Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBu to eat a peanut butter sandwich at work?

136 replies

TwistMyMelons · 14/08/2023 21:38

Every time I take one I wonder if I’m being unreasonable to do this. I work in an open plan office. But I don’t have anyone sitting very close to me. It’s a quiet office and not one where I can reasonably ask people if they have allergies.
Is it ok for me to be eating a peanut butter sandwich in work or is it inconsiderate?? Please help 😂

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Barney60 · 15/08/2023 09:41

I would have thought most work places ban peanuts

Ive NEVER worked anywhere where nuts have been banned.

OhBeAFineGuyKissMe · 15/08/2023 09:40

Nutella is hazelnuts which is less likely to be airborne / minimal contact and the allergic person has to eat it themselves.

It is also confusing as peanuts are not actually nuts (they are a type of pea - a legume) which makes dealing with allergies a bit trickier.

10HailMarys · 15/08/2023 09:29

Nevermay · 14/08/2023 23:02

I would have thought most work places ban peanuts

My office (large organisation, known for being responsible and right-on, very strict on safety and inclusion) sells plenty of peanut-containing snacks in its vending machines, so no.

TwistMyMelons · 15/08/2023 09:28

@Fraaahnces

I had never even considered Nutella!

OP posts:
Fraaahnces · 15/08/2023 09:26

My DS and I both have anaphylaxis to various nuts. (And other things).Thank you for being so very considerate. I have never heard of anyone being so proactive about this. While I think asking HR whether anyone has a tree nut allergy is great, I also think that it is in only very rare cases that inhaled aerosolized peanut are going to be an issue. If you hotdesk at work, take some wipes and clean the desk, chair, monitor, keyboard and mouse and everything you are likely to have touched as well as your fingers, of course. Take the used wipes with you or dispose of in a knitted plastic bag and don’t leave bottles in or on your desk that you may have touched or sipped from and you’d be fine. (Btw, how many people eat Nutella and don’t think twice?)0

Nevermay · 15/08/2023 09:22

BlossomCloud · 15/08/2023 09:13

Incorrect and utterly ignorant. Milk is the leading cause of death from anaphylaxis in children in the UK

And I have witnessed my son have several anaphylactic reactions to it.

(People can be intolerant to milk (non IgE) but they can also be anaphylactic (IgE))

Both Benedict Blythe and Karanbir Cheema died in school from milk allergies. In Karanbir's case the cheese was just thrown at him , he didn't eat it

but roughly 90% of anaphylatic incidences ( and deaths) in the uk is down to nuts

sorry your son has so much to face, this is just about the stats though, not about individuals

thereisnorightanswer · 15/08/2023 09:20

Do you hot desk?

If it's your desk, and no one is going to have to potentially type at your keyboard and expose themselves to nut dust, that's fine. If you do hot desk, please clean your stuff at the end of the day with a wipe to make it safer for the person using your desk tomorrow. Most office cleaners just wipe down the desk (assuming you've gone home already) and that's it.

Even if you don't hot desk, please be considerate when washing your nutty hands - if you touch communal stuff after your sandwich but before you wash them, you're introducing risk.

TBH, if you only touched the bread and no peanut butter spilled out, I'd be OK with that. It would be more if it was overfilled, some came out and you smeared it back in with a finger, wiped your finger (but didn't wash it) then went touching things in the office.

The contamination of office property is unlikely to kill me (as has been said, most people with allergies only die from consumption) but it will make me ill, I won't understand why, and I'll drive myself loopy for days after trying to figure out what I did wrong.

As long as you're considerate with how you eat your sandwich, I don't care if you eat a peanut butter sandwich at your desk. You say you're far away from people anyway, so no one is going to smell it.

Again, the smell won't kill me... but because I know it smells like something that know will kill me, it isn't pleasant.

OhBeAFineGuyKissMe · 15/08/2023 09:19

I work in a school (independent boarding so different from state day) - every teacher is 1 day first aid trained with autoinjector training. Students are expected to carry their pen with them and there are occasional spot checks to make sure (every so often I will ask my tutee if he has his). They also need to show their pens on any trip off site.

On top of this there are auto-injectors in the dining hall, health centre and all boarding houses.

This should be standard but it costs money - training alone is expensive and needs to be updated every 3 years. School budgets are severely stretched and schools are being asked to do more and more with less.

ActDottie · 15/08/2023 09:15

I worked in an office where someone had a nut allergy so we were a nut free office. I think if someone had an allergy you’d likely have been told about it

CattingAbout · 15/08/2023 09:13

I've eaten peanut butter sandwiches at work plenty of times. several of my colleagues took the piss and said it was a kid's lunch, but no-one at any point mentioned allergies.

BlossomCloud · 15/08/2023 09:13

Nevermay · 15/08/2023 09:02

I think you are confusing intolerances and allergies.

about 90% of anaphylactic incidents in the UK are caused by nuts

Most the most common intolerance in the world is milk. And it isn't even really an intolerance, anymore than people are "intolerant" of eating sand.

Milk is not an adult food, it is a baby food, human babies can digest it, human adult can't. Except in two populations where a mutation has lead to the continuation of a baby enzyme into adulthood, some white northern Europeans, and the massia in Kenya/Tanzania

Therefore, 80% of the worlds adult population can't digest milk - and some white northern europeans class that as an "intolerance" when it is actually the human norm, and they are the deviants.

