Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Get your child period ready

133 replies

Autumnsoon · 15/08/2023 11:36

That is the advert flashing up on Mumsnet ,next to threads I’m looking at
since when did they start using child ,rather than daughter
ffs .
how many boys need to be got ready for their period age 10 ,
,so just say daughter ,girl ,woman …
are they trying to be subtle so we don’t notice the change in language
fucks me of no end

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
16
StephanieSuperpowers · 18/08/2023 15:57

HootyMcBooby76 · 16/08/2023 10:56

Interesting article, thanks. Especially this bit:

"Instead, Sex Redefined is about obfuscation and replacement: first, obscuring sex by overwhelming the reader with a vast array of scientific information irrelevant to the argument, and second, replacing sex with the completely unrelated political ideology of gender identity. Sex Replaced would have been a more appropriate title."

It's been fascinatingly successful. Even years after it has been fully debunked, it is still being referenced by the credulous to prove that you can't really say what sex anyone is, can you, because like, any number of them, yanno, so...

HootyMcBooby76 · 16/08/2023 10:56

Interesting article, thanks. Especially this bit:

"Instead, Sex Redefined is about obfuscation and replacement: first, obscuring sex by overwhelming the reader with a vast array of scientific information irrelevant to the argument, and second, replacing sex with the completely unrelated political ideology of gender identity. Sex Replaced would have been a more appropriate title."

Sueveneers · 16/08/2023 01:29

Weatherwax134 · 15/08/2023 13:44

Lol here's your article- unless 'what you reckon' means you know better than people who work in this field as specialists? Sex Redefined: The Idea of 2 Sexes Is Overly Simplistic - Scientific American

@Weatherwax134 And here is the response to that junk science 'article' from an ACTUAL specialist in the field: https://www.theparadoxinstitute.com/read/a-response-to-natures-sex-redefined

You're welcome.

A Response to Nature’s ‘Sex Redefined’ — Paradox Institute

A scientific rebuttal of Nature’s famous piece, “Sex Redefined: The Idea of Two Sexes Is Overly Simplistic.”

https://www.theparadoxinstitute.com/read/a-response-to-natures-sex-redefined

OsirisservesAnubis · 15/08/2023 22:33

I read "child" as being aimed at younger than teen age and also to be inclusive of those whose 'child' is not their daughter, due to being a foster child, granddaughter, step kids etc.

StillHereStillBreathing · 15/08/2023 16:42

Louder, then, for those in the back:

Only laydeez get periods!

Only men have penises!

HootyMcBooby76 · 15/08/2023 16:38

Yes, exactly. The article has been consistently misinterpreted and used as a "gotcha" when in fact all it does is state what biologists already know. That DSDs/VSDs are SEX SPECIFIC and actually prove the sexual binary, not disprove it.
There are male DSDs and female DSDs. Just because something has gone wrong along that pathway does not change the fact that they are either male or female. True hermaphrodism does not exist in homo sapiens, and nobody has EVER existed that produced both functioning gametes or something else entirely.
The current estimates are 0.018% of live births, and even within that microscopic figure there exists an even more microscopic segment whose genitals are unidentifiable, and even then with the advent of karyotyping, we know if they are male or female.
There is no third sex.
DSDs do not prove anything, and they certainly don't prove anything about trans culture, because as we all know, the incidence of DSDs is exactly the same in the trans population as it is in the rest of the population.
And as we know, the DSD community has repeatedly asked not be be brought into this debate.

All of this is part of the reason that the old term "intersex" is being phased out by the medical community. There IS no "inter" sex. We are learning more about DSDs every year and we know now that there are, and have only ever been, two sexes.
And the push to include things like PCOS and other common conditions in order to artificially inflate the DSD statistics is an underhand ploy by certain groups in order that the claim could be made that you are practically pushing DSD sufferers out of your way as you walk along the street. Again an attempt to erode the sexual binary and erode the lines between what it is to be a male or female and manufacture a useful "spectrum" which affirms that narrative.

They are, and remain, exceedingly rare conditions.

StillHereStillBreathing · 15/08/2023 16:36

Men and boys can't get periods. Girls and women who identify as boys and men can get periods but they are not actual boys and men . You can't change sex.

