Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask how often you have treats?

116 replies

Purditnin · 14/08/2023 23:10

I have always considered myself a reasonably healthy eater. Balanced diet, not overdoing the treats, etc.

I’m currently staying with a friend’s family (DF, her DH and 15 yo DD). They’re all gorgeous and slim and sporty - and the way they eat has been pretty eye opening. Everything cooked from scratch, whole foods, lots of fish and seafood, lots of vegetables in interesting preparations, herbs and spices I’ve never even heard of.

And they don’t snack. Possibly the occasional piece of fruit and she’s baked a cake once this week, which we had after dinner a couple of times. But, that’s it. No little treats. Just three (admittedly large and delicious) meals a day.

I commented on this and DF shrugged and said “I don’t think things are treats if I have them every day. An occasional treat, for me, is once a week or something.”

I feel a bit stupid, but this blew my mind. I have ALWAYS had a little daily treat (sometimes several) and have always just assumed this was the case for everyone. A bar of chocolate or a packet of crisps or something. AIBU? If you consider yourself reasonably healthy, how often do you snack/have a little treat?

OP posts:
Purditnin · 15/08/2023 11:59

leonde · 15/08/2023 07:09

I think this poster is suggesting that you reflect on the way you are framing what a 'treat' is in your mind.

Why are bad foods/ chocolate etc labelled as 'treats' as a 'catch all', when actually you are really enjoying the home cooked food etc?

I understood what she was suggesting and I responded. It’s used as a catchall in the context of this post as an umbrella term was required in order to ask the question and, as it’s common parlance, people understand exactly what I’m asking.

OP posts:
Babdoc · 15/08/2023 11:26

I eat three healthy meals a day and treat myself to one Belgian chocolate each evening from a box in the kitchen.
That’s all - I don’t eat puddings, cake, biscuits, crisps, pastry or snacks, (and don’t drink alcohol, unless hosting visitors.)
I am five pounds over a normal BMI, gained during three years of long Covid fatigue, so am determined not to gain any more!

Milkkbottles · 15/08/2023 11:19

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the OP's request.

megletthesecond · 15/08/2023 11:17

Every single day. But around that I eat really well, at least 5 fruit / veg a day, never had a takeaway, veggie, nuts, no alcohol etc.

purplecorkheart · 15/08/2023 11:14

I don't limit myself to treats once a week etc as I found by doing that I craved them more. I know have them in the press but tend to want them less when I know I can have them whenever.

I do tend to eat more treats at weekends or days I am not working so try to make extra filling meals those days.

phoenixrosehere · 15/08/2023 11:13

1-2 times a week usually. Sometimes go a week or two without one.

Not a fan of chocolate and never really was. More of a savoury fan than sweets but do bake once every few months when I have a craving for something but am happy and content with having fruit instead. I find most crisps too salty so DH or one of the boys finishes the rest.

Treats for me when I crave them is usually chips or really spicy crisps. Often the former because the latter is more expensive (ones I like are from an Asian grocery store).

TheChosenTwo · 15/08/2023 11:02

Every day I have something you would describe as a treat. I just call it and see it as food though. Everything is food, some is more nutritious and some is less nutritious but it’s just food.

lovewoola · 15/08/2023 11:02

Don't really see them as treats though, more a snack or a sweet after dinner.

lovewoola · 15/08/2023 11:01

Every day as do my parents & dc 🤷🏻‍♀️. Breakfasts are often cereal/toast but dinners 90% cooked from scratch.

zingally · 15/08/2023 11:00

Every day!

Life is too short not to enjoy some simple pleasures!

I'm currently working my way through a lovely tub of chocolate icecream from Lidl. Had a portion every evening for about the past 5 days, and tonight there is enough left for one final, quite large portion. I woke up this morning and was already looking forward to it!

ConnieTucker · 15/08/2023 10:48

@Baldieheid We anticipate cherry season with pure greed, and eat boxes of them when they're in season

thats me with peapods!

Youcancallmeirrelevant · 15/08/2023 10:29

fallenbehind90 · 14/08/2023 23:35

I eat treats every day and I'm slim and healthy. I enjoy them and have a balanced diet so I don't think it matters.

I'm the same

Longwhiskers · 15/08/2023 10:28

We try to scatter treats across the week - on the weekend I might make a crumble or a cake to take on a walk or morning out. What I find tricky is the habit we have of putting crisps and biscuits into packed lunch - not the kids school packed lunch but if we go out for the day or are in a road trip. Otherwise it would just be a sandwich and fruit.

mondaytosunday · 15/08/2023 09:31

No. But I am trying to lose weight, so a treat is either carefully included in my calorie count or only once every three weeks or so (bbq tonight for example I know it will include too much food).
A friend once said she got in the habit of eating a bar if chocolate every day as her boyfriend did, but soon realised that extra 200 calories a day meant she put on weight, so she stopped.
The slim people I know fall into three categories. The naturally 'eat anything but have a high metabolism' so haven't ever really thought about it so don't obsess (so don't deny themselves but don't binge either); those that are super vigilant about food and/or exercise; and those who see food as fuel so don't really think about it. Most people I know fall in to the second, and all the overweight people I know do too, but with less success.

