Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MIL taking my daughter to lake waterpark

380 replies

YorkshireLucy · 15/08/2023 06:50

So, my DH has taken my children (16 and 13) to visit her for a few days.

I had a message from my 16 year old panicking because grandma has booked a day at a lake doing watersports.

My DD has just had her ears pierced (seconds and tragus so 3 altogether). She was told not to go swimming in the first few weeks and to be careful for a couple of months after that. It is less than two weeks since she had them done. She should especially avoid open water.

Now, grandma has told her she WILL go and she WILL enjoy herself because she's paid over £90 for this.

I'm fuming. She never mentioned this and never asked them to pack swimwear. She's told them to put an old T-shirt and pants on under a wetsuit? They only have nice new clothes with them that will get ruined!

For context my MIL has form for this. She's quite controlling and a bit of a bully. Constantly makes my children feel like crap. She's passive aggressive with me which is why I personally refuse to see her now. But hubby insisted on this trip.

I get she's paid for a fun activity but has completely disregarded my daughters feelings and worries about this. What if her ears get caught on a helmet or worse get infected?

As for my husband, I'll be speaking to him before they go. Can't believe he's not stuck up for her or said anything (well I can, but that's another story). He knows she shouldn't be getting her piercings wet through swimming/activities like this.

AIBU to not want to let them go?

OP posts:
SoHereBesMe · 17/08/2023 12:02

My DD had ears pierced in June. She wanted to go in lake during July. We didn't as her ears showed signs of infection after we forgot to spray with saline spray. I wouldn't be letting her in dirty water after 2 weeks. Not a mission.

Toomuchtrouble4me · 17/08/2023 10:37

The clothing issue is a non - issue. They can just go in pants under a wetsuit and shorts and a T-Shirt don’t get ruined by getting wet. That’s a daft excuse.
Presumably DD washes her hair? So ears get wet anyway? The ears will be fine, she can just bathe them in antiseptic lotion afterwards.
The BIG issue is - Is it you who doesn’t want them to go because you hate mother in law? (I get that btw, I hate mine and am always awkward whenever I can be, because she’s a bitch) Or do they genuinely not want to go? They are old enough to be asked and if they were asked and agreed before tickets were purchased then they should go. If they weren’t asked, and don’t want to go then they should just say no. They are old enough. Just No. And if it escalates then tell them to train home or go and get them. Is DH with them there?

Toria33 · 17/08/2023 06:51

So I don’t wish to alarm but I did catch a rare bad infection from outside water from a cut in my finger that lead to a week long stay on Iv antibiotics, so do not think that mum is over reacting. (acetobacter) I actually came pretty close to sepsis.
Children teens of any age should not be forced to do activities, just because adult of supposed authority says so. They are allowed to say I don’t want to do something.
it almost feels like purposely disregarding comfort (saying to wear their clothes) any sane grandparent would by swimming costumes, it almost feels like an act of humiliation as they didn’t go along with what she planned. I feel water sport requires some written consent from a parent, as my mum gave some when we went on a school trip to Wales but she retraced consent for a activity , they made me to it and got in trouble. So pretty sure you could call and say that you don’t give consent for them to do the activities.

PUGMEISTER21 · 17/08/2023 04:55

More to the point you say MIL has form for this, so why do you continue to send them there and then have to deal with the uncomfortable situations for all involved? I wouldn't bother sending them anymore.

Solonge · 16/08/2023 23:44

You may need to be confrontational. Ring MIL and tell her your daughter is not going, period and there is no room for discussion. Let her know that your daughters are not visiting so they can be bullied into undertaking a day out they don’t wish to take part in. I suggest you also ring your husband and offer to fly out and help him find his backbone. Make it clear, this is not happening.

Grammarnut · 16/08/2023 22:00

Why are you so stressed? The waterpark sounds fun. Ear piercings will be fine as long as DD uses the medication supplied to clean them two or three times a day. What does passisve aggressive mean, btw, and are you sure your MIL isn't reacting to your hysterical reaction to her? Tell your daughters to have fun and tell your DH to go and buy them swimming costumes - that'll teach him a lesson without anything else' he'll feel the pain and irritation of buying swimming costumes for two girls, who will, without doubt, be fussy.

YorkshireLucy · 16/08/2023 20:41

pollymere · 16/08/2023 20:07

Oh - it wasn't about safety or whether it was done with a needle. My local piercer won't do more than one piercing per ear at a time so that healing isn't delayed and swimming is definitely not allowed. She's strict but excellent. My child is very unimpressed as they got a cartilage piercing and now have to wait.

I'm glad they managed to do canoeing instead. It's a lot easier to keep the ears dry.

It's fine to get upto 4 at a time. But, I agree your piercer is being cautious. It can take longer for healing so I see why she uses this method of no more than one 🙂

MIL taking my daughter to lake waterpark
OP posts:
YorkshireLucy · 16/08/2023 20:36

FuzzHair · 16/08/2023 20:18

This plus how can water ruin clothes?

