Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder if giving any breast milk is that important?

242 replies

Tiredstressedmum · 15/08/2023 09:00

Posting on AIBU for traffic.

I’m a FTM to a gorgeous ten day old.

Prior to delivery, DH and I did a lot of research into feeding. We both read a lot of studies and reached the conclusion that any potential benefits of BFing are likely to be marginal; we couldn’t find any conclusive swings in outcomes for BFing and found a lot of the outcomes were confounded out by factors such as socioeconomic status and parental behaviours. I reached the conclusion that I would try BFing but be quick to switch to formula if it wasn’t working for us, although secretly was confident it would work and I’d have one of those snuggly milky newborns all mumsnetters seem to have Sad.

As it turned out, the birth did not go to plan and BFing was really hard; I don’t think LO ever had a feed (lots of latch issues) and was on top up formula from day 1. Feeding was becoming distressing for both of us and I could feel myself becoming very anxious, low and obsessive about it despite a lot of midwife support. On day four, DH bought formula and we had several days of bliss.

However, despite our previous research I felt (and still feel) wracked with guilt about being selfish and depriving LO of a good start. I decided to try pumping with good effect and have started replacing one or two bottles a day with breast milk. This sounds good in theory but LO is very unsettled after these feeds and ends up constantly crying (screaming) / taking top up breast milk until the next formula feed ‘resets’ her. I’m worried my attempts to assuage my own guilt are actually leaving her hungry and possibly causing digestive issues and discomfort.

I can’t find any information on how much breast milk is beneficial (have seen as low as 50 mL quoted a lot but no idea where this comes from) and whether my feeding regime is actually helping her in any way at all. AIBU to wonder whether giving her these bottles of breast milk is really helpful to her or whether I’m just complicating her feeding to make myself feel better?! It’s so psychologically difficult to be producing good milk for her and not giving it to her. Selfishly, I also fear judgement from other parents and professionals - I wish I could be wonderfully logical and rational like DH, who thinks formula is the best thing ever, but I’m just full of emotions and guilt and it’s stopping me enjoying my darling. Every time she cries (which is a fair bit because she’s a baby!) I end up crying too because I’m worried she’s hungry and I’ve deprived her, and DH ends up taking over.

OP posts:
TwoShades1 · 15/08/2023 10:51

Whichever way you feed is totally fine and will make bugger all difference in the scheme of her whole life.

The simplest answer is probably that breastmilk is digested very fast so her stomach will feel empty sooner than with formula. Formula packs a lot more calories, etc per ml and is slower to digest. So if you compare milk volumes she will need less formula to satisfied compared with bottles of pumped milk.

Unless you are exclusively pumping and feeding bottles, most women have no idea how much their baby drinks (in ml or oz) per breastfeed as there’s no way to measure it when it’s going directly boob to baby.

Nowthenhere · 15/08/2023 10:50

Birth didn't go to plan? This directly effects breastfeeding. Mum's feelings on their baby's birth effects the part of the brain that produces milk.
Your little one is not the problem. You are not the problem.
The way that the birth unfolded is the problem and greatly increases the need for mums to rely upon alternatives to breastmilk.
Breastmilk is optimal but not every child will receive this. There are long term issues with formula and one thing you never get with breastmilk is "we are going to have to recall this breastmilk" which happens a lot with formula because they find metals, plastic and other substances in it.

Mummy08m · 15/08/2023 10:50

Xlap · 15/08/2023 10:12

OP please don't stress yourself about this. I was in a similar situation to yours. DS never latched, I was heartbroken, this guilt almost lead to PND. We put him on Formula,he is almost 2 now, on 99th centile for height and weight for his group. He is active, smart and a great problem solver for his age.
One of my observations is that most of the technological advancements comes from the countries with the lowest breastfeeding rates like UK, USA and Sweden etc, while you hear none of the breakthrough from the countries with highest breastfeeding rates like Burundi, Rwanda, Sri Lanka etc.
I don't think Breastfeeding or not leads to any difference in the outcomes for a child. Intelligence etc depend on the lifetime of hardwork from parents, genetics, child's own interest etc.
My friend was totally formula fed, now in 40s, studied at Oxbridge, high flying job, C level executive and six figure salary.
I wouldn't worry too much, just do whatever works for you ❤️ enjoy this time, it goes quick. All the best !