Simonjt · 15/08/2023 09:25

I eat things I enjoy everyday, sometimes the ‘treat’ is something some people may find boring, today it was six poached eggs with sourdough toast and harissa beans, yesterday it was half a tub of dairy free ben and jerrys (I’ll likely finish the rest today, I wouldn’t want it to go bad!).

80sMum · 15/08/2023 09:18

DH bought a large packet of crisps last week to take on a picnic. I ate the whole pack over the next few days. For me, that's my problem with snack foods - if they're readily available then I'm vulnerable to temptation and will probably eat them, regardless of whether or not I'm actually hungry.

If I kept a stash of snacks/"treats" in the house, I would probably eat them several times a week, maybe even daily! But because I have no stash, I only eat them rarely, such as at Christmas and Easter (chocolates), ocasional picnics in the summer (crisps) and grandchildren's birthdays (cake).

Baldieheid · 15/08/2023 09:17

A treat for us is something that is unusual, not part of our ordinary diet, or seasonal. We anticipate cherry season with pure greed, and eat boxes of them when they're in season.
Oranges are around all year, but they taste best in winter so that's when I buy them. That's the treat to me - something that you look forward to.
A meal treat is something that takes time to make, or involves a little planning. Homemade sourdough is a treat, despite it just being bread. Roast potatoes are a treat.
I don't consider snacks out of packs as treats. They're just snacks, and I'm not a big snacker. DH is, but he has to keep fueled for a very physical job so he tops up his tank every couple of hours

Bobbybobbins · 15/08/2023 09:11

I have typically snacked and eaten treat kind of food every day. Since I turned 40 my weight has started to creep up and I know it is a result of snacking as we eat healthy meals and are active. I am having a few weeks of no snacking between meals apart from a piece of fruit and relearning how to sit with my hunger (greed).

Wilkolampshade · 15/08/2023 09:01

But it's not a treat if its so frequent is it? It's just your diet? A treat is an infrequent pleasure, surely?

EllaPaella · 15/08/2023 08:53

I'm slim, a size 8-10 and eat chocolate everyday. Maybe a kitkat or a few squares of one of those big bars of lindt dark chocolate. I rarely eat cake as I don't really like it but I might have an ice cream or flapjack on occasion (not every day). It's surely just about balance? If you are exercising regularly and otherwise eating healthy food then a small snack a day isn't going to make a lot of difference.

Janieforever · 15/08/2023 08:47

I also dislike the term “treat” in this context and personally never use it. I think it’s very damaging. Had a bad day, have a treat. Had a good day, have a treat. Feeling tired, have a treat. Succeeded in something, have a treat. Someone pissed you off. Have a treat. It’s also very childish.

a treat should not be a term used to describe some crap that’s routine and unhealthy. If you want to eat it, eat it. Eat as much of it as you wish. Your body your choice. But don’t kid yourself it’s a treat. It’s not. Call it what it is. Don’t use a twee term for it.

FelicityFlops · 15/08/2023 08:33

It depends on what you class as a treat. From your post it sounds like you are thinking of sweets, biscuits, chocolate etc. All of which are UPFs and add no nutritional value to your diet or wellbeing.
An edible treat for me would be buying some lovely, fresh figs, for example, but I actually do not believe in food being seen or used as a treat. It is fuel for your mind and body. Just as I wouldn't put 2-stroke into my car, I wouldn't put anything similar into my body. It isn't worth it.

Curseofthenation · 15/08/2023 08:29

I eat more snacks when pregnant, but yeah, I agree with @Snapsnap1 that I am not in the mindset of calling things like chocolate 'treats'. I don't feel shame either though.

If I eat too much crap then I don't feel great, but it is more of a physical feeling. It also depends on what you're defining as a treat.

So, while pregnant I eat a bar of Lindtt dark chocolate approx. once a week, generally over two days, a donut and x2 cupcakes. Sometimes my DH will make a crumble on the weekend or I'll make banana bread with my toddler.

I didn't eat the donut or chocolate pre-pregnancy but I did drink a couple of gin and tonics every Friday. Everything else was the same.

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 15/08/2023 08:18

I hate the word “treats” (no idea why)

Me too. There's something a bit twee, infantilising and performatively self-indulgent about it, in an 'Ooh aren't I naughty!' kind of way. Sweet stuff and crisps are tempting and I probably eat too much of them, but I see them as normal, common (if unhealthy) foods, not treats. A treat would be something special and properly indulgent - a luxurious homemade cake etc.

Isthisexpected · 15/08/2023 08:15

My treat would be a particularly expensive cut of meat or a very fancy cheese etc. So perhaps once a fortnight. Eating processed crap daily doesn't appeal to me and I don't see it as a treat just a bad decision (that I sometimes make!).