JohnnyYenSetHimselfOnFireAgain · 15/08/2023 16:31

Sueveneers · 15/08/2023 16:30

What is your suggestion? That we should say girl +disabled, +guardian raised children? A paragraph long sentence to describe every single infinite base?

Do you really lack the ability to understand that your argument that every single qualifier be used, is bullshit? A female child with disabilities is still....a female. Your argument makes zero sense. And surely you must know that on some level. Saying girl or female, is the way to get over this problem easily, and uncontroversially.

Spot on.

Sueveneers · 15/08/2023 16:30

JanieEyre · 15/08/2023 15:47

Way to be inclusive. Let's not bother to cater for disabled people, shall we, because the majority of people aren't disabled. Let's not bother to modify our language to leave out racist terms, because the majority of people who hear it won't be of the race concerned. Let's not worry about making it clear that both men and women can apply for traditionally male jobs, because the majority of women won't want to.

Can you see how this argument just doesn't work, particularly when you can get over the problem so easily and uncontroversially?

What is your suggestion? That we should say girl +disabled, +guardian raised children? A paragraph long sentence to describe every single infinite base?

Do you really lack the ability to understand that your argument that every single qualifier be used, is bullshit? A female child with disabilities is still....a female. Your argument makes zero sense. And surely you must know that on some level. Saying girl or female, is the way to get over this problem easily, and uncontroversially.

Sueveneers · 15/08/2023 16:26

I am waiting on further clarification from a geneticist however in regards to the article posted from 'Scientific American', there is this from the author of the article. "The best reply to this article is the author herself denying the idiotic way people quote it and use it lol Remember, Claire Ainsworth, the author of the "Sex Redefined" piece in Nature that gender activists like to tout as undeniable proof that there are more than 2 sexes, has explicitly rejected that interpretation of her article."

Get your child period ready
StillHereStillBreathing · 15/08/2023 16:24

Only Women Bleed.

RoseslnTheHospital · 15/08/2023 16:20

@JanieEyre periods aren't inclusive. They happen to girls and women, female humans only. Companies like Always are marketing their products to the female half of the population. It's ok to use the words that apply to that half of the population.

Removing terms that discriminated against women is not the same thing.

nothingcomestonothing · 15/08/2023 16:15

HootyMcBooby76 · 15/08/2023 15:33

It's trying to de-couple women and girls from their biology so that anyone claiming to be a woman or girl can have access to that category without having to fulfill the biological necessity of being a female.

ANYONE can be a woman if they say so, it's not about biology etc etc.

It's been going on for a long time and this is just another example.
It's NOTHING to do with people raising girls who are not their daughters. People have been doing that for centuries and we have never felt the need (before now) to start changing language on the off chance that an Aunt somewhere will feel hugely offended that she was "excluded".

It's ALL about the current ideology and anyone who doesn't see this is being disingenuous.

This.

It's not about being inclusive to non traditional families, it's about erasing the terms for human females. As the '1 in 3 individuals' makes clear, because they mean 1 in 3 female individuals, don't they? So why don't they say that? (rhetorical question).

JanieEyre · 15/08/2023 15:47

Sueveneers · 15/08/2023 13:26

And it's not uncommon for the website template/sections to say women/girls, tht could have been there for years, and someone now adding on a section that has differing language. The paragraph is the most recent, and it's quite telling. As to how many are raising nieces/grand daughters/foster daughters etc, I wager that the overwhelming majority of girls are raised by their mums, so why not cater to the majority? It's not like a grandmother/aunt/foster mum can't figure out what it means anyway.

Way to be inclusive. Let's not bother to cater for disabled people, shall we, because the majority of people aren't disabled. Let's not bother to modify our language to leave out racist terms, because the majority of people who hear it won't be of the race concerned. Let's not worry about making it clear that both men and women can apply for traditionally male jobs, because the majority of women won't want to.

Can you see how this argument just doesn't work, particularly when you can get over the problem so easily and uncontroversially?

Peony654 · 15/08/2023 15:35

YABU. Who cares. And all children should learn about periods

Merkins · 15/08/2023 15:33

JohnnyYenSetHimselfOnFireAgain · 15/08/2023 14:30

"Time to get your girl period-ready." Sorted.

Absolutely not. I would say “my child”, but not “my girl”. God help anyone who referred to her as “your girl”. Yuck. I don’t know why, but it sounds incredibly creepy.