One of my observations is that most of the technological advancements comes from the countries with the lowest breastfeeding rates like UK, USA and Sweden etc, while you hear none of the breakthrough from the countries with highest breastfeeding rates like Burundi, Rwanda, Sri Lanka etc.

Wow this is truly nuts. So people in developing countries experience poverty because they breastfeed more? I thought I'd heard it all on here but this...

WonderingWanda · 15/08/2023 10:48

I breastfed both of mine, it was hard and I really wanted to swap to formula at about 8 weeks but my babies were very against having any kind of bottle in their mouths. Obviously it got easier but my point is babies can get fussy when something isn't what they are used to. Plenty of babies combination feed and switch between the two but maybe your baby just prefers the formula, which always appears a bit thicker than breast milk. I think we are conditioned to feel so much guilt as mothers. Guilt over not having a natural birth, guilt over pain relief, guilt over cosleeping or not etc etc. In reality however your baby is fed and cared for in a safe loving home they will thrive. Try to stop feeling guilt and just do what works for you. You will never get a conclusive answer on exactly how beneficial breastmilk, but it has benefits. Apparently avocado is a great food to eat in term of beneficial fats and nutrients but they give me horrific heartburn so I don't eat them, I'm not spending anytime worrying about the health impact of lack of avocados in my diet.

bryceQ · 15/08/2023 10:46

If you do want to try getting her to latch directly buy some nipple shields, they will make it easier for her and be more similar to the bottle she is used to

GlasgowGal82 · 15/08/2023 10:45

I really struggled to breastfeed for the first month or so. I did eventually get it established and fed until LO was 13 months old, but looking back those initial struggles definitely contributed to a downward spiral in my mental health which has had long term impacts on my bond with that baby. Once established it was a really handy way to feed a baby and I was really glad I didn't have to fuss with bottles when I was out and about. However, my advice now would be fed is best and prioritise your own mental health and wellbeing because failure to do so can have negative impacts that could outweigh the benefits of breastfeeding.

Summerrainagain1 · 15/08/2023 10:44

AuntieJune · 15/08/2023 10:26

I write about current breastmilk and infant nutrition research for work. Post doc level research.

Breastmilk has components in it that provide immune support. It also has HMOs that establish beneficial bacteria in the gut (microbiome). This is important in shaping future health (there is an effect throughout life, not just infancy) and something that formula does not offer. If you took stool samples from formula-fed and breastfed infants you could tell which was which by the bacteria present.

However there are other factors that are also important for infant health - being born by C-section has a negative impact on microbiome, so does using antibiotics, having a poor diet, having a mother with a poor diet prior to and during pregnancy, living in poor conditions etc.

So breastmilk is important but it's not the be-all and end-all. If breastfeeding is stressful, that will communicate to your DC as well and stress is bad for health too. A formula-fed child who is brought up with good nutrition and lots of love and care still has a very good start in life.

It sounds a bit like you've come on here looking to be told that breastfeeding doesn't matter - it does, but if the overall picture for you makes it not worth it then that's fine too. If you want to continue I'd also invest in a lactation consultant - they can pay for themselves in savings on formula.

Good, informative, post.

ShowerintheDark · 15/08/2023 10:44

If I could go back I would have mixed fed dc1 at the very least and then migrated over to formula after a couple of months or so. Exclusively breastfeeding after a traumatic start in the world drove me crazy. I was useless as expressing, as it took 3 hours to get a bottle which meant I had baby with me all of the time until 6 month old when I stopped. Even then I felt guilty!! Where does it end?! I think being miserable, and stressed over feeding is so much more detrimental to baby, than a happy Mum and a bit of formula! Hindsight is a great thing, I wish somebody has stepped in and told me this before I made myself ill.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 15/08/2023 10:44

Your husband seems to be contributing to your distress - you wanted to breastfeed, but he's done nothing except press for formula from the outset. And then you describe him literally as taking over.

How about what you want to do? Not him, he doesn't have the equipment to qualify as having a say in the matter - he's supposed to be there to support you, not tell you you're doing it all wrong and he's the intelligent and rational one, whereas you are just the hormonal, emotional mother.

If you choose to BF, that's your choice. If you choose to FF, that's your choice. Not his. Not anybody else's. Your choice.

