Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder if giving any breast milk is that important?

242 replies

Tiredstressedmum · 15/08/2023 09:00

Posting on AIBU for traffic.

I’m a FTM to a gorgeous ten day old.

Prior to delivery, DH and I did a lot of research into feeding. We both read a lot of studies and reached the conclusion that any potential benefits of BFing are likely to be marginal; we couldn’t find any conclusive swings in outcomes for BFing and found a lot of the outcomes were confounded out by factors such as socioeconomic status and parental behaviours. I reached the conclusion that I would try BFing but be quick to switch to formula if it wasn’t working for us, although secretly was confident it would work and I’d have one of those snuggly milky newborns all mumsnetters seem to have Sad.

As it turned out, the birth did not go to plan and BFing was really hard; I don’t think LO ever had a feed (lots of latch issues) and was on top up formula from day 1. Feeding was becoming distressing for both of us and I could feel myself becoming very anxious, low and obsessive about it despite a lot of midwife support. On day four, DH bought formula and we had several days of bliss.

However, despite our previous research I felt (and still feel) wracked with guilt about being selfish and depriving LO of a good start. I decided to try pumping with good effect and have started replacing one or two bottles a day with breast milk. This sounds good in theory but LO is very unsettled after these feeds and ends up constantly crying (screaming) / taking top up breast milk until the next formula feed ‘resets’ her. I’m worried my attempts to assuage my own guilt are actually leaving her hungry and possibly causing digestive issues and discomfort.

I can’t find any information on how much breast milk is beneficial (have seen as low as 50 mL quoted a lot but no idea where this comes from) and whether my feeding regime is actually helping her in any way at all. AIBU to wonder whether giving her these bottles of breast milk is really helpful to her or whether I’m just complicating her feeding to make myself feel better?! It’s so psychologically difficult to be producing good milk for her and not giving it to her. Selfishly, I also fear judgement from other parents and professionals - I wish I could be wonderfully logical and rational like DH, who thinks formula is the best thing ever, but I’m just full of emotions and guilt and it’s stopping me enjoying my darling. Every time she cries (which is a fair bit because she’s a baby!) I end up crying too because I’m worried she’s hungry and I’ve deprived her, and DH ends up taking over.

OP posts:
Boymummyofone · 15/08/2023 12:16

My baby had a tongue tie and I tried so hard to breastfeed (because of social pressures including my own mother) to the point where my nipples were bleeding! I stayed up all hours of the night trying to pump but my supply was quickly dwindling, I'm talking about 5ml an hour! It did so much damage to my mental health and was seriously sleep deprived. We moved on to formula very quickly with the courage of my husband who could see the affect it was having on me.

Don't listen to what people say and trust your gut. Although I still feel guilt about not doing more, he's a perfectly happy clever child who's about to turn 2.

herewegoroundthebastardbush · 15/08/2023 12:12

In your specific case I'd do the fllowing:

  1. take the pressure to breastfeed off yourself. You were obviously very ambiguous about it in the first place or you wouldn't have gone out looking for evidence to undermine it. Formula is a perfectly adequate replacement to breastmilk, will do your baby no harm, and is working for you both. So just stop worrying first of all. Feed her formula on the schedule that keeps her full and happy.

  2. if you still want her to have breastmilk, then pack up the pumping (except to maintain supply) and try to get her on the breast. That way whatever she has will be 'extra' nutritionally to her formula feeds, she won't get hungry, but she might get used to it and come to like it - either simply as a comfort, bonding ritual and a nutritional/immunological supplement, or perhaps she might as she gets bigger be able to more easily extract enough milk at the breast to satiate her.

  3. to encourage easy feeding at the breast, I would recommend lying in bed with your baby when she's sleeping after a formula feed, getting skin to skin (if she likes that - contrary to received wisdom, not all babies do!), and when she stirs and is still half asleep offer her the breast (you can get videos that show you how to do side-lying feeding). She's young enough that her suckling instinct should take over, and if she's not hungry it won't matter if she's getting milk at all really - the comfort and enjoyment will still be there for her, so she won't get frustrated at the breast. She may not even wake up at all.

Hopefully this sort of low pressure comfort feeding may grow into something more long-term and sustaining. If nothing else it will be some pleasant, relaxed time bonding with your baby, and you can know you have offered her breastmilk while still ensuring with formula that she's well fed and contented.

