Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder if giving any breast milk is that important?

242 replies

Tiredstressedmum · 15/08/2023 09:00

Posting on AIBU for traffic.

I’m a FTM to a gorgeous ten day old.

Prior to delivery, DH and I did a lot of research into feeding. We both read a lot of studies and reached the conclusion that any potential benefits of BFing are likely to be marginal; we couldn’t find any conclusive swings in outcomes for BFing and found a lot of the outcomes were confounded out by factors such as socioeconomic status and parental behaviours. I reached the conclusion that I would try BFing but be quick to switch to formula if it wasn’t working for us, although secretly was confident it would work and I’d have one of those snuggly milky newborns all mumsnetters seem to have Sad.

As it turned out, the birth did not go to plan and BFing was really hard; I don’t think LO ever had a feed (lots of latch issues) and was on top up formula from day 1. Feeding was becoming distressing for both of us and I could feel myself becoming very anxious, low and obsessive about it despite a lot of midwife support. On day four, DH bought formula and we had several days of bliss.

However, despite our previous research I felt (and still feel) wracked with guilt about being selfish and depriving LO of a good start. I decided to try pumping with good effect and have started replacing one or two bottles a day with breast milk. This sounds good in theory but LO is very unsettled after these feeds and ends up constantly crying (screaming) / taking top up breast milk until the next formula feed ‘resets’ her. I’m worried my attempts to assuage my own guilt are actually leaving her hungry and possibly causing digestive issues and discomfort.

I can’t find any information on how much breast milk is beneficial (have seen as low as 50 mL quoted a lot but no idea where this comes from) and whether my feeding regime is actually helping her in any way at all. AIBU to wonder whether giving her these bottles of breast milk is really helpful to her or whether I’m just complicating her feeding to make myself feel better?! It’s so psychologically difficult to be producing good milk for her and not giving it to her. Selfishly, I also fear judgement from other parents and professionals - I wish I could be wonderfully logical and rational like DH, who thinks formula is the best thing ever, but I’m just full of emotions and guilt and it’s stopping me enjoying my darling. Every time she cries (which is a fair bit because she’s a baby!) I end up crying too because I’m worried she’s hungry and I’ve deprived her, and DH ends up taking over.

OP posts:
AuntieJune · 15/08/2023 14:06

coxesorangepippin · 15/08/2023 12:56

I was traumatized by the pressure to bfeed. Recovery form a c section, new born baby, no family help and pressure to breastfeed??

Fed is best. And formula is fine.

As the top says, there are no statistics that say that breastfed babies/adults are higher achieving or whatever, as it's simply not proven.

Erm, no the benefits of breastfeeding are proven. It's just that it's not as black and white as saying if you don't breastfeed, your child will be doomed.

Breastfeeding is one of many things you can do to benefit your child's health and development.

It's not the be-all and end-all but that doesn't mean there's no difference between breastfeeding and formula feeding.

Dinoswearunderpants · 15/08/2023 14:02

Yea2023 · 15/08/2023 13:48

@Dinoswearunderpants

Think of it simplistically, you're body has created a life, it has grown that life then born that life. It then has the ability to continue nurturing and growing that life by feeding it... why would you choose to provide something created in a factory over your own body with the required nutrients and antibodies.

My DC (born/unborn) were made in a lab and were (and due to be) born in a theatre. I did manage to BF, but wondered how you felt simplistically about my DC having/due to life thanks to technology/‘factory’ conditions?

You needed help to create them but they still grew inside you.

Did you also not breastfeed then?

Yea2023 · 15/08/2023 13:48

@Dinoswearunderpants

Think of it simplistically, you're body has created a life, it has grown that life then born that life. It then has the ability to continue nurturing and growing that life by feeding it... why would you choose to provide something created in a factory over your own body with the required nutrients and antibodies.

My DC (born/unborn) were made in a lab and were (and due to be) born in a theatre. I did manage to BF, but wondered how you felt simplistically about my DC having/due to life thanks to technology/‘factory’ conditions?

