Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder if giving any breast milk is that important?

242 replies

Tiredstressedmum · 15/08/2023 09:00

Posting on AIBU for traffic.

I’m a FTM to a gorgeous ten day old.

Prior to delivery, DH and I did a lot of research into feeding. We both read a lot of studies and reached the conclusion that any potential benefits of BFing are likely to be marginal; we couldn’t find any conclusive swings in outcomes for BFing and found a lot of the outcomes were confounded out by factors such as socioeconomic status and parental behaviours. I reached the conclusion that I would try BFing but be quick to switch to formula if it wasn’t working for us, although secretly was confident it would work and I’d have one of those snuggly milky newborns all mumsnetters seem to have Sad.

As it turned out, the birth did not go to plan and BFing was really hard; I don’t think LO ever had a feed (lots of latch issues) and was on top up formula from day 1. Feeding was becoming distressing for both of us and I could feel myself becoming very anxious, low and obsessive about it despite a lot of midwife support. On day four, DH bought formula and we had several days of bliss.

However, despite our previous research I felt (and still feel) wracked with guilt about being selfish and depriving LO of a good start. I decided to try pumping with good effect and have started replacing one or two bottles a day with breast milk. This sounds good in theory but LO is very unsettled after these feeds and ends up constantly crying (screaming) / taking top up breast milk until the next formula feed ‘resets’ her. I’m worried my attempts to assuage my own guilt are actually leaving her hungry and possibly causing digestive issues and discomfort.

I can’t find any information on how much breast milk is beneficial (have seen as low as 50 mL quoted a lot but no idea where this comes from) and whether my feeding regime is actually helping her in any way at all. AIBU to wonder whether giving her these bottles of breast milk is really helpful to her or whether I’m just complicating her feeding to make myself feel better?! It’s so psychologically difficult to be producing good milk for her and not giving it to her. Selfishly, I also fear judgement from other parents and professionals - I wish I could be wonderfully logical and rational like DH, who thinks formula is the best thing ever, but I’m just full of emotions and guilt and it’s stopping me enjoying my darling. Every time she cries (which is a fair bit because she’s a baby!) I end up crying too because I’m worried she’s hungry and I’ve deprived her, and DH ends up taking over.

OP posts:
Oliotya · 16/08/2023 09:04

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

No I will not fuck off. A single day of breastfeeding is not effort. If a mother doesn't want to make the effort, that's a valid choice, and I don't judge. But a single day of anything is not what I would consider effort.
I've formula fed and breastfed, so I can assure you I don't judge either way.

RosaGallica · 16/08/2023 09:02

I would be very suspicious of any ‘research’ purporting to show that formula milk is better than breast milk. Breast milk has evolved over millions of years and been going as long as mammals have. Formula milk, weirdly enough, has definite known and proven benefits for the manufacturers and shareholders of private companies providing formula milk. They have been known to try and push their costly artificial milk before, at the expense of human health, as have many other private companies. Breastmilk is so convenient too. It can be difficult to start, but is definitely worth pursuing until / unless it is really too painful to continue.

herewegoroundthebastardbush · 16/08/2023 08:57

Another direct quote from the P @MariaVT65 - really don't know where you got the idea she isn't happy with pumping:

Nothing else is going right but I’m finding pumping very easy and producing good quantities now, I’d love to be able to get it into her.

herewegoroundthebastardbush · 16/08/2023 08:52

MariaVT65 · 16/08/2023 07:35

Your post is disgusting and not applicable to this thread.

’Lack of effort’ is not the issue. Quite the opposite infact. Breastfeeding does not work for everyone because of latching issues or lack of supply. OP is making a great deal of effort trying to pump, which is still not getting anywhere near the full supply (i had the same issue). Pumping is utterly exhausting and sometimes has a really negative impact on the mother’s wellbeing. It is twice the effort as you have to pump the milk and then feed it. Give us mothers some credit here.