To be honest I think you sabotaged yourself a bit with your prenatal attempts to convince yourself breastfeeding was not important - if you've already psyched yourself out like that then the difficult bit at the beginning (and it is usually difficult at the beginning, it's a skill to be learned like everything else!) will seem like more trouble than it's worth. In a sense the 'is breast better than formula' question is a bit of a red herring. As I said, formula is a perfectly adequate way to feed a baby if done safely. The important question is always 'do you want to breastfeed?'. Because what you want is important. It sounds like you do want to, when it comes down to it. So give yourself a chance!

ShowerintheDark · 15/08/2023 11:59

was /s

AuntieJune · 15/08/2023 11:59

Tessisme · 15/08/2023 11:40

That's very interesting and informative @AuntieJune, thanks.

I breastfed both my babies for three years. My youngest was diagnosed with Crohn's Disease at 10yo and of course two of the questions I was asked by the IBD consultant were whether I had a normal delivery and whether he was breastfed. I have wondered from time to time if what I was eating while breastfeeding had an impact on his bowel which only manifested itself last year when his symptoms began. And of course I have also wondered whether his frustratingly fussy attitude to food contributed in some way too. An attitude which I stopped fighting against for an easy life. I was losing the battle anyway. In the end, as mums, we always seem to end up feeling as if it's something we have done 'wrong'.

@Tessisme I'm sorry about your youngest, Crohn's Disease is horrible. I hope you've been able to bring it under control.

I suppose you could say that if tomorrow, the entire population decided to only have c-section births and formula feed, in coming years you would expect to see increased rates of various diseases including inflammatory disease like Crohn's - if all other factors like diet, exercise, pollutants etc stayed constant. (This would be impossible to measure or achieve but theoretically).

It wouldn't mean all children would get ill. But statistically, more would overall.

I wouldn't blame yourself at all, whether you breastfed or formula fed or however he was born. The main factor is nature sometimes being a massive and arbitrary bitch, to be honest.

ShowerintheDark · 15/08/2023 11:58

'There just isn't enough information about combi feeding.'

@Creepyrosemary

That's exactly it, and part of the reason I chose not to. I was abit lost, didn't understand how to do it so that baby took both without issues of preference. I also waw unsure how many feed or each/when and how to mix it! MWs & HVs didn't give any information on this, it was very much a either/or.

lolacherricoke · 15/08/2023 11:57

Please please please ignore the breastfeeding mafia! Do what is right for you and your beautiful bubba! I breast fed one of mine and not the other due to hospitalisation! They are both strong, healthy, happy children.
Congratulations xx

PumpkinPie2016 · 15/08/2023 11:51

I'm sorry you had a tough start @Tiredstressedmum

I would say, please don't worry about your daughter having/not having breastmilk. Any benefits really are minimal.

FWIW my son was born after a difficult delivery and while he was totally fine and a healthy 9lb 6oz, I was badly anaemic due to blood loss in theatre when I had an emergency c-section, exhausted and a bit of a car crash.

I didn't even attempt breastfeeding- I wasn't well enough. Didn't express either, he was formula fed from day 1.

He's 9 now - extremely healthy, tall and slim. Eats anything, never ill and loads of energy. So not having breast milk hasn't made a jot of difference.

Please do whatever works for you 🌺

Ghan · 15/08/2023 11:42

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Oliotya · 15/08/2023 11:41

Tiredstressedmum · 15/08/2023 09:03

I should add that I’m finding combination the worst of both worlds. With EBF, I’d pop her on the breast as soon as she was fussy. With FF, she was fairly consistently satisfied and we could be confident that if she was unsettled immediately post feed it probably wasn’t hunger. With combination, we have no real idea and she seems constantly ravenous even though she’s getting 2-3x more breast milk by quantity in each feed than formula…

If she's been formula fed from day 1, then she's never been EBF (exclusively breastfed). A healthy 1 day old does not need top-up formula, so if that was medical advice, I'd be questioning that.
If you're looking for permission to drop the breastmilk, you don't need it. If you want to breastfeed, get some proper support and give it a real, good, sustained try. Take baby to bed and just feed feed feed.
She's 10 days old. She will seem ravenous. The urge to cluster feed will persist to some extent, whether formula or breastfed. It doesn't mean your breastmilk is insufficient.
If you don't want to breastfeed, don't. You don't need an excuse or a reason.

Tessisme · 15/08/2023 11:40

That's very interesting and informative @AuntieJune, thanks.