WeetabixTowels · 15/08/2023 10:42

But honestly OP and anyone saying the word ‘guilt’. I implore you to just stop! The world will try and make you feel guilty for the most piddly of parenting decisions for literally the rest of your life. How you choose to feed an infant makes up such a tiny teeny part of your overall parenting self - there will be a LOT more significant moments in their life and even a few where you go “Right so this next decision will be the difference between putting them on the right path or fucking then up completely”. How you feed an infant is NOT one of those decisions. There is nothing to feel guilty about - I mean I bet it, it’s shit when things don’t go as you plan and being a new mum is hard. But then they get to 10 and you wonder if moving cross-country will forever destroy them or be the best thing you ever did and you will long for the day you just simply had to choose one type of sustenance over the other 😂

Xlap · 15/08/2023 10:41

Clarification for all the breastfeeding advocates who are highly intolerant and give new mums so much grief and guilt to drive them to PND. Let mothers choose what works for them. Please start a new thread to moan about things like colonisation. I gave her an example that FF isn't going to ruin your child's future. It doesn't matters. Stop derailing OP's post and behaving like a tyrant.

Summerrainagain1 · 15/08/2023 10:41

I think you are overthinking this. Also, it seems like some strange confirmation bias post - you seem to be making a case not only for BF to not be as beneficial as people say but actually inferior to FF. I expect this is to relieve your guilt, but (1) I think you are reading things into your baby's experience of BF to make yourself feel better (which is fine of course and (2) it's unnecessary to poo poo BF just because it doesn't work for you.

Feed your baby the way that makes you and your baby happy. 5 years down the line you won't even give this a second thought.

Leopardpj · 15/08/2023 10:40

Honestly OP, I would 100 per cent formula feed in your position (and I'm someone who was fortunate to be able to breastfeed both my kids without too much trauma.) Like another poster said, how you feed is not all that important. What is important is that your baby has a happy and relaxed mum. Also, for you - these early days are precious. I spent the first few weeks with my new daughter very stressed and fixated about a different but similar issue, and I just wish I had stopped overthinking it, done what suited us best and got on with enjoying my new baby. There is absolutely nothing wrong with formula milk, and it obviously works for your baby, which is all that matters! (Side issue - you say she hates the taste of your expressed milk - I just wondered if you were freezing then defrosting it? I know everyone says it's fine to do this but my DD wouldn't touch it once it had been frozen and defrosted and when I tasted it myself I could see why!) Either way expressing is a massive faff and I gave up on all that a about three weeks in when I threw my breast pump across the room and just did a mix of boob and formula from that point on, gradually moving to full formula. Good luck!

WeetabixTowels · 15/08/2023 10:38

I tell you what though I bet Nestle are pissing than elves with joy thinking “Wow people are SO bought into our products that they think formula is responsible for technological advances in the West rather than the whole colonisation thing” 😂😂 brilliant! Funnily enough one of the world leaders in healthcare and AI - Israel - has very high breastfeeding rates.

bagforlifeamnesty · 15/08/2023 10:37

Listen to @AuntieJune. I’m also a scientist (but not a specialist in this area like a pp but I’m an academic in my science subject) and tried to do similar research to you before my DD1 was born. I came to similar conclusion that @AuntieJune posted above - breastmilk DOES matter, but so do lots of other things, and BF vs FF is very unlikely to be the most important parenting decision you make. You have managed to give baby some early breastmilk and that will have had some benefits. At this point, after reading your updates, I think you need to try to switch to exclusively BF or exclusively FF. Some people love combi feeding but in my experience when that is a combination of expressing and formula feeding then you get all the hassle of both and none of the benefits as you are still tied to the pumping, having to sterilise even more stuff every day, etc. If you could manage to switch to directly breastfeeding perhaps overnight (definite benefits - no getting up to make bottles!) and FF during the day then that might work for you. But you do need to be in a position to work on your baby’s latch and know that it will take time for them to adjust - it’s common for bottle fed babies to latch onto the boob and then quickly come off screaming because they’re furious that the milk isn’t immediately available like it is in a bottle. It can be stressful so if you want to try it then do be prepared for that and have a read about what things might help eg expressing to get your let down going beforehand. But if that sounds like it would be too stressful then just formula feed. It’s fine!