See I may disagree with you on some things but this? 👏👏👏👏

Pumping is hard, it's hard on mothers. But sometimes it is what enables them to avoid something much harder, which is giving up on their strong desire to feed their babies their own milk. This is not a stupid wish, it is for some women an enormous drive and to have to give it up is utterly heartbreaking and can be even more injurious to their mental health than a pumping regime may be. It's about the individual woman, what matters most to her, what she needs, and what is possible. If the whole breastfeeding discussion started from that - what the mother wants - we'd have a lot less trouble with the debate. We'd have a lot fewer people 'trying' bf and giving up because it's not for them or they never really wanted to but felt they ought to, but feel judged for that and so have to give the impression bf was IMPOSSIBLE for them when in fact it simply was not what they wanted; we'd have a lot fewer mothers forcing themselves to try to do the impossible with insufficient supply or insurmountable latch issues, harming themselves and their babies long past the point where this was what they wanted; we'd have a lot fewer mothers being told to give up at the first sign of trouble because bf 'doesn't make any difference [to the baby]', when it makes an absolutely massive difference to her because she's desperate to bf.

I mean honestly, women being made to feel selfish for bf, women being made to feel selfish for not bf - all this headfucking and statistics-waving and emotional blackmail on both sides, when in fact where the conversation should start is what the mother wants, what's important to her, and how to get as close to that as possible. It goes without saying that for the vast, vast majority of mothers, that starts with their baby being healthy and happy, because no-one cares about the baby's wellbeing like its mother does. The idea that the mother's interests and the baby's are in any way pitted against each other is a fabrication from both sides. They are a dyad, and the mother is the one best placed to decide the best direction for that dyad - if she is empowered and supported to do so.

herewegoroundthebastardbush · 16/08/2023 08:40

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

herewegoroundthebastardbush · 16/08/2023 08:31

MariaVT65 · 16/08/2023 07:29

Have we read the same post?? OP has literally said:

-She is not enjoying it
-Combi feeding is the worst of both worlds— She has accepted expressing is not for her

Direct quote from OP below:

Instinctively, I don’t want to breastfeed but do want her to have my pumped milk. I just hope those two statements aren’t conflicting / selfish.

She doesn't want to breastfeed any more but she does want baby to have her pumped milk. Hard to be clearer than that really. What the hell are YOU reading that says she has accepted expressing is not for her?

Oliotya · 16/08/2023 08:20

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

MariaVT65 · 16/08/2023 07:35

Redmat · 15/08/2023 16:48

Why would you not give your baby a food that is so clever it can even produce the right antbodies for when your baby is ill?
Breadt milk is best. People seem scared to say that because they don't want to upset new mums.
Perhaps if it were made clearer people would put more effort in. Because it does take effort but once established it has to be the most rewarding wonderful experience for mother and baby.

Your post is disgusting and not applicable to this thread.

’Lack of effort’ is not the issue. Quite the opposite infact. Breastfeeding does not work for everyone because of latching issues or lack of supply. OP is making a great deal of effort trying to pump, which is still not getting anywhere near the full supply (i had the same issue). Pumping is utterly exhausting and sometimes has a really negative impact on the mother’s wellbeing. It is twice the effort as you have to pump the milk and then feed it. Give us mothers some credit here.

MariaVT65 · 16/08/2023 07:29

herewegoroundthebastardbush · 15/08/2023 16:10

Actually it's you who has missed the point and tone. OP has explicitly said she doesn't want to breastfeed any more but DOES want to keep pumping and giving her DD milk. That's what SHE wants. But you'd rather paint your narrative of the poof beleaguered mother onto her instead of listening to what she's saying and dealing with that.

Have we read the same post?? OP has literally said:

-She is not enjoying it
-Combi feeding is the worst of both worlds— She has accepted expressing is not for her

MariaVT65 · 16/08/2023 07:20

Somethingsnappy · 15/08/2023 18:43

But you were the one who approached the feeding specialist yourself, or at least accepted the referal? Of course they would then try to help you. It's not up to them to acknowledge that you need to switch to formula, as presumably they assumed you were seeking help with breastfeeding?

I didn’t actually say anything you’re accusing me of?? I didn’t say it was up to the specialist to say ‘use formula’ didn I? Yes i reached out for help out of desperation as I wanted help with positioning/latching etc (as it was lockdown so had received fuck all help from anyone else), but the tube thing went too far for me personally.