I breastfed both my babies for three years. My youngest was diagnosed with Crohn's Disease at 10yo and of course two of the questions I was asked by the IBD consultant were whether I had a normal delivery and whether he was breastfed. I have wondered from time to time if what I was eating while breastfeeding had an impact on his bowel which only manifested itself last year when his symptoms began. And of course I have also wondered whether his frustratingly fussy attitude to food contributed in some way too. An attitude which I stopped fighting against for an easy life. I was losing the battle anyway. In the end, as mums, we always seem to end up feeling as if it's something we have done 'wrong'.

AuntieJune · 15/08/2023 11:33

Mummybud · 15/08/2023 11:27

These posts are so polarising and the smug people on both sides always ruin it. I’ve BF both my babies and feeding the first is probably the hardest thing I’ve ever done. I probably should have FF her. The second was slightly easier.

Here’s the point: BF isn’t easy for 99% of people. Professionals (NCT particularly 👀) need to stop perpetuating the myth that babies and mothers naturally know what to do, latch is perfect and everything goes swimmingly. Those who breastfeed do it because they believe it is the best thing for their baby, despite the fact it’s hard.

You won’t find BF mothers telling you there’s no benefit over formula. The “research” you will have read will have been paid for by formula companies. Boobs don’t have research or marketing budgets. You will find FF mothers telling you their kids are absolutely fine on formula, which they are. You cannot tell the difference between a FF and a BF kid, believe me. You should feed however you want feed.

I mean, if you analysed their stools then you would find a difference between a FF and BF child.

I get your point and I broadly agree, although I don't think it's true that 99% of people find BF hard. I've had two DC, first one it was a nightmare establishing BF and second one came out, latched on and I barely had to think about it.

Part of the issue is a lack of inbuilt community support - if you've grown up seeing women breastfeed you'll understand more about it and have people to ask for solutions if you struggle, you'll know about a cousin using hot and cold compresses for blocked ducts or a neighbour using cabbage leaves or seeing different feeding holds or whatever.

As it is, for many women if they struggle they're just told to switch to formula because it was good enough for their mum, or pay £££ for a consultant.

Mummybud · 15/08/2023 11:31

Oh and I absolutely agree with the “veg out” suggestions above. Strip baby down to a nappy, snuggle him/her and sit on the sofa or in bed all day. If you want to BF, try different positions (rugby ball is the only one that worked for me with newborns).

Gpnever · 15/08/2023 11:31

LadyGrinningSoul85 · 15/08/2023 09:25

What an awful response.

It's a good thing I didn't read that a couple of months ago when I was desperately hanging on to trying to continue bf even though it was effectively starving my baby, due to issues that had affected my supply severely.

Your babble is not needed. It's not the game changer that you breastfeeding enthusiasts make it out to be, it just really isn't.

Seriously, look at the actual facts and figures, not just statistics (which by the way, can be worded to make whatever point the person writing them wanted to make. I know this for a fact as my husband's job is statistic dependant and he's seen just how crafty you can get with them).

Greek salad Vs chinese takeaway.
Jesus Christ. What a vile comparison and what a horrible comment to make in general.

How about you just let people feed their babies and don't be so bloody judgemental.
My daughter (bf for 19 months) and my son (not bf at all) are no different.
I bonded the same with both, both are pretty much equal with their academic abilities, neither are obese.
Almost like some of those facts people like you LOVE to spout are utter horseshit. Who would have thought it 🤔

Amen 🙏

AuntieJune · 15/08/2023 11:28

Babdoc · 15/08/2023 11:12

There is a lot of nonsense talked by breast feeding zealots, OP.
My generation - the baby boomers - were majority formula fed, and we’re the longest lived, healthiest generation in history.
My own DDs, formula fed, have IQs in the 160s - top 1% of the population. They have no allergies, eczema or asthma, but both are university graduates with well paid careers and engage in many sports activities.
The research suggests that breast feeding is of marginal if any benefit, once you exclude confounding variables, except in third world countries with dirty water supplies and no way to sterilise formula feeds.
By the time children are at school, you cannot pick out any advantages of those that were breast fed. Don’t put yourself through hell, it’s completely pointless.

So @Babdoc confounding factors mean you can't say breastfeeding is beneficial

On the other hand boomers being majority formula fed must mean that's fine, no whopping massive confounding factors like the founding of the NHS, agricultural reforms that made food more affordable and available, removal of toxins like lead, asbestos, coal etc from the environment, improvements in healthcare, better housing, etc etc

74% of deaths worldwide are now related to non-communicable disease like stroke, heart disease, diabetes, obesity rather than communicable disease like tuberculosis, cholera, measles etc

We need strategies to address non-communicable disease and that includes encouraging breastfeeding, not least because it is linked to lower rates of obesity later on. It's not the one and only thing but it is important.