It could make people very ill, and even be dangerous, as could eating sand, but this is not a medical problem, this is the biological norm

Incorrect and utterly ignorant. Milk is the leading cause of death from anaphylaxis in children in the UK

And I have witnessed my son have several anaphylactic reactions to it.

(People can be intolerant to milk (non IgE) but they can also be anaphylactic (IgE))

Both Benedict Blythe and Karanbir Cheema died in school from milk allergies. In Karanbir's case the cheese was just thrown at him , he didn't eat it

Mouk · 15/08/2023 09:13

Unless somebody has a nut allergy, the YANBU. Crack on!

BarqsHasBite · 15/08/2023 09:10

So funny, I’ve been contemplating this on my way into work with a peanut butter sandwich in my bag!

Can I recommend Wow Butter for anyone who is worried, it’s like peanut butter but is nut free (made with soya). They sell it in Holland and Barrett, it’s expensive but soooooo delicious! I love peanut butter but think Wow Butter is nicer.

Great for school packed lunches too (that’s why I started buying it).

Comtesse · 15/08/2023 09:08

Never worked anywhere where peanuts ate banned. I would say you are fine unless HR says anything.

LuvSmallDogs · 15/08/2023 09:03

If an adult has an allergy, then it's up to them to manage it. Whether that involves turning down cakes colleagues have brought in "just in case", or talking to HR about banning the allergen from the building.

If you haven't heard anything, eat what you want until you hear otherwise.

Nevermay · 15/08/2023 09:02

BlossomCloud · 15/08/2023 08:54

@Nevermay nuts are banned yet the leading cause of anaphylaxis is milk....

I think you are confusing intolerances and allergies.

about 90% of anaphylactic incidents in the UK are caused by nuts

Most the most common intolerance in the world is milk. And it isn't even really an intolerance, anymore than people are "intolerant" of eating sand.

Milk is not an adult food, it is a baby food, human babies can digest it, human adult can't. Except in two populations where a mutation has lead to the continuation of a baby enzyme into adulthood, some white northern Europeans, and the massia in Kenya/Tanzania

Therefore, 80% of the worlds adult population can't digest milk - and some white northern europeans class that as an "intolerance" when it is actually the human norm, and they are the deviants.

It could make people very ill, and even be dangerous, as could eating sand, but this is not a medical problem, this is the biological norm

Dotjones · 15/08/2023 08:59

Peanut butter sandwiches in the office are fine, the only foods that cause a problem are those which are noisy to eat or smelly (fish, curry, polish sausage etc.). There's the allergy thing but I don't worry about that, it's the responsibility of those with the allergy to manage their condition and publicise it in advance if they're concerned about someone eating it nearby.

GCSister · 15/08/2023 08:55

Nevermay · 14/08/2023 23:02

I would have thought most work places ban peanuts

I've never worked anywhere that banned peanuts

BlossomCloud · 15/08/2023 08:54

@Nevermay nuts are banned yet the leading cause of anaphylaxis is milk....

JenniferBarkley · 15/08/2023 08:54

I take your point it might be useful to know who has an epipen, maybe I could find that out, but it is extremely unlikely to make any difference whether I know or not.

This leads into the questions I was about to ask. If a child went into anaphylaxis in your classroom a) how would you recognise it b) would you know where their rescue meds were and c) would you know how to use them.

Because knowing who is at risk for anaphylaxis, where to find their epipens and how to use it is the difference between life and death. A delay while you figure out why they've fainted or if they're having an asthma attack, and then search for the meds could well prove fatal.

BlossomCloud · 15/08/2023 08:53

Teachers might not want to be responsible, but if a child died there is no way the investigation wouldn't be utterly horrendous, and imagine not being able to look the child's parents in the eyes and say "I did everything I could".

You don't have time to wait for the first aider if there is anaphylaxis and you can't move the child.

Nevermay · 15/08/2023 08:52

You cant make teachers responsible for allergies in schools, it just wont work. Teachers are responsible for more than enough as it is - first aiders are responsible for allergic reaction, and are paid to be.

Trying to hold teachers responsible for yet more stuff will simply result in fewer teachers, and we don't have enough as it is, so all children will be less safe.

Hence we are back to where we started, nuts are banned in my school, and in most schools I have worked in

Nevermay · 15/08/2023 08:49

BlossomCloud · 15/08/2023 08:40

Attitudes like this are why this petition is so important https://petition.parliament.uk/petitions/633614?fbclid=PAAaZbpJ5WfAXX_ADIZ8nX0gl3nSlSCUe4Ye8vCFSxNoESypvWxROlGAO7c0U

@Nevermay even if you don't care about being able to save the child's life, you might care if you knew how awful the subsequent investigation and possible prosecution would be. You can't afford to not know

I think you misunderstand the situation in schools. Many teachers have done epipen training, I have many times, but the training goes out of date very quickly, and there is no time to keep updating it, as well as all the other training you have to update.

I would not be held responsible, or prosecuted if a pupil had anaphylactic shock - it is not my responsibility and cannot be pinned on me

I have dealt with a student in severe life threatening shock in the past, but it had never happened before and they were not listed as having an allergy.

Many children, in their school records are listed as having allergies, there is no indication of level of seriousness, and parents are unlikely to update the lists - I certainly didn't when my children were at school!

I take your point it might be useful to know who has an epipen, maybe I could find that out, but it is extremely unlikely to make any difference whether I know or not.