HootyMcBooby76 · 15/08/2023 15:33

MysteryBelle · 15/08/2023 15:16

Daughter, not child. Girl, not individual. What are the powers that be trying to do here?

It's trying to de-couple women and girls from their biology so that anyone claiming to be a woman or girl can have access to that category without having to fulfill the biological necessity of being a female.

ANYONE can be a woman if they say so, it's not about biology etc etc.

It's been going on for a long time and this is just another example.
It's NOTHING to do with people raising girls who are not their daughters. People have been doing that for centuries and we have never felt the need (before now) to start changing language on the off chance that an Aunt somewhere will feel hugely offended that she was "excluded".

It's ALL about the current ideology and anyone who doesn't see this is being disingenuous.

StillHereStillBreathing · 15/08/2023 15:16

Signef · 15/08/2023 14:05

Even 25 years ago it was ingrained in teachers that not all kids are raised by their mums and dads.

It didn't need to be ingrained . Much further back than 25 years ago many children not a small minority had lost a parent or both. Many. We are lucky now to have fewer parents dying young due to our good standard of living.

MysteryBelle · 15/08/2023 15:16

Daughter, not child. Girl, not individual. What are the powers that be trying to do here?

MysteryBelle · 15/08/2023 15:15

Who are these insane people who put themselves in charge of our language and are essentially telling us to stop using words like daughter, mother, female, woman or replacing them with made up words that prop up some weird agenda? Making everyone androgynous or fluid or the opposite of what we are.

RoseslnTheHospital · 15/08/2023 15:06

This is the text from the advert's click through link:

"Let’s talk first periods

On the journey of growing up, the road is paved with a myriad of emotions, and for many young people, the first period can be an overwhelming experience. Studies reveal that one in three individuals entering puberty feels unprepared for this significant milestone in their lives. Feelings of fear, embarrassment, and confusion often dominate thoughts as they face this natural process. It is essential to address these concerns and provide a supportive environment that encourages open conversations about periods, bodies, and the invaluable knowledge required to navigate this new chapter.

We are proud to present a three-part educational series - Zara and Sam will cover topics such as what changes might start to happen before your first period, what period protection is out there, and different types of flow.

First period signs

A common question is when can I expect my first period to start? Zara and Sam discuss signs and signals that indicate the onset of menstruation, providing reassurance and guidance during this transition. By familiarising yourself with these signs, you can embrace the journey while feeling prepared and confident.

Different types of flow

The second video delves into the different aspects of menstrual flow, looking into how flow can change from person to person but also day to day during your period. Zara and Sam will shed light on light flows, medium flows, and other flow patterns, helping you better understand the changes your body can undergo. Empowered with this knowledge you can navigate your periods more confidently, knowing what to anticipate and how to manage your own experiences.

How to use a period pad

This video focuses on one of the most commonly used menstrual products (especially for first periods!) – the period pad. Zara and Sam will guide you through using and disposing of pads while addressing any concerns or misconceptions surrounding this essential period product. Gaining a thorough understanding of pad usage can help you make informed choices that align with your body and flow to ensure comfort – because everyone’s period is different.

Understanding your body is a fundamental step towards feeling empowered and confident when it comes to periods. By dispelling the taboos surrounding menstruation and embracing education, we can create a supportive environment where everyone feels comfortable discussing their experiences, concerns, and questions."

Not a use of "girl", "women", "woman", "female" or anything else to indicate the sex of the "individuals" that might be about to experience their first period.

Then there's the claim that 1 in 3 individuals entering puberty feels unprepared for a first period. They don't mean 1 in 3 individuals entering puberty, they mean 1 in 3 girls. Why don't they say so? Why the need to remove language that identifies the sex of those involved?

StillHereStillBreathing · 15/08/2023 15:01

BodegaSushi · 15/08/2023 14:59

And again

First time I actually saw the advert with my own eyes. It does seem like just an inclusive thing then which is fine.

Sueveneers · 15/08/2023 15:00

@BodegaSushi Again, we're talking about the paragraph here, which is more recent than that.

BodegaSushi · 15/08/2023 14:59

And again

Get your child period ready
Get your child period ready
BodegaSushi · 15/08/2023 14:59

Posting again for everyone complaining about language, girls, women, daughters, mothers and females are used all over the Always site.

Get your child period ready
Get your child period ready
Get your child period ready