Dirty lake water with a well used wetsuit can.
I did a lot of scuba diving when younger and trust me, if not cleaned properly they can leave marks on clothing, especially from lake water.
The clothes they have are new. When they were bought I didn't envisage they'd be jumping into a lake with them on or I'd of bought much cheaper clothing for them to ruin on a 50 minute activity.

OP posts:
FuzzHair · 16/08/2023 20:18

RedHelenB · 15/08/2023 07:10

If she's old enough for those piercings she's old enough to say she can't go to her gran. However, I think it's mountain molehill territory and she'd be fine doing it, it's just you looking to moan about MIL.

This plus how can water ruin clothes?

pollymere · 16/08/2023 20:07

Oh - it wasn't about safety or whether it was done with a needle. My local piercer won't do more than one piercing per ear at a time so that healing isn't delayed and swimming is definitely not allowed. She's strict but excellent. My child is very unimpressed as they got a cartilage piercing and now have to wait.

I'm glad they managed to do canoeing instead. It's a lot easier to keep the ears dry.

Rosscameasdoody · 16/08/2023 20:00

Twentytwothousand · 16/08/2023 18:50

She doesn’t want to swim because of her piercings or because she doesn’t like water sports? I’m sure she could plaster over her piercings and then clean them thoroughly after swimming. Appreciate you don’t like your MiL but presume she’s booked this as a treat even if she’s got that wrong. There are plenty less enjoyable things she could have booked if she was just trying to be a controlling bully. Or ask her to investigate what’s safe with recent piercings - if she hears it first hand she may realise she’s got it wrong, not just that your DD doesn’t fancy it.

This is the daftest post so far. Tragus piercing can take a year to heal and are troublesome sometimes. ‘Plastering over’ piercings in cartilage is painful and ineffective. Swimming in open water - a lake - is dodgy at the best of times, let alone when you have piercings vulnerable to infection.

YorkshireLucy · 16/08/2023 19:47

pollymere · 16/08/2023 19:19

I'm surprised your ear piercer let you have three piercings done at once. Why is that relevant? Because healing times are extended apparently. Mind has just had a piercing and the piercer won't do the second lobe ones until the first ones have healed. And definitely no swimming.

We did manage it in a pool with a bit of tape and avoiding getting the head wet but I've been and done lake watersports and it's incredibly difficult not to get completely soaked in grimy water.

Other than ensuring they are covered with surgical tape and cleaning them when it's done, I would say it's a no-go.

On the MIL front, I totally sympathise. I would point out that swimwear is expected under a wetsuit and not just a t-shirt and pants. I usually wear shorts and a t-shirt with regular underwear but tend to stick to things where I won't fall in. I'm not sure she's thought this through and it's very telling that she didn't ask you to pack swimwear...

Maybe your DD could stick to kayak or canoeing if MIL is not for turning.

The piercings were done with a needle. One tragus and the other two seconds in the lobe. Perfectly safe to do. Healing time is different from the lobe to the tragus piercing though and we expect the likes to heal much sooner.
Yes, it's not asking them to bring swimwear that got me a bit surprised (or not, given the stunts she's pulled in the past).
They did in fact change the session to canoeing (apparently much to her annoyance). She basically said my DD shouldn't have had her ears pierced (yet, she never told us she was planning this). She's 16 and she's wanted them done for years, but had to wait for school to finish as they only allow one small stud per ear.
The joys of (some) MIL's.
When I was pregnant with my first she said to my parents that she didn't know what her son was playing at as he never wanted kids.
Honestly, she's a delight 🙄

OP posts:
WoosMama13 · 16/08/2023 19:24

I think many people here saying two weeks is fine, don't understand cartilage and upper lobe piercings are NOT regular lobe piercings. They can take MONTHS to heal, so DD is right to be concerned about being in open water, etc, and the professional who did her ears gave her advice as such.
Stick by your daughter lovely. Seems your husband isn't going to. If MIL kicks up a stink, it's her problem not checking beforehand. While I get it's great she wants to do stuff with them, they're not little anymore, she needs to realise this. Can she sell them on to not lose the money? Or better still get them refunded or exchange to another date so everyone can go? There will be a day if her behaviour continues, that they'll never want to visit. Does she want to risk that?
Good luck!

pollymere · 16/08/2023 19:19

I'm surprised your ear piercer let you have three piercings done at once. Why is that relevant? Because healing times are extended apparently. Mind has just had a piercing and the piercer won't do the second lobe ones until the first ones have healed. And definitely no swimming.

We did manage it in a pool with a bit of tape and avoiding getting the head wet but I've been and done lake watersports and it's incredibly difficult not to get completely soaked in grimy water.

Other than ensuring they are covered with surgical tape and cleaning them when it's done, I would say it's a no-go.