TheGoogleMum · 15/08/2023 10:36

OP with my first baby she would not suckle she just fell asleep. So we formula fed. I too felt quite guilty but as she had been losing weight before I made the switch it was the right thing to do. You absolutely cannot tell which kids were breastfed and which were formula fed.

My second baby has taken to breastfeeding so take heart that next time it may work if you plan to have more children. Nutritionally formula has all the right nutrients and breastfed babies are meant to be topped up with vitamin drops. Breastfeeding is very clever but only if it actually works for you, and if it doesn't then the best thing is to make sure baby is fed which is exactly what you are doing. I tried to pump too and quickly gave up as for me finding yime to pump on top of feeding was too much stress.

Your baby will be fine don't worry, you are doing a brilliant job making sure your baby is fed and happy xx

WeetabixTowels · 15/08/2023 10:36

I also think we need to stop telling mums that they absolutely have to give their baby Xoz of breastmilk and reach XYZ centile. I remember freaking out because my baby was breastfed and was always on the lower centile a which to the MW was A Bad Thing. It’s wasn’t until my GP pointed out the DD was probably a short arse because her parents are that I relaxed. She’s 10 now and still a short arse bless her 🤣 but HV/MW tick boxing can be very toxic!

Xlap · 15/08/2023 10:36

AuntieJune · 15/08/2023 10:33

Fucking hell. I think a history of colonialisation might have played more of a role in the development status of countries in Africa and Asia than breastfeeding.

We systematically suppressed their potential, not to mention very often making women unable to care for their own children by forcing them to work or making them be nannies to white children (maybe breastfeeding them too as wet nurses).

Are you really saying people in those countries are less intelligent? Maybe ask your formula-fed friend to explain world history to you.

That is truly breathtaking @xlap, well done

@AuntieJune lol, good try to derail OP's post but may be you can start another thread of your own to moan about colonisation etc etc

forgivingfiggy · 15/08/2023 10:35

You are feeling guilty about it because you gave birth 10 days ago and your hormones are still settling. Prime guilt time.

I wonder if she's maybe reacting to something you are eating through your breast milk? Either way, if you want to stop expressing, stop. I believe the 'best' stuff is the colostrum which she had in the couple of days after birth. So tick that off in your head and proceed to formula guilt-free.

Xlap · 15/08/2023 10:34

AuntieJune · 15/08/2023 10:26

I write about current breastmilk and infant nutrition research for work. Post doc level research.

Breastmilk has components in it that provide immune support. It also has HMOs that establish beneficial bacteria in the gut (microbiome). This is important in shaping future health (there is an effect throughout life, not just infancy) and something that formula does not offer. If you took stool samples from formula-fed and breastfed infants you could tell which was which by the bacteria present.

However there are other factors that are also important for infant health - being born by C-section has a negative impact on microbiome, so does using antibiotics, having a poor diet, having a mother with a poor diet prior to and during pregnancy, living in poor conditions etc.

So breastmilk is important but it's not the be-all and end-all. If breastfeeding is stressful, that will communicate to your DC as well and stress is bad for health too. A formula-fed child who is brought up with good nutrition and lots of love and care still has a very good start in life.

It sounds a bit like you've come on here looking to be told that breastfeeding doesn't matter - it does, but if the overall picture for you makes it not worth it then that's fine too. If you want to continue I'd also invest in a lactation consultant - they can pay for themselves in savings on formula.

@AuntieJune just curious, do those biome/bacteria last forever since breastfeeding would only be till 2 years of life and then life happens with sickness and antibiotics. Do you not have to keep eating probiotics and other fermented food to maintain good guy health for tha average life span of 80 years?

WeetabixTowels · 15/08/2023 10:34

https://www.nhs.uk/conditions/baby/breastfeeding-and-bottle-feeding/breastfeeding/benefits/

I mean…with the greatest of respect it’s human milk, made for humans, as opposed to the milk of a whole other animal. I let always surprised me that people question the benefits of breastmilk. Why wouldn’t something literally designed solely for humans be beneficial for them?