Piggyplate · 15/08/2023 13:31

If you still want her to have breastmilk pump and freeze it and just give it in her bottles. Or save for when you wean her? Could be latch issues taking wind when feeding straight from the breast. Also breast milk is easier digested so they tend to feed little and often. Have you considered that around this age there's a growth spurt so may be fussy anyways.

MalloryMae · 15/08/2023 13:23

Congratulations on baby. Is baby allergic to anything that you're eating that could be unsettling them? A friend of mine who breastfed realised that baby was allergic to cows milk so she had to change her diet, after she switched and went dairy free baby was absolutely fine with breast milk.

londonrach · 15/08/2023 13:22

Just fed what works for you. For the record I choose to ff DD as my dsis regretted bf as she got severe pna and didn't bond with dn until at six months she stopped bf. I'm happy with my decision and have a very healthy dd. I've friends who bf no problem and very happy with their decision. Different baby, different mum ...as long as baby is fed. That's all that matters. Do what works for you!!!!!! Congratulations on your baby x

sarahc336 · 15/08/2023 13:14

From someone whose pnd was rapidly worsened through struggling to breast feed, if you want to formula feed please just do that. Honestly don't put yourself through an ordeal, it's hard enough with a newborn let alone making yourself struggle with feeding too. A fed baby is a happy baby, no matter the style, good luck op 😁

MariaVT65 · 15/08/2023 13:10

Upsetrethis · 15/08/2023 12:48

I see threads like this constantly on mn…. I live in Ireland and breastfeeding is boarder line extinct here , they produce formula in Ireland so there’s a big formula lobby here.
You are in the majority op if you live in the us or Ireland. There’s no correlation or connection between breast milk and formula.
Formula is a highly processed food that in it’s origin is from an animal and species completely different to a human, that milk is usually from a cow (which often is treated with antibiotics etc ) and then processed into formula with added vitamins.
Breastmilk is milk from a human to a human baby , it has antibodies, it changes when a mother comes into contact with illnesses to protect the baby. I had raging tonsillitis when I had bf my baby (usually contagious) , their little brother had chicken pox ; both times they didn’t catch it as more than likely my breast milk adapted itself when it came into contact with those virus’s and protected the baby . Breast-feeding can offer a mother some protection against breast cancer and ovarian cancer (maybe not hugely but any little helps 🤷‍♀️) and helps prevent against sids for baby and helps to regulate babies breathing.
Formula doesn’t do any of those things above , it feeds the baby and obviously vital in keeping babies alive if a mother can’t feed a baby which in nature is actually pretty rare as otherwise the human race would have died out by now… Formula increase the chances of obesity even in later life, formula is huge in Ireland , we have one of the lowest breastfeeding rates in Europe if not the world , the vast majority of people here are overweight-possibly connected as formula has been dominant here for 50 years.
Of course you can say there’s minimal advantage to bf , you’ll get loads anecdotes on here backing you up and saying formula makes no different and their kids are fine blah blah.
I mean I know plenty of people who smoke and drink for years and they are fine or for a more direct comparison people who eat way more processed junk food than organic, natural, healthy food and they are also absolutely fine so why should people care and is it all a myth ? Obviously not on a scientific, population level ….

Not sure your post is entirely accurate, especially your point about breastfeeding issues being ‘rare otherwise the human race would have died out’. There were so many more infant deaths before formula, and there was a reason why wet nurses existed.

OP, well done for making the best decision for you :)

herewegoroundthebastardbush · 15/08/2023 13:02

Tiredstressedmum · 15/08/2023 12:50

This was a lovely reply and made
me cry. DH read it too. It’s so hard not to treat this whole thing like a project and become obsessive. Maybe a bit more instinct and a bit less research is what we need here! Instinctively, I don’t want to breastfeed but do want her to have my pumped milk. I just hope those two statements aren’t conflicting / selfish.

They are not remotely conflicting or selfish ❤️ you so clearly love your baby, she has two loving involved parents who take the time to research and worry and talk about what's best for her. She is going to be 110% fine OP. Just make sure you are too xx

coxesorangepippin · 15/08/2023 12:56

I was traumatized by the pressure to bfeed. Recovery form a c section, new born baby, no family help and pressure to breastfeed??

Fed is best. And formula is fine.

