite the sales patter, the multi policies are chiefly designed to make it better for them - and harder/more confusing or time-consuming to compare or leave - and not for your convenience or money saving at all.

FlyingFlamingo · 15/08/2023 16:56

I just renewed. I’ve been with Direct Line for years and my renewal quote was nearly double last years, I phoned them to query it and said I’ve found a quote elsewhere for roughly what I paid last year with you and the call handler said she couldn’t match it because ‘we have a higher level of service’…I said not £400 worth and took the cheaper quote (with Flow, they are part of LV I think and get good reviews, they were the second cheapest but the other company got poor ratings for claim handling)

I can believe it’s partly down to the cost of parts though - my car has recently been returned to me after 5 months waiting for a part due to an electric fault (luckily under warranty!)

Swimbius · 15/08/2023 16:56

Mine is admiral too, but seem to be getting the same price on comparison sites too 😢

Aprilx · 15/08/2023 16:53

CakAndMoreCake · 15/08/2023 16:48

Admiral doubled mine after it had been stable for years. Shopping around I’ve paid less than last year

@CakAndMoreCake
Mine was Admiral too (see post at 15:38). I haven’t shopped around yet because it is a multi policy so it is a bit more time consuming.

JustAnotherUsey · 15/08/2023 16:51

The quote I got was more than double last years. About £900. I went to Aviva zero for about £450 in the end. Last year was £350. Very annoying.

Knackeredhamster · 15/08/2023 16:50

I know of a case where the insurance renewal came in the post. Call it 260 compared to 160 last year.

Old car, 15 yrs NCD and very safe postcode.

Customer rang up insurance company to ask if they could do it any cheaper at all. This was bearing in mind that over the quote was always slightly lowered by phoning up.

They quoted £600.

I don't get that scenario at all.

It's just numbers it seems like!

CakAndMoreCake · 15/08/2023 16:48

Admiral doubled mine after it had been stable for years. Shopping around I’ve paid less than last year

FatherJackHackettsUnderpantsHamper · 15/08/2023 16:39

So each year ones of their businesses they'll pump up the prices for everyone and in this way can charge their old loyal customers higher prices. And obviously new customers wont choose them. But via their other names can still attract new customers.

Hmm, that's very interesting - makes perfect mathematical sense, as long as you leave any trace of morals and fairness locked safely away.

So might that be the explanation for some (even most) of the random unknown companies that always come up as the cheapest on comparison sites - the ones with amateurish names like 'Cheap Cover 4 U' - are they just the big, well-known companies with a different brand name?

I mean, you need immense reserves to become an insurance company, don't you - it's not like Bob from down the road getting fed up of the prices at the local cafes and so getting his own second-hand snack trailer from eBay to pitch up outside the park and undercut the others, is it?!

PyongyangKipperbang · 15/08/2023 16:15

Summerwhereareyou · 15/08/2023 14:16

I take it people are looking the month beofe it's expiring and not leaving it till the last min?

Yeah its not due until 10 September.

OP posts:
Bonfire23 · 15/08/2023 15:45

Set up a Quidco account
Shop via that and use it to go to confused and go compare
Input all your details (tedious for year 1) and get the quote and you'll get Quidco cashback if you take out the policy
Then following years just go via Quidco again, the comparison sites have the details and it's loads quicker

lookingfordairymilk · 15/08/2023 15:39

Had the same very recently. They said it was because of other claims. I hadn't made a single one!

Aprilx · 15/08/2023 15:38

I took out a multiple policy a few years ago, it seemed to make sense so I have two cars and the house insurance linked up. My renewal is 1st September and it just came through for £1500 versus £900 last year. The cars don’t seem too bad, it seems to be the house that has increased. No claims made.