Im not sure why people are offended by facts. But yes breastfeeding as a substance is much more beneficial than cows milk is. That doesn’t say the breastfeeding experience is better though.

nhs.uk

Benefits of breastfeeding

Breastfeeding has lots of health benefits for your new baby, including fewer infections and a lower risk of obesity, as well as protecting you from some cancers and other health problems, too.

https://www.nhs.uk/conditions/baby/breastfeeding-and-bottle-feeding/breastfeeding/benefits/

AuntieJune · 15/08/2023 10:33

Xlap · 15/08/2023 10:12

OP please don't stress yourself about this. I was in a similar situation to yours. DS never latched, I was heartbroken, this guilt almost lead to PND. We put him on Formula,he is almost 2 now, on 99th centile for height and weight for his group. He is active, smart and a great problem solver for his age.
One of my observations is that most of the technological advancements comes from the countries with the lowest breastfeeding rates like UK, USA and Sweden etc, while you hear none of the breakthrough from the countries with highest breastfeeding rates like Burundi, Rwanda, Sri Lanka etc.
I don't think Breastfeeding or not leads to any difference in the outcomes for a child. Intelligence etc depend on the lifetime of hardwork from parents, genetics, child's own interest etc.
My friend was totally formula fed, now in 40s, studied at Oxbridge, high flying job, C level executive and six figure salary.
I wouldn't worry too much, just do whatever works for you ❤️ enjoy this time, it goes quick. All the best !

Fucking hell. I think a history of colonialisation might have played more of a role in the development status of countries in Africa and Asia than breastfeeding.

We systematically suppressed their potential, not to mention very often making women unable to care for their own children by forcing them to work or making them be nannies to white children (maybe breastfeeding them too as wet nurses).

Are you really saying people in those countries are less intelligent? Maybe ask your formula-fed friend to explain world history to you.

That is truly breathtaking @xlap, well done

TheBeesKnee · 15/08/2023 10:30

Tiredstressedmum · 15/08/2023 09:26

To those mentioning trying to directly feed again - I know this is a far wiser solution if I want her to have my milk but I just don’t think I can. I was finding it so very stressful. I tried yesterday as she was settled on me and started rooting and it just escalated instantly into her screaming and thrashing and me crying - not a high oxytocin environment! I’d love to be stronger and persist and seek more qualified support but I panic and cry at the thought of latching her and just think it’ll wreck my mental health which already seems pretty wobbly after the birth. I genuinely don’t think I’m strong enough to keep trying.

Interested to hear the consensus that it isn’t the milk unsettling her; it just seems so temporally linked. I assumed it was to do with the different ways breast milk and formula milk are taken and that trying to alternate between the two isn’t a good idea. Maybe I should be adding my milk to her formula bottles, I don’t know ..

Hi OP, just to give you a success story: I had problems latching and my baby was fed formula and expressed milk for the first 3 weeks of his life. I had a transitional period where I'd offer him the breast for 5 minutes max before most feeds.

At first he refused them all and we used formula, but with time he started latching more often. I think it was just a case of him needing to get bigger and stronger and my nipples to come out a bit more.

I switched my thinking to along the lines of yours: I was going to supplement him for his immune system and digestive benefits. I think that helped me to relax as I was aiming for a few feeds/a bit of milk in him, not a complete switchover.

It was a LONG process but I now exclusively breast feed and he's 14 weeks old.

Also what kind of cry is she doing? Have you looked up the Dunstan baby language?

Xlap · 15/08/2023 10:28

Another thing which makes me laugh is when the EBF advocates jump over and advice that women should just sit with the baby day and night trying to establish BF for weeks is who do they assume will look after the other children and the household chores because not everyone has got tons of family to help and especially if you have other children to look after as well !

PizzaPlease7 · 15/08/2023 10:26

The poster who said BF is like a salad and FF like a Chinese takeaway…I don’t think she meant in terms of nutrition. More so that formula tends to be heavier and keeps baby full for longer. Breast milk (like a salad) is lighter and digests quickly leaving baby hungry quicker. Probably could have been worded a bit less controversially! For what it’s worth, I rather a Chinese takeaway than a salad any day of the week 😁

OP breast milk is undoubtedly best for baby, but it’s really not a make or break for their future so just do what is easier and makes you happy. I BF dd1 and FF dd2. Dd2 gets unwell all the time and has crap immunity in general. Could be a total coincidence but I do have pangs of guilt for not BF.