As the top says, there are no statistics that say that breastfed babies/adults are higher achieving or whatever, as it's simply not proven.

herewegoroundthebastardbush · 15/08/2023 12:53

To those suggesting a final attempt at BFing - I just don’t want to. I feel so guilty admitting it but do need to as it makes it easier to make onward plans. I find it incredibly stressful and just have a block around the whole thing now. I know she’ll be frustrated as taking from the breast is less easy than a bottle and I’m just not strong enough to work through that frustration with her.

OP that is fine. You can just say you don't want to, you don't have to justify it or muddle yourself inside out reading this or that and asking Mumsnet. If you don't want to breastfeed, you don't have to, you never did.

Re the frustration, just my own story. I breastfed DD1 exclusively until she was 2.5 (had a hard 6 weeks or so getting established, injured nipples etc, very upsetting at the time as I'd had an unwanted C-section so put a lot of pressure on myself to get breastfeeding 'right' but now looking back I see my experience was very normal in itself, just i got a bit overwrought as first time mum). So When I was expecting to find BF much easier, knew what I was doing etc.

She wouldn't latch. absolutely WOULD NOT. I tried every trick I knew, and she HATED it. I was distraught giving her formula for the first time. I pumped (like you I had a good and ready supply). She was exclusively fed on pumped breastmilk from a bottle from day 3 onwards. I was gutted. Pumping was inconvenient (until I found a handsfree pump that worked for me) and bottle warming, bottle washing, pump washing, sterilising, blah blah was a NIGHTMARE, I found it so annoying after the ease of bf DD1 - so I never quite gave up on bf, even months in. I started trying the method I described overnight, just trying to 'trick' her onto the breast when she was half asleep - sometimes it worked, sometimes it didn't, and then suddenly somehow at 4 months all her night feeds were from the breast. Slooooowly slowly some day feeds crept in - usually around naptimes, again when she was sleepy. And then one day when she was about 9 months old, she shoved away the bottle every time I tried to give it to her and climbed me like a tree and that was that 😆She got it at last. Either her mouth got bigger or my flow got more regular or it just clicked, but she's still feeding now at 2.5 and doesn't want to stop (I do!!! 😛).

I'm not saying all this in a 'don't give up!' scolding way. Just that it's hard now (god you're 10 days in, EVERYTHING is hard never mind feeding). But I am saying it won't always necessarily be hard, and to keep your options open.

Upsetrethis · 15/08/2023 12:52

Op re pumping (in case this is a concern ) I ebf all three of my dcs but pumping was extremely difficult and I produced almost no milk despite them feeding loads directly from the breast . Often pumping milk is no indication of how much milk is being produced. And breastfed babies need way more frequent feeding than formula fed babies generally, there’s a lot more watery (fore milk in breast milk ) there’s no foremilk/ hind milk in formula

Tiredstressedmum · 15/08/2023 12:50

herewegoroundthebastardbush · 15/08/2023 12:41

I wish I could be wonderfully logical and rational like DH, who thinks formula is the best thing ever

Ahh it's this bit isn't it. I see what you mean now @NeverDropYourMooncup !

OP, there's nothing logical about raising babies, it's about biology and love. Logic comes in later! But right now your body and your baby's are trying to engage in a delicate dance that's been designed by millions of years of evolution to provide an optimal outcome for both of you. There's instinct, and there's learning, and you two are doing it together. It's hard to listen to that music if someone else is playing a different tune loudly in the background. So if what your DH is suggesting/implementing feels wrong to you, or doesn't chime with your instincts, it's OK t pull rank and insist on listening to those instincts and to your baby. No-one will want and need her to be happy and healthy like you do; so trust yourself when you feel like you know what she needs. Don't be afraid to try different things, to go back on a 'plan', to adapt. You know her. She's yours. You have this.

This was a lovely reply and made
me cry. DH read it too. It’s so hard not to treat this whole thing like a project and become obsessive. Maybe a bit more instinct and a bit less research is what we need here! Instinctively, I don’t want to breastfeed but do want her to have my pumped milk. I just hope those two statements aren’t conflicting / selfish.