It's great your kids are doing well, but these things are best looked at on a statistical level. I've read those studies, they conclude that breastfeeding is valuable and makes a difference. It's not the only thing but it is important.

Mummybud · 15/08/2023 11:27

These posts are so polarising and the smug people on both sides always ruin it. I’ve BF both my babies and feeding the first is probably the hardest thing I’ve ever done. I probably should have FF her. The second was slightly easier.

Here’s the point: BF isn’t easy for 99% of people. Professionals (NCT particularly 👀) need to stop perpetuating the myth that babies and mothers naturally know what to do, latch is perfect and everything goes swimmingly. Those who breastfeed do it because they believe it is the best thing for their baby, despite the fact it’s hard.

You won’t find BF mothers telling you there’s no benefit over formula. The “research” you will have read will have been paid for by formula companies. Boobs don’t have research or marketing budgets. You will find FF mothers telling you their kids are absolutely fine on formula, which they are. You cannot tell the difference between a FF and a BF kid, believe me. You should feed however you want feed.

Mummy08m · 15/08/2023 11:26

Although I suppose I'm in the pro-breastfeeding "camp" I agree strongly with everyone who says expressing is a nightmare.

Many of the benefits of breastfeeding are from direct breastfeeding: you secrete an oil from the areola which has benefits which is lost when expressing. The oxytocin from bodily contact - this has benefits that have been studied in babies. Your body also feels the temperature of the baby (whether he is sweaty or hot skin etc) and the viscosity and dilution of your milk alters in real time, in a similar mechanism (and concurrently) with you producing sweat.

Expressing is not done in real time so you don't get the real time changes in consistency. Expressing hasn't got the same bodily contact. You don't pass the areola oils through the pumps. Expressing machines are hard to clean and can harbour traces of mould etc.

Finally of course, expressing is time consuming, stressful and painful, and yields frustratingly low amounts.

In short, I am absolutely not a fan of expressing and wouldn't recommend it to anyone at the newborn stage- only when returning to work, expressing in your lunch break to prevent engorgement.

My advice to op: bin the pumps. If you want to, have a last-ditch go at my "veg out" technique described above - aka traditional postpartum confinement - or don't. Then, please formula feed without feeling the need to rubbish the WHO or the benefits of breastfeeding.

egowise · 15/08/2023 11:25

Kindofcrunchy · 15/08/2023 09:59

Fed is not best, fed is the minimum. Informed is best

Unhelpful and wrong.

Summerrainagain1 · 15/08/2023 11:23

MariaVT65 · 15/08/2023 11:17

Exactly. I only managed about 7 times a day with help from my DH because he was wfh during lockdown. It was hell. I actually raised that whole ‘12 times a day’ think in my hospital complaint as it’s honestly like midwives just care about breastfeeding and give zero fucks about the mother’s wellbeing.

I think the issue is bad advice and overworked midwives. My experience was that the midwives gave very poor BFing support even though I really wanted to BF. They were super keen for me to move onto formula to avoid having to spend more time on it, or investigating/ treating the tongue tie I could see DD had. In fact they gave DD formula against my wishes when grabbing my breast and forcing it into screaming DD's mouth, surprisingly, didn't work to establish a latch. I only got decent advice once I was out of hospital and could seek my own, and from there it went really well. They gave zero fucks about my wellbeing OR breastfeeding and just wanted me out of hospital to clear the bed.

Creepyrosemary · 15/08/2023 11:23

There just isn't enough information about combi feeding. The breastfeeding fanatics make it an all or nothing thing. I combi fed fir 20 months. I couldn't handle cluster feeding in the evening and replaced that with formula. Look into giving the breastmilk at a time that baby is slightly hungry instead of ravenous. I have no research to back it up but if breast milk is filled with good stuff then it's still filled with good stuff when they drink formula as well. By the time they're 3 they all eat shitty stuff anyway. You'll end up wondering why you were so strict about the first few months anyway.

WeetabixTowels · 15/08/2023 11:22

MariaVT65 · 15/08/2023 11:17

Exactly. I only managed about 7 times a day with help from my DH because he was wfh during lockdown. It was hell. I actually raised that whole ‘12 times a day’ think in my hospital complaint as it’s honestly like midwives just care about breastfeeding and give zero fucks about the mother’s wellbeing.

I completely agree, postnatal care is shocking and women are treated like cattle not humans. Awful.