NalafromtheLionKing · 16/08/2023 07:14

Tiredstressedmum · 15/08/2023 12:50

This was a lovely reply and made
me cry. DH read it too. It’s so hard not to treat this whole thing like a project and become obsessive. Maybe a bit more instinct and a bit less research is what we need here! Instinctively, I don’t want to breastfeed but do want her to have my pumped milk. I just hope those two statements aren’t conflicting / selfish.

I think it could be something in the breast milk (eg I once tried to be healthy by drinking banana juice and it caused my DS to scream with wind). Either way, just do whatever makes you and DD happy without any guilt or pressure.

lifehappens12 · 16/08/2023 06:53

Hi, reading your messages you seem really tired, stressed and that you want to do everything the best way for your child which is great.

I wanted to but couldn't bf my two babies. With my first I felt really down about it. With my second I had the attitude that if it doesn't work we go to formula. My view was I wanted to enjoy this baby and not be stressed. I still spent most of the first month cuddled up on the sofa with my new born on my chest not feeding but bottle feeding on demand.

At ten days we had no feeding schedule - at that age she could be growth spurting so just feed as often as she asks. Even bottle fed babies can cluster feed and demand more milk even after a feed.

Good luck - and I would ditch the pumping and focus on you and your baby

Mummy08m · 15/08/2023 22:11

herewegoroundthebastardbush · 15/08/2023 21:48

Of all the things I didn't give a monkeys about when I decided to breastfeed my children, exam results were right up there at the top of the list. Honestly really who breastfeeds on the hope it's going to give their kids an edge on the eleven-plus?? Do these people exist? It's hardly a gotcha.

100% agree with this - I was (and am) just so bloody glad my dd was a healthy weight, breathing and (occasionally) sleeping. Never once thought smugly that my extended-breastfed toddler would do better in school 13 years from now (!) just vaguely hoped she might have fewer vomiting bugs in the early years

herewegoroundthebastardbush · 15/08/2023 21:48

tikfock · 15/08/2023 20:15

Oh and you may find this episode of Radio 4's More or Less, they do a good analysis of studies that look at whether there is a link between breastfeeding and better exam results - spoiler alert - there isn't!

podcasts.apple.com/gb/podcast/more-or-less-behind-the-stats/id267300884?i=1000617339766

Of all the things I didn't give a monkeys about when I decided to breastfeed my children, exam results were right up there at the top of the list. Honestly really who breastfeeds on the hope it's going to give their kids an edge on the eleven-plus?? Do these people exist? It's hardly a gotcha.

tikfock · 15/08/2023 20:15

tikfock · 15/08/2023 19:50

OP, is your baby producing enough wet and dirty nappies? And gaining weight as expected?

If so you have enough "wiggle room" to experiment with feeding.

Why not try the breast before every feed for the day, she how it goes, if things get stressy. Go for the bottle, but you might find you can relax into it when you know it's not the end of the world if a feed doesn't go how you want?

Oh and I agree with others - please don't beat yourself up - being a first time mum is HARD! You do not need to give yourself additional pressure.

Honestly, after 6 months your baby will be eating all sorts, and after a year they will probably be on cows milk - this whole breastfeeding/formula thing is actually only for an astonishingly short period of their life.

Please know you are doing great - be kind to yourself.

Oh and you may find this episode of Radio 4's More or Less, they do a good analysis of studies that look at whether there is a link between breastfeeding and better exam results - spoiler alert - there isn't!

podcasts.apple.com/gb/podcast/more-or-less-behind-the-stats/id267300884?i=1000617339766

ladygindiva · 15/08/2023 19:52

Purely anecdotal but:
DC 1 - exclusively breastfed for over a year, went like a dream.
Dc2 and 3 ( twins) : DC2 not a drop of breast milk passed her lips. Despite all my efforts .DC3 combi fed for about a fortnight with expressed milk, until I fell apart emotionally over the sheer stress of it.

DC 1- fussy eater, always ill, riddled with allergies.
Dc2- eats anything, never ill, no allergies
Dc3 - fussy eater, fairly average health-wise
Oh and academically they were all on a par with each other, if anything dc3 is the brightest.
I'm not that sold on breastfeeding tbh.

tikfock · 15/08/2023 19:50

OP, is your baby producing enough wet and dirty nappies? And gaining weight as expected?