OP posts:
Upsetrethis · 15/08/2023 12:48

I see threads like this constantly on mn…. I live in Ireland and breastfeeding is boarder line extinct here , they produce formula in Ireland so there’s a big formula lobby here.
You are in the majority op if you live in the us or Ireland. There’s no correlation or connection between breast milk and formula.
Formula is a highly processed food that in it’s origin is from an animal and species completely different to a human, that milk is usually from a cow (which often is treated with antibiotics etc ) and then processed into formula with added vitamins.
Breastmilk is milk from a human to a human baby , it has antibodies, it changes when a mother comes into contact with illnesses to protect the baby. I had raging tonsillitis when I had bf my baby (usually contagious) , their little brother had chicken pox ; both times they didn’t catch it as more than likely my breast milk adapted itself when it came into contact with those virus’s and protected the baby . Breast-feeding can offer a mother some protection against breast cancer and ovarian cancer (maybe not hugely but any little helps 🤷‍♀️) and helps prevent against sids for baby and helps to regulate babies breathing.
Formula doesn’t do any of those things above , it feeds the baby and obviously vital in keeping babies alive if a mother can’t feed a baby which in nature is actually pretty rare as otherwise the human race would have died out by now… Formula increase the chances of obesity even in later life, formula is huge in Ireland , we have one of the lowest breastfeeding rates in Europe if not the world , the vast majority of people here are overweight-possibly connected as formula has been dominant here for 50 years.
Of course you can say there’s minimal advantage to bf , you’ll get loads anecdotes on here backing you up and saying formula makes no different and their kids are fine blah blah.
I mean I know plenty of people who smoke and drink for years and they are fine or for a more direct comparison people who eat way more processed junk food than organic, natural, healthy food and they are also absolutely fine so why should people care and is it all a myth ? Obviously not on a scientific, population level ….

herewegoroundthebastardbush · 15/08/2023 12:41

I wish I could be wonderfully logical and rational like DH, who thinks formula is the best thing ever

Ahh it's this bit isn't it. I see what you mean now @NeverDropYourMooncup !

OP, there's nothing logical about raising babies, it's about biology and love. Logic comes in later! But right now your body and your baby's are trying to engage in a delicate dance that's been designed by millions of years of evolution to provide an optimal outcome for both of you. There's instinct, and there's learning, and you two are doing it together. It's hard to listen to that music if someone else is playing a different tune loudly in the background. So if what your DH is suggesting/implementing feels wrong to you, or doesn't chime with your instincts, it's OK t pull rank and insist on listening to those instincts and to your baby. No-one will want and need her to be happy and healthy like you do; so trust yourself when you feel like you know what she needs. Don't be afraid to try different things, to go back on a 'plan', to adapt. You know her. She's yours. You have this.

lyralycra · 15/08/2023 12:39

And don't let posters like @Dinoswearunderpants influence you OP!

Tiredstressedmum · 15/08/2023 12:39

Thanks so much for all the replies. I’ve had a bit of time to relax and read now after being very emotional this morning.

I’d like to be clear and state I absolutely do believe breast is best on a population level. I just meant what I’ve read so far doesn’t convince me that not BFing will be disastrous to DD’s health. I wasn’t looking to rubbish BFing at all (and definitely not to state FF is better as someone stated!!). I really just wanted to know if there was any benefit in giving her some over none as I’ve accepted that EBF just isn’t for me.

I also am aware the ‘fussiness’ after expressed milk is probably due to the different digestion rates etc and that naturally she’d be taking it in cluster feeds, not one drink. This is why I’m finding combination hard and wanted to know if it’s worth it for her. If it’s worth it, I’ll do anything to make it work. The hind milk is a very good point though, as is trying it out on a feed when she’s not already ravenous.

DH comments useful also. He’s been beyond hands on and far more confident than I am. He does want me to stop pumping but only because he thinks I’m getting very upset and formula is fine for her. He’s got no ulterior motive beyond our happiness and is frustrated at how guilty I am feeling (although really that’s come from within as everyone has been very supportive to me). I think I’d feel better if I could give her some milk. Nothing else is going right but I’m finding pumping very easy and producing good quantities now, I’d love to be able to get it into her.