Oliotya · 15/08/2023 11:22

Babdoc · 15/08/2023 11:12

There is a lot of nonsense talked by breast feeding zealots, OP.
My generation - the baby boomers - were majority formula fed, and we’re the longest lived, healthiest generation in history.
My own DDs, formula fed, have IQs in the 160s - top 1% of the population. They have no allergies, eczema or asthma, but both are university graduates with well paid careers and engage in many sports activities.
The research suggests that breast feeding is of marginal if any benefit, once you exclude confounding variables, except in third world countries with dirty water supplies and no way to sterilise formula feeds.
By the time children are at school, you cannot pick out any advantages of those that were breast fed. Don’t put yourself through hell, it’s completely pointless.

You're the longest lived because of medical advances. Not because of formula.

nutbrownhare15 · 15/08/2023 11:22

I'd suggest going to a bf support group. They won't be judgemental and will have had training to give you more evidence based guidance than some of the comments on here. They are there to support mums with their breastfeeding goals. If yours is to explore possible reasons why breast milk may not be working for your baby or perhaps reassure you they'll support your with that. If it's to move her onto formula either now or later, they'll help you with that. They can give guidance on bottle feeding too.

Ghan · 15/08/2023 11:22

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

MariaVT65 · 15/08/2023 11:17

WeetabixTowels · 15/08/2023 11:13

When DD lost too much weight at 7 days old and I had to pump/combine with formula for 3 days solid to get her fat and my supply up (as no one had bothered to tell me my traumatic birth and blood loss affected supply until 7 days later 🙄) the midwife said “pump 12 times a day for 30 minutes “ I said “I’m sorry and I am supposed to sleep when exactly?”. But as it was only for 3 days I stuck it out but bugger me I wouldn’t have lasted a minute longer, I’d have lost my mind entirely.

Exactly. I only managed about 7 times a day with help from my DH because he was wfh during lockdown. It was hell. I actually raised that whole ‘12 times a day’ think in my hospital complaint as it’s honestly like midwives just care about breastfeeding and give zero fucks about the mother’s wellbeing.

AuntieJune · 15/08/2023 11:14

Xlap · 15/08/2023 10:34

@AuntieJune just curious, do those biome/bacteria last forever since breastfeeding would only be till 2 years of life and then life happens with sickness and antibiotics. Do you not have to keep eating probiotics and other fermented food to maintain good guy health for tha average life span of 80 years?

Yes and no - the bacteria in the gut change quite a lot at weaning as all the bacteria up to that point are there to digest milk.

When babies start eating other food the gut transitions to bacteria that digest plant matter, meat etc - the community of bacteria to deal with this becomes more established over time which is why the first foods often come out the other end looking barely digested.

Gut bacteria need to be fed - they digest the things we eat, and that's what keeps them going. The bacteria established during breastfeeding are still present in the gut when you start eating other foods, but if you eat nothing but crap that will feed other bacteria and they will be a greater proportion of the overall community.

Probiotics can introduce good bacteria but if you have a community initiated in early life and maintained by a good diet, that will continue. It's about fibre as well as fermented foods - good old wholefoods and unprocessed fruit and veg.

The whole thing is immensely fascinating and complicated, because bacteria also function in communities among themselves, so they impact each other. They are linked to inflammatory responses which underlie a lot of disease.

There's a concept of 'first colonisation' - the first bacteria that enter the gut kind of claim it and often stay there for life. If you're born by c-section you might be colonised by bacteria hanging around in the hospital, if you're born vaginally you will probably end up consuming a bit of maternal faecal matter on the way out and being colonised by the her gut bacteria. If you are breastfed then the milk contains HMOs that provide food for those beneficial maternal bacteria and help them to grow.

What this adds up to is kind of common sense - eat a healthy diet and you'll be more likely to be healthy. Mode of birth, mode of feeding, use of antibiotics that clear out the whole lot of your gut microbia etc - they can all interfere with the microbiome but none of them are 100% the thing that makes you healthy or not healthy.

Formula companies are spending lots of money attempting to see if they can produce the HMOs found in breastmilk to make formula closer to human milk, which would be no bad thing. But it's very complicated because human milk varies through the course of breastfeeding, the course of a single feed, the course of a day. And it has thousands of components we don't fully understand yet, some of it is might be junk left behind through evolution, similar to having an appendix.

Faecal transplantation is being attempted in some places to introduce the bacteria from one healthy person's gut to an unhealthy person's gut to combat things like inflammatory bowel disease, which tells you how important it is.