If so you have enough "wiggle room" to experiment with feeding.

Why not try the breast before every feed for the day, she how it goes, if things get stressy. Go for the bottle, but you might find you can relax into it when you know it's not the end of the world if a feed doesn't go how you want?

Oh and I agree with others - please don't beat yourself up - being a first time mum is HARD! You do not need to give yourself additional pressure.

Honestly, after 6 months your baby will be eating all sorts, and after a year they will probably be on cows milk - this whole breastfeeding/formula thing is actually only for an astonishingly short period of their life.

Please know you are doing great - be kind to yourself.

Yellowlegobrick · 15/08/2023 19:22

DD would accept formula from a bottle but not breast milk.

Perhaps baby associates the taste of breastmilk with breastfeeding directly, especially the non nutritive sucking element of sucking for comfort, and is unsettled because she wants that?

Its bizarre for a baby to require more breastmilk than formula as formula is specifically designed the have the same calorie, fat etc content as breastmilk.

Since you've still got milk supply, you could try offering the breast as well as formula. None of the pressure or worrying if she's fed and lots of babies get much better at latching a couple of weeks after they are born - you might find it easier and pleasant now

Favouritefruits · 15/08/2023 18:59

I felt just like you, I felt like a failure at the time and it consumed my mind. It seems such a huge deal but when your children are past 12months it’s a nothing, you will never think about it again and nobody I’ll ask how you fed your 6year old. Please make this issue small in your mind as it such a minor thing in all honesty.

IAmKenough · 15/08/2023 18:58

Your last statement struck me OP. It's not selfish for you to want your baby to have breast milk if it's delivered my bottle, either mixed or on its own.

Breastfeeding worked for me for convenience and I was lucky. You have inadvertently set yourself up with the worst of all worlds. Doing all options is logistically more difficult and stressful. Any changes in baby you relate back to feeding. If breast feeding is not for you, that's absolutely fine. I'm not a scientist, but I work with Early Years children and the factors that influence a child would not have breastfeeding on the long list never mind the short list.

Feed your child however suits you, but make your choice and be at peace with it. These are precious days and weeks you will zoom through. And having a stressed mummy is a bigger worry to your baby than what's in the bottle. Good luck, and enjoy. X

Dropthedonkey · 15/08/2023 18:51

Professor of breastfeeding 😀
OP your dh seems to have far too much of a say in this imho. His role is to support you not to push you.

Oliotya · 15/08/2023 18:45

Oliotya · 15/08/2023 18:44

Yes! Ime no professor will ever recommend them, but definitely worth a try before giving up. My 2nd destroyed my nipples, so I used nippple shields. Weaned off them by 6 weeks and he fed almost 2 years.

Professional not professor

Oliotya · 15/08/2023 18:44

shaniahoo · 15/08/2023 16:27

Haven't RTFT but has anybody said nipple shields? Could be a game changer for getting her to latch on.

Yes! Ime no professor will ever recommend them, but definitely worth a try before giving up. My 2nd destroyed my nipples, so I used nippple shields. Weaned off them by 6 weeks and he fed almost 2 years.

Somethingsnappy · 15/08/2023 18:43

MariaVT65 · 15/08/2023 11:10

Yeah sorry, it was ridiculous for someone who was going through severe PND and PTSD after a traumatic birth in a pandemic who had got bugger sleep in weeks, along with midwives telling me to pump 8-12 times a day to keep my supply up. Sometimes things just push you over the edge and it needs to be acknowledge that a mother needs to rest rather than fannying about with tubes. Great it worked for your sister though.

But you were the one who approached the feeding specialist yourself, or at least accepted the referal? Of course they would then try to help you. It's not up to them to acknowledge that you need to switch to formula, as presumably they assumed you were seeking help with breastfeeding?

Dropthedonkey · 15/08/2023 18:39

Why would anyone tell a new mum that the baby needed a formula top up, when she was trying to breast feed, on "day 1"? What milk could she have on day 1, it hasn't come in yet!
The advice dishes out to women really sucks sometimes.

Swipe left for the next trending thread