On the MIL front, I totally sympathise. I would point out that swimwear is expected under a wetsuit and not just a t-shirt and pants. I usually wear shorts and a t-shirt with regular underwear but tend to stick to things where I won't fall in. I'm not sure she's thought this through and it's very telling that she didn't ask you to pack swimwear...

Maybe your DD could stick to kayak or canoeing if MIL is not for turning.

pinkgrafittirat · 16/08/2023 19:09

The whole "periods stop in water" thing is one of those myths that get repeated online so much people just blindly believe it.

Some women find that they either stop bleeding or bleed so little that they can't visibly see it, and others don't, which is due to a combination of multiple factors unique to the individual. Anyone making a blanket statement "ALL women's periods stop in water/while swimming" is just wrong, period. (No pun intended.)

My periods definitely don't stop either in the bath or while swimming.

I don't swim in a pool during my period, but I have multiple times swum in lakes or in the sea and then noticed a massive bloom of blood in the water and had to sheepishly get out. I'm sure someone will try to invent a reason why you continue to bleed while swimming in a lake but not a swimming pool, but the reality is it's just down to the individual.

Twentytwothousand · 16/08/2023 18:50

She doesn’t want to swim because of her piercings or because she doesn’t like water sports? I’m sure she could plaster over her piercings and then clean them thoroughly after swimming. Appreciate you don’t like your MiL but presume she’s booked this as a treat even if she’s got that wrong. There are plenty less enjoyable things she could have booked if she was just trying to be a controlling bully. Or ask her to investigate what’s safe with recent piercings - if she hears it first hand she may realise she’s got it wrong, not just that your DD doesn’t fancy it.

rainbowstardrops · 16/08/2023 18:10

I should think so too @YorkshireLucy! MIL being an arse is one thing but your DH should 100% have his daughter's backs and it doesn't seem as if he did. Presumably yet another wet lettuce of a husband who can't say no to his family in case he upsets them above his immediate family.

YorkshireLucy · 16/08/2023 18:05

rainbowstardrops · 16/08/2023 17:25

Why on earth didn't your DH step up and tell his mother that DD couldn't do water sports at the moment??? I'd be bloody having words with him!

Trust me, we have had words on the phone. We'll revisit the conversation when he gets home.

OP posts:
LookItsMeAgain · 16/08/2023 17:26

That sounds like a positive result all around. Hope they're all able to enjoy the rest of their break.

rainbowstardrops · 16/08/2023 17:25

Why on earth didn't your DH step up and tell his mother that DD couldn't do water sports at the moment??? I'd be bloody having words with him!

YorkshireLucy · 16/08/2023 17:12

LookItsMeAgain · 16/08/2023 17:01

What did your DH and kids end up doing @YorkshireLucy ?

They changed the activity to canoeing so no wet ears 😊

OP posts:
LookItsMeAgain · 16/08/2023 17:01

What did your DH and kids end up doing @YorkshireLucy ?

Rosscameasdoody · 16/08/2023 08:46

sadaboutmycat · 15/08/2023 10:51

The NHS site says 24hrs, other sites say 2 weeks.
This is nothing to do with ear piercing is it?

Do your DCs usually enjoy swimming? Are they competent swimmers? Have they ever done this kind of thing before?

If they are not, they and you are perfectly wishing your rights to say "Hang on a minute; they don't want to do this"

If they are, and it's just a MIL moan, then they and you are being ungrateful.

In your rush to turn this into a different issue you’ve over simplified what it says on the NHS site - this is what it actually says:

You should avoid swimming for at least 24 hours after having a piercing, and ideally until it has healed properly. While it's still healing, it's important to keep the piercing dry as there's a risk of infection. The healing time for a body piercing can vary depending on which part of your body is pierced and how well you look after it. Earlobe piercings usually take 6 - 8 weeks to heal. Ear cartilage piercings take significantly longer, because cartilage tissue is much tougher. There are many types of cartilage piercings, including helix piercings which heal within 3 - 6 months, and daith and tragus piercings, which can take up to 12 months. It's possible to pick up an infection from any body of water, so while your piercing heals you should avoid swimming in swimming pools, the sea, streams, lakes and rivers. You should also avoid using hot tubs.

And it doesn’t matter how well the DDs swim, whether they enjoy doing so, or if they’ve done similar before. MiL booked the activity without checking, and it turns out there’s a specific and significant risk. So no - not just another MiL moan, or ingratitude.

autienotnaughti · 16/08/2023 03:37

BlossomCloud · 15/08/2023 07:56

I'd rather my children were having fun doing watersports in the summer than worrying about piercings and clothes, but I guess it's too late for that now.

So I'm sort of on the fence as I think the activity sounds amazing and I feel sorry for your MIL too

If you find water sports fun? I don't.

LongingForWolverhampton · 16/08/2023 02:43

She is a controlling bully? But you and your husband are allowing her to see your kids. Shame on you both.