To those suggesting a final attempt at BFing - I just don’t want to. I feel so guilty admitting it but do need to as it makes it easier to make onward plans. I find it incredibly stressful and just have a block around the whole thing now. I know she’ll be frustrated as taking from the breast is less easy than a bottle and I’m just not strong enough to work through that frustration with her.

OP posts:
lyralycra · 15/08/2023 12:38

As a society, we've become incredibly baby-centric. You do whatever feels right for you, OP. BF has some marginal benefits, like you found in your research, but nothing that should trump your own well-being. Baby won't suffer if he or she isn't BF!

Dinoswearunderpants · 15/08/2023 12:38

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

HappierTimesAhead · 15/08/2023 12:37

Xlap · 15/08/2023 10:12

OP please don't stress yourself about this. I was in a similar situation to yours. DS never latched, I was heartbroken, this guilt almost lead to PND. We put him on Formula,he is almost 2 now, on 99th centile for height and weight for his group. He is active, smart and a great problem solver for his age.
One of my observations is that most of the technological advancements comes from the countries with the lowest breastfeeding rates like UK, USA and Sweden etc, while you hear none of the breakthrough from the countries with highest breastfeeding rates like Burundi, Rwanda, Sri Lanka etc.
I don't think Breastfeeding or not leads to any difference in the outcomes for a child. Intelligence etc depend on the lifetime of hardwork from parents, genetics, child's own interest etc.
My friend was totally formula fed, now in 40s, studied at Oxbridge, high flying job, C level executive and six figure salary.
I wouldn't worry too much, just do whatever works for you ❤️ enjoy this time, it goes quick. All the best !

This is one of the most offensive posts I have seen on here. The implication that breastfed babies don't necessarily go on to earn lots of money so therefore breastfeeding isn't better is like some sick joke. The countries you mention have been ravaged by colonialism - there is no comparison.

You can pretend breastfeeding isn't better that formula if it makes you feel better but it isn't true (I say that as someone who has breastfed and had to bottle feed). Breastmilk has incredible benefits for babies. It doesn't mean we should breastfeed at the expense of our own health but it is the truth.

herewegoroundthebastardbush · 15/08/2023 12:36

NeverDropYourMooncup · 15/08/2023 12:19

I'd add to that making clear to her husband that he is not to interfere, criticise or negatively comment in any way - he is, in my opinion, deciding how she feeds her baby because he has decided it doesn't make a difference because the emotional and physical aspects of breastfeeding aren't quantifiable. For some mothers, those aspects can be less important, for some, they can be more so - in both cases, whether in favour of or against a choice to BF.

His role should be of support, of providing her with food, drinks, affection, comfort - not sweeping in with a 'I knew this wouldn't work, we've already decided it isn't important, give her to me, I know what I'm doing, you just get on with your hormonal crying whilst I do the parenting' type of attitude.

I have to say I'm not getting where you're getting all this about the husband - all I've read is that he researched with the OP antenatally and that he takes the baby from her when baby and mum are getting distressed, which does sound quite helpful. I'm going to reread the OP's posts but I don't know where you're getting this authoritarian bullying from.

Fundamentally I think feeding the baby largely falls to the mum whichever way you do it (which is no bad thing as long as she's adequately supported, because the baby instinctively wants to attach to a main caregiver, usually mum) so it's up to mum how she wants to do it. So in that sense I agree he should take a supporting role; but I haven't read anything here which says he hasn't.

Tiredstressedmum · 15/08/2023 12:30

PumpkinPie2016 · 15/08/2023 11:51

I'm sorry you had a tough start @Tiredstressedmum

I would say, please don't worry about your daughter having/not having breastmilk. Any benefits really are minimal.

FWIW my son was born after a difficult delivery and while he was totally fine and a healthy 9lb 6oz, I was badly anaemic due to blood loss in theatre when I had an emergency c-section, exhausted and a bit of a car crash.

I didn't even attempt breastfeeding- I wasn't well enough. Didn't express either, he was formula fed from day 1.

He's 9 now - extremely healthy, tall and slim. Eats anything, never ill and loads of energy. So not having breast milk hasn't made a jot of difference.

Please do whatever works for you 🌺

Thanks pumpkin. Our starts sound similar. We never got skin to skin and I barely remembered I had a baby on the first night! I was too exhausted and weak and sore to properly try in the first few days and now I’m better I feel so upset and stressed by the whole thing I can’t bring myself to try..

OP posts:
Tiredstressedmum · 15/08/2023 12:27

Oliotya · 15/08/2023 11:41

If she's been formula fed from day 1, then she's never been EBF (exclusively breastfed). A healthy 1 day old does not need top-up formula, so if that was medical advice, I'd be questioning that.
If you're looking for permission to drop the breastmilk, you don't need it. If you want to breastfeed, get some proper support and give it a real, good, sustained try. Take baby to bed and just feed feed feed.
She's 10 days old. She will seem ravenous. The urge to cluster feed will persist to some extent, whether formula or breastfed. It doesn't mean your breastmilk is insufficient.
If you don't want to breastfeed, don't. You don't need an excuse or a reason.

Sorry poor wording. I meant if I were EBF I would just pop her on. I know she’s not been BF let alone EBF Grin. Thank you for a very supportive reply though Flowers

OP posts:
NeverDropYourMooncup · 15/08/2023 12:19

herewegoroundthebastardbush · 15/08/2023 12:12

In your specific case I'd do the fllowing:

  1. take the pressure to breastfeed off yourself. You were obviously very ambiguous about it in the first place or you wouldn't have gone out looking for evidence to undermine it. Formula is a perfectly adequate replacement to breastmilk, will do your baby no harm, and is working for you both. So just stop worrying first of all. Feed her formula on the schedule that keeps her full and happy.

  2. if you still want her to have breastmilk, then pack up the pumping (except to maintain supply) and try to get her on the breast. That way whatever she has will be 'extra' nutritionally to her formula feeds, she won't get hungry, but she might get used to it and come to like it - either simply as a comfort, bonding ritual and a nutritional/immunological supplement, or perhaps she might as she gets bigger be able to more easily extract enough milk at the breast to satiate her.

  3. to encourage easy feeding at the breast, I would recommend lying in bed with your baby when she's sleeping after a formula feed, getting skin to skin (if she likes that - contrary to received wisdom, not all babies do!), and when she stirs and is still half asleep offer her the breast (you can get videos that show you how to do side-lying feeding). She's young enough that her suckling instinct should take over, and if she's not hungry it won't matter if she's getting milk at all really - the comfort and enjoyment will still be there for her, so she won't get frustrated at the breast. She may not even wake up at all.

Hopefully this sort of low pressure comfort feeding may grow into something more long-term and sustaining. If nothing else it will be some pleasant, relaxed time bonding with your baby, and you can know you have offered her breastmilk while still ensuring with formula that she's well fed and contented.

To be honest I think you sabotaged yourself a bit with your prenatal attempts to convince yourself breastfeeding was not important - if you've already psyched yourself out like that then the difficult bit at the beginning (and it is usually difficult at the beginning, it's a skill to be learned like everything else!) will seem like more trouble than it's worth. In a sense the 'is breast better than formula' question is a bit of a red herring. As I said, formula is a perfectly adequate way to feed a baby if done safely. The important question is always 'do you want to breastfeed?'. Because what you want is important. It sounds like you do want to, when it comes down to it. So give yourself a chance!

I'd add to that making clear to her husband that he is not to interfere, criticise or negatively comment in any way - he is, in my opinion, deciding how she feeds her baby because he has decided it doesn't make a difference because the emotional and physical aspects of breastfeeding aren't quantifiable. For some mothers, those aspects can be less important, for some, they can be more so - in both cases, whether in favour of or against a choice to BF.

His role should be of support, of providing her with food, drinks, affection, comfort - not sweeping in with a 'I knew this wouldn't work, we've already decided it isn't important, give her to me, I know what I'm doing, you just get on with your hormonal crying whilst I do the parenting' type of attitude.

Hotmilk1 · 15/08/2023 12:18

I’m not sure how people can question whether breast milk, which is designed for human infants, is more beneficial than cows milk, which is designed for calves.

Feed your child however you like, but let’s not pretend that breast feeding doesn’t have a range of health benefits for both mum and baby, to